# data[].attributes.body
In the boat by Mcleod conveys that tradition and comfort clashes for tradition gives a sense of belonging but it also forces one to sacrifice their desires and vice versa if one gives up following tradition in order to follow their desires they long for it.

Evidence: The father who works as a fishermen follows the tradition of the men being the providers even if it means giving up his dreams. He longs to study and go to university but in order to do that he would be going against society's expectations

Evidence 2: The son who's comfort is with books and the school but this clashes with his mother's beliefs.

When he grew older he became a professor meaning that he went against tradition but there was still lingering feelings of guilt for not following his fathers footsteps.

# data[].attributes.body
The Boat by Allistair Macleod represents that at times some people tend to prioritize their desires leaving a familiar place, and others want routine and to stay in one spot. Both finding comfort in their choice but longing for something more.

In the narrator's case, he leaves home to live his own life as a professor. He still yearns for his mother's approval, his father and supporting his family, but finds comfort in being independent and educated.

The mother finds comfort in being traditional, staying by the water her whole life. She longs to keep the family together, and pushes her values onto them.

# data[].attributes.headline
Rediet Alana's Thesis in response to the question

# data[].attributes.subject
Rediet Alana's Thesis in response to the question

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story "The Boat" by Alistair Macleod shows comfort isn’t always the place you’re from; if the shore life doesn’t fit you, you make comfort inside yourself, but you still end up missing home. some people feel safe in routine, others need a private space to breathe, and the hard part is you can win freedom and still carry the ache.

Evidence 1 - the dad is most at peace in his room with his books and radio, because the boat work wears him down, so his real comfort is the private world he builds, not the shore routine. he keeps fishing anyway to feed the family, which proves the shore is duty, not joy, for him. when he tells his son to go back to school, he’s basically saying real comfort comes from choosing a life that fits your mind.

Evidence 2- the son feels steady when he works beside his dad that one good summer, but later he moves away and keeps early morning habits to calm his feelings, which shows he didn’t fit the shore life and had to make his own inner comfort. his new job is safe and normal, but he still acts like the day starts before dawn, like the sea is still in his head. that means leaving didn’t erase the place, it just turned it into a feeling he carries. his comfort ends up being a mix of memory, small routines, and the love he had with his dad.

Evidence 3- The mom: she lives by the sea’s rules and feels safe there. the kitchen window “faced the sea,” she trusts what the sea gives and hates anything that tries to change the pattern, like tourists, books, or city life. for her, comfort equals order and loyalty, which is why she pushes back when her kids drift away.

# data[].attributes.body
in the Short story “the boat” by Alistair McLeod, the dad is basically really attached to his little fishing village. Even though his life is really tough and the could have an easier time somewhere else, he just can’t leave. Macleod is trying to say that a sense of place isn’t just about where you live. it’s tied to your identity, your family history, and the sacrifices you make. the dads whole life and even his death show that for some people, stying in one place is so important that leaving would feel like losing who they are.

evidence- the dads hands are a strong symbol of his life. They are calloused (basically hands of a worker) form all the years working fishing. showing that he’s identity is almost tied to his work and home, I think for him comfort is not about escaping the hard work that he has to do, but about the physical proof of his effort.

the mom says a things that shows the dads loyalty, something similar to “he will kill himself for the place” (I’m not sure about that quote:) shows she sees his life as a sacrifice. him not stop working with the boat, proves his comfort comes from his loyalty to the place that defines him, and his heritage, not from having an easy life.

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story "The Boat" by Alistair MacLeod, the author suggests that an individual may force themselves to sacrifice their own comfort and desires for validation and a sense of belonging within their family, which ultimately leaves them feeling hopeless and bound to a life of misery.

Evidence: The father works as a fisherman and is forced to give up his dreams of becoming a scholar, for the purpose of providing for his family, continuing the family tradition, and approval from within his community. It is believed that the father commits suicide in the end to free his children from the burden of living a life they don't want. It is said that he had "brass chains on his wrist" when he was found, symbolizing that even in death, he still feels trapped living a life he never wanted and still yearns for an education and freedom.

Evidence: The mother is very traditional and forces her way of life on her entire family, although almost all of them don't want to live a traditional lifestyle. This ultimately causes her to live a life of poverty and loneliness. Her own bitterness and desire to live a traditional lifestyle caused her to lose the comfort of having a family.

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis: In the short story "The Boat" by Alistair Macleod suggest that a person's need for longing and comfort with a sense of place is compromised by tension between personal freedom and tradition; although familial expectations may give one a sense of belonging, true comfort comes only when one attempts to reconcile duty with personal identity.

Evidence #1: The father, despite his attachment to the sea, sleeps not at nights but reads books, which signifies his quite wish for a world away from the fishing life. This is a witness to his inner struggle: he belongs to the sea but aspires for a place of convenience and intellectual satisfaction other than it.

Evidence #2: The narrator gives up fishing in favor of education and breaks away from the family tradition. His decision demonstrates how an individual finds comfort in building a new sense of place is agreeable to individual desires and not inherited desires.

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story "The Boat" by Alistair McLeod, the author gives insight about how the fathers longing for comfort can be destroyed by the responsibilities of the sea.

He loses comfort through the clothes that he wears which strangle him as if he's being choked into a life molded by responsibilities he does not want. His boots dragged through the pebbles of the beach as he "trudged from the wharf showing how exhausting his responsibilities are.

The author mentioned that his fathers body was not loved by the sea, due to his reddish complexion, while the salt water irritated his skin and he burned all over. He was never intended to be a fishermen physically and mentally since he's never loved it. He stated that he always wanted to go to university but never did due to the circumstances of his wife and children.

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story "The Boat", the narrator highlights the struggle people often face to pursue their personal dreams while being confined by generational traditions.

the father had dreamed of pursuing further education driven by his love of literature. Due to his family's economical dependency on fishing, he ultimately sacrifices his personal dreams to become a fisherman to support his family. His wife holds this standard of him and their children, which she ends up restricting them to pursue any education. This conflicting decision can often lead to unfulfillment and resentment.

the son, like his father, also dreams of a higher education. But due to traditional expectations, he feels stuck from making the decision to stay with his family on the island or to leave the island and focus on education. His father had quietly supported this.

# data[].attributes.body
The short story "The Boat" by Alistair Macleod shows the difficulties between choosing whether to pursue a path where you find comfort in, but having a connection in a place where you feel dispirited in. Allowing us to see the complications with choosing passion over obligation.

Evidence: The narrator for this short story tells us about his family being traditional and them wanting him to follow the same path, but with him he wanted to go to school and stir away from becoming a fisherman, which was looked down on especially by his mother, this opened up a feeling in him, the feeling of guilt but with his fathers help, his fathers dreams it allowed the narrator to move on to a path where he follows his passion rather than living a life of discomfort.

# data[].attributes.body
In Alistair MacLeod's short story The Boat, the son aspires to become something greater than what his current life offers. He longs for a more comfortable life but struggles with whether to live for himself or for others, reflecting the universal conflict between personal dreams and family responsibilities.

evidence 1 - he loves his father, but he doesn't want to end up like him. He admits that reading gave him “a world elsewhere” no matter how tied he is to the obligations of the sea.

evidence 2 - fishing, even when with the father on his side, drains him mentally and physically as opposed to doing what he loves, which involves books

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis - In Alistair MacLeod’s “The Boat,” the struggle between personal goals and familial expectations is key to the son’s reflection on himself. The story highlights how individuals who attempt to break free from traditional roles, like the family’s fishing, must often go through internal conflict. Through his father’s quiet protest against fishing and his son’s decision to pursue education, the author suggests that living free by rule, needs not only courage but also the willingness to face loss and guilt. Overall, the story shows that personal freedom is deeply significant, but it often comes at the cost of belonging and feeling guilt.

Evidence - The father is conflicted between fishing and supporting his family and his love for books and knowledge. The father spends nights alone reading, proving how disconnected he is from his reality. The son, like his father, is stuck between family loyalty and pursuing education. Feeling guilty, he follows his path towards education and ultimately becomes a teacher. The narrator admits he feels selfish for leaving his family behind, but realizes without his father's sacrifices and his mother's loyalty to tradition, he would not have been able to pursue his passion.

# data[].attributes.headline
Paul Briobo's Thesis In Response To The Question

# data[].attributes.subject
Paul Briobo's Thesis In Response To The Question

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis Statement: In Alistair MacLeod’s The Boat, the narrator’s conflict between his tradition and his own desire for education. Evokes an image that an individual’s longing for comfort with a sense of place is never simple, as it can require balancing tradition with the pursuit of personal freedom to feel like they have a sense of place.

Evidence:

In Alistair MacLeod’s The Boat, the narrator struggles between his family’s expectations and his own dreams. His father works long, tiring days at sea, but finds escape in books, wanting a life beyond the sea. His mother, however, wants her children to stay tied to tradition, which leaves the narrator torn between tradition and independence. When he chooses to go to university, he honours his father’s sacrifice while stepping into his own future, showing that finding comfort with a sense of place often means balancing heritage with personal freedom.

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis: In "The Boat" Alistair McLeod suggests that an individual's longing for comfort is tied to a sense of place, as physical spaces and everyday environment offer a sense of familiarity and safety even with conflicts of everyday life and personal responsibility.

Evidence: The father find comfort in his room although trapped by responsibility to family life and work. He finds time to read in his space which connects him to his long forgotten dreams.

Evidence: The mother is a great example as she is strictly about tradition her comforts come from her beliefs. She choses to stay in a house filled with despair rather than experience the world as it is. Her tradition is her sanctuary.

# data[].attributes.headline
Thesis statement/ evidence: Chisom Akunne

# data[].attributes.subject
Thesis statement/ evidence: Chisom Akunne

# data[].attributes.body
In the Short Story "The Boat" by Alistair MacLeod, the narrator suggests that a sense of place is a yearning that provides comfort and the feeling of home, free from the traditions of life.

Evidence 1:

Father's love of books when he stays up at night reading his books, free from the sea

Evidence 2 :

The father shares his comfort with his books, passing them down to his children to share the love that comes with intelligence.

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis: In The Boat Alistair MacLeod shows how people can feel torn between responsibility and their true passions which can make them feel stuck.

Evidence: The dad works as a fisherman to support his family but what he really loves is reading and learning after long days on the sea he stays up at night with a book and the narrator says the light from his cabin this shows that although he lives the life of a fisherman his heart belongs to books.

# data[].attributes.body
in life we have a deep routed desire to fit in with our family traditions that have been set in place for us, rather then interest we would rather follow in life tearing us between choosing whats expected of us versus what we desire.

evidence- our unnamed author has struggles with the life on the boat versus his teaching job feeling torn between family and his path, he finds that it was meant to be tradition to be followed but it wasnt suited for him so he departed but still has the guilt following him about walking away. he wants to forget about the past and move forward however it haunts him in a sort of way

# data[].attributes.body
Thesis: In The Boat, Alistair MacLeod shows that people sometimes feel torn between where they live and what they truly want, and this can make them feel stuck or unhappy.

Evidence- The father loves both the sea and books, but he can't fully enjoy both. He works on the boat to support his family, even though he really loves reading and learning. And the narrator sees the light from his father's cabin at night and knows he's still reading. This shows that even though his father is a fisherman, his heart is somewhere else, he finds comfort in books.

# data[].attributes.headline
MRS. KELLAR      THESIS IN RESPONSE TO QUESTION

# data[].attributes.subject
MRS. KELLAR      THESIS IN RESPONSE TO QUESTION

# data[].attributes.body
specific supporting evidence 1

specific supporting evidence 2