# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe are alive because I think that they will build a home and live in a place. More specifically, I believe that they make a home without no one and see the real world. For example,The author states “He knew they were shining Through the windows of rooms, that they were red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love”(Lowry 178).Lowry shows that they were in a loved place without rules or nothing just peace. Although others might disagree that he might not have survived but it seems they see rooms and are in a calm place,I maintain that same idea that Jonas is alive and in a home. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are alive because they express a home in the quote and explain the peacefulness .

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe found the other world where they were supposed to go because Jonas heard music and saw colored lights inside the houses.. More specifically, I believe that he found the sled where it was supposed to be and that was a sign.  For example, “for the first time he heard something that he knew to be music, he heard singing.”  (Lowry 225.)  And, “Jonas found the sled that was waiting for him at the top of the hill.  (Lowry 224.)   Lowry shows that Jonas found the sled and slid down a hill. Although others might disagree and think he died because he went to heaven and saw lights and heard music, I maintain that he survived because there are other people there so he probably didn’t die. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe lived, and that’s why there are other books in the series..

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe make it to Elsewhere because the author states that Jonas can see lights and an hear music. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe make it to Elsewhere because he is near other people who can see color and hear music, which can only be found Elsewhere. Even though Jonas was losing consciousness on the sled ride down the hill, it was said that the people were waiting for him at the bottom. Because of this, it is very likely that Jonas survived. An example of this is, “Suddenly, he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby”(Lowry, 178-179). Lowry shows that Jonas had made it to Elsewhere, where the people were waiting to welcome him and Gabe to the new, happy life that was in store for them. Although others might disagree that Jonas made it to Elsewhere, instead losing his life on the ride down the hill, I maintain that Jonas had the strength left to make it to those who would help him. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe make it to Elsewhere because he can sense people there; people who had color, music, and love.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and gabe will all die because they tell you that they are running out of food water and it was very hot. Lowry shows that by stating, “ were out of food “ (lowery pg near end of book).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe survived and got a place to stay because it says Jonas lost his consciousness. It is not necessary that he died. More specifically, I believe, since Jonas and Gabriel are young and have a long life to live and also Jonas due to his good deeds should have survived enjoying the fruits of his hard work.  For example, When Jonas fell down, he held Gabriel and made sure Gabe was  not hurt though Jonas sprained his ankle and had a lot of cuts and blood flowed through his torn pants .  He then heard music and could imagine about the good things during Christmas. Lowry shows that Jonas and Gabe finally found a place to be safe from the community and the freezing snow. Although others might disagree that the statement that Jonas and Gabe could survive and stay safe. I maintain that Gabe and Jonas could have had a chance of being rescued by the good hearted citizens of that town during Christmas. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe survived and got a place for shelter and food because of the good people in the town (if it is real).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe lose their lives at Elsewhere because they were cold, weak, and starving. More specifically, I believe that they meet Rosemary and she helps them get the memories to the community. For example, “He and Gabriel became cold and wet, and it was hard to get dry, even when sunshine occasionally followed” (Lowry 173). Lowry shows that there was little hope left of them keeping on going. Since their strength is diminished, I didn’t think they would go on. Although others might disagree that they used their last bit of strength and arrived, I maintain that they were at their last bit of strength so they couldn’t possibly survive the wilderness. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe pass away at Elsewhere because they were freezing, tired, and hungry.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe do make it to Elsewhere because he can hear people singing. More specifically, I believe that Gabriel and Jonas are rescued by the  singing citizens of that town and brought in. For example, in the last few sentences in the book, Lowry states, “ For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that, in the last sentences in the book, that Jonas might have found a community of people with emotions, since he has never heard music before. Although others might disagree that this is simply a hallucination caused by Jonas’s weak state, I maintain that this cannot be a hallucination, as Jonas has never heard music before. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe do make it to Elsewhere because he can hear people singing.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe went to Elsewhere, also known as heaven, because the book specifically explains how cold and weak Gabe and Jonas are. More specifically, I believe that as Jonas and Gabe were “walking up the hill” they were slowly going into heaven. For example, “If anything, he felt more numb, and more cold” (Lowry 177). Lowry shows that they are slowly losing their conciousness. Although others might disagree that they did reach elsewhere, I maintain that they were slowly losing consciousness and reached elsewhere, but elsewhere was actually heaven. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe passed away.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe didn’t make it to that elsewhere. . More specifically, I believe that worst case scenario, Jonas imagined seeing the house in the distance due to hallucination and getting close to dying.. For example, “Jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright…” (Lowry, 178). Lowry shows that Jonas might be going in and out of consciousness or could be already unconscious but doesn’t know it.. Although others might disagree that they might’ve made it to the warm house with all the music, I maintain that I give up. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe (restate your thinking) because (restate your own claim here using different wording than at the beginning).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe make it to the houses and receive help because we saw that they could see the houses and Jonas had memories. More specifically, I believe that Jonas made it to the house, got care, and whether it was that family from the house or another family then adopted/took them in as there own kid.. For example, “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby”(Lowry 225). Lowry shows that they was promise and possibly people that will take care of Jonas and take him in. The quote tells us that Jonas is certain that they were waiting for him and the baby. Although others might disagree that they will take him in because he is a complete stranger, I maintain that they are loving people who would gladly take in Jonas and Gabriel.. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe will be taken in by the house if not one of the other families in another house because Jonas said he was certain and there was many signs and clues to leave me reason to believe this.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have found another community that exists beyond Jonas’s because Jonas hears people singing as goes downhill on the sled and see’s lights of different colors being emitted from what seemed to be rooms. More specifically, I believe that the community Jonas has stumbled upon or Elsewhere is celebrating Christmas as Jonas recollects the memory of love The Giver had given him, which was supposedly his favorite. For example, “He forced his eyes open as they went downward, downward, sliding and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love”(Lowry 225). Lowry shows that in this land beyond the community that people were celebrating what The Giver had described through the memories showing that the ways of the old world that had not been genetically perfected still existed and was being practiced by people who weren't pulled into the ways of those who sought “peace” . Although others might disagree that this sight could have simply been fabricated from Jonas’s current memories as he was in great pain as was desperate and had only shreds of hope and could have subconsciously tugged the memory forward to fulfill his wanting to be right that Elsewhere existed , I maintain that Jonas did find elsewhere because he was barely able to pull the memory of sunshine out and when he did it was brief and there was no way he could pull out a memory so complex and he did feel joy but that was his own memory from his childhood. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe stumbled upon another community because there were signs that indicated that the ways of the past still existed and that Jonas was right about the existence of Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe do survive and find people who live outside of the communities because at the very end of the chapter, he hears the echo of singing and music. More specifically, I believe he is able to start an entirely new life with Gabriel outside of the community. Near the end of the chapter we  learn that he finds a sled and it’s revealed that in the distance he sees a place from his memory. It’s possible to assume that we will travel to that house and find people there who will help him. For example “He heard people singing” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas had heard people. People who were alive and well. Jonas stumbled upon people who lived outside of the community. Although others might disagree that there we not found and instead were lost forever, I maintain that at the end he finds a sled and is able to see a house in the distance as well as hear the echo of singing, which could have only been made by people. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe survive and find people outside of the community who can help them.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a new community because they saw houses with lights and they saw trees and birds. More specifically, I believe that they are not at their old place because there are things that Jonas and Gabe have never seen in person before. For example, Jonas states “It’s called snow Gabe”(Lowry 174). Lowry shows that Jonas has never seen snow in person and either has Gabe. It was shown that the snow was colder than they both expected it to be. Although others might disagree that this was only a dream, I maintain that it was way too harsh to be a dream because he saw an animal that was never seen before and the snow was colder than from his memories. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to a new community because there were houses with lights and he heard songs.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe had died and imagined finding Elsewhere because Jonas saw a place with light and warmth hearing music in the background in the distance but never actually reaching there. More specifically, I believe that He died in the snow because of starvation and the freezing cold. For example, “You have never been starving, he had been told. You will never be starving. Now he was” (Lowry 172). Lowry shows that Jonas has no food supply for neither him or Gabe. He soon will grow very hungry since he is using the last bit of energy he has to climb up the snowy hill carrying a baby. Although others might disagree that there is no way they survived because there are more books, I maintain that at their state in the snowy hills, they are unlikely to survive and I have read series with a different main character. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe did not survive in the end of the book because of their hunger and the blasting snow freezing them and making it harder for the to reach Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe are brave because they are willing to fight for a cause to have feelings and live a normal life. Not one that is controlled by the society. More specifically, I believe that fighting for your loved ones and yourself and a better life is important.. For example, “Jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright atop the sled,” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas is willing to go through serious pain in every way to live a life of peace and what is considered normal for us. He willed himself up so thathe and most importantly Gabe would live freely. Although others might disagree that Jonas is brave, I maintain that Jonas shows tremendous bravery for a 13 year old boy. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are brave because they fight for a life full of memories and joy with emotion and not one which drains them of this.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe successfully make it to Elsewhere and there, they can live happily. I think this because Jonas describes the feeling of certainty and joy upon arriving to Elsewhere. More specifically, I believe that the people of Elsewhere will help them and adopt them into their community. For example, “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and they were waiting, too, for the baby” (Lowry 225). Lowry shows that there is hope for Jonas and Gabe in the new community. Although others might disagree that Joan and Gabe will not be accepted and welcomed, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe came all this way and couldn’t be turned away.. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe successfully make it to Elsewhere and there, they can live happily. because upon arriving Jonas feels certainty that they will be welcomed into this new community.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here: In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe get taken in by the other community because of the loud singing probably they arrived somewhere with people More specifically, I believe that they came to a new village with people probably singing for a special event. For example, "He heard something that he knew to be music, he heard people singing"(Lowry 179). Lowry shows that Jonas heard others singing outside. Although others might disagree (that they were not found, I maintain that they might not see him, and he could do anything to cause attention to him. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe get taken by the other community.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died because It says Elsewhere and he finally hears music. More specifically, I believe that he dies because in the end it say perhaps it is a echo which he didn’t make it and it's there on the snow freezing to death. . For example, There is no response from the child”. Lowry shows that Gabriel has died and is not moving. Although others might disagree that They may still be alive, I maintain that They have died from the snow storm. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe died because He dies and, in the end, it says that it's possible that it's an echo that he didn't hear and that it's frozen to death on the snow.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe Approach people who we read about in the memories because the sled and the snow were in the same spot as the memories as they were in Elsewhere. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe will find the people who live in that cabin and that the memories were actually the future. For example, “Using his final strength, and a special knowledge that was deep inside him, jonas found the sled that was waiting for them at the top of the hill,” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that is was the sled, not just any sled on a snowy hill. Although others might disagree that it was a different sled, however, from the details we know it was most likely the same one. I maintain that Jonas thought of the sled as the same, therefore we can only expect it to be true. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are in the memories rather than a different future because everything in the memories is the same as what they experienced now.

# data[].attributes.body
n my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a new community because Jonas saw lights and recognised them. More specifically, I believe that Jonas went into  a different community who aren’t like his former and he we celebrating something in which jonas saw before when the Giver gave him memories. For example, The author writes, “He forced his eyes open as they went downward, downward, sliding, and all at once he could see lights, and he recognised them now” (lowry 178).. Lowry shows that Jonas is familiar with the sight he saw which means there is something out there and he knows from the memories he received form the Giver. Although others might disagree that Jonas might be passed out and hallucinating, I maintain that Jonas would not have been familiar and would be conscious enough to see the lights and connect to it. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have found a new community that is different from their previous. Because he saw sights that we're familiar and that are sights you would see where humans live..:

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe Have completed their destiny they have made it to the other side. Because They are complete the have gotten out of the prison of a life. More specifically, I believe that They have escaped the mindless emotionless prison of a life. For example, in the text it says,“If he had stayed he would have starved in other ways”(Lowry 173). . lowry shows that (That He is starving for food, but back  in the community He would have starved in other ways.). Although others might disagree that (That he should’ve stayed ant the community because he would have had food and I good no worries life. I maintain that (He will live a better life with out the community and having feelings.). Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe (rHave completed their journe) because (They have gone and left the mindless life of a controlled community behind.).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe both perished from environmental factors because they have been traveling towards this mysterious elsewhere with lack of supplies and rest. More specifically, I believe that the houses, lights, and music Jonas was perceiving were basically hallucinations. Jonas was deprived in multiple ways, ot just sleep. However, sleep deprivation already creates a drunk like vision. For example, “ He cried because he was hungry and cold and terribly weak. Jonas cried, too, for the same reasons, and another reason as well. He wept because he was afraid now that he could not save Gabriel” (Lowry 218). Lowry shows that both children were suffering from hypothermia and hunger. I repeat, children. Even Jonas was admitting how bad of situation they were in. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe did not die and found their rightful place in Elsewhere, I maintain that as much as readers would like a happy ending, there is a much higher chance Jonas and Gabe died on their journey to a place they have no idea about. Plus, Jonas didn’t have a clear future in the beginning with guidance from memories that aren’t even his. Again, this ending was made for different interpretations, so it is easy to understand all ideas. Nonetheless, the one I chose just made the most sense. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe passed away before they could finish their journey to a safer place because their already ghost of a chance was foreshadowed by environmental factors.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have found another world, the normal world. This is because in the ending they describe seeing christmas lights and hear people singing, but this could als be hallucinations. More specifically I believe that this place is going to be their new home, cause this palace is more of what he is going to be used to. For example, “ For the first time, he heard something that he knew t be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179). Although some might disagree that he might have been hallucing about the whole new community, I maintain that he was able to identify that he was somewhere safe with other people in a normal world. Therefore I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are now in the normal world because the ending of the book describes red and green light, and people singing since it’s Christmas.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe are thoughtful because Jonas didn’t want to stay in his community with nothing and wan’t to see what he had missed and what was holding him back. More specifically, I believe that Jonas had a feeling for Gabe and for his community. Although he didn’t like it and wanted to leave there was that tiny space in his heart that told him to leave and he knew he would find something truely more better. For example, “ But he began to feel happy, suddenly, to feel happy. He remembered his parents, his friends, Asher, Fiona” (Lowry 177). Lowry shows that although Jonas had all those rebelling feelings on his community he still knew that his community cared for him in a way which took everything he knew out. Although others might disagree that Jonas had hated the community and the reason he left, and wanted to adventure further, I maintain that Jonas throughout the book did show against for the community, he knew that his community was what it was and that all that life, his parents, and friends he had known as been in that community supporting and loving him. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are thoughtful because they both had been alikeand knew they had a community which was wrong but cared for them..

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe got to live a better life because they saw all the joyful memories that Jonas had received as memories. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe started a new life at the new place they discovered. For example, ¨ He forced his eyes open as they went downward, downward, sliding, and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now ¨ (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that Jonas has found one of the things that made him happy. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe hadnt stayed at the new place they discovered, I maintain that they found comfort there. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have found a new home because they feel comfortable there.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here: In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe found another community where everything was like the past because he said he could hear singing and people together with love. More specifically, I believe that the community that he found was like modern day. They didn't release people and did not take pills to eliminate love. For example, For the first time, “He heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that these people were singing and having fun. Although others might disagree that Jonas was only lost in his memories because of the cold and exhaustion, I maintain that Jonas has lost all other memories except his own and was making new ones for himself. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found Elsewhere because he was searching for a better place and could hear people at a party.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died and went somewhere else, because I could imagine he heard music in the afterlife, etc. More specifically, I believe that he went to heaven. For example, “Behind him, across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo”(Lowry 179). Lowry shows that it was farther than space and time, as such he was probably in the afterlife. Although others might disagree that he is just recalling memories, and that he arrives in a village. I maintain that The giver still has the memory of music, and that is just a hallucination. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe died and went to the afterlife because The giver still has the memory of music.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe make it because it seems the people would notice and go out and help them. More specifically, I believe that the story goes on with them. For example, the text reads “For the first time, he heard something he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that people were singing possibly outside. Although others might disagree that they might not notice him, I maintain that if Jonas could yell, and people would notice a boy and a baby. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe make it to the house(s) because the people could notice and help them.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here:  In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe arrive in a village because for him to be able to hear the music probably means that a lot of people are singing at the same time.. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and little Gabe had arrived to a small village where many could’ve been singing for a special holiday.. For example, “He heard people singing” (Lowry 179).. Lowry shows that Jonas had heard more than 1 person sing which explains why they could’ve arrived at a village.. Although others might disagree that Jonas could’ve heard multiple people singing in one isolated house. I maintain that he made it to a village because of the bright lights and singing Jonas mentioned. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to a village because could’ve heard a choir singing holiday songs.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it into another community instead of dying because his memories came back to him. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabriel are sliding towards a community that is celebrating Christmas. For example, “He knew that they were shining through the windows of rooms, the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry,225). Lowry shows that there are people at the bottom of the hill by showing the reader that Jonas faded memories came back to him, that shows the reader that he is close to where the memory originated. Although others might disagree that Jonas is hallucinating from the cold instead of actually sliding down a hill because how would a sled stay in a good condition being stuck on a hill, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe were actually sledding, because hallucinations aren’t actually there so if the sled was a hallucination Jonas wouldn’t have been able to ride it. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere because Jonas’ faded memories came back.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have may imagined the lights and the house because of how hungry and tired they were. I believe that Jonas was to tired and may have hallucinated what he saw even if his eyes were completely wide open. For example “Jonas felt himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright atop the sled, clutching Gabriel, keep him safe.” (Lowry 178). Although others might disagree that Gabriel to could have saw the house and the lights. I maintain that since they both were in the same state that Gabriel to could have hallucinated the house and lights like Jonas. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabriel have may imagined the lights and the house because of how hungry and tired they were because they were to tired to function normally and hallucinated.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a warm town while Christmas was going on because in the text it says its snowing and usually when it’s snowing it’s winter time when Christmas is happening. More specifically, I believe that Christmas was going on not only for the snow but because in the text it says there were warm lights and he heard music so I think there was a christmas party going on. For example, The author states “he could see lights, and he could recognize them now. He knew they were shining through the windows of the rooms,that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families  created and kept memories”(Lowry-179). Lowry shows that there is christmas going on because of the green and red lights which are christmas colors and that there is a twinkling tree, like a christmas tree? Although others might disagree that its just his imaginations or a memory that has come to him, I maintain that because he gives his memory all to the people of the community when he leaves so he can’t have that memory. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to a warm town while Christmas was going on because in the text it says its snowing and usually when it’s snowing it’s winter time when Christmas is happening. Also in the text it says there were warm light and a twinkling tree

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to the elsewhere and lived happy lives because Jonas is certain that they are waiting for him.  More specifically, I believe that Jonas finally found the “Elsewhere.” I believe that he found love and a family that will take him in. For example, “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead they were waiting for him; that they were waiting, too, for the baby” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that someone is waiting for him down there. Someone who will love Gabriel and him. The warmth of the houses was anticipating them. Although others might disagree that Jonas may have lost consciousness, and that elsewhere he entered was actually heaven waiting for him, I maintain that he lives and encounters joy. Jonas will experience love in the rooms filled with joy. Jonas is thrilled that he has found this new place, and therefore would not let himself lose consciousness, especially withe the baby there. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe live and experience joy and happiness. because Jonas has finally found the place he is looking for.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe make it to Elsewhere and start a new life there because Jonas was so determined to survive and was not going to give up regardless of the obstacles. More specifically, I believe that they arrived in Elsewhere at Christmas time and were welcomed into a new happy family. The author writes “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby. For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 225 ). Lowry shows that a new and improved life was awaiting Jonas and Gabriel, and that Jonas was intent on getting there. Although others might disagree and assume that they were unable to endure the conditions and succumbed  to the cold, I maintain that Jonas’s will to survive overpowered any feelings of resignation or despair. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are living happily ever after because I really want to know what happens next.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabriel get to the village that they saw and heard and live there. I don’t know what they will do in the village but I imagine that they will just get there, and stay there. My reasons for thinking this way? I just think that it would be the most satisfying ending for most people. No one wants a character who went through so many hardships and not make it to the end. In fact, I feel like Lois Lowry made it sound like Jonas would make it to the village. Chapter 23 had a moment when Jonas remembered everything in his life, and it made him happy, but before that he felt pain and he wanted to stop moving forward. “But he began, suddenly, to feel happy. He began to recall happy times” (Lowry 177). This quote from chapter 23 is one part of the whole chapter that shows how far Jonas had come, and how happy he is with the path he has taken. And because of this happiness that Jonas gets, I have a hard time believing that he doesn’t get to the village and live there.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe will eventually stop as the hill flattens because they can’t go downhill forever, and even if they did, it wouldn’t be a good end to the book. More specifically, I believe that they’re in Elsewhere right now. I think that everyone that has been released goes to Elsewhere after they’re killed and this is their afterlife. For example, (pull a quote from the text that supports your thinking). Lowry shows that, “Gabriel giggled and waved bye-bye back to him. ‘And somebody else comes to get him? Somebody from Elsewhere?” (Lowry 137). Although others might disagree that there is no afterlife in The Giver and they put the bodies down the chute just to get rid of them, I think the bodies go to Elsewhere and are put in a home with a family with a Christmas tree, and a fireplace, with presents neatly wrapped under the tree. I maintain that maybe Elsewhere is quite literally not even a place and the Giver and community adults say “elsewhere” meaning any place but here, but the community is so perfect that there would have to be somewhere else you can escape to, especially with a long adventure to pay the price. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are in Elsewhere now and will find a home here because they have come all this way and to find such a nostalgic place Jonas had in his mind makes a perfect place of Elsewhere.

Side note: I think the Giver gave Jonas the memory of snow and the sled as one of the first ones because he knew that if Jonas wanted to be released just as Rosemary was early on in her training, he wanted Jonas to at least recognize the place he was going.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have reached the place Jonas always wanted to go a family with feeling because the giver transmitted christmas memory to him so maybe that memory was actually happening in elsewhere.   . More specifically, I believe that the giver said he heard music first and ow Jonas is starting to hear music and it is snowing and there is music which means it is christmas.  For example, “For the first time , he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179).Lowry shows that he saw a house and he heard music and people singing but he also thought it was from the behind but he knew it was an echo, this is a sign of christmas in a house.   Although others might disagree that they are in heaven and dead I would disagree because they might go unconscious that doesn’t me they are dead. , I maintain that when Jonas thinks people are singing which means they are real people in a house singing carols.  Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have reached their christmas memory which is real because The truth is those memories actually happened and I think Elsewhere is the place where all the things happened, which means Jonas has reached his memory in real life.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to Elsewhere, where feelings, love, and empathy do exist. Where lives are truly lived. This is because happy endings exist.. More specifically, I believe that after all that struggle, there is just no way that Jonas and Gabe wouldn’t have made it. Jonas even says, in his last moments of The Giver that he heard music, and joy, and everything that he yearned for. For example, “Suddenly, he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby. For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 225). Lowry shows that Jonas and Gabe did arrive, by sheer luck, to where they needed to go. It was their salvation. Since they wandered aimlessly, I would also call it a miracle.. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe made it to their new community, I maintain that just because they were terribly weak, hungry, malnourished, thirsty, and without hope, doesn’t mean they weren’t among friends.Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to their desired community because happily ever afters exist, if not in the real world, but in the world where people can fly, do magic, and strive to beat the impossible.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe found the elsewhere that they worked so hard to find and I think that the family in the house took them in as their own raising Gabriel and Jonas. More specifically, I believe that they lived a happy life of the one they have always dreamed of. For example ¨they sped in a straight  line through a incision that seemed to lead to the final destination.(Lowry, 178).   Lowry shows that
this quote shows how Jonas can feel the joy of the house the same way he could feel his memories. Although others might disagree that a after book that would not have been able to exist if they had died or been released., I maintain that the book states this plenty of times on page 178. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found elsewhere and lived a happy life because this is why I think Jonas and Gabe lived a happy life at elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe (insert your thinking here) because (make your claim here). More specifically, I believe that (go deeper into your reasons why you believe this). For example, (pull a quote from the text that supports your thinking). Lowry shows that (explain the quote here). Although others might disagree that (this is where you anticipate their counter-argument here), I maintain that (this is where you show their counter argument to be false). Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe (restate your thinking) because (restate your own claim here using different wording than at the beginning).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died and found peace.because Jonas started to hear music and a place with love which is everything he wanted and he found that in peace.More specifically, I believe that Maybe the echo was the last thing he heard and when he crashed he reached heaven a place with music and love.For example,”Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below ahead they were waiting for him”(Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas starts to feel joy and no pain no struggles and that there was someone waiting for them which could be the past givers. Although others might disagree that they might have just joined a new community I maintain that why would people wait down there for Jonas to arrive since they never know that Jonas is coming to their community beforehand Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe died at the end because Jonas started to see everything he wanted a place with love and music which means he could have found peace.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere because when they went down the sled, Jonas saw elsewhere. More specifically, I believe that Jonas found elsewhere because he started to hear music and see colorful lights. For example, “He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry 225). Lowry shows that Jonas has reached the place that was always described in his memories. This place was elsewhere where there was love, and memories were made and kept. Although others might disagree that Gabe and Jonas didn’t make it to elsewhere, I maintain that they have reached elsewhere to start a new life, where they can live with emotions and memories. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have reached elsewhere because they heard music and saw the lights that were in the memory.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here: In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe die because they went Elsewhere. More specifically, I believe that they were released and that is how they went Elsewhere. For example, ¨…. the Elsewhere that held their future and their past¨ (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Elsewhere is the end of anyone´s life because it says it holds their future and their past. Although others might disagree that they found a new family, I maintain that they are just seeing memories when they are in Elsewhere. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are dead because you can only go to Elsewhere if you die or you get released.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe will have two different fates because Jonas is stronger than Gabe (health-wise) in the moment. More specifically, I believe that Jonas will find some shelter and live while Gabe dies from the cold. For example, at the end it talks about how Gabe was already very weak before they climbed what I believe not to be a hill but, a mountain “Gabriel moved feebly and whimpered briefly..” (Lowry 220). Lowry shows that before they started the climb he was starving, dirty, and tired. Although others might disagree that this ending may not be true and that if one dies both die, I maintain that my ending may not be official but still is a possibility because of logic. A baby (I don't believe) can survive in the snow without the proper clothing. While jonas was trained for this with the memories. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe will have different fates because Jonas was prepared while, Gabe was not at all.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe was able to find a house that is celebrating Christmas because in the book Jonas states that he sees green, red, and yellow lights and also hears music. More specifically, I believe that they found a house with warmth because the light may indicate that there was fire in the chimney. For example, the book states “He knew they were shining through the windows of the rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights” (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that by describing the lights in rooms and how vibrant they were. The author also shows that by describing the holiday as feeling love. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabriel found a house celebrating Christmas, I maintain that they found house because it says that they felt warmth again as they got closer to elsewhere. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe was able to find a house celebrating Christmas because Jonas had the memories that came back to him about his parents and friends giving love to each other, This might give the memory of love and warmth as they got closer to elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe sled into the afterlife because Jonas could feel happy memories when he got to the top of the hill. More specifically, I believe that Jonas will see everyone who was released in his community. For example, “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby” (Lowry, 178).  Lowry shows that Jonas could feel happiness coming from ahead and that everyone who was released was waiting for them. Although others might disagree that the released are dead, and Jonas did not die, I maintain that elsewhere has been where the released go all along. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have gone to elsewhere in the afterlife because Jonas could feel happy memories when he got to the top of the hill.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died because they didn’t have any food or any means of shelter, and the chances of finding houses with people there are very low. More specifically, I believe that they died because people usually say that you life flashes before you die, and Jonas’s memories flashed through his head. For example, ”Memories of joy flooded through him suddenly” (Lowry 177). Lowry shows that in that moment, all of Jonas’s memories flashed through his mind. Although others might disagree that Jonas survived and found Elsewhere, I maintain that were freezing and weak. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe died because they didn’t have any food, shelter, and they were weak and frozen.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe passed out before they reached the snow. because if the sled was from his memory its probably from another person from a long time ago the sled wound not survive. More specifically, I believe that Gabriel died of hypothermia Jonas then passed out and the rest is a dream. For example, “using his final strength and a special knowledge that was deep inside him Jonas found a sled” (lowery,178). Lowry shows that Jonas knew where to find a sled that magically appeared.. Although others might disagree that someone would have left his sled there and Jonas stumbles upon it   , I maintain that the lights that Jonas sees is far off in the distance and if people where to stop there and sled there should have been people there when Jonas found the sled. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe suffered immensely due to the snow because of the sudden finding of life in the distance and music that echoes.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe survived and ended up making it to a house wear the memories were then released to everyone because Jonas had explained that he felt like he was almost to else wear. More specifically, I believe that Jonas reached the house which was wear his memories of snow and the sled had come back. For example, “For the first time, he heard something he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 225). Lowry shows that Jonas had reached some place that could be else wear. Although others might disagree that Jonas ended up surviving and reaching elsewhere, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe heard the music and the people singing nearby. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe survived and made it to elsewhere because they were most likely very close based on what they had been through so far the journey could not have been too tough to make it to the house.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here: I Believe that Jonas and Gabe have found a new home and that they would have no regrets of leaving their old one. In the text, it states,” Memories of Joy flooded through him suddenly” (Lowry 177). Since Jonas sees that a new age/era in his life is to begin he feels happy. He remembers happy things such as his friend The Giver. This happiness both Jonas and Gabe haven’t felt in quite a while. Thus, signaling to me that they feel happy reaching their new home. Therefore Jonas and Gabe's new home is a start of a new chapter for them.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have found Elsewhere because all the memories Jonas has received started from this location. More specifically, I believe that most of the memories the giver transmitted to Jonas such as the sled, snow, music, and love are evident in Elsewhere. For example, Lowry states, “He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated lover” (Lowry 225). Through this quote, Lowry summarizes most of the memories that Jonas has received from the Giver and shows how this city contains all of the recollection. Although others might disagree that Jonas may have been hallucinating or he was slowly dying, I maintain that Jonas and Gabriel have found the city Elsewhere because memories such as music and the family gathered together during Christmas showing love and affection were all shown and made from this city. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have founded the city they call Elsewhere because the city contains all of the memories Jonas has received during his training.

# data[].attributes.body
In my personal opinion, I believe that Jonas and Gabe passed away and reached Heaven, what they acknowledged as Elsewhere. In further detail, I think that they passed away while they were going down on the sled hill to reach Elsewhere, which is why I believe that what Jonas saw was a hallucination. The author states, “Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too, for the baby” (Lowry 178). Lowry expresses the knowledge that Jonas is suddenly aware of his surroundings, even though he had lost all his strength and almost all of his consciousness. This means that Jonas must have gotten a surge of energy, most likely due to his passing. Although others may disagree with this idea, it makes sense, as for a twelve year-old boy to survive all alone in the snow with a baby is nearly impossible as both bodies aren’t strong enough for that. That is why I therefore conclude that Jonas and Gabe passed away and experienced a hallucination of all of the pleasant memories that they had once seen and wished to experience.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to the place with all the good memories of happiness, love, and family because when he came down the hill he was talking how they were in the middle of a celebration with the lights on the tree, signing, and love between the family. More specifically, I believe that he found the place that he wanted everybody in his community to have in their life. For example, “He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love”(Lowry 225). Lowry shows that He has found the memories that The Giver gave him of love and happiness in the past. Although others might disagree that this just a dream or a imagination, I maintain that this is not a dream because he is trying really hard to keep going which means he has to be doing it right then. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found their place that has all of the good and warm memories because he saw everything that makes you feel good and warm the happiness, the family, and most important the love.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe were going into the hospitality of Rosemary, The Giver’s daughter, because earlier in the book The Giver claimed that he was going to visit his daughter, so that must mean she is still alive and now waiting for Jonas. More specifically, I believe that since Rosemary has the power to receive, she may have to power to hear beyond as well and she could be the one singing inside the home filled with love. For example, “‘But I have another place to go. When my work here is finished, I want to be with my daughter’” (Lowry 162). Lowry shows that The Giver longs to be with the person he loves, so he could come home to find both Rosemary and Jonas waiting for him Although others might disagree that the ending could take place like this, where The Giver, Rosemary, and Jonas all reunite, I maintain that this is possible because The Giver had cared for Jonas a lot as well as he did Rosemary so what was going through his mind could only be wanting to be with them both after the chaos in the community. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were journeying into the house where Rosemary lives because Rosemary knows exactly what the feeling of warmth and love is, so an arranged reunion for Jonas and Gabe is just what they need.

# data[].attributes.body
In my perspective, I imagine Jonas and Gabe sled down the hill and arrive at warm and pleasant houses during the celebration of Christmas: because the winter season brings merriment and mirth to everyone. More precisely, I believe that there could be a shift between the harsh, bitter winter and the warmth and glee of the houses of Elsewhere after the grueling travels of Jonas and Gabe. In moreover detail, they will finally experience the memories for which Jonas longed and yearned. As an exemplification, the text in The Giver writes, “He knew they were shining through windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry 178). Although others may dissent that Jonas and Gabriel only face misfortune after eluding the Community, I maintain that Jonas and Gabriel’s efforts would not go to vain and that they would find the happiness and love they sought after their plight of traveling. Therefore, I deduce that Jonas and Gabe arrive at the joyful houses in Elsewhere; they will finally discover what they sought: the vast world of happiness, love, and hope.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe didn't make it to Elsewhere and instead died, because when people die, most of them describe it as 'their life flashing before their eyes', as we can see with Jonas when the author writes, "Memories of joy flooded through him suddenly. He reached the place where the hill crested and he could feel the ground under his snow-covered feet become level. It would not be uphill anymore. "We're almost there, Gabriel," he whispered, feeling quite certain without knowing why." (Lowry 175). Lowry makes it very clear that Jonas had memories rush to him, like 'his life flashing before his eyes". Another example from the passage is when the author writes, “Jonas found himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright on the sled”(Lowry 178). This means that Jonas, nearing the end of his life, didn't have control over his body, as he slowly lost conciousness.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe actually dies because people who are released goes to Elsewhere. More specifically, I believe that in “The Giver”, there is actually a gateway or way that actually leads to death or Elsewhere since Jonas and Gabe just went there. For example, “Then I perform a small Ceremony of Release...someone else comes gets him?  Someone from Elsewhere?  That’s right.”(Lowry 137). Lowry shows that people who are released actually goes Elsewhere just like the smaller twin among the twins. Although others might disagree that there is no gateway to death, I maintain that this is how it is in Jonas’s world or dimension. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe dies because release means going to Elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe, had survived and they had found “elsewhere” where they lived a happy life, because I believe that they had a happy ending. More specifically, I think they get taken in by the family in the house, because Jonas said that he could he a house, and lights. For example, “He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms,that they were red, blue and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories , where they celebrated love” (Lowry,178). Lowry shows that, hey found elsewhere because he could hear music, and see lights which he would have not seen in the community. Although other might disagree and say,they died, I maintain that they have a happy ending where everything works out. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have a happy ending where they find elsewhere because I just believe that all the hardships he went through deserves a happy ending.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe will find a new family in the elsewhere because at the end the shows us that Jonas can hear music, laughter and he can feel love. More specifically, I believe that (Jonas and gabe will start a new life in the elsewhere). For example, (¨Downward download faster and faster suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead,they were waiting for him; and that they were waiting, too,for the baby. For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music¨ (lowry, 179). Lowry shows that Jonas has reached his goal he has entered the elsewhere. Although others might disagree that Jonas has reached elsewhere, I maintain that Jonas is feeling happy Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have reached the elsewhere  because of the joyousness they feel.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have entered into the Elsewhere that Jonas believed in because It made Jonas suddenly happy.More specifically, I believe that Jonas have entered the memories that Jonas received from the Giver.. For example, “where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry 225 ). Lowry shows that Jonas and Gabriel have traveled into the memories that the Giver gave Jonas because the scene with the celebration families were one of the memories given by the Giver. Although others might disagree that They didn’t enter the memories, I maintain that Jonas and Gabriel have entered Elsewhere, a place where people aren’t constrained by emotions.. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have traveled to a place where happiness is real because Elsewhere, the only place of happiness in Jonas’s world, is where Jonas and Gabriel went to at the end.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a  cabin filled with lights and snow because i think if they stick with the plan they should make it ok .More specifically, I believe that christmas was being honored and everyone was enjoying their time, For example, “and all at once he could see lights” (Lowry 225). The author shows that jonas can see lights so he can see colors.. Although others might disagree that he might have imagined seeing colors. I maintain  that he did see colors. Therefor a concluded  that jonas and gabe did make it and had a wonderful time and had a miracl

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe do make it over the hill alive because Jonas was constantly giving and thinking of warmth to myself and Gabe. More specifically, I believe that with the promise Jonas made to the giver he might still want to  keep that promise and let Gabe live unlike that baby who was released. For example, “We’re almost there, Gabriel,” he whispered, feeling quite certain without knowing why” (Lowery 177). Lowry shows that Jonas has the feeling the will make it out alive and that Lois Lowry would out this statement to prove that they do make it to elsewhere. Although others might disagree that maybe Jonas and Gabe don’t make it in time due to their physical condition,I maintain that they have enough energy from the memories and feelings. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe make it to the lights.

# data[].attributes.body
Your draft goes here: In my view I believe that Jonas and Gabe found a place to stay where they hears the music. I believe that because it was probably a house or restaurant where they would be able to get comfort and food by going inside. More specifically there could be a kind family or person at the place that would help them and treat them to food out of kindness. Lowry shows that they basically found a place that can comfort them even though he didn’t show us the ending. Although others might disagree with me that something else could have happend I believe that the place they saw was either a home or a restaurant because usually at some restaurants they play music. This could also be a home because maye some people in the house play music and like singing. Therefore I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were met by a home or some sort of restaurant by the music playing.

# data[].attributes.body
In my veiw, I beleive taht Jonas and Gabe found somewhere that they can live and share their memories. For example “red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry 178). This shows that Jonas heard  music and people.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe fell and lost consciousness and were found by the people that live Elsewhere, because the residents of the houses would probably have found them and would have tried to save them. More specifically, I believe that Gabriel was weakened, exhausted, and hungry, but he was cared for; so he lived on. For example, Jonas continues to lend Gabriel memories of comfort and warmth to keep him alive. By doing this, Gabriel “...stirred against him as he began to climb” (Lowry 176). Lowry shows that Jonas gathered the strength and will to live through his lifestyle, making him invulnerable to any circumstances. Although others might disagree that Gabriel and Jonas were just fine, I believe that they had the courage and the tiniest bit of strength to be saved, maintain that they were okay throughout their entire journey. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found hope through their travels because they had the courage to live a new life in honesty.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to some kind of a village that is not a community because he was hearing music and maybe in that village, someone was playing music and so Jonas heard music from outside. More specifically, I believe that he found “elsewhere” and “elsewhere” was a village far from the community he was living. Jonas got the memories of joy, warmth, love back because the place he found was a normal place with everyone having the memories. For example, “But he began, suddenly, to feel happy. He began to call happy times. He remembered his parents and his sister, he remembered his friends, Asher and Fiona. He remembered The Giver. Memories of Joy flooded suddenly” (Lowry 177). Lowry shows that because he got the memories he lost while coming to this place, he somehow found a place where memories of joy and happiness still belonged to everyone and so he found the place where he needed to go. Although others might disagree that he was dying in the snow with happy memories or already dead, I maintain that he found a good place with all the memories. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to the place where memories are in everyone because he was hearing music and maybe in that village, someone was playing music and so Jonas heard music from outside

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe the Jonas and Gabe celebrate Christmas with the caroling families, and he experiences grandparents because he does the exact same thing as in the memories, so I think he will experience them himself. More specifically, I believe that he is going to go into one of the buildings and become adopted along with Gabriel. For example, “For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 179). Lowry shows that he hears music, and that there is snow shortly before. Although others might think that they are in the Southern Hemisphere, there is much more population and land in the Northern Hemisphere, so there is much less chance. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are going to be adopted on Christmas.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe meets the female receiver because the female giver ran away. For example, “red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas finds a small house and he hears music with people celebrating. Although others might disagree that this might be the female giver that ran away.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe found somewhere to stay and be cared for and shown new things because They saw a house with lights and singing and most books and movies end with a happy ending. More specifically, I believe that (Jonas and Gabe found a very happy place with people that loved and cared for them and eventually adopted them as children. For example, The author states, “...he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him; and for the baby too” (Lowry 225) Lowry shows that Jonas feels like people are waiting for him and that people love him and are ready for him. (Although others might disagree that they are found and loved because they are such outcasts and unloved and known be no one and people might think they are crazy.  I maintain that people are good enough to love and care for someone with a little child and for a kid who is desperate. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found a house that cared and loved for them because They are good kids and loving and they need a home.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died because they had starved to death or in other ways. More specifically, I believe that they no longer had the energy to continued and died right when they reached elsewhere. For example, “Jonas found himself losing consciousness and with his whole being willed himself to stay upright on the sled”(Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas used his final energy in order to get gabriel to safety, but in the process sacrificed himself. Though he made have reached elsewhere he would most likely be on the brink of death and because gabriel is a baby he too would probably be gone too. Although others might disagree that Jonas reached elsewhere and survived, I maintain that he died at the moment though exhaustion, starvation or freezing to death. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe died when they reached elsewhere because both boys could not possibly survive the extent that there fragile bodies experienced without prior experience.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe got to Elsewhere and began to see things that they have never seen before. More specifically, I believe that they were able to see/hear new thing like when Jonas started to hear music as he got closer to Elsewhere. For example, “Behind him, across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too” ( Lowry, 179 ). Lowry shows that once Jonas and Gabe got to elsewhere, they right away got to experience music. Although others might disagree that this is what happened with Jonas and Gabe at the end, I maintain that the book shows that Jonas and Gabe will get to learn to things at Elsewhere in the future. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe will continue to learn more things in the future because Elsewhere will show them brand new things they have yet to see.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe go into the town, and somebody helps them into their own house because people in this town have feelings and care for Jonas and Gabriel. More specifically, I believe that they were given food and a shelter. For example, “ Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, that they were waiting for him” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that people are waiting with open arms to care for him and him. Although others might disagree that it never shows that he is welcomed in to a home, I maintain that he was welcomed into the town. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were taken in and cared for because this is elsewhere and in elsewhere people have feelings for Jonas and Gabriel.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe meet up with the Giver, and possibly Rosemary because, The Giver’s love for the children is too strong to leave behind. More specifically, I believe that inside the house is Rosemary and the Giver because the Giver loved both Rosemary and Jonas, and I don’t think that the Giver would just let that all go. For example, “You can understand, then, that that’s what I felt for Rosemary, the giver explained, I loved her. I feel it for you too. The giver added”(Lowry 141). Lowry shows that the bond between the Giver, Rosemary, and Jonas were so strong, that there is no way they could leave that all behind. Although others might disagree that the Giver would leave the community to deal with the memories themselves, I maintain that The Givers love for the children is too strong. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe meet the Giver at the Cabin because their love for each other is too strong.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe passed away and entered heaven because Jonas was able to feel warm and happy, cleary there was no source of warmth anywhere nearby so the obvious answer is that Jonas was slowly dying..  More specifically, I believe that the “Elsewhere” that Jonas and the Giver kept talking about was  actually Heaven. I also think the Giver knew this, and thought that the only way Jonas could actually escape was by dying.  For example,”..he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only and Echo”(Lowry 179). Lowry shows that the music Jonas was hearing was actually a faint voice calling him up into heaven. Although others might disagree that Jonas actually found a place that was exactly like he imagined, I maintain that Jonas and gabriel passed away and were entering heaven. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found “Elsewhere” because “Elsewhere” was heaven, the only place where Jonas and Gabriel could truly be free.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Jonas and Gabe had gotten to elsewhere and everyone had been reminded of the past and everyone started to change. I think this because he had here people singing and Jonas was starting to hear beyond. For example it says that “From the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo” (Lowry 225). This shows that Jonas had changed the community by giving them the memories he had received from the Giver. This is why I think Jonas and Gabe had gotten to elsewhere.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe find a new family because at the end of the story they hear music and see a house. More specifically, I believe that the Giver knew about this place/house and that’s why he told Jonas to leave. For example, the book states, “He would need those to help him find him the Elsewhere that they were both sure existed”(Lowry, 158).. Lowry shows that they both knew where Elsewhere was.. Although others might disagree that and might think he lived somewhere else with Gabe, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe both found  a nice cabin by the woods with a family. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe found a new family  to start a new life.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jonas and Gabe rode down the hill toward a house that was celebrating Christmas because Jonas had a memory about Christmas and love like the house that they are approaching.  More specifically, I believe that this happened because Jonas had a memory of riding down a hill and christmas which was what happened in the book. It relates to him because he left to experience the things like love and family which is what was in the house. For example,”...life hungry for feelings,for color, for love” (Lowry 173).  Lowry shows that the reason Jonas left is because he wanted to experience those feeling and not be stuck in a sameness community. . Although others might disagree that he wouldn’t go to a house of family and warmth. I maintain that he is going somewhere where there is a family waiting for him and able to give him love. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe was going to a house with a family and love for them to because Jonas had the memory of love and family which shows that he was leaving the community for those things.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere  because in the last chapter in the book it said Jonas heard music and saw twinkling lights which were not in his community. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe were able to find elsewhere . For example,¨ For the first time he heard something that he knew to be music He heard people singing¨( Lowry 179). Lowry shows that Jonas had heard people singing and herd music which he knew had to be elsewhere. Although others might disagree that it might have not been elsewhere , I maintain that he was able to find elsewhere . Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were able to find elsewhere and live a happy life  because  Jonas heard music and saw twinkling lights which were not in his community .

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe venture towards the music and eventually become safe  because in the book it is common for joy to be affiliated with joy as we can see through the Giver. More specifically, I also believe that Jonas and Gabe start a life in elsewhere because of the music proving that there isn’t sameness any more . For example,”Suddenly he was aware with certainty and joy that below, ahead, they were waiting for him” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that throughout his memories and wisdom he could tell that this was “elsewhere”. The music is a symbol for happiness and love which further proves that Jonas and Gabe were safe.. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe died as they were very weak and malnourished, I maintain that they were okay as there were music and lights and love, a feeling virtually unheard of before Jonas’s selection.. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were joy and received much joy because of the music which symbolized joy and happiness.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe find another place to become their new home, because Jonas says he can hear people singing ahead, see the lights of houses, and feel that their destination is just ahead. More specifically, I believe that they find a town or other settlement where they are welcomed, and it becomes their home. For example, in the book it states, “He forced his eyes open as they went downward, downward, sliding, and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew that they were shining through the windows of rooms...For the first time, he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people singing” (Lowry 178-179). In this quote, Lowry shows that Jonas and Gabriel’s destination is just ahead of them. Although others might disagree that the two boys die, I maintain that they live and find a new place to call home. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe find another settlement just ahead, because Jonas can see and hear the signs of civilization, and feel that his destination lies just a bit further.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe go to the houses because that is something Jonas is familiar with. More specifically, I believe that since Jonas is familiar with houses, he might feel safer as to if he saw something new. For example, “And all at once he ould see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew they were shining through windows of rooms” (Lowry 178). Lowry shows that Jonas knows that the lights he is seeing are houses. Although others might disagree that since it was a new place Jonas doesn’t have memories of, I maintain that obviously Jonas still has those memories of his own if he is recognizing them. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe may go towards the houses because Jonas is familiar with them.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe were taken into another dimension of space and time because obviously they were not in the regular world. This possibly was because they were in another dimension were all these things existed. More specifically, I believe that they were in another galaxy, in another dimension in space and time, where an event like the big bang occured, but traits such as color and emotion didn’t come through.  For example, “Behind him, across vast distances of space and time, from the place he had left”(Lowry 225). Lowry shows that the community is another dimension across space and time. This could mean that Jonas escaped that dimension and possibly was granted the ability to hear music. Although others might disagree that, they went to another dimension of space and time, the author clearly tells us that they are in another dimension. I maintain that as author shows us what happened. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were taken to another dimension in space and time, possibly even our time, because the author shows that they have been crossing dimensions during their ride.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to a nice snowing cabin with warmth and family, because I want to think positive, because you could think negatively about this but I want a happy ending for them and seeing the lights made me think of a little christmas tree in the snow. More specifically, I believe that they were celebrating Christmas, and they were handing out presents and they were grandparents, parents, and siblings. For example, “and all at once he could see lights” (Lowry 225). Lowry shows that Jonas could see the lights of a tree, because later own they say he could see the colors. Although others might disagree that this could be a hallucination and him maybe slowly dying with a happy thought, I maintain that I think there would be a happy ending. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe saw a house celebrating Christmas because of the lights they saw.