# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning of the book elizers father sems stoic and emotionless he also seems to talk and cre for others rather than prioritizing his children however once they reach the camp eliezers sees his father cry for the first time they also must depend on eachother now as they can only trust eachother elizers even makes sacrifices for his father like giving his gold tooth away the holocaust may not bring them close but at the very least they are somewhat dependent on eachother now

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father undergoes a transformation, due to the conditions of the Holocaust. His experiences in the concentration camps reveal a different side of him. Under the harsh conditions, he became more vulnerable and emotionally open. This is a drastic change from his earlier demeanor where emotions were rarely shown from him. The circumstances forced him to remove the layers of reservedness in order to show fear, and pain to eliezer. It's the evolving relationship that sustains eliezer and his father together. Providing emotional support which becomes as essential in order to survive on these camps. -Belen

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezers father used to be very tolerate but concerned with others but recently he is described as becoming more emotional, and vulnerable. I think this is because they are in a life and death situation and their living conditions are poor, I think he is starting to feel lost and his emotions are coming out more than when life was normal and he could be closed off. The holocaust changed their relationship because although they experienced a lot of trauma they had each other and it helped them become more emotionally open and vulnerable with each other, and taught them that nothing is promised.

# data[].attributes.body
Ellies relationship with his father changes from a distant, colder, and greyer relationship to a much more emotional, close, and sacrificial relationship. In the beggining of the book it states how ellie's father is very much deep into his work. So deep in fact that Ellie subtly explains how cold he has been recently. When his father cried for the first time, it opened up to ellie that he is still a human being with a much more emotional side he had never seen before

# data[].attributes.body
Before moving to the camps Eliezer's father was almost "cold" in a way from showing lack of emotions. But as these traumatic events are occurring around him his feeling are starting to show more. The first time when Elizer saw his father cry was when they had to leave the very place they thought they were safe. Seeing his father cry for the first time must have been a life-changing moment for him because he's already 15 years old and when your that age and haven't seen your dad cry it almost is a reality check everybody has feelings. Having these kinds of traumatic experiences would change both father and son the holocaust made Eliezer blamed his father for everything in a attempt to at least blame someone for his fathers torture.

# data[].attributes.body
Jaden Cheng- It seems that the father used to be less attentive and thought about others first but he is starting to realize the importance of his family over trying to be there for everyone. Him and Elie's bond seem to grow closer and their refusal to leave each other's side seems to create a stronger bond. This goes as can be seen when Elie was livid when his father was getting beat.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel Changes Discussion - Maleyah Slade

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel Changes Discussion - Maleyah Slade

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father change comes due to now the fact that his life, other lives and most importantly his children lives are in danger. I think the reason he was closed off was because he could always worry about his kids but he knew they were at least fine. When they sent to Auschwitz then the fact his families life was in danger probably scared him. Eliezer's father now feels he needs to protect Eliezer so he doesn't end up beaten badly or cremated like the children they saw.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer’s father’s temperament was changing because he knew that his time and their time as a family was coming to an end. He knew that either him or his family were not going to live for long because of the labor and treatments they would be going through so his emotions got the best of him. He did not want his family to be scared so he would act tough around them but, as he got further down he realized that it was going to be a scary time for everyone. He knew he couldn't do anything to protect or save his family so when walking to the ghetto he started crying and came to the realization that he is powerless. The holocaust made everyone more emotional because many rethought their life and what they could have done and thought about their future, even if they didn't have one. To them, it showed their true emotions and changed their relationship with others because as they grew a stronger relationship (Elizer and his father) he considered him the tough guy, then to see him cry and become a softer person, it changed his perspective of him.

# data[].attributes.body
His father's temperament is changing because now he and his father are connecting/bonding. They only have each other in the camps and are separated from Elie's mother and sister. And since they are together in the camps Elie's father is no longer worried about other people and is now only worried about his son. Elie's father is now more sensitive and is now able to show emotions. The holocaust has changed their relationship for the better because now they are there to protect each other.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's fathers temperament changed in many ways throughout the events of the story. He goes from a mentally strong man to a broken and beaten down man. When Eliezer sees his father cry, it destroys him because he's never seen his dad (who he views as the strongest person in his life) cry. This impacts their relationship because they both know that they only have each other now. The Holocaust changed there relationship even more because they both went the the same things together.

# data[].attributes.body
Back then, a very big social stereotype for men was that they didn't, or refrained from showing their emotions. Because of this, some families might not have felt as connected to each other on an emotional level. His father's temperament changes when going through the Holocaust. Silly societal constructs don't seem as important in a setting like that. Sometimes, it takes something really terrible happening to bring others together. When people find a common enemy, or a common experience, it brings them closer together. It's sad that it takes something so terrible for it to happen though.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezers father used to be really concerned with other people and what they did rather than his family. But sense the holocaust has happened the only thing he is concerned about is his family and sense he has already been separated from half of his family there relationship has only grown. he wont do anything with out him and ever advantage he gets she wants it to do it with her dad in hopes they can make it out together. His father was really hurt with being separated from his family so there father son relationship has grown cause they dont want to loose each other to.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's dad has kept his feelings hidden, caring about other people's feelings more than his own. But, as the problems from the Holocaust came, he began showing his emotions more and cried for the first time. This shows how when people are put their bad circumstances it changes the way they feel and act. As well as, some relationships get stronger and relying on each other to survive and be there for each other through the tough times.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel Changes Discussion - Jeremy Moreno

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel Changes Discussion - Jeremy Moreno

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father early on in the book is said to always be worried about other matters not involving his family. This immediately paints the picture that Eliezer's father didn't care much about family business and instead cared more about work. Eliezer also says that he had never seen his father cry which is a stark contrast to the father we see later in the book at the concentration camps. Eliezers father cries and gives up from all the pain that he suffered. Eliezer and his Father get closer as they face persecution they become the soul reason either of them haven't given up. His father no longer worries about work and instead worries about Eliezer and his wife and daughter.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezers Dad's emotions/temper is changing and is slowly starting to show it more. He use to not show his emotions that much or give much thought to his actions, but he would just be very protective. I think he would be overprotective and wouldn't show his emotions that often because he felt as if he had everything under control, but now that everything isn't under their control but instead their under the Nazis control its sort of started to break him down physically and mentally, for example when he isnt sure how to march correctly instead of him having it under control its Elizer whom is now teaching him how to do it, so i think they are now crceating a unique bond and that is what is making the father care about more things that he wasnt before because now he is afraid of what might happen in the concentration camp. Maybe he is starting to feel useless and thinking thats there is no longer a need for him to help. -Isabel

# data[].attributes.body
Before the camp, Elizer's father was the highest authority figure in their family and was always hopeful but never showed his emotions fully. The two of them also did not have a very close relationship. But since they have been in the camp, Elizer's father has lost this hope and has allowed his emotions to show. This is because he no longer has authority over his family and doesn't have to pretend to act strong. This has caused their relationship to change because Elizer now sees his father as weak and unable to stand up for himself. It is also shown that he is starting to develop hatred towards his father while also feeling like he has to care for/protect his dad.

# data[].attributes.body
As the story progresses, Eliezer's father becomes more vivid in how he talks to Elie. This can be seen as Eliezer's father used to have less emotion, with the first time Elie saw him cry when the people that Eliezer's father cared about were hurt in unimaginable ways. The moment that he saw these houses that belonged to people in his community that were close to him be ransacked and looted beyond comprehension, he cried for the first time. After that, Eliezer's father is seen to show more emotion to Elie as he knows that either of them could die at any second, without the other being able to help in any way. This desperate nature leads to Elie and his father getting closer to each other, which though it isn't a bad thing, shows the change that his father experiences because of the Holocaust. The way that the Nazis treated the Jews changed their perspectives on life and the way that they reacted to situations that wouldn't happen under normal circumstances. These people, especially Eliezer's father, were hurt beyond belief and were trying to cling to anything that they still had to their name. The Nazis were willing to kill anybody that they could put prejudice on, and it made it that much scarier for those who only had one thing left, as they wanted to cling to it in the hope that they would still have hope or be human even after all of the hurt that they go through.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father seems to show more emotion mostly because he was starting to lose hope. There is a possibility that earlier he was telling himself that he would live to see another day. As things start getting more violent around him, he started to feel less hopeful. Also he could be in fear, but just never wanted to show his son that there was no hope for them. They had to carry on and just wait for what would happen next. This affected the relationship between the narrator and his father mostly by showing each other that they relied on one another to bring hope. They needed each other even if they don't beg for help.

# data[].attributes.body
before everything his father was very joyful .Over time everthing started to rain them with them not being one thing it being another it wasn't very good on there self state and metal too Elie and his father having a strong thing but after being separated and his father trying to help out his kid for him to be safe.no matter the back lash or anything he would do anything for his child.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel Changes Discussion-Madison Scranton 

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel Changes Discussion-Madison Scranton 

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament has changed from having this very tough personality in his life. To now having changed our perception of him, this happens after we see his reactions to everything that has been taken from him and fellow Jews. This event that takes place causes him to open up in a way that shows the audience and different side of him, as to being vulnerable. He now has seen the potential danger that is going to happen to him and his family. For him this is a real eye-opener to see that, what he has is something very special. He now may regret not making those tight bonds within his family, because he realizes that this could be the end for all of them. The Holocaust causes Elie and his Father to become closer to one another in a way that brings comfort. This separation of family members has created a forced bond between Elie and his father. Out of fear, they rely on each other and now all they have is each other, and together they feel safe instead of loneliness.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's fathers temperament changes a lot throughout the entirety of this book. His temperament changes a lot because of all the heavy emotions he faces throughout different time periods. In the beginning of the book he is the rock for his family. Very strong, optimistic, and the person who makes the decisions. As time goes on on he is seen as someone who can be emotional at times. Overtime Eliezer's dad has less and less faith that they will make it out of these camps alive.Also he is really scared that he won't be able to protect his family from this. The Holocaust changes their relationship because it allows Elie to see a different side of his dad or the more human side of his dad. it allows them to appreciate each other and their family more. It also reassures Elie that his feelings about all of this are normal.

# data[].attributes.body
Elie and his father had a very stone-cold relationship and his father didn't show much emotion until they saw how ruthless the Nazis were and when they realized how real the situation was and started to really help each and care for each other more. Given the horrible circumstances, I think Elie's father realized that caring for the other people in the camp does him no good and that everyone is in this for themselves to escape so he started to focus more on himself and his son's well-being.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament has been changing throughout their journey through the Holocaust. His next emotion that is being developed is caring more about his loved ones. This is because he has accepted that they might not get out of this, so those emotions have finally hit him. The Holocaust has something to do with his relationship with Eliezer. This is because he has already lost his wife and daughters so he doesn't want to lose his only son too. But, in the story, I think that Eliezer is more looking out for his father than his father is looking out for him. This is because Eliezer keeps trying to stay with his father through everything so he doesn't lose his only family there.

# data[].attributes.body
Elie's father used to be much more concerned about his community rather than his own family. He also seemed to be care-free and fearless before Nazi occupation. As the Nazis storm their town however, he begins to realize that he can't go through life without his family. His experience through Auschwitz and Nazi-induced cruelty made him realize how important his family truly is. For the first time in what seems to be forever, he weeps. He does not weep because he is afraid to die, but he is afraid of losing his family. He could also be weeping at his sudden realization on how he hasn't been paying attention to his family as much as he should. He weeps because he now only begins to realize his past mistakes at a moment where he may possibly never see his family again.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament has changed throughout the story. In the beginning, he seemed as a cold family man who rarely showed emotions with other people. Since he and the community altogether has been deported he cried in front of Eliezer for the first time. As Eliezer and his father spend time together working their relationship begins to change also. Eliezer begins to notice that his father is actually not a strong man, he even becomes upset at him when Idek targets his father. Although he was upset he still does care for him and decides to try and help him so he can stay out of Idek's anger.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father changes throughout the story because at the beginning his dad was more closed and didn't talk about his feelings but as the story goes on he starts to open up more because of the stress and strain that the holocaust has on him he starts to become more emotional as he is exposed to something that is no common to see in your daily life. the holocaust changes their relationship from a father son relationship to more of a acquaintance we see this because in times when his dad is being beaten he isn't scared or sad he's mad at his dad for being beaten and in the beginning of the book when he says that his father is being beaten to death he just stands there and watches like he's a stranger.

# data[].attributes.body
His father was worried about others because he wanted to care for them. Now, he is only worried about keeping his son with him. Every time somebody talks to him, he is anxious and doesn't know what to always say. The Holocaust changes how Elizer's father cares for him and is more concerned with him than anybody else. He wants to make sure that Elie stays alive. They only have each other after Elizer's mother and sisters split up. They both have to work together to survive.

# data[].attributes.body
Father was too into the problems of others that once I the camps the only on left to care for is his own son, because Elia has a lot of free time know.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning Elizer's father could be seen as a distant father. Elizer only saw his dad cry when they were sent to the ghetto. Once they were sent to the camp we see Elizer and his father sticking together and caring for eachother. Elizer gives up his gold crown to stop his father from being beat. Elizer also hopes for his father's safety during the bombing. The camp is causing Elizer and his father to care more for eachother.

# data[].attributes.body
I Feel like elizers father and his relationship had changed a lot during the story for the better of them like towards the beginning they had a very separate and not very close relationship and it seemed that they didn't care about each other. but after I felt they grew much closer and cared about her and staying with each other while in this camp. One example is on page 59 when the bombing happened and Eliezer immediately thought about him which shows how their care how changed from the beginning to the end of the story

# data[].attributes.body
Elie and his father were close before all of this happened, they relied on each other a lot. Elie's father had a lot more happiness and joy in him and now that he is at this camp he is just slowly draining himself out and has no motivation. His emotions have finally come out and he isn't putting on a strong face for his kids anymore. He doesn't even believe he will make it out alive. Elie is currently helping him and supporting him, trying to make him better so he doesn't go away. All Elie's father has ever done is show support for his kids and be there for them always and now Elie is the one showing support to his dad and being there for him.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezers fathers temper changes as the realization hits him that he has basically lost everything from his house, his possessions, and his family. Eliezer earlier in the book describers him as someone that is emotionless, especially with his family. As the readers and Eliezer may think that him being emotionless was his constant feeling but we see their relationship change through out the story, and they are connecting. The Holocaust makes them bond during the scene where Eliezer is teaching his father how to march in line. Another good time is how Eliezers father was trying to help him avoid getting his crown removed.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father has begun to adopt much more of a protector role. Before the Holocaust he was extremely concerned with their community as a whole and didn't focus very much on Eliezer's well being. Now, Eliezer's father has begun to ignore the needs of others and is strictly on making sure the Elie survives. On a different note, Eliezer has begun to see his father very differently. He has become far less compassionate towards his father. This can be seen when his father is being beaten and Elie blames his father for getting in the way.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel Changes Discussion - Julian Hernandez

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel Changes Discussion - Julian Hernandez

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father didn't show much affection to his family giving his attention to others rather then his own family. But as they get sent to the Ghettos he slowly starts worrying about his family while still caring for and helping others he starts to look after his family for his is starting to get worried and afraid. Once he is separated from his wife and daughters all he has is Eliezer and he doesn't want to lose him too so he is putting all his attention and care to him now no longer worrying about others only his son for his son is the only person he has left.

# data[].attributes.body
Elie’s father is becoming emotionally beaten as the days pass on. Additionally, he sees no point to be the stone-faced man he always is when you’re in a situation like he and Elie is in. Each day has taken a toll on both of them, the effect it has on his father is emotional decay. The Holocaust is, from Eli’s side, is making their relationship more like co-workers or old fiends. Elie is viewing his dad more as someone to look after incase something happens and I feel the dad has the same view for Elie. There isn’t mental room to try and care for one another like family would normally because they’re constantly working, seeing traumatizing views, and are being constantly separated.

# data[].attributes.body
Elie's temperament has changed throughout the story in a lot of ways, instead of him being very happy a lot of the time he has now cried in front of Eile and showed more emotion. Now he isn't able to hide the things he is going through. He has gone through so much throughout the Holocaust that I think it is pretty impossible for him to show happiness. The Holocaust has had an important impact on their relationship because they are now closer than ever. They are both in the same situation together and have to hold on to each other because they are all each one of them have. Both Elie and his father realize they have lost everything but each other and want to make sure they keep the one thing they have.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament undergoes significant changes throughout the course of the Holocaust. Initially portrayed as reserved and stoic, he is characterized by his lack of emotional expression and prioritization of others' welfare over his own family. However, as the Holocaust unfolds and they face increasingly dire circumstances, Eliezer's father begins to display more vulnerability and emotional depth. His tears during their march to the ghetto signify a departure from his usual demeanor and suggest a profound emotional impact of their situation. The Holocaust fundamentally alters their relationship, as they are forced to confront unimaginable horrors together. The shared trauma and struggle for survival in the face of adversity ultimately bring them closer. - Beau

# data[].attributes.body
Elizer's father at the start of the book seemed like he had hope and was always trying to seem happy and show joy. Overtime in the book you are able to see how he is hanging and slowly showing Elizer more emotion on how he feels and by them sticking together also I think helps them share more emotion with each other cause they are now able to see the same events. I also think that by Elizer helping his father in many ways helps show his emotions together grow even thought they might not know how long they are going to be together in this camp.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizers father and his relationship has changed much for the better. At the beginning you couldn't really say that they had a positive relationship because, as he described, they didn't really have one at all. But afterwards they grew much closer, caring for each other and helping each other in order to stay alive. We can see this because Elizer says he instantly is worried for his father when the bombing raid happens, because his father may be in the area that is hit.

# data[].attributes.body
The relationship between Eliezer's and Father changes over time and the way Eliezer's view his father changes. For instants before the war Eliezer saw his father as emotionless, but as time goes on he starts to see the emotional side to his father from everything the Germans were putting them through. Eliezer starts to become angry with his father because he doesn't do what he is told, and doesn't keep his head down. Which Eliezer doesn't really blame the Germans for beating his father because Eliezer see it as he deserve it. Which thats what the Holocaust has done to Eliezer it has changed him as a person, and his views causing it to affect his relationship with his Father because he sees him as weak.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel changes discussion- Gabby Munoz-Gonzalez 

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel changes discussion- Gabby Munoz-Gonzalez 

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer´s temperament changes due to the amount of emotions that he is going through. As in the earlier parts of the story, we can see that Eliezer's father is almost emotionless and blunt. Once at the Ghetto, his whole persona is changed and he is moreover brought out of his shell such as his bluntness, toughness, etc. The holocaust changed the relationship between Eliezer and his father because it caused them to rely on each other more and to let them both know that everything was going to be better. this reliance opened a comfort between them. Eliezer's anger towards his father causes some effects on their relationship so Eliezer's respect can be seen as slowly going away due to the fact he is seeing himself more as a father than, his actual father.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father has been losing his composure since the start of the Holocaust. He has become more frantic and emotional. He is showing his son a side of himself that he has never seen before. The Holocaust changed their whole relationship dynamic by putting them both down to the same level. Before his father was there to discipline him and teach him but now they are both just trying to survive together. An example of this was when Ellie was trying to teach his father how to march.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament is changing because in the beginning he was more insensitive towards situations within his family but the Holocaust has changed his views of life. He realizes that he needs to be more open and caring to his family and that he doesn't have to put on a tough character anymore. It also shows how certain things can break people like how the Holocaust made his father less stern. I think that he tried to act tough to show inspiration to his kids and wanted to hide his weakness. This might've made Eliezer think that he wasn't as strong as he thought he was and he isn't looked up to as much as in the start of the story. Eliezer knows he is in the same situation as his father but feels the need to protect him instead of the other way around, but they both work to strengthen each other.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father is starting to become more and more emotional now that he has been through some tramatic events along with his son which I feel has brought them close. But I also feel that Eliezer isn't as concerned for his father as much as he used to be. Before he couldn't bare the thought of being separated from him but now it feels like he isn't really concerned for him anymore. I also feel that Eliezer's father worries for him a lot more now then he did before because of everything that he has suffered from. While at the camps Eliezer sees that his father is becoming less and less tough and isn't standing up for himself anymore. This dosen't even make Eliezer react anymore he just stands there with no emotional and watches his father get beaten because this place has traumatize him so much to the point of not even feeling anything anymore.

# data[].attributes.body
In Night, we see Eliezer's dad go through some big changes. At first he's strong and caring, protecting Eliezer in the tough times. But as the Holocaust gets worse his strength starts to go away. He becomes more weak and scared like anyone would in such a horrible situation. But the awfulness around them, Eliezer and his dad hold onto each other relying on their bond to survive. The Holocaust tests their relationship in ways they never imagined but it also brings them closer together showing how love can help people even in the darkest times.

# data[].attributes.body
Prior to the Holocaust he was very lenient and didn't hold lots of accountability to care for him. Eliezer's father is now beginning to realize the traumas and suffering of the camps. This realization leads him to start to care about being together. Eliezer's father now knows that he is all Eliezer has, and he knows that as a father, he has to protect him. From this, they begin to have each other's back and help each other with what is necessary. More from just realization Eliezer's father is not starting to appreciate his son more. The holocaust ultimately brought their relationship closer to each other.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament changes through this story because, in the beginning, you can see him as strong, independent, and protective of his family. As he and his family are pretty much separated, you can tell something inside his body flipped and changed him in a way that he didn't even think could happen. Even though he seems like the tough guy, he's always going to have that soft spot for his family because he truly loves them, and separating each other hit him in the chest. He might have felt like he failed his family by not protecting them hard enough so he is now scarred and very emotional. Eliezer and his father's relationship changed after this tragic holocaust event because I believe Eliezer has a different view of his Dad when it seems like he's giving up while being stuck at the camps, and Eliezer is doing his best to make it out alive and do it for his family. As Eliezer sees his Dad cry, it makes him worry less and less when they are not with each other and you can tell they begin to drift apart. He doesn't see his father the same anymore.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Eliezer's father is being less mean or tough and actually start getting close to his son. I feel like the Eliezer's view of his father changed from someone who he obeys to someone who needs help. Their relationship is getting closer because of his dad needing support from Eliezer. He often requests to work around his dad to strengthen their relationships and to support each other. But I think that Eliezer is slowly getting angry at his dad because in his mind, his dad is supposed to be the one supporting him and not the other way around. But overall their relationship bonds strengthened.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father seems less authoritative and appears less strong because he cried as he, his family, and his neighbors were deported from the ghetto. Eliezer's father is often the subject of beatings by the Kapo and is tormented by his fellow prisoners. The Holocaust has made Eliezer no longer view his father as a strong and dependable man because Eliezer only feels anger towards his father when he is beaten by their Kapo and is unable to protect his son from Franek, who wants his gold crown.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father usually thinks more about others than his own family. He was a man who knew was was happening and when it was going to come. His temperament is changing by him kinda breaking down into this mess. He is becoming very weak and showing that he is starting to give up. He doesn't know how to do simple things such as marching and I think the holocaust helped their relationship bloom. It's letting Eliezer become more of an adult in the situation but his father wants to help just as much. The holocaust brought them closer by how he wanted to stay with his father desperately, never leaving his side. It's changing their relationship big time.

# data[].attributes.body
During the beginning of the story, the father of Eliezer is hardly talked about, the only words saying "My father was a cultured man, rather unsentimental. He rarely displayed his feelings, not even within his family, and was more involved with the welfare of others than with his own kin." After being separated from his wife and daughters, Elie became his only family and began to show that he feels the need to be a protector and guide for Eliezer. He gives advice when asked and reassures Eliezer when he is harmed. Because of the Holocaust, the father became closer to his son, but Elie didn't respond the same. He became more distant and even blamed his father for the leaders getting mad at his dad. Even in the preface it is admitted that fear was greater than their relationship. His father being abused, he refused to even speak to him, afraid of being attacked and punished for it.

# data[].attributes.body
His father's temperament is changing becuase he is starting to be more in touch with his emotions when around his children. Before he did not show really any sort of emotion with his children, but now he is starting to cry around them. This is most likely because he knows what is about to happen is going to be terrible and that he and his family are going to have to rely on one another and are going to have to go through these unimaginable hardships together. The Holocaust changes their relationship becuase previously it the dad was more of a dictator figure by instructing Elie on what to do and holding power over Eli. Now, they are both in the same boat and neither of them has power over the other. They now have to look out for each other in the camps and one is not greater than the other.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament changes over time because of the amount of emotion that is coming over him and his family. Families don't go through the Holocaust everyday. I think that Eliezer's father realized that something bad was going to happen to them. The Holocaust can change relationships and bring out your true emotions. The Holocaust has brought Eliezer and his father closer to one another. Eliezer was finally happy that he got to spend time with his father even if it was in a horrible place. Eliezer started to get frustrated with his father because before his father showed no emotion. Now in a place where prisoners couldn't show weakness, is where his father decided to show emotion. When Eliezer saw his father crying for the first time, I think his father was realizing that he might never see his wife and daughters ever again.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezers father is slowly starting to show his emotions. In the beginning of the book he was very unemotional and protective. Due to being in the concentration camp, it has broken him down, he is starting to care more about certain things and has lost hope for himself and his son. He is realizing that the concentration camp might be were he ends up dying, which is very sad for him. He feels there is nothing he can do to help him or his family anymore, which was his main focus in the beginning of the story.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizezer's Father in the begging of the novel was more or less seen as a parental figure. Elizer quoted that his father barely displayed his feelings with his family. His father was seen as more involved with his welfare. However that changes when they get sent to Auschwitz. His father is now get completely thrashed and beaten by the guards there. In the book, it shows that Elizer's dad is in deep distress. We know this because that was the first time Elizer sees his dad cry at the camp.

# data[].attributes.body
When Elizer's father cries for the first time, it is a marker of their relationship growing more interdependent. His father cries in response to the thought of losing his life and his family to germans. The idea that he cannot protect his kin is probably crushing to him and he is allowing his son to see that he is struggling too and that it is okay to rely on him because he is just as reliant. As they are getting used to the conditions of the death camp his father starts to show more weakness as a result of the lack of control they have over the situation. Although the only thing that matters to him is the safety of his son. He also gains more of a it happens but we must make it through mentality.

# data[].attributes.body
His dad is starting to become more emotional and show that he cares. Eli views him as someone who is smart and tough, but as the days go on he is seeing him getting weaker and he is needing more help. It does seem like the relationship between Eliezer and his father starts to get stronger and they get closer. They are both going through this together and it is kind of like their relationship is being tested. Them being there for each other can help.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament changes before he starts off as more of an authority figure and someone to tell Eliezer what to do. To Eliezer, he was nothing more than someone to listen to and do what he was told to do on a daily basis. Now however he is someone who is more caring of Eliezer and wants to protect him at all costs as we can see how much more protective over him he is. His father now realizes how little time he might have left with Eliezer and how he needs to make sure that his son is being treated or protected the very best that he can. I think that the Holocaust changed their relationship in a way where they both realized that they needed each other, especially in this time, and this caused them to grow closer to each other. The Holocaust changed both of their perspectives about each other as Eliezer realizes that his father does have emotions and is not someone without compassion. Eliezer's father realizes that he needs to protect and love Eliezer as he no longer can predict what will happen and how much time he will have left with his son who is also the only family that he has at this time.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father would be more concerned with other people than his children at first. But now his father realizes that Elie is all he has left. They have to stick together if they want to survive this and so the relationship between them grows more and more as they try to survive the Holocaust together. They refuse to be separated from one another and try their hardest to remain close together at all times. Though Eliezer does seem to think that his father is weak and needs help from him now, we know that he still wants to be with his father no matter what.

# data[].attributes.body
His father is beginning to act with his emotions and be more empathetic. We can see how he slowly accepts their situation and how the panic sets in, he knows he has little to no control over anything, he's less tough on his son or in general, and he cares for the people around. While he's making this transition his son is making one as well but very different. He begins to realize he needs to help his father in any way he can caring for his dad almost more then he does himself such as teaching him how to march

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father seems to come to a sort of realization. He seems more understanding of emotions in a way. He also seems to care more for his son and interact with him, not be as hard on him since they are in a pretty bad situation with that being the holocaust. His father knows they have to stick together to get through this. They have become reliant on each other to get through this. It's like a new reason to live, to keep on fighting. Elie doesn't want to be separated from his father so he hopes to stay with him and endure this hardship together.

# data[].attributes.body
Elles father used to have authority and not pay much mind to his son. As the two got placed in the concentration camps all worry of the outside world left the minds of Elle and his father. No more did his father have higher authority, but rather they just needed to stick together. Them sticking together brings hope, as time goes by Elle is becoming more dependent on his own actions rather than relying on his father.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning, Elie's father was the authority figure of the family and felt the need to always be there and provide for his family. Since he has been at the camp, Elie's father has begun letting his emotions show. He is starting to lose faith that they'll make it out alive. I think that Elie's father is beginning to show more concern for Elie because he is scared and doesn't know how to protect his family anymore. I think this shows Elie that him and his dad are going through the similar feelings which might end up bringing them closer together. Since Elie and his dad want to stick together, they both will have to work hard in order to survive.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizers fathers temperament changed through his emotions. He is thinking harder about discussions that pop up. The holocaust changed their relationship in a few different ways but one way that really stood out to me was how at the beginning of the story they weren't super close but as the story goes on you can tell that they have a stronger connection now.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizer's father was more joyful before all of what is happening currently. He overtime seems to be more down and down. You can tell that his mental health is draining him, because he never cries and is starting to now. Elie gives his father strength by being close to him. The bond between them makes it easier for his father and keeping him from dying. I think that if they were separated then the father would be dead already, the father is concerned and all he wants is to keep the kids safe.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father is slowly realizing the importance that he holds and must stay together. Before the Holocaust happened, he didn't care for him and brushed him off in a way. However, in these recent events, we see his father show more emotion and open up a bit more to Eliezer and appreciate him more than he as because he's realizing that Eliezer is all he has left and that he matters. The Holocaust allowed him to appreciate what he has and not take his son for granted. Eliezer noticing his father's changes also makes the reader see how big of a change this is for not only Eliezer but also his father. The Holocaust changed their relationship by bringing them closer together during a time of crisis as bad as this, they must stick together to make it to the other end and live to share their stories about this experience.

# data[].attributes.body
His temperament is slowly changing as we see his behavior switch like a lightbulb. We're presented with this father to be a man who showed his loyalty to his family. During the first few chapters, we see the father be more optimistic trying to seek until the family is forced to be sent to the camp. Once they were sent to the camps and separated, the fathers perspective is drastically changed and he breaks into tears being there. Being in a concentration camp has drastically changed their relationship because now he's given up in way. Him giving up and trying to hold in his emotions changes the man who Eliezer once saw to look up towards.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's feelings are changing because the camps are getting real and he is recognizing that. He used to care about others than his own children and now he cares about Elie. They are both clinging and caring on each other because now they are all that each other has left. I think his dad is starting to care more and letting himself have feelings instead of pretending everything is okay because this could be their last time alive together. The Holocaust is changing their relationship because in the beginning it showed that Elie only cared if him and his father were together. Now Elie cares about staying alive. They are closer now because they are together, but now he sees his father in a weak way.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father is starting to gain more concern for his now only child. He is all he has now so he knows he must protect and care for him so they both get through this. Eliezer refuses to separate from his father and helps him in any way he can to continue pushing through this difficult time. I wouldn't say they grow to become closer to each other but instead have each other's back. I also think that now his father knows he must live for his son because he is what keeps Eliezer going. I do believe they are each other's motivation for living and not giving up like others most likely have.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer’s father is starting to show his emotions, especially love, for his son more often. We can see this by Eliezer’s father crying for the first time in front of his family. Another example of Eliezer’s father’s change is that, before he would always be looking out for others in their community but now his only concern is his son. The Holocaust is starting to weaken their relationship. Elie is starting to see his father as more of a liability that needs to be taken care of than a dad that he wants to protect. In the beginning of the book when they first were taken to the camps and separated from the women in their family, all Eliezer wanted to do was stay with his father and try his best to protect him. Now when Elie’s dad was getting beaten by a frustrated Idek instead of hating Idek for hurting his father, Eliezer started to resent his father for getting Idek’s attention.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizer´s father would never show his emotion and Elizer saw him as serious and he barely shpwed emotion to his family. As they were going to the concentration camps Elizer noticed that his father was showing more emotion as usual, he was even crying. Elizer´s father would start show more emotion to his son because he knew that many family members were being split up during that time so he needed to enjoy every second he had with him just incase they would be split up in the future. I also think that his father was showing more emotion because someone needded to look out for Elizer because he was just a kid that was seeing his own kind being tortured by germans.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament changes from stoic and unsentimental to disheartened and emotional. Before the Holocaust, his father kept his feelings to himself as he was busy with the responsibility of taking care of everyone in their community. When the two are taken to Birkenau, Elie's father tragically wishes that Elie went with his mother because he doesn't want to see his son burnt to death. The Holocaust changes their relationship because before, Eliezer respected his father and didn't want to be separated from him. Then when Elie watched his father being beaten by Idek, he was angry not at Idek, but at his father. Eliezer no longer held his father in a higher respect.

# data[].attributes.body
The behavior or nature of Eliezer's father was affected by the Holocaust and has led to him becoming a much more emotional man. It has been read that he is supposedly a non-emotional man most likely to show that he's fine hiding what he's truly going through. His father's concern for others was very strong avoiding people's concern for himself because he most likely wanted to stand out as a tough guy. The Holocaust most definitely showed him how much more care he should have for those around him because it doesn't take much for them to disappear. After being separated from most of his family he now sees what he has had and how much more he should've appreciated it before losing it. The relationship between the two has most definitely grown indefinitely stronger as they both only have hope and each other to cling to at this point.

# data[].attributes.body
The ways that Elizer's father is changing is how he started to become more open, and concerned. But while they were in the camps, His father started to care more for his family. This causes Eliezer and her father to grow closer and create a stronger bond with each other. As well as appreciating each other's presence throughout the story. Elizers father doesn't stay cold but also becomes weaker, he thinks its the best to stay together and become more protective of his family. And trying to stay alive and strong since it's only just him and his son left.

# data[].attributes.headline
How does Eliezers father temperament change during the story (Jazper Randell)

# data[].attributes.subject
How does Eliezers father temperament change during the story (Jazper Randell)

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament changed during the holocaust because his more emotional than he was before in the book Eliezer states that his father rarely showed emotion. He was often focused on the townspeople. Since the march His father has cried and seems to be depressed like everyone else at the ghettos. This shows how bad the holocaust was, it turned a none emotional man into a very emotional sad and angry person. The german nazis took his wife away from him beat his son and took everything he has worked for away. Eliezer says that his father is stoic which means someone who has been through a tragic event in their life leading to depression PTSD and other disorders. But throughout the story, Eliezers father begins to toughen up and take these are times up front. He still cries often but knows he has to be their for his son.

# data[].attributes.body
In the story Night, Eliezer and his father in the beginning of the story they are seen to be more involved in other families or community other than his family. I can see that his Dad changes his temperament when he has to leave his wife and daughter and wishes they were all together. He also gets more emotional when he gets separated and doesn't have his same bossy attitude he used to have. The holocaust has changed the relationship of Eliezer and his dad in a positive and negative way. Positive since they are building a better bond with each other and working together in the factory. But a negative because he used to see his dad as an independent man and the top dog, but now he thinks he's weak and won't say anything to help others like how he once was doing.

# data[].attributes.body
Elizers fathers temperament has changed because of aushwits at the beginning of the story his father was not a very emotional guy and he thought that his way of doing this was the correct way and that eliezer should follow everything he says without any questions at all just do it so in aushwits his father has been put in his place and has changed his personality by him just trying to stay alive in aushwits. The Holocaust has changed there relationship because before he had a pretty decent relationship with his father but now because of the holocaust there relationship is now being tested like when his dad was being beat eliezer did nothing but everywhere he goes he wants his father to be with him so i think that there relationship is struggling but in order to survive they need to try to stick together and keep there relationship.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Eliezer's father's temperament is changing in that originally he was trying to protect his family and his only job in life is to be a father to his family. Now that its just him and his son I believe his idea has kind of changed to still protecting his son but also trying to stay alive for his son. I think Elie's father now has a higher value of his own life and is more trying to survive himself with his son than giving his life up at any opportunity for his son. He thinks he needs to stay alive to guide his son. So when they went to the ghetto or any other place that striked fear in them he was scared as well.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father crying for the first time in front of him could show that he is a changed man knowing that his family is now in danger. The ghetto could make his children not grow up in a normal life and change them for the worse. Especially because if they are ever going to go back to normal society they would act differently and not fit in. The holocaust now affects the father and Eliezer because it helped them get closer together. After all, they were now in danger. They had both heard that people had been dying and now they have the stress of dying themselves. The trauma put on the both of them helps build a connection knowing that they are both in the situation together.

# data[].attributes.headline
eliezers father in the begging of the book was a  very excited and happy person. While the book kept going and the Holocaust began to become serious,  he became to be more protectivive and told all of them to stay together. as the Holocaust began to keep going, he became a very worried person and he lost his hope. I think he's starting to see everybody around him passing, so he expects them to be next. (Isaac Morales)

# data[].attributes.subject
eliezers father in the begging of the book was a  very excited and happy person. While the book kept going and the Holocaust began to become serious,  he became to be more protectivive and told all of them to stay together. as the Holocaust began to keep going, he became a very worried person and he lost his hope. I think he's starting to see everybody around him passing, so he expects them to be next. (Isaac Morales)

# data[].attributes.body
During, the Holocaust Eliezers dad cry's for the first time in his in Eliezers life. Eliezers dads emotion are showing for the first time because he is realizing that these might be his last bit of his life and he might die soon. He is probably thinking about his life and what he wanted to do and everything that has led up to this point in time. The Holocaust makes him and his dads relationship stronger because they are going to have to fight together to stay alive. This event is going to make them be with each other more often and they are going to bond more often. They are also trying to help each other stay alive so they need to give hope and strength and a reason to live and try to survive.

# data[].attributes.headline
Cruel Changes Discussion (Makayla Zelaya)

# data[].attributes.subject
Cruel Changes Discussion (Makayla Zelaya)

# data[].attributes.body
Ellezer's father is changing emotionally in many ways, he is showing that he cares more about things such as his son. His only concern is to keep his son alive, he doesn't care about anything else but if his son is okay and alive. The Holocaust changed their relationship severely, in the beginning, all Ellezer was concerned about was staying with his father, keeping him and his dad safe and fed. Now you can see that Ellezer is starting to be only concerned about his survival, he wasn't angry at the man beating his father he was furious at his father for not staying out of his way.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament is changing by his expression of emotion. He is giving more thought to his actions but is not the dad he once was. Before he seemed to know everything and had it all under control whereas now his son is teaching him how to march correctly. The Holocaust changes their relationship in many ways. One of them is they used to have a distant relationship but now since they are binded together by the Nazis, they are having more interaction. We can also see that Eliezer is growing angry with his father because he always saw him as a man of action but now his father doesn't rebutle and gives in.

# data[].attributes.body
It seems like Eliezer's father and his relationship starts to get closer and it seems like his father is starting to care more. Before in the story he used to be a strong man who would always look over his family but as the story proceeds he shows how tough of a position they are really in and how his mentality is being to switched to more of a softer person. He is becoming weaker and instead of being the strong nonchalant person he was before he starts to show emotions of weakness but still hides how he feels in a way. As they were very close before the Holocaust their relationship is really tested by just being there for each other after seeing all the cruel things. As they both try to support each other they are challenged and both affected by all the overall traumas.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father's temperament is changing by breaking down. In the earlier parts of the story, his father was much more stoic. The decline of his rights as a human being leads also to a decline in his stoicism, and so he cries when he arrives to the ghetto. He was someone Eliezer admired much more than he (Eliezer) would later on. In the earlier part of the story that we've read, Eliezer has much more respect for his father, but as we move through the sufferings in the book, the conditions of the camp harden his heart to him.

# data[].attributes.body
He is slowly starting to become more emotional and he is starting to care more. He is starting to act less tough and he acts less like everything is okay. I feel like while their at the camps, Eliezers view of his dad changes from seeing him as someone who knows everything and someone he looks up to and adores, to someone that he thinks is weak and who needs help. While they are at the camps, Elizer starts worrying less and less about if they are together. He finds himself more taking care of his dad than he is taken care of by him. And I think that he is kind of starting to loose respect for him.

# data[].attributes.body
Eliezer's father used to be more concerned with others than his own children, but not Elie is all he has and they must stick together. Them sticking together gives hope and strength, a reason to live. The Holocaust causes the two to grow closer and to become reliant on each other. Elie refuses to be separated from his father with the hope that they can make it through together.

# data[].attributes.body
To-Do:

1. First, you will read the 'Book Events' to understand the content from the novel we will be discussing.

2. Second, thoughtfully respond to the questions posed under 'Worldly Connection' in 6-8 sentences.

3. Third, on Wednesday, you will respectfully respond (2-3 sentences) to another student's post in your group discussion board.

1. You can build on the subject matter/opinion they have posted

2. You can respectfully challenge their world view, or

3. You can connect their post to a new idea/subject where you see a meaningful connection.

Book Events:

Early in the book, Eliezer says his father "rarely displayed his feelings, not even within his family, and was more involved in the welfare of others than with that of his own kin." When they begin the march to the small ghetto, Eliezer sees his father cry for the first time.

Worldly Connection:

In what ways is Eliezer’s father's temperament changing?  In what ways does the Holocaust change their relationship?