# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph was talking about the fact that no one was there to have his back after Jupiter was born and after Maddie died he felt alone.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph has gone through a lot of bad things so he finds it hard too believe that there is good people in the world.

# data[].attributes.body
i think that Joseph was never happy and that that he went threw a lot of bad things in his life and it was hard for him to get threw and there was not a lot of people there for him  and that he did not have his real family he was a foster

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to how he never had angel for when he went through bad things. I think that he was referring to when he went through bad times and there wasn't any angels.

# data[].attributes.body
What Joseph was referring to when he mentioned the idea of angels in his discussion with Reverend Ballou at the Christmas Eve service was talking about his past. Joseph was pretty much just saying where the angels when he went through all that trouble in the past.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to how he didn't think he had found any angels for himself, and so he didn't really believe most of the story the Reverend had told.

# data[].attributes.body
What Joseph was says when he mentioned the angels and his discussion with the Reverend Ballou at the Christmas Eve Service was his life. How Maddie was gone and how she died, but in the Bible Mary and Joseph had a baby and everything was fine, but in Joseph's life, it was the opposite.

# data[].attributes.body
I thin that he is referring to the things that he had to deal with when he was a kid. He is no longer with his biological family. He fell in love and she ended up dying because they had a kid together. Then the kid, Jupiter, was taken from him and his rights were signed away. I think that he feels like all thought out his life, he had been alone and the Angles have no been there to shield him from those horrible things that happened. This is important moment for Joseph because it shows that he doesn't believe that he has angles with him or that he has been helped.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph was referring to his life at home with his dad and when he had to give up Jupiter because a lot of bad things have happened to him. This is important to Joseph because if the angels weren't there for him it either means that angels aren't real or they just weren't there for him, maybe for an important reason

# data[].attributes.body
The Angels are important to Joseph, because he was referring to when him and Maddi got split apart and when he lost his daughter and when he had to sign her life away to another family. I think that he was wondering where the Angels where when him and Maddi had Jupiter and no one would support them and all they did was try to keep them away from each other.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that he was referring to all the bad times he has had in his life. He was thinking of where were they when he needed them in his life when all the bad things were happening. This is an important moment for Joseph because he thinks that angels are not true but the Reverend thinks they are and the angles didn't want to help Joseph.

# data[].attributes.body
What Joseph was referring to when he mentioned the idea of angles is that he was talking about his past. He was also talking about why the angles weren't there when he went through all of those challenges that he faced in his lifetime before he meant Jack and his parents.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Joseph mentioned the ideas of angels, because of his past. Joseph has  gone through so much and he wanted to know why all the bad things happened to him and why if there were angels, why did they not help him.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to when Maddie died. Also to when he had to sign over the rights to Jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
This is important because he did not really know about the angels because he did not know what they meant. This moments was very special because Joseph never really knew about angels and he thought they were not really real.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph wanted to know why angels hasn't helped him yet. He asked the priest for answers and he gave him some but he didn't agree so he asked where the hell they were. Then they left.

# data[].attributes.body
It is important moment for Joseph because when he attempted to kill that teacher the Angels weren't there to help, and when he took the drugs they weren't there to help him.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was meaning the bad stuff that had happened in his life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to when him and

# data[].attributes.body
He was referring to when maddie died and when he had to sign over rights to Jupiter. He was saying that when he found this out it was bad and that angels did not come to help him or maddie. So thats what the reverent was sad about. It was important because he got to talk about what happened and learn that there was apparently something that could have helped him.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to his own life.

# data[].attributes.body
When Joseph was talking about the angels to Reverend Ballou Joseph was referring about who will help him find Jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
i think that Joseph was referring to the story about Joseph and marry to his own life because when he Maddie and him were having a baby no would help them or didn't want to help them

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to the bad times he had and asking where were the angels to help him then? He thought that if there are angles then what are they here to do, and why didn't they help him? I think that Joseph doesn't believe much in angels because of the bad times he has been through.

# data[].attributes.body
i think that Joseph was deferring

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to his past. I say this because the story about Mary and Joseph he can kind of connect to a little bit, because it is a story about to people who loved each other that went though a rough time for example having al baby and feeling in trouble. This is an important moment for Joseph becuase he connects to this story with his memories with Maddie .He is confused becuase he thinks that the angels should have been there for him too when he was going though the stuff with Maddie and that it is not fair that they were not.

# data[].attributes.body
I think he doesn't believe in them because he is probably wondering like where was the angel's when his girl died like the story the man read he relates it to himself.

# data[].attributes.body
He didn't know about the angels, he was talking with Reverend Ballou. He did not sing because he don't know lot about songs.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was asking about the Angels because never went to Church. He has experienced a lot of bad things in his life . Joseph was asking a lot of Questions about the Angels.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that he was referring to angels, because he is kind of referring to his own life. Such as Joseph and Madeline are kind of like Joseph and Mary, because they have a kid an don't have much help, but in the story with Mary angels help. I also think that Joseph does not realize that his life is the same as that story and he does have angels and those three are Jack, Jack's mom, and Jack's dad. This is important to Joseph, because he starts to realize many things and relates his life o Joseph and Mary and sees that his life could become much better in the future.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was talking about his own life because the story told when Joseph went to church is very relatable to him . this moment was important to Joseph because he asks Ballou if angles were real and that if they were then bad things wouldn't happen. When he talks about this he is referring to when Joseph lost his child and Maddie.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Joseph was referring to his own life. I say this, because the whole story connects to his life and what happend to the people he loved. Joseph's life connects to the story of Mary, and Joseph, because they were about to have a child that they weren't expecting at all, they and no support, and they had no idea what to do with their life. This is what Joseph went through.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joesph is trying to say that he thinks it is a bad thing.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph was referring to his own life and experiences with Maddie. They had a baby unexpectedly like Joseph
and Mary in the story ,and no angels came to help him with his problems. This also refers on his belief of angels too. He does not believe in them since the angels never helped him out with Maddie and Jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to his own life . This was important for Joseph because he thought about it relating to his and Maddie life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was trying to connect the story about Mary and Joseph to his own life because they are so much alike. The way that they are alike because in Joseph and Maddie's life, no one would help them when they found out that Maddie was pregnant. The reason Joseph asked if the story about Joseph and Mary was true or false because in that story, it says that angels tell them that it will be ok but in Joseph's sake, he doesn't think that he did or ever will get that sign.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph was referring to his own life. His name was mentioned, and Mary is pretty closed to Maddie. He thought the story could've been written about him in a past life. The story was pretty similar to his story with Maddie. A man named Joseph got a women named Mary pregnant. Most of the people around them to told them to not have the baby. This happened until they found a place, that they thought was a good place to have a baby. This is similar to Joseph, and Maddie's story because all of the people around the two didn't want them to have the child, but they, against everyone's wishes, had the child anyway. He met that he wanted angels in his life, to make sure that Maddie didn't die, or to make sure he was able too get Jupiter. He also meant that he was mad that even if there were angels at Jupiter's birth, then they should've helped Maddie survive.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to his own life and what similar experience he has had before. This story reminds Joseph about Maddie and Jupiter because they had a baby unexpected, like with Joseph and Mary. They have had the same experience has the story. This is an important moment for Joseph because this reminds him about his own life and whar he has gone through before and that story makes him think about Maddie and Jupiter and when he says what he says about the angels coming for bad things to happen, Joseph was wondering where were they would Joseph was going through his situation.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to his belief that there is no such thing as angles. I think that Joseph doesn't believe in angles becasue he wonders were were the angles when Maddie was dying and why can he not see jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think he was referring to the fact that he doesn't believe in angels. I think the reasoning behind this is because the reverend had said the angels were there for when bad things happened. But the reason Joseph was so salty was because the angels were never there for him, Madeleine, or Jupiter. This was big because it helped him get his feelings across, and I think that Jack's family understood, causing them to write that paper.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that when Joseph heard of the angles he was thinking that they were miracle and where they were at when he needed them with Maddie and Jupiter, because they are supposed to help but they didn't when he needed them.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to when Madeleine  had Jupiter why weren't the angles protecting her.This is important to Joseph because he got to thinking about him and Maddie and how much the story relates to him in his life

# data[].attributes.body
I believe Joseph was referring to his life. So Joseph never herd that story and it kinda interested him. He though of his life, Maddi, and Jupiter. Since the angels were there fro Joseph and Mary, where were they for Joseph and Maddi. It was an important moment becasue it told that not all life it bad. It kind agave him a message of his life is starting to change or turn around.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that he was referring to his own life. When he heard the story he was thinking that it wan't true because he wasn't aloud to see Maddie and Jupiter. This makes him think that Angels don't exist, because where were they when he was having problems with Maddie and Jupiter. Because the story is that there will be Angels with them so that they will be safe and that everything will be okay, that there is nothing to be scared about. But the exact opposite happened to Joseph. He was banned from seeing Jupiter and couldn't be there with Maddie. Or ever see her again. This is important for Joseph because it was a good message for Joseph. Like maybe he will find Jupiter in the future, then he will know that Angels do exist. They they are always looking over him.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to what happened in his life. He was thinking as if all the bad stuff happened to him, and not the good stuff. He was confused on where the good stuff was to help him for life. Considering it was really his first time hearing about the angels, it kind of got to him.
This is an important moment for Joseph because he is realizing that the world has some good to it, and things will end up getting better.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph is trying to say that he thinks it is a bad thing. People think that they are protecting them but Joseph thinks that it is a bad thing.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was meaning the bad stuff that had happened in his life. Joseph needed to know if the angels were real because he had gone through the tough times but, then Reverend Ballou said "Maybe angels are not meant to stop all bad things, Maybe they are there to be with us when they happen". This is also an important moment for Joseph because it gives him faith that he might find Jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think when Joseph heard of angels and the people saying how protective they are he disagreed. I say this because he has experienced such bad things in his life and he has major disbelief in the angels due to these things.

# data[].attributes.body
When he hears all these people talking about angels and them being good and always protecting people from bad stuff he was confused. He was confused why all this terrible stuff had happend to him and there was no good to him. So when he asks " Then where the hell were they," he is wondering why they didn't bring him good.So thats when the preist said angels are ones maybe who are they when these bad things happen. I think this is importnat for Joseph because when this happens he realizes that he wasn't alone when these ad things happend he just didn't realize it. I am begining to think that Jack and his family is the angels Joseph needs.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that he was thinking about the things that he has gone through and how the angels were there for Mary and Joseph. He asks the reverend about were they were because he was hoping that he would have a angel or angels that would be there for him. I think It was important because he wanted people to be there for him.

# data[].attributes.body
He was asking where the angels were at when he wasn't allowed to see Jupiter and Maddie. He was asking where they were at when all the bad things in his life happened.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was thinking about everything he had went through in his life lately, such as juvy, everything that has happened with Maddie and Jupiter, and having issues at his foster home and at school. It is an important moment for Joseph because he hears about how angels are there for you in the hard times, and he asks where his were during all of the rough times he has gone through lately.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph was referring to the bad things in his life that he had been put through. He wanted to know if the angels were real, because if they were he wanted to know what he was still struggling in his life. Whenever Reverend Ballou said the angels are there for you in the hard times, Joseph questioned him about why he is still going through hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph was referring to how Jupiter is with someone he doesn't know, instead of him. Or the fact that Maddie is gone, and not alive with Jupiter.  This important to Joseph because he wanted answers and he wanted to know why bad things happen if there is angles, and his answer was that maybe angles are there for the bad times in life.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to what had happened in his life because he had a really rough time growing up and he still is kind of having a rough time. But life is somewhat getting better for him. Also he just wanted to know about the story because he can relate to that story, and just wanted to know about why he hasn't seen any angels.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to all the bad and hard times he was going through. The story about Christmas Eve could relate to Joseph and he could put himself in that spot. He was also mad because he wanted to know were the angles were when him and Madeleine were having trouble.

# data[].attributes.body
He meant angles were meant to help that's what they were there for to make sure bad things didn't happen. So he questioned the existence of angles because so so many bad things happen to and all around Joseph before he met Jack and his parents bad things were all he knew so if there were angels, why do they let bad things happen why did they let Joseph go through that why would they let that happen to Madeline?

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was thinking that when he was going through the hard times with Maddie and Jupiter, where were the angles at this time with Joseph when he was going through all the bad things. This is an important moment for Joseph because it gives Joseph faith and pride towards the angles.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to all of the bad things that have happened in his life. Like him being sent to Stone Hill, being separated from Maddie and Jupiter, and being sent away by his father. He was wondering why angels were real because he thought that the angles did not help with through his struggles. This is a important moment for Joseph because he realizes that the angles might be able to help him and get him through the tough times.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that he was talking about all the bad things that had happened to him like why did the bad things happen if the angels were always there. He wanted to know how they were always there but yet still let the bad things happen.

# data[].attributes.body
When Joseph mentioned the idea of angels, he was referring to where his angels were for when he was going through bad times. I think this is important moment for Joseph because of how Joseph could have needed the help from angels when he was going through rough times

# data[].attributes.body
He meant that where were the angles at whenever Joseph was going through hard times in his life. That was an important time for Joseph because he had been through a hard time and he is going to look for the angles in his hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that he was referring to when he had to sign his right to Jupiter away to a random person that he didn't know. This is an important moment for Joseph because this was reminding him that he had a daughter that he loved and he wanted to see but he didn't know where she was and he didn't know.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to all of the bad things that have happened to him. He was asking where the angels were when he was separated from Maddie and wasn't able to see Jupiter, and when he was in Stone Mountain. It was an important moment for Joseph because he realized that the angels might not stop bad situations, but they will be there to look over you while they happen.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to all of the bad times that he has had in his life like having to go to juvie, getting to not see his kid, not getting to see Maddie, and all of the other bad things that he had to go through. This is an important moment for Joseph because he was wondering is there were any angles there with him when he went through these hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
He is thinking that when he was going through hard times where were they at. He wants to know were his angles were at in his hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph was referring to all the bad things that had happened in his life. He was wondering if angels were real because if they were then he wanted to know where they were when he lost everything.This is an important moment for Joseph because it gives him faith that angels will help him when he is in a bad situation.