# data[].attributes.body
33 Jonas and Gabriel died.

46 Jonas and Gabe reached Elsewhere.

8 Other Ideas

Total 87

11 Missing Responses

# data[].attributes.body
9 Jonas and Gabriel died.

16 Jonas and Gabe reached Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
11 Jonas and Gabriel died.

8 Jonas and Gabe reached Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
8 Jonas and Gabriel died.

8 Jonas and Gabe reached Elsewhere.

3 Other Ideas

# data[].attributes.body
5 Jonas and Gabe died.

14 Jonas and Gabe made it to Elsewhere.

5 Other Ideas

# data[].attributes.body
Based on chapter 23 of "The Giver," I am inclined to believe that Jonas is still at the place where he is contemplating whether to continue persevering for himself and Gabriel, or to give up. Later at the end of this novel, Jonas supposedly makes it to another civilization with lights, music, and love after choosing to keep moving. However, at the end of this chapter, Jonas now realizes that he "had only thought he heard music... But perhaps it was only an echo" (Lowry 168). This leads me to believe that maybe earlier, Jonas had chosen the latter; drop the immobile bike into the snow and "to let himself and Gabriel slide into the softness of snow, the darkness of night, the warm comfort of sleep" (Lowry 65). If this is true, Jonas is lying in the snow, slowly dying, leaving Gabriel to die consequently.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the ending Jonas and Gabriel saw was just a part of their imagination. Instead, I believe they were slowly dying from starvation and the cold. In the book it says, "Jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright-" (Lowry 168). While Jonas was going down the hill, he was already slowly losing himself. Often, during the couple minutes before a person passes away they replay the happiest moments of their life. For example, Jonas replayed the memories of his closest friends/family and the memory of Christmas.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas received a piece of the giver's last memory since he had died. In previous chapters, The Giver had mentioned if a Receiver or Giver dies the memories will be spread slightly across the rest of the community. It was implied that he was released because in the text it states," when my work is finished, I want to be with my daughter" (152 Lowry). What he means by his daughter is Rosemary who has already been released previously. In addition, Jonas saw colored lights on trees hinting that he had found a remote village separate from the community because of the unique colors.

# data[].attributes.body
In the end of the Novel, The Giver, I think Jonas and Gabriel both died together. I know this because the book states "But he began, suddenly, to feel happy. He began to recall happy times." (Lowry 167) This shows how right after he pushed through the harsh snow, he started to remember his own memories, along with seeing ones he received from the Giver. In real life, it is said that once you die your memories play for 7 minutes before you actually rest. I think the author is showing us Jonas's memories and relief he feels thinking that he made it.

# data[].attributes.body
People would most likely go with the ending of Jonas and Gabriel making it to 'Elsewhere'. I, however, think this is false. The last moment in the book might be the last moment of Jonas' and Gabriel's life. In chapter 23, Jonas began to slowly crumble down as he is carrying Gabriel presumably up a mountain. But as he begins to fade, he suddenly receives a bright burst of hope as he remembers his good times with his family, friends, and The Giver. That warmth gave him strength to slowly but surely lift Gabriel and him up to the peak of the mountain, a little sled waiting for them. As the brothers slide down the snowy peak, Jonas begins to see what looks vaguely familiar to his Christmas memory. Alongside the happy memory, he begins to hear a sound he's heard very little about, but knows that it's a pleasant feeling - the sound of music. But as "The Giver" concludes its final chapter, it ends on a very peculiar note, its final words stating, "But perhaps it was only an echo." (168), implying that maybe Jonas and Gabriel didn't make it to elsewhere, and instead experienced one final memory - a memory representing what love truly means.

# data[].attributes.body
Gabriel and Jonas reached Elsewhere, which I think might be the world before Sameness, the world where the memories come from. Jonas says in the book that he was approaching "...the Elsewhere that held their future and their past." The memories come from the world in the past, but it could be that the world they think got buried in Sameness is actually still out there. My other guess is that it's a different community that rebelled against their Elders and received memories of life before sameness, and that's why they understand that Jonas and Gabriel are coming to them.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they found a community. One that excepts people for who they are. I also they are celebrating a holiday, because it says that there were red blue and yellow lights, because there are usually only lights during holidays. Also he said there was love, which means that they are a community more similar to ours.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that at the end Jonas and Gabriel found a place like the memories where there is no Sameness and no very strict rules and regulations. On page 167 it states, "Memories of joy flooded through him suddenly...'I remember this place, Gabe.'"

this shows that he remembers from some of his first memories the times of happiness and that they will be there, wherever "there" is.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabriel found an area without sameness past the mountain and lived with other people. I know this because the book "The Giver" states that there were people singing and that he saw there were lights that were Christmas colors. Jonas leaves around December 1st so he could have made it past the mountain around December 24th or 25th. This shows there were many people singing and celebrating indicating another society. In addition he heard music which he had never heard before so he was away from where sameness was used.

# data[].attributes.body
Towards the end, I think Jonas and Gabriel had died from the cold weather. From the last page of The Giver, it had stated, "For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people's singing. Behind him, across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo." The textual evidence at the end had convinced me that as Jonas's hope sparkled, the cold weather had eventually gotten to them. "But perhaps it was an echo", shows me both of them may have gotten too weak, where the music they heard had faded.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the ending of "The Giver" has something to do with events unfolding back at the community. At the end of the story, Jonas says he can hear music coming from the place he had left. I think it is possible Jonas is hearing beyond and hearing something from the community. I think it may symbolize freedom in the community. The people may have broken free using the memories given by Jonas when he left. I think it is also possible Jonas and Gabe were reliving one last happy memory.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel both died in the snow. Do to them not having a lot of food. They had to walk for days and on days which made him fell weak and hard for him to walk. When he saw the sled, he was probably hallucinated when he was walking for a long time. In the book The Giver, it shows us that “They finish the meager store of potatoes and carrots... now they were always hungry.” This shows us how they're going to starve and will soon start to have hallucinations and then died in the cold snow.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel die because in the book because it talks about them getting on a sled and riding it down a hill, and I think it's odd that there would just be a sled from one of his memories from a long time ago just sitting there in the same place. It also talks about how he knew that people would be waiting for him and Gabe, which to me, suggests that he might be going into the afterlife. The same thing goes for when it talks about him hearing music. Then, the very last paragraph is very thought-provoking and psychological, which reminded me of the confusion of death.

# data[].attributes.body
What I thought would happen to Jonas and Gabriel was that since they can hear music now, they can now experience what it feels like to be a normal human being with freedom instead of experiencing what people experience in the previous community that Jonas and Gabriel was in that had many strict rules. I know this because at the very end of the book, it states, "...he thought he had heard music too." (Lowry 168) This shows that there wasn't music in the community and now that Jonas and Gabriel had escaped, they can now hear music outside of the dystopian community.

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a new town and survived. I think this because in the end of the book, Jonas said he could see people. He said he saw them while he was sledding down the hill with Gabe. He also went through multiple weather and landscape changes such as hills, snow, and rough ground. Then, he made his own memory. This shows he made it out of the community and would no longer have to bear the pain of keeping others' memories to himself. These two reasons make me think that Jonas and Gabe survived and made it out of the dystopian society they were in before.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that what happened to Jonas and Gabriel at the end was them experiencing there last memory together. As they were on the sled, reaching there destination slowly they were fading away and dying. In the text it says, "Jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with hi whole being willed himself to stay upright atop the sled, clutching Gabriel, keeping him safe" (Lowry 168). This helped me come to a conclusion that giving their last bit of energy on the sled slowly they were dying together while finally reaching elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
My prediction on what happens to Jonas and Gabriel at the end of the book is that they both find elsewhere. I believe that when you find elsewhere, you live in your favorite memory. I think that it is different for Jonas than the rest of the community because Jonas has memories and the community does not. the community probably goes to darkness or one of the memories they received when the old receiver, rosemary, got released. My evidence from the passage on why I believe that you live in your favorite memory when you go to elsewhere is "He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love." (Lowry 168). This piece of evidence from the passage shows that Jonas' favorite memory was Christmas and joy and happiness.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel are still alive at the end of the story. At the end of the story it talks about them finding Christmas lights and people singing. You can connect this to the holiday Christmas and the memory Jonas received about it. Jonas also talks about how the people had a spot ready for him and Gabriel. In the book The Giver it states "Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby" This improves my hypothesis because it shows how Jonas believes that they are waiting for him and shows that he thinks that him and Gabriel are Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas reaches the elsewhere with Gabriel. I know this because it states "they sped in a straight line through and incision that seemed to lead to the final destination, the place that he had always felt was waiting, the elsewhere... He forced his eyes open as they went downward, and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby." (Lowry 168) This setting conveys the lights and music preceive that their is a Christmas town in the elsewhere, the memory that giver gave the dream about. A place in a new community with warmth and a new beginning, that is the elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
Jonas made it elsewhere with Gabe and lived through the snow storm. I still think he had a hallucination about the Music and all that other stuff but I think through everything they made it to their destination.

# data[].attributes.body
I think the Jonas and Gabriel made it to Elsewhere.I think this is because they heard the music and saw the light and color and left sameness. In the last page of ,"The GIVER" the author explains,"For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music.He heard people singing." This shows Jonas and Gabriel reaching Elsewhere by hearing people singing and music.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel survive and live in the new community. This is because on the last page, Lois Lowry creates a hopeful and optimistic tone by writing "For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing." This shows that they have reached Elsewhere and hear the people singing and having a good time, creating an positive tone, making me think that they survive and are saved by the people of Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
At the end of the book, I think Jonas and Gabriel survived. I believe this because the details in the book tell me that, he found a sled and a saw people. This shows that he survived because he went through multiple weather changes that do not happen in the community. Another reason they survived is because Jonas and Gabe saw people at the end of the hill playing and singing music which also doesn't happen in the community. I almost believed that it was a dream because snow was a memory and could've happened in the dream, but rain. Rain wasn't a memory that Jonas was given meaning he had to escape the community to really feel the weather of rain and he did.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabe had passed away at the end. In chapter 23, it mentions him reliving his happiest memories of everyone he cherished, and it's scientifically proven that your brain will replay your best memories for 7 minutes until your death. He also describes the experience while he slid down the hills as he loses his conscious, which people do when their losing their life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they make it around Christmas time, since when they got towards the end it started snowing. and when they started going down hill they heard music. but Jonas ether passes out from exhaustion or dies since the text states, "jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright atop the sled, clutching Gabriel, keeping him safe. the runners sliced through the snow and the wind whipped at his face as they sped in a straight line through an incision that seemed to lead the final waiting, the elsewhere that held their past...for the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music." this explains to us that as he was heading down, losing his consciousness he did see elsewhere and knew that he made it threw everything. he might of passed out because if he did die, he would feel himself getting even more weak than he already was. but my theory is he made it, but passed out.

# data[].attributes.body
I Think that Jonas and Gabriel at the end of the story the giver found a city and its Christmas time in the city. I think this because in the story it states that "He Knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were red, blue , and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love.". Many people accociate colors of red, blue, and yellow with Christmas that quote shows hey a sliding into somewhere were Christmas is happening and there is people where there are sliding into.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabriel reach Elsewhere which turns out to be the world we live in, with music and color and all of the emotions we experience. I think this because in chapter 20, the Giver talks about hearing music before seeing color, and he says that he will give Jonas some music before he leaves. Jonas never gets to hear music, but then, at the end of the book, the author writes, "...he[Jonas] thought he heard music too." Maybe this is because he has entered our world, feeling joy and happiness, hearing music.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the Giver died. In the book it says, "he heard something that was known to be music. He heard people singing. Behind him. from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo." (Lowry 168). Since Jonas had never received the memory of music, he wouldn't of known of what he heard. The only way for him to receive music is from the Giver, transferring it to him. Though another way for memories to be released, is when the person who holds it dies.

# data[].attributes.body
I think what happens to Gabriel and Jones at the end was them reliving their past memories and then dying at the end. I think this is what happened because in the book it shows him reaching a memory he got from the giver. The memory was him on the sled going down, and he had to climb up to read that elsewhere. Gabriel and Jones go down the sled where they were before going up. Based on the book it states,"But perhaps it was only an echo." This shows these might just be a memory and actually did not happen. Then I infer it was he reliving his memory.

# data[].attributes.body
I think what happened at the end of the giver was Jonas being on the last grip of life with Gabriel as they share one last memory to keep for themselves. The memory the giver gave of being on the sled, going down the hill and Jonas's memory he truly wanted to feel most was love. Before the brink of death he holds onto that memory sharing it to Gabe one last time with him, closing his eyes imagining it. Elsewhere was him and Gabriel passing away with their memories to keep, and passing peacefully at the thought of love with the both of them. Twinkling lights, and the music. Music was one of the things the giver never gave him, so when going through the last memories together, maybe it was just an echo?

# data[].attributes.body
I believe Jonas and Gabe were dying at the end because it says when a receiver is released/dies the memories all go out into the community so I think as he was dying he was reliving his favorite memories like the sledding and love of a Christmas day as they were released into the community as he passed away.

# data[].attributes.body
In the end of the story I think that Jonas begins hallucinating, a sign that maybe he is starting to die. I think this because the end of the book gives the feeling of finish or ending.

# data[].attributes.body
DEATH, I think they dead. For one he felt warmth and happiness which is what happens right before the human body dies from the cold. (Honestly I have no idea, Im guessing)

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabe died in the end. I believe that they died because when Jonas and Gabe were on the sled they were going downward very fast. And in one of the memories Jonas received from the Giver, he was going down a snowy hill on a sled and crashed. So, I think that in the end Jonas and Gabe died in order to reach elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel died because before he got to the top of the hill, he felt happiness. I think that when he started to die, he tried to think of all his happiness. He also saw the sled, but how can there be a sled in the middle of nowhere? I think he started hallucinating and hearing music. In the end, it also says, "But perhaps it was only an echo"(Lowry 168). This is hinting that everything he "sees" is an echo.

# data[].attributes.body
I wonder If Gabriel and Jonas died at the end of the story. In the last bits of the story Jonas became very desperate with the memories. He started transmitting memories of warmth, feasts, and banquets to him and Gabriel. This makes me think that they died because Jonas was doing everything they could to make them stay alive. But in the very last part he became happy and went through the memories of happiness that the Giver gave him. Why would he be happy and be going through his happiest memories in life if he was not dying? "But he began, suddenly, to feel happy. He began to recall happy times."

# data[].attributes.body
I think what happens to Jonas and Gabriel at the end is something truly amazing, they experience hope and happiness as they find the light and love in Jonas's memories. I think this because he had the feeling that Elsewhere was near and that they would be safe. In the book "The Giver" it states that the Giver said to Jonas once he reaches Elsewhere he will know by hearing music, the rush of all the happy memories coming to him, and maybe the distant voice of The Giver. So Jonas and Gabriel have reached hope, they are alive, and maybe the narrator has something more in store later for Jonas and Gabriel.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that in the end, he starts to reminiscent all the memory he was given because he had reached beyond. All the memory's were escaping and going back to the people. Before Jonas had left the giver had stated when rosemary left all the memory's she had came back to the community when she had reached beyond and she likely experienced what Jonas had. So when the memory's left her she had one final moment to imagine them before they left, like with Jonas he started to imagine them and when they left it was gone, "But perhaps it was only an echo."(Lowry 168)

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that at the end of the book Jonas was having a hallucination as he reached the end of his journey to elsewhere. In the book it talks about him seeing the light through windows, twinkling lights from trees, people singing, and snowy atmosphere. I think that Jonas was living out his first and favorite memory that the Giver gave him, but it was a sign of happiness because he finally reached elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel didn't die because they survived and reached Elsewhere. In the book, Elsewhere is a real place and people know about it. This means that Jonas did in fact survive and reach another community. It also talks about how he heard music and saw lights in colors. This means that he probably survived to see and hear these things. My final guess is that he passed out after he reached the new community. He must've had barely enough strength left to be conscious before he passed out.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that at the end of the giver that both Jonas and Gabe find die and he relives his first memory he ever received. I think this because if it wasn't a memory why would the sled just be sitting at the top of the hill. this suggests that he dies recalling his first ever memory he recived

# data[].attributes.body
At the end of the story Jonas and Gabriel ride on a sled down a hill towards a town, and I think the Giver died because earlier in the story he had said that when his work was done he wanted to be with Rosemary, and as he was the only person with the memory of music, Jonas would not have known what it was unless the Giver gave it to him. This also would imply that the community has learned to live with the memories even if some of them are painful, and that the community now is wiser as a whole.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel died. in the text, when they are on the sled, Jonas goes unconscious and hears music. I think this is him dying and maybe going to heaven because why would he be hearing these things. I think since he passed out he and Gabriel died of starvation and crashing into a tree when Jonas passed out.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they are both dead because that's the only reasonable ending, how would they survive if he was in a state like that and even if he survived he would have to go back and that's impossible.

# data[].attributes.body
In the end of The Giver, I think Jonas starts to loose consciousness and drift off into death because the text explains how he tries to "stay awake" at the beginning and keep pushing. But he keeps recalling things from his memories and seems to think they are real like the lights on Christmas morning. The text proves this when it states, "For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music... But perhaps it was only an echo," (Lowry 168). From this we can infer that the sound of music was only and illusion meaning the the rest of the sights had to be an illusion as well; making me wonder if Jonas had already went unconscious at the top of the hill and the sled ride was all a "dream". So the time he actually died was when the music ended.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that at the end of the story, when Jonas finally reaches elsewhere, he was slowly dying. I know this because when the book states, "Memories of joy flooded through him suddenly." (Lowry 167) this examples his last few minutes of living. It has been scientifically proven that when a person is on the verge of dying, their brain projects their happiest times of life. In a moment of freezing to death, Jonas's brain shows his moments of joy to let him die happily.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel find a new community or village at the end of the book. The book quotes, "... there were red, blue, and yellow lights... he heard something he knew to be music." (Lowry 168). The lights show that there is something among them and that could be a village. The music could also be a celebration along with the twinkling lights which could bring hope to Jonas and Gabe. Communities, villages, cities, ect. all can have celebrations and lights and music.

# data[].attributes.body
Jonas and Gabriel passed away because in the text the author describes Jonas and Gabriel's life depleting. In the text " The Giver", it states," He felt his face begin to glow and the tense, the cold skin of his arms and hands relax." ( Lowry 165 )

# data[].attributes.body
I think they found a town, during Christmas time, and saw a home with a family in it that could take both Jonas and Gabe in. I know this because of the text clues Lois Lowry gave to us in the last 3 paragraphs of page 168, "...and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love...Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting, too, for the baby."

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that in The Giver, Gabriel and Jonas both die and their lives were flashing before their eyes. First, they remembered the good times they had at the community and then saw flashing lights about the memories they both got from The Giver. Jonas feels love because he always wanted to feel love so that is why the memory he saw before he died was Christmas for him. And then Jonas felt hope that the community also feels the same way Jonas feels, love and happiness, and feelings.

# data[].attributes.body
What I think that happens to Jonas and Gabriel is that Jonas is imagining a scenario because he is so much pain just like how he used the memories of warmth to keep him and Gabriel from the cold. I know this because in the book it says, "..he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only a echo" (168 Lowry). This shows that he thought the scene was real but it faded away like an echo because it was never true.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel have now moved on into elsewhere, which is truly the afterlife. I think they died because of the last couple lines of the book. "For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing...But perhaps it was only an echo." (Lowry 168). I think this shows that Jonas is reminiscing and hallucinating his favorite memories from the giver. I believe this because the final pages combines some of Jonas' memories. For example, it includes sledding and love. The line about the echoes proves that the music was all in his head as a final memory in his life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think in the end of "The Giver" Jonas and Gabriel actually die of everything that was happening like the starvation and the weather that they've never experienced before, and at the end where he sees all the lights and hears everything, it says right before that he was losing consciousness so he began hallucinating before he passed away.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabriel were taken in and experienced things that they hadn't before. According to text, it says," Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him: and that they were waiting, too, for the baby. For the first time, he heard something that he knew was music." This shows that people were waiting for the. If people wait for you they will take you in. Also they heard music and they didn't hear that in the community. Therefore I believe that Jonas and Gabriel experienced new things and were taken in.

# data[].attributes.body
Jonas was dreaming that he escaped to a secure and joyful place because, it states "Behind him across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo." (Lowry 168) this shows that it could have been a dream because, it was perhaps and echo.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel did escape the community. They saw colors that they couldn't see in the community and also saw people celebrating love. They heard people singing and music. Jonas recognizes the place where he had been before.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabriel reach their destination; a new community with people waiting for them. As stated, "Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting too, for the baby" (Lowry 168). Jonas heard music, and people singing, which shows a sign that they have made it after countless days of rain and snow.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that the ending to The Giver, is Jonas and Gabriel slowly die on the hill. During the time he was walking up the hill the book stated that Jonas became happy and remember all of his family and friends, and the best memories he had, and usually in real life, that happens to us humans too. The book also stated that he tried to keep his eyes open, while also trying to stay upright while losing consciousness. The one thing Jonas wanted was to be able to have feelings and love, which is what he felt right at the end of the book before the line " But perhaps it was only an echo."

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel die at the end. I think this because I remember hearing that scientist found out that when someone dies their brain replays their best moments in life and I think this is what is happening to Jonas since he is the only character who we know of his thoughts and feelings, and we know that the memory of Christmas was one of his best and favorites.

# data[].attributes.body
At the end of the book I think that Jonas and Gabriel end up getting to be in a community that is normal celebrating a holiday Christmas and that the new community that they discovered may not also value all of the other things that their former community had valued also not in as much control. I know this because in the book it says, " ...they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love" (Lowry 168). This supports my answer because it talks about the familes celebrating Christmas Even though the other community didn't celebrate it.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel reach a place where they are free and are not controlled like they were in their community. I know this because when they are sledding down the hill their is lights and people singing and their is family and love which was not a thing in their community.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that in the end, the hill led Gabriel and Jonas back to the community, but the community had changed. My evidence for this is that when Jonas was begging the Giver to go with him to find elsewhere, the Giver had said he wanted to stay with his daughter, but he also stated that he wanted to make the community whole. Maybe the Giver accomplished his goal and changed the community.

# data[].attributes.body
I think in the ending Jonas and Gabriel are saved because it says in the book that there is lights and people singing and when they see the 2 of them they are gonna give them food and help them. So I think they all survive.

# data[].attributes.body
In the end, I think Jonas lost consciousness and the sled, music, and lights might have all just been memories. Gabriel might have also passed out or even away. "...he could barely move his freezing, tired legs. But he began, suddenly, to feel happy" (Lowry 167). He was using his final strength, yet he was suddenly remembering happy times, which could be what his brain is doing before he passes away. Gabriel was beside him, and the ending doesn't describe him moving or doing anything as the book ends. Jonas was also remembering not only the memories he received, but his own special memories, too. He was forcing his eyes open and freezing so harshly that he was numb, but suddenly he felt joy and remembered memories that he once only had a wisp of.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel both fell unconscious to the hypothermia dying but what Jonas witnesses is probably a hallucination. I think this as it was very random for there to be a random sled at the top of the hill to be waiting for them and it isn't realistic. Also, no regular human can survive the conditions that they were in as they were very numb, could barely move and was very weak. He was recalling happy times as well which could be a sign of his life flashing behind his eyes. Finally, the strongest piece of evidence is in the final sentence when he says perhaps it was only an echo signaling that everything was a figment of his imagination

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas is hallucinating. Why is think this is because Jonas was cold, weak, and starving, so I feel that he was dreaming of what he wished to happen. In chapter 22, it states, "He cried because he was hungry and cold and terribly weak" (Lowry 163). This show that Jonas may have been thinking about what he wished would have happened since he and Gabriel were suffering. And I think when he was going down the sled and Christmas and music, he was only thinking about the memories he loved.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that at the end of "The Giver", Jonas and Gabriel sled down the hill and are accepted into the new community "elsewhere". This is mainly because of the sled Jonas finds, meaning that whatever place Jonas is attempting to reach allows for those types of items that his old community did not, meaning that this new community has choice and less censorship. As he sleds down, he hears music and singing as well, furthermore hinting that elsewhere allows previously censored things to be encouraged and accepted. As he reaches the bottom, Jonas feels hope and happiness as he notices bright lights and colors, with hope that the people below are waiting for him and Gabriel and they both will be saved.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Gabriel and Jonas are going to be accepted into the community. It will be many changes for the both of them, but they will get used to it quickly without following all of the strict rules they had before. Here in the new community, they have freedom, and can live their life how they want to. I think they will both like experiencing the real world. In "The Giver", the author states, "...and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love. Downard, downward, faster, and faster. Suddenly he was aware with certainly and joy that below, ahead, they were wating for him.." (Lowry 168). This quote shows how Gabe and Jonas were already filled with joy, feeling the warmth of the feelings and holidays they have entered. I think they are really going to like the real world and experience joy.

# data[].attributes.body
In the end, I think Jonas and Gabriel began to lose consciousness when he saw the sled. It is very much possible that seeing the sled was not a coincidence but at his state and mind, he most definitely could be hallucinating. He also started to hear music and see windows shining in bright colors on trees. He was cold and starving and "felt himself losing consciousness... (Lowry 168). His starvation could cause him to start hallucinating.

# data[].attributes.body
I think what happened at the end was Jonas felt so much hope of reaching a community, that he imagined warmth and music and the sled for himself. I think he was so desperate and so weak, that he made a new reality with his memories. In the last page of The Giver, there was so much buildup, and so much hope for himself at the end, and Jonas thought that he was warm, and music was around him. In ''The Giver'' by Lois Lowry, it says "But perhaps it was only an echo'' (168). This piece of evidence shows that obviously there was no music, and no warmth. This shows that in the end, he was not able to reach a new community.

# data[].attributes.body
In The Giver, I think that Jonas and Gabriel reached a town celebrating Christmas. I know this because in the book it states, "that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love." (Lois 168). This indicates that they are having a party of some sort.

# data[].attributes.body
I think in the ending of The Giver, Jonas hallucinated the memory of the village that celebrated love. It is stated that "He forced his eyes open... But perhaps it was only an echo." (Lowry 168). I think this means that while he was sledding down, he was thinking of the memory that the Giver gave him of Christmas, which led him to hallucinate a town celebrating it. Also, the last sentence says that it could have all been an echo meaning it might have been his imagination.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabe will not make it to elsewhere because he is so tired and weak, so how is he going to carry himself and Gabe. And how is he going to feed both of them because of the snow, there won't be a lot of food, not a lot of easy food. It is also extremely cold in the place he is at, including the large amount of snow he is describing. I think he isn't going to make it.

# data[].attributes.body
After they get off of the sled I think that they will knock on the door of the house and the people will see that they are in need and then they will basically adopt him and Gabriel. Then I think that something happens with him getting way more memories and his will go into the community causing panic and calmness because of the good and bad memories. And then they will rey to escape and the chief elder will go crazy because maybe she didn't know about all of this. Does the committee have answers. A piece of textual evidence to support this is on the very last page of the book where the author of The Giver states that that he could hear music and see lights and he thought he could hear the echo of the people in the community. This is showing the chayos that will happen in the community.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Gabriel and Jonas slide down the hill and realized there was nothing there. That everything they saw and heard was all a memory the Giver gave to Jonas. The author states "But perhaps it was only a echo" (Lowry 168). This evidence suggests the music and lights could of been only a echo. This leads me to conclude that the echo was from the memory and not real life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel made it to a family celebrating Christmas. This is because in the book it said that he heard music. It also says that he saw sparkling lights. Jonas also said that he recognized the sparkling lights and music from his memory's.

# data[].attributes.body
I think what proceeds to happen next is the people that Jonas perceives to be present discover Jonas and Gabriel and take care of them. However, when they do find him, Jonas' condition has already been pronounced as obsolete given that he's not able to form complete thoughts by the end of the book. "Behind him, across vast distances of space and time, form the place he had left, he thought he has heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo." (Lowry 168)

This indicates that Jonas isn't in the right state to draw conclusions because he is unsure whether he's actually apprehending music.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they reach elsewhere at the end of the book and that they did reach a place where there was music

# data[].attributes.body
I think they were able to find a Christmas resort and they might have found some regular people that could help them. I think this because the text shows that Jonas saw red, blue and yellow lights on some trees, and heard music, so this makes me think that they found some people and they were able to find a warm space for the both of them.

# data[].attributes.body
There are many possibilities of what could have happened to Jonas and Gabriel at the end of the story. Due to some clues in the book I think that Jonas and Gabriel found elsewhere, a place where they could feel love. Towards the end of the book it tells us the Jonas see lights of different colors, hears music and is in the presence of snow. This makes me think that they arrived in a place that is celebrating Christmas. The memory of the family around a tree opening presents seem to be familiar with the scenery at the end of the book. I think that they will be found by a caring family who will take them in and care for them. They will gain a true sense of family and love.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that in the end Jonas was going through a memory of the holiday and he heard the singing but it wasn't actually real. I think that he will blink and come back to reality only to realize that there was no one waiting for him and he was alone in the elsewhere. I can infer this because in the giver it states, ".. he thought he heard music too. but perhaps it was only an echo" (Lowry 168) this quote shows that jonas thought he heard singing and music but it was just a dream or a memory.

# data[].attributes.body
They continue sliding down the hill where there is a dome over top. They walk through this dome and right in front of them is a cabin playing this music. This cabin will have the same family in it from the memory of family that Jonas had previously received from the Giver. Once he passes through the dome all of the memories that both him and Gabe have will be transferred into the community, along with themselves re-entering the community. Everyone will have their own memories and memories of the past.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel will feel like this push of like force and then will slide through into the real world. It will soon then come to Jonas as he realizes they have been living in a dome. Jonas and Gabe will start to walk and here more music and houses with a firery

glow inside with colorful lights around a tree. He will then remember this memory that was given to him by the receiver. He will see that this is Christmas.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabriel reached elsewhere because they heard the singing of people and he saw lights before he blacked out. One quote in the "Giver" is "For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing"(Lowry, p168). This backs my evidence by showing that they had reached a place of happiness and singing and colors.

# data[].attributes.body
Earls, Ja'mez

I think that Gabriel and Jonas end up running to more people celebrating Christmas and I know this because he ends up seeing lights, Christmas lights and then all of a sudden he hears music and he starts to get happier and he was telling Gabe that they were there and not to worry anymore. But I also think that when the new community sees them and Jonas tries to explain where they came from and how they got there.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that what will happen is that people are going to find Gabriel and Jonas, and will let them celebrate Christmas with them for the first time. This is because during Christmas everyone Is cheerful and happy so I feel like if there where kids on the streets they would try to help them by at least getting them a place to stay, and by giving them food, then taking them to an Adoption center where they can get a home.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas and Gabriel almost die but the people in elsewhere find them and help them. Then, I think they are gonna accept them into their lives and Jonas will create his own family. I know this because at the end it said there were lights on trees, and music, and snow which indicates it is Christmas which means there are people there.