# data[].attributes.body
Celestine finds out that she has the video and it is in her possesion. She is told that Mr. Berry gave it to her. She doesn't know where it could be, but she thinks Carrick may have it.

# data[].attributes.body
Celestine finds Art and her sister together. She is extremely upset and she couldn't believe her eyes. Her sister had known where Art has been this whole time and she never told her. She leaves them, and tells them she will never speak to them again. Ever again. I think this is a little bit over the edge. Celestine is just extremely surprised and I believe that she will speak with them again.

# data[].attributes.body
Celestine knows she is close to home while she in the shed. She sees the farming tools, she knows that they didn't drive far, and they are on a hill. This thinking amazes me because of how much she is freaking out, and how she can just calm down like that and know where she is, along with knowing where she needs to go.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the theme is about power and what you do with it with Judge Crevan and the Guild and how he uses it for his own intersts and his greed and also how the Flawed look up to Celestine and how she will use it..

# data[].attributes.body
Celestine comes home from school, and Pia Wang is already there, waiting for her. Pia wants to talk with her, but Celestine does not want to. She ends up talking to her, and before she leaves, she tells Pia about the sixth symbol that she recieved. Pia is devestated and she cannot believe it. I think this was a bad idea, because if Celestine wanted to get away from all of the reporters and the followers, she just gave herself some more reasons to get more people over her all the time.

# data[].attributes.body
Nobody is perfect.
In the story, Celestine gets caught for helping a man out on the bus. He is choking and she helps him into a seat because he looked as if he was going to pass out and die. The only bad part about this was that the man was flawed. He was flawed and she helped him. In the society today, they are not allowed to do this, and she is marked flawed. Basically, her family thought from day 1 that she would be perfect forever, until one mistake, and it only takes one. i think this rule is pretty ridiculous because she was helping a man out, and she gets punished for it. Even if she lied about the incident, she could have still been guilty and flawed for lying and could have been a worse punishment than she got already.

# data[].attributes.body
Everyone can change over time.
At the beginning of the story, Celestine is this perfect girl who never questions anything about society. She loves school, has lots of friends, and loves her family. But, as the story goes on, her mindset starts to change. When on the bus with her sister and boyfriend, an flawed man comes on the bus and doesn't have a seat. Celestine thinks at first that he is her granddad, but then she realizes he isn't. Then the man starts coughing and sounds like he may pass out, which causes Celestine to bravely help the man to a seat. In this society, helping a Flawed is considered flawed. Celestine now starts to question everything and everyone. Her mind, character, and life changes now that she is older. It's hard for her to show this, but eventually she does to help the flawed man. This leads us the a potential theme that people can change over time.

# data[].attributes.body
When Celestine gets all of her flawed marks on her, other than the last her tongue, the judge talked to her about her last symbol. He offered her to say that she is sorry, but she would rather just take the symbol than to ever surrender to that man. She absolutely hated him after what had happened to her. I think this was a mistake. She could have had a chance to not get the flawed mark on her tongue, but she didn't take the offer.

# data[].attributes.body
The changes of the central character are greatly obvious. In the start of the book, Celestine is living a perfect life, getting everything she wants, along with her boyfriend Art, but one day, Celestine becomes a little too nice, and decides to help a flawed out, which is not allowed. Anyone that is not flawed cannot help one that is flawed. People noticed this, and the guild did too. She helped the flawed man on the bus, and she was taken off of the bus by the guild. She has went back and forth on whether to tell a lie or not to the judge, but either way, it can result in her being flawed. It has impacted me because it is confusing what she is actually going to tell the judge, or if she will lie or not. Either way, she can be flawed.

# data[].attributes.body
The central character has changed dramatically over time. At the beginning, Celestine was this perfect girl living in a perfect world. She always followed the rules and disliked the flawed like everyone else. But once someone she knows becomes flawed, she seems to be effected by this. Then, after what seems to be committing a flawed act (helping the old man), Celestine's mind set about this society changes. She fights herself for not wanting to change, but in her heart, she knows what's right. Due to her heart, and some help from her granddad, Celestine admits to helping the old man. This impacts me because it goes to show we can all change. We don't have to be exactly like everyone else, and if we are, we can change to who we want to be. Ourselves. Inside, we should be happy, not everyone else. This is exactly what Celestine did. She truly became herself.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that Celestine is going to say something different than the others, and they are going to rule her flawed because she has lied about the situation, or she could be telling the truth, but either way, lying or not, she still can be ruled flawed.

# data[].attributes.body
As Celestine is entering the court hearing, she is stopped by many thrown objects, from people that believe she is flawed. This to me is a gruesome act, because she should not be getting hate from others because she helped someone, and she should definitely be getting bombs thrown at her.

# data[].attributes.body
Celestine's response makes sense, she did the right thing. But, she will be flawed and her life will chnage forever.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Celestine has changed throughout the story.  I think she has still done the logical thing. She helped a dying man, she told the truth, and stayed true to herself. Even though society may think what she does is wrong it is something that defines her which is the right thing to do. This impacted me by making me think about doing what is right even though it might result in bad consequences.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Art is just trying to make Celestine feel better, but I don't believe that they will get Celestine out of being flawed. The other judges are doing everything they can to disagree with Bosco.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Celestine will be ruled flawed since she is being outnumbered. The judge has enemies, and the judge uses these enemies against Celestine to rule her flawed.

# data[].attributes.body
Celestine's granddad made some very good points to Celestine and and it's very interesting how some people are siding with Celestine. Again, I believe Celestine will change her mind and join the group to change society.

# data[].attributes.body
Soldier fills the void in Celestine's life left by Art who won't be a character witness for her and hasn't visited. She talked about how when she would look in Art's blue eyes she would calm down and now when she is nervous she just looks over at Soldier.

# data[].attributes.body
Mr. Berry brings a whole different perspective of the effects, that are going to come from the trial.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Celestine will crack under pressure in the court room and won't follow through with the agreement she made with Bosco.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with Justin on how Celestine will crack under pressure. She is going to attempt to lie, but she will not succeed.