# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia effect a high school students social life when attending school at home during Covid, compared to the students now attending school in person.

# data[].attributes.body
How dose nostalgia affect people’s social life’s and behavior?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia impact American gen Z teens when going into situations talking about their childhood dealing with covid-19?

# data[].attributes.body
In what ways do different generations experience nostalgia and what role does it play in shaping their identity?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent can nostalgia help an elderly individual manage there feelings they have with a dead family member or friend?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent do past familial memories create a window of opportunity or a barrier when people in their late 20s are trying to create a family?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia have an effect on American teenagers today than how it used to have back then in the years?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia take effect on a college students memories when using their five senses?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia affect the lives of suicidal teenagers who struggle with the loss of a loved one in America.

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nolstgia affect the mental well being of highschool graduates that are transitioning from highschool life to college life.

# data[].attributes.body
In what ways can nostalgia positively affect social and emotional bonds between family and friends?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia impact family traditions and shape identity and connections to the past ?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent, does nostalgia affect American adults well being, regarding their childhood experiences?

# data[].attributes.body
how does nostalgia affect young teenage boys who grow up without a father

# data[].attributes.body
How does nostalgia for the 1990s influence millennials' purchasing decisions in fashion and technology markets?

# data[].attributes.body
in what ways do films and music from the past bring up nostalgia and what are their effects on the audiences emotions?

# data[].attributes.body
In what way does listening to childhood songs affect feelings of happiness in adults?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent, should people rely on nostalgia to get through tough times?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does Nostalgia negatively affect people mentally and their abilities of moving on from their past?

# data[].attributes.body
In what way does listening to childhood songs affect feelings of happiness in adults?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent can nostalgia affect families to bring them together and to strengthen family bonds?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does nostalgia affect people in their 20’s who are dealing with depression and anxiety?

# data[].attributes.body
To what extent does being nostalgic about past childhood experiences affect the emotional well-being of adults?

# data[].attributes.body
In what ways, positive or negative, does nostalgia have an impact on adolescents who are currently going through a depressive state?

# data[].attributes.body
See this document before writing your question.

# data[].attributes.headline
Group 2 didn’t get to mention in seminar.

# data[].attributes.subject
Group 2 didn’t get to mention in seminar.

# data[].attributes.body
I didn't get to mention this in my seminar, but I have a theory about Miss Lucy's departure from Hailsham. Although it's not explicitly stated that she was fired, page 111 mentions that “Miss Lucy is leaving Hailsham”. I believe the altercation she had with Tommy, where she admitted she was wrong about everything and emphasized the importance of artwork as evidence, played a significant role. It seems like the higher-ups might have pressured her to say that. Why else would she change her mind so suddenly and then just leave?

# data[].attributes.headline
Group 2 didn’t get to mention in Seminar 

# data[].attributes.subject
Group 2 didn’t get to mention in Seminar 

# data[].attributes.body
I didn't get to mention this in my seminar, but I have a theory about Miss Lucy's departure from Hailsham. Although it's not explicitly stated that she was fired, page 111 mentions that Miss Lucy is leaving Hailsham. I believe the altercation she had with Tommy, where she admitted she was wrong about everything and emphasized the importance of artwork as evidence, played a significant role. It seems like the higher-ups might have pressured her to say that before they let her go. Why else would she change her mind so suddenly and then just leave?

# data[].attributes.body
I don’t think the students at Hailsham would want to escape at this point because they would have already done it and it would’ve been talked about in the book and I also think that they are attached to there guardians since they haven’t seen family like parents or siblings if they have any. They also don’t have a big idea of the outside world because they haven’t experienced anything out of Hailsham.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the fact that they shouldn’t have been told about what’s going to happen in their future because they might rebel because they’re stripped of freedom but I also agree with the fact what do they rebel about because they’ve never felt freedom anyways.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree that the guardians possibly being forced into their job at Hailsham. I wonder if the guardians even make money. The guardians also live at Hailsham, and are very secretive about the whole situation. Maybe the kids become donors, carers, and some become guardians.

I disagree with the idea of the students rebelling against the guardians. They are completely brainwashed and don’t know what life is outside of Hailsham. They have no reason to rebel against the only adults that they have known their whole life.

# data[].attributes.body
Jocelyn

She talked about how if the guardian got to pick of get put in there job. I was thinking that they might have been a donner who survived so they were hopeful the kids would to. So they never said anything because they believe that they will live again.

Farrakh

I agree with what he said about how the kids wouldn’t want to lose there guardians. I wouldn’t want to lose my parents and i feel like that the guardians were like the kids parents in a way. Because they raised them.

# data[].attributes.body
1. I agree with how madame broke out of character when she saw Kathy singing and thinking she would have a future but she doesn’t and there lives are already put out for them and that is to be doners.

2. I agree with how the guardians used to students at hailsham and they were the best of the best students and an instead of being a doner they choosed to be a guardian.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Miss Lucy not understanding what she was getting into. She seemed like she was the only guardian at hailsham who wasn’t fully ‘under control’. I remember in the movie, mitre students were telling miss Lucy the horrific stories that had supposedly happened when students went beyond the borders of hailsham. Miss Lucy thought those stories were a bit unbelievable. Also miss Lucy’s confrontation scene when she reveals who’s the students are going to donate their organs later. Coincidently, she later left hailsham and was never going to return. Miss Lucy has more free will than the other guardians or is more willing to tell the truth to help the students.

# data[].attributes.body
I really liked the question Jocelyne asked about whether the guardians like their jobs or not. I believe in the theory that the guardians could’ve been previous kids at hailsham previous carers that had the chance to live there lives if they became guardians and I don’t think they like there jobs.

# data[].attributes.body
If they knew fully what they were going to be when their older and it wasn’t hidden, it would definitely be different because they would become scared for the future and maybe try to get away before it happens.

# data[].attributes.body
Xitlaly said that she thinks Miss Lucy didn’t realize what she had gotten herself into until it was later on, and I agree with this because although I still think they had Miss Lucy sign some sort of waiver saying she would not tell the kids of their future, but I believe that Miss Lucy wasn’t informed that the children had no recollection of what they would become as donors and would only be informed until there was no way to get out of it.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with xitlaly i think that the gardens where either once doners or have went hills ham or something that’s why they are working there. People that work for it have to be very trustworthy to keep all the secrets from children and just do there job. Like when mis.lucy when told them the truth she was fired so She was not trustworthy enough they need people that will do there jobs nothing else. Like MJ said not all grdeans want to work there because they are meant to keep secrets.

# data[].attributes.headline
Are the guardians forced to do there job?

# data[].attributes.subject
Are the guardians forced to do there job?

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they are forced to do there jobs because when madame started crying when seeing a Kathy dancing and she just walked away I think she was trying to stay in charecter and not show she feels bad and when Miss Lucy was like what do you mean there is no way out I think she was weirded out about these rules and that shows she doesn’t want to be there.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the guardians at halsihum don’t really dislike or like thier jobs. Thier like humans nobody really like thier job but I don’t think they hate going there if they did they would quit like Miss Lucy . Miss Lucy stoped working there and there wasn’t nothing in the book that represented a struggle to stop working there. I feel like the guardians feel emphatic for the students but are aware of what goes on at halishum.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree that the guardians are not there by their free will and instead they are forced to be there. I think this because Ms Lucy for example hated it and got fired because she talked to much.

# data[].attributes.body
I like grace was saying about Norfolk being this place of hope i forgot what she said directly but I liked that theme of it being this place of hope and excitement for the kids because they already have nothing to lose.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the fact that we have a choice in our lives but the students in hailsham don't have one. They all are going to become donors and like Ms Lucy said they are all have their lives set out for them and they are all going to die at a young age.

I disagree with the fact that the teachers could just leave. An example of this is madame when she was crying. You can that she was probably crying because of these kids. But if she didn’t want the kids to be donors she could just leave her job but she doesn’t. I think this means that they are all held at hailsham and don’t get to leave because they know the “secret” of Hailsham.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the idea that the guardians were forced because their actions show how they see the kids differently. Like the scene with madame crying when she saw Kathy listening to the tape with the pillow holding it like a baby.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Maurice and how he says that the guardians struggle with their jobs and I feel as if they may be stressed about keeping the kids in the dark and just trying to make their lives seem as normal as possible and even if they are distant they care about the kids in their own way

# data[].attributes.body
I’m unsure about the guardians getting their positions AS guardians because they were great carers and previous students at Hailsham. I feel like if I were being raised at hailsham I wouldn’t want to return to hailsham UNLESS the guardians had no other option other than to be a guardian at hailsham and were forced to take their role.

# data[].attributes.body
Jocelyn said that she had the question on how the guardians came to be guardians at Hailsham. Do they want to work there or were they forced? I think that the Guardians chose to work at Hailsham, I don’t think they would be forced unless there was a higher hierarchy controlling who comes in and out of Hailsham. I do believe that there are multiple other boarding type schools such as Hailsham raising these kids to be donors, however I think every Guardian that works at Hailsham chose to work there, knowingly aware of what the children will grow up to be. Miss Lucy was clearly uneasy with the fact that the children have not been told in full what they will grow to be, and I feel like before joining Hailsham she had to sign something saying she wouldn’t tell the children in full, which is why I think she was soon fired at the end of part 1.

# data[].attributes.body
I also don’t think they like their jobs and maybe they are being forced. Their feelings about their roles vary, some show discomfort like madame and some show they care about the students and what they think/known about their future like miss Lucy.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with vicotoria, the obsessed with the fact that there organs will be donated. They look for the good that there going to be ok when they donate r here organs. They kids want to strive to live as long as they can and to get to experience different cultures, states, countries, outside.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of Kaths cassette tape and her hoping it ends up at Norfolk related especially to kids at halishum because of the kids having to donate thier organs and hope they continue to live and experience life.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Jocelyn.A I’m curious if the guardians were forced there or even like the job cause you don’t really know if they Do or don’t but maybe more in the story you could find out but I also had a thought myself that I didnt say in my circle which was what if the guardians that are currently there what if they were once hailsham students and instead of going out into the real world what if they just stayed of came back as a guardian and built more on it

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of Kaths cassette tape and her hoping it ends up at Norfolk related especially to kids at halishum because of the kids having to donate thier organs and hope they continue to live and experience life.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of Kaths cassette tape and her hoping it ends up at Norfolk related especially to kids at halishum because of the kids having to donate thier organs and hope they continue to live and experience life.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with how the students look for hope their going to be ok after they donate there vital organs. The students want to be ok after donating to experience the stuff they never go to. So

I agree with how they said madame has a little soft spot because how she started crying after she saw Kathy holding a baby and singing never let me go.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of Kaths cassette tape and her hoping it ends up at Norfolk related especially to kids at halishum because of the kids having to donate thier organs and hope they continue to live and experience life.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of Kaths cassette tape and her hoping it ends up at Norfolk related especially to kids at halishum because of the kids having to donate thier organs and hope they continue to live and experience life.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree that Miss Lucy is a “good” guardian for the students. She wants the kids to know some of what their future holds, as well as making them feel better about themselves when she told Tommy about not being creative. This could be a bad thing but for what Tommy was going through, she absolutely made him feel better and improve his life.

I don’t know about the idea of the kids being obsessed with lost things like their organs. I think they want that item because it represents Hailsham and some of their childhood. They already don’t have much in their lives, so keeping a childhood tape for example, is a valuable object in their life.

# data[].attributes.body
I’m unsure about the children having nothing left to lose. I feel like even thought they will eventually have to donate their organs, I feel like they won’t just give up on trying to live a normal life. They use Norfolk as a place to cope and be hopeful for the future, meaning that they hope that after they lose their organs, they’ll still try to find a way to fulfill their life despite losing their vital organs.

# data[].attributes.body
I disagree with how they lose personal belongings like physical objects gonna affect them because i feel like their is more to that and more to lose then like bags and shoes and stuff.

# data[].attributes.body
Yes kids will be able to go fine things that they lost as in memories, stuff, and there own things they are looking for differEnt so they can expand there curiosity . And I agree with grace they want to look for things they lost and for the hope that they will be okay after they donate their organs. They are scared to live the life after they donate because they want to be okay and life another life.

# data[].attributes.body
battles for morality was a great way to describe the last few chapters, I think grace put allot of insight on the memories and I like that this group added the page numbers I didn’t hear allot of those from group 1&2 and I liked the analysis of Norfolk I thought that was interesting

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with grace saying that the loss of cassette tapes and hoping that it ends up at Norfolk especially relates to the kids of halishum because of the loss of thier organs and having to hope thier okay and continue to live.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Cadence because they always related or connected the lost things to Norfolk. As a matter of fact the Hailsham students start making jokes about the things they have lost being in Norfolk.

# data[].attributes.body
i agree with grace saying that the loss of Katy cassette tape resembles a chance of hope and recovery and I agree that these kids at halishum especially relate to hope because of thier loss of a normal childhood and having to give up thier life’s and organs for others and hope that they will be able to survive and continue to live

# data[].attributes.body
Battling morality by Mis.lucy trying to tell the kids the truth but they don’t understand what is going on . Batting morality in different ways not only about them being donors but what else’s is going on in hilsham. I agree with grace when madam has a soft side for the kids and she might realize that they are more of real humans and that they should get recognized more of children that should live there own life’s and not just be used as donors.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Jackies comments around the them or battling of morality. I think that there were moments for sure where characters couldn’t decide what was right and what was wrong like as Jackie said when Miss Lucy struggles with telling the truth which was a good example of her fighting her mortality.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with people saying that they think this part of the book is important because it really showed how they both are as a charecter. When someone asks Ruth about whered she get her pencil case from she didn’t know what to stay but she was trying to stay strong in a way, and Kathy felt bad for confronting her about the way she was acting , she stood up to for her.

# data[].attributes.body
i agree ms lucy is tying to show the children at hailsham the truth but she doesn’t know exactly how to tell them and she would struggle to explain that to the kids

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with miss Lucy having a battle of morality . Miss Lucy faces this battle of morality by feeling like she should help these kids and change their futres and stand up against the kids having a set future for them but she also faces the struggle on how these kids impact the world

# data[].attributes.body
Grace was saying that when Madame catches Kathy holding her pillow ‘baby’ and she starts crying that she sees a different side in her. I agree with this statement because we get more of a look into one of the Guardians emotions and how she chooses to express it. Madame would have never guessed that Kathy was holding the pillow pretending it was a baby, so it’s confusing on why Madame would start crying at the scene of her doing so. I think when Madame starts crying this is because Kathy is being herself, she’s using her imagination and using her free time to focus on herself, but when she sees Madame she stops. I believe that Madame is sorry for not only Kathy but all of the students at Hailsham who have to grow up on half-truths and lies, and eventually grow up to be a donor when they’re given all these different types of career paths they’ll never be able to choose.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the fact that they are telling them and not telling them that they are going to be one thing and one things only because they would lose all creativity.

I disagree with the fact that made me is considered the bad person because although all the kids thought they should be scared of her but they ended up realizing that madame herself was sort of scared of the kids. I know this because in the beginning chapters the text states that she wouldn’t even touch the kids and would just sit there until they passed by. The book also describes that the way she was scared was the way we would be scared of a spider.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with them about how Madame had a another side of her that she didn’t show because everybody has another side that people don’t see.

# data[].attributes.body
Responding to the question about what we think of Ms Lucy I believe she’s acts similarly to teachers around the world in many different schools the only difference is the students the fact that WE get the choice to do what we want after it’s over compares to the students of hailsham. I believe Ms Lucy felt bad for these students similarly to Ms Madame except Ms Lucy tries to supply a level of realism to these students.

# data[].attributes.body
I disagree that Madame is the “bad” guardian just because she was scared of the kids and told them that their future is already set out for them. I think madame was crying at the door way because she knows that Kathy can’t have kids while she’s singing that song which makes her feel sympathy for Kathy.

# data[].attributes.body
I don’t think that the guardians were trying to get the kids to believe they could be what they wanted at some point. I think they just didn’t tell them so they would keep working harder and trying to get that life they wanted and believed they would have.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Grace saying that she’s trying to make the students at Hailsham understand what there future is like and what is going on, but I think she did that no matter how old they were. Like in the beginning chapters she was responding to Kathy saying there is no way out of here, she was like what do you mean there are no way out of here, and her exposing the organ donation, is two things that she comments on with reality with two different ages.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with how Ruth was morally wrong for her to “take” Tommy away from Kathy. I agree with this because she knew that Kathy liked Tommy first and she still got with him. This kind of took shots at Kathy.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the idea that the children are being “told and not told” because they are sort of being guided into growing up to be whatever they want to be without being directly told that. If they are told they’re going to donate their organs right away, then why would they try being ‘creative’ or dreaming about their futures that have already been set out for them? Hailsham doesn’t want the kids to ‘rebel’ against them so the truth is being kept from them indirectly.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Jackie . I think that Miss Lucy trying to reveal the truth to the kids is pointing out her conflict with breaking the law of Hailsham with the truth and is foreshadowing her role in the book.

# data[].attributes.body
Based on what ms Lucy told the students of hailsham saying if it’s immoral or not I believe it depends on the students as wether or not they were told upfront or they got told bit by bit this isn’t a choice for them and they’re not escaping this inevitable future of being carers and donors.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree how Ruth kind of stole Tommy away from Kathy because Kathy had a crush on Tommy But Ruth was picking on Tommy in a flirtatious way. Kathy was trying to be nicer and Tommy kind of looked at her as being a friend.

# data[].attributes.body
Someone said Miss Lucy was battling with her morality, and she felt sympathy for the students since they were not told the full truth about their futures. I agree with this because what led Miss Lucy to tell the kids in full their future was that she couldn’t bare with the fact that the kids would grow up in the dark not knowing their planned life ahead of them until it eventually reached them. Although Miss Lucy told the children what lies ahead of them, they didn’t fully grasp it. I think that Miss Lucy didn’t intend to scare the children away and have them run off because they don’t like what their future is going to be for them, she just wanted to warn them with what will eventually come for them.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree when she said that Ruth is an attention seeker and villainous because, she kind of uses Kathy to get closer to Tommy. Because Kathy is good friends with Tommy.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Jackie saying miss Lucy had a battle with morality because she’s conflicted on feeling bad for the kids and wanting to do something to change these kids futures but she knows the impact these kids have on the world .

# data[].attributes.body
I disagree with the idea where Miss Lucy was told by people of “higher power” to tell Tommy about having to be creative. I feel like there is a bigger picture here meaning that I feel like Miss Lucy willingly told Tommy that his artwork was awful to PROTECT him from what’s coming. She has always been different from the other guardians and I feel like she wants to protect the children from what’s to come for them.

# data[].attributes.body
1. I agree with the idea that Ruth was holding on to the pillow the way she would with her memories, thinking about everything she lost.

2. I don’t think miss Lucy left willingly I think she got fired because she was saying too much information. She’s trying to let the kids know the truth but also protect them

# data[].attributes.body
Didn’t get to say

I also agree with how they referred “You’ve been told and not told” with how high school teachers always bought up that college is the most important factor to your future. Teachers made it seem like if you didn’t plan on going to college you can just start getting ready to give your resume to McDonald’s. Buts that’s false news. There are plenty of entrepreneurs who didn’t go to college. Take Bill Gates and Steve Jobs for example. They both dropped out of college and are way more successful than any collage grad. They went on to build billion-dollar owned companies. There are plenty of business owners out there who didn’t go to college and now are really successful and living their best lives. So saying college is the only way to be successful is just not accurate.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with klaudia, cadence and Roseanna, I think that miss Lucy struggles with the truth and tries to explain to them about their future but they just never understand

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with what Amir said I think that the Hailsham students are brainwashed and thats why Kathy thought the Miss. Lucy was different and maybe in her mind weird in a way. I think that this might also be the reason why Miss. Lucy is judged by the students because they were brainwashed.

# data[].attributes.body
I agreed with Amir when he was talking about Miss Lucy getting actually getting fired instead of leaving Hailsham, because she was just telling the kids too much that was going to happen to them. I thought that this was a really good point to make, at least a different point of view to think about why or how she left.

# data[].attributes.body
I’m not sure Madame is sympathetic for the students. She wouldn’t have reacted like the kids were spiders earlier in the book. I think it’s a possibility that Madame doesn’t want to get close to the students because she knows they won’t live long lives, or she is just simply scared of them because they aren’t normal and haven’t really experienced a normal life.

I agree that the students are not making a big deal about the idea of being donors, and not living long lives. They really just kind of brushed off what Miss Lucy had said to them. They might just not want to talk about it and live their best lives right now, or simply be brainwashed and think it’s normal.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree how school is designed and built in a way that makes you keep going all the way to college and how we are told that we need to go to be successful and kinda like brainwashing us to believe that school is the only way to make money and be successful

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with the idea of there being other places like hailsham. I remember a page in the book where Kathy refers to us as “you” which makes me wonder who she was talking to. She was talking about whether or not “you” had collections where “you” were from.

# data[].attributes.body
Madam was crying because she can’t do anything about Kathy not having kids and knowing that she might have been going throw the same things.

Yes I agree Kathy is higher up in the standings and she can be more than just a donor or she is a gold one that’s why people wanna find out more about her .

Mis Lucy feels bad and she needs to tell them what it is really about and she wants the students to find out what they are really going to be

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Anas saying that the reason they didn’t seem to not accept their future because they couldn’t do anything about it which I agree with because they’ve been at hailsham all this time I think deep down they already knew they’re future with all these hints and signs they’ve been getting.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree that the kids are kind of in denial about the future that’s set out for them because they don’t show that they’re bothered, they brush it off. It’s understandable as to why they respond to that information in that way because they’re still young and it’s not something normal regular kids go through so they don’t know how to react.

# data[].attributes.body
I would say that i agree with everything that was said there was a lot of talk about ms Lucy and telling the kids to much and I think ms Lucy did the right thing, i also really agree with the theam off loss or the fear of unknown. I feel like that’s the whole point to the title of never let me go. I also agree with the guardians build hailsham on half truths and the kids are brainwashed

# data[].attributes.body
I disagree with Madame being scared of getting close with the kids because when Kathy saw Madame crying, she said she still had that look of disgust in her eyes while she was crying, I don’t think that Madame even likes the kids so I don’t see why she would want to get close to them. I think she just genuinely felt bad about it.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree that ms lucy wants nothing but good for the kids and to inform them the best she can before she leaves hailsham so they know what’s coming in their future

# data[].attributes.body
Joslyn

I agree how she said that Ruth might have thought she was talking tommy in the movie when she was holding the pillow. But when Madame was crying i think it is because she is sad that they are leaving and Didn’t want to lose them because she knows there faith.

Cadence

I agree how she said that Ms.Lucy that wants to tell the kids what their life will be like after Hailsham. But the kids feel like they understand some of the things that will happen but dont have the full story. Or how the kids once they find out they don’t try to run away or get out of there.

# data[].attributes.body
You’ve been told and not told I agree that ms Lucy has a discomfort in the ways hailsham is ran and how the kids are not fully told the truth about their future because she wants them to have an actual understanding of their reality and future