# data[].attributes.body
"When you give a horse a job, he is protected," McKeever said. Carriage owners insist their horses are as healthy and happy as any in a well-run rural barn. (Source 1, Paragraph 11)

# data[].attributes.body
"Mayor Bill de Blasio already has declared his intention to shut down the industry, saying it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan" ( Source 1, Paragraph 2).

# data[].attributes.body
"When you give a horse a job, he is protected"

# data[].attributes.body
"Allie Feldman, executive director of New Yorkers for Clean, Livable and Safe Streets (NYCLASS), the main group fighting to abolish the horse carriages, scoffed at that. "Anybody who knows horses knows that horses don't need five consecutive weeks of vacation," she said. "They need daily turn-out. There's no pasture in Manhattan for these horses to go to. They live their lives between the shafts of the carriage and the shafts of their stalls. They don't have time to roll, to socialize, to graze."(Source 2,Paragraph 7).

# data[].attributes.body
All we want a horse to do is just give a nice walk through the park. It's relatively easy for the horses, and it's a good life for what I would call a working-class horse," he said, adding that draft horses bred to work would not do well if they spent their lives in pastures. "Their work is their exercise, and it gives them a purpose, and earns their keep," he said. (Source 2, Paragraph 6)

# data[].attributes.body
Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007.

"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like," de Blasio said last week during an appearance on Comedy Central's "The Daily Show." He has favored replacing the hansom cabs with old-timey electric cars.(Source 1 Paragraph 13 and 14)

# data[].attributes.body
"roughly 140,000 U.S. horses were shipped off to slaughterhouses in Canada and Mexico"(Source 1, Paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street"(Source 1, Paragraph 17).  :)

# data[].attributes.body
"Feldman said that horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets. She and other opponents also point to occasional accidents when carriage horses have bolted and to incidents of abusive treatment or neglect by owners." (Source 2, Paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like" (Source 1, Paragraph 14)

# data[].attributes.body
"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like"(Source 1, Paragraph 14).

# data[].attributes.body
"Incidents of abusive treatment or neglect by owners"(Source 2, Paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"Most live in one of four stables, hidden away inside old three-to-four-story buildings on Manhattan's far West Side. On days they work, the horses clop through city traffic, amid honking cabs, for up to 2 miles before reaching the spots where they line up for customers near Central Park. Most of the rides are in the park itself, but during some hours, the horses are allowed to visit a handful of other nearby attractions, such as Rockefeller Center." (Source 1, Paragraph 12). - unfair

"At the largest of the city's barns, Clinton Park Stables, the horses have enough room to lie down on beds of straw. They get regular visits from veterinarians and horse dentists. The building is equipped with sprinklers in case of fire". (Source 1, Paragraph 15). -fair

# data[].attributes.body
" "If you asked the horses, 'Do you want to be out in a mud paddock with no feed, standing in a snowstorm, or in a dark stall on the fourth floor of some building in New York City?', I'm not sure how'd they'd answer." (Source 1, Paragraph 20)

# data[].attributes.body
Feldman said that horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets. She and other opponents also point to occasional accidents when carriage horses have bolted and to incidents of abusive treatment or neglect by owners (Source 2, Paragraph 8)

# data[].attributes.body
its unfair because.     "Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years" (source 1, paragraph 13").

# data[].attributes.body
unfair:  "Most live in one of four stables, hidden away inside old three-to-four-story buildings on Manhattan's far West Side. On days they work, the horses clop through city traffic, amid honking cabs, for up to 2 miles before reaching the spots where they line up for customers near Central Park. Most of the rides are in the park itself, but during some hours, the horses are allowed to visit a handful of other nearby attractions, such as Rockefeller Center." (source 1, paragraph 12)
Fair: " Even people who don't necessarily take a carriage ride, just being near the horses on Central Park West gives people the opportunity to interact with them, to see how horses work in partnership with people." (source 2. paragraph 3)

# data[].attributes.body
" The industry, which employs about 300 people and 200 draft horses, is regulated by a myriad of animal-welfare rules. Horses may not be worked long hours or in very hot or cold weather, and must have regular veterinary check-ups. Each horse must also be sent for a five-week annual "vacation" in a Pennsylvania pasture."(Source 2,Paragraph 4).

# data[].attributes.body
its unfair because... "horses do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be like and what our society is like (source 1 paragraph 14).

# data[].attributes.body
It is unfair because...."Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007." (Source 1, Paragraph 13).

It is fair because....  "If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead" (Source 1, Paragraph 5

# data[].attributes.body
"Last year, roughly 140,000 U.S. horses were shipped off to slaughterhouses in Canada and Mexico when they became unenforceable, or unprofitable, for their owners" (source 1 paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007" (Source 1, Paragraph 13).

# data[].attributes.body
''it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan''(source 1, paragraph 2)

# data[].attributes.body
Every horse spends a minimum of five weeks each year at an out-of-town farm, but critics say that isn't enough for animals that would benefit from daily turnout in a pasture(source 1 , paragraph 18).

# data[].attributes.headline
michael "Anyone who cares about a horse wouldn't think that taking it and sticking it in midtown traffic is the right answer to that problem (source 1, para. 7).

# data[].attributes.subject
michael "Anyone who cares about a horse wouldn't think that taking it and sticking it in midtown traffic is the right answer to that problem (source 1, para. 7).

# data[].attributes.body
"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like,"(source 1, paragraph 14).

# data[].attributes.body
Feldman said that horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets(source 2 , paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"But there are drawbacks. The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street" (Source 1, Paragraph 17).

# data[].attributes.headline
michael "The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street (source 1, para. 17).

# data[].attributes.subject
michael "The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street (source 1, para. 17).

# data[].attributes.body
"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like," (Source 1, Paragraph 14).

# data[].attributes.headline
  (Source 1 Paragraph 5)"If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead,"

# data[].attributes.subject
  (Source 1 Paragraph 5)"If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead,"

# data[].attributes.body
- Jacqueline

# data[].attributes.body
"Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007" (Source 1, Paragraph 13).

# data[].attributes.body
"If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead," said Ian McKeever, an Irishman who owns nine Central Park horses and has been driving a carriage in the city since 1987.

# data[].attributes.headline
"They're not humane; they're not appropriate to the year 2014. It's over," De Blasio told a crowd last December" (source 2, paragraph 2 ).

# data[].attributes.subject
"They're not humane; they're not appropriate to the year 2014. It's over," De Blasio told a crowd last December" (source 2, paragraph 2 ).

# data[].attributes.body
Yishka Hylton

# data[].attributes.headline
(Source 1 Paragraph 2) "saying it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan."

# data[].attributes.subject
(Source 1 Paragraph 2) "saying it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan."

# data[].attributes.body
- Jacqueline

# data[].attributes.headline
  "Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007 (source 1 paragraph 13)."

# data[].attributes.subject
  "Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007 (source 1 paragraph 13)."

# data[].attributes.body
Payton

# data[].attributes.body
"The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street." ( Source 1, Paragraph 17).

# data[].attributes.body
Anybody who knows horses knows that horses don't need five consecutive weeks of vacation," she said. "They need daily turn-out. There's no pasture in Manhattan for these horses to go to. They live their lives between the shafts of the carriage and the shafts of their stalls. They don't have time to roll, to socialize, to graze."(source 2 paragraph 7.)

# data[].attributes.body
"Mayor Bill de Blasio already has declared his intention to shut down the industry, saying it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan."

# data[].attributes.body
horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets( source 2, Paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"...saying it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan."

{source 1, paragraph 2} -Tommy

# data[].attributes.body
"Anyone who cares about a horse wouldn't think that taking it and sticking it in midtown traffic is the right answer to that problem," said Allie Feldman"(Source 1,paragraph 7).

# data[].attributes.body
At the largest of the city's barns, Clinton Park Stables, the horses have enough room to lie down on beds of straw. They get regular visits from veterinarians and horse dentists. The building is equipped with sprinklers in case of fire (source 1, para 15)

# data[].attributes.body
"Horses do not belong in the middle of traffic in New York City. They do not belong in an urban environment like this. It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like," { source 1, paragraph 14} -Tommy

# data[].attributes.body
Every horse spends a minimum of five weeks each year at an out-of-town farm, but critics say that isn't enough for animals that would benefit from daily turnout in a pasture.(source 1 paragraph 18.)

# data[].attributes.body
"Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007"(Source 1, Paragraph 13).

# data[].attributes.body
"Anybody who knows horses knows that horses don't need five consecutive weeks of vacation," she said. "They need daily turn-out. There's no pasture in Manhattan for these horses to go to. They live their lives between the shafts of the carriage and the shafts of their stalls. They don't have time to roll, to socialize, to graze" (Source 2, Paragraph 7).

# data[].attributes.headline
  "If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead,"(source 1,paragraph 5)

# data[].attributes.subject
  "If they did not come to New York City, most of these horses would be dead,"(source 1,paragraph 5)

# data[].attributes.body
lynsey

# data[].attributes.body
"  Feldman said that horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets. She and other opponents also point to occasional accidents when carriage horses have bolted and to incidents of abusive treatment or neglect by owners".(source 2, paragraph 8)

# data[].attributes.body
Feldman said that horses inevitably suffer from the noise and unpredictability of congested city streets. She and other opponents also point to occasional accidents when carriage horses have bolted and to incidents of abusive treatment or neglect by owners. However, her group does not object to mounted police horses, although their conditions are similar. It also has not campaigned against the Aqueduct Race Track in the city, where at least ten horses have died in the last five years.(source 2, Paragraph 8).

# data[].attributes.body
"It's not safe for them. It's not fair when you think about what their lives should be and what our society is like,"  (source 1, Paragraph 14).

# data[].attributes.headline
 "The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street (source 1 paragraph 17)."

# data[].attributes.subject
 "The stables have no outdoor areas, so the horses must spend all of each day either in their stalls or in harness on the street (source 1 paragraph 17)."

# data[].attributes.body
Payton

# data[].attributes.body
"On days they work, the horses clop through city traffic, amid honking cabs, for up to 2 miles before reaching the spots where they line up for customers near Central Park" ( source 1, paragraph 12).

# data[].attributes.body
"On days they work, the horses clop through city traffic, amid honking cabs, for up to 2 miles before reaching the spots where they line up for customers near Central Park"(Source 1, Paragraph 12).

# data[].attributes.body
Mishaps involving horses that bolt or get hit by cars make headlines every few years, with the most recent traffic or spooking deaths in 2006 and 2007(source 1, paragraph 13)

# data[].attributes.headline
''it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan.''(source 1, paragraph 2)

# data[].attributes.subject
''it is inhumane to keep horses in modern-day Manhattan.''(source 1, paragraph 2)

# data[].attributes.body
lynsey