# data[].attributes.body
Black - Clarence
Square - Suspect Home
Circle - Orchard Road for Beers
Took a detour to office 21:59
From statement - he said been home around 11pm, location data is 23:17 (checks out)

Red - Christina
Square - Home?

# data[].attributes.headline
Timeline of Beng and Charlie/Charles Park

# data[].attributes.subject
Timeline of Beng and Charlie/Charles Park

# data[].attributes.body
Stephen - no if the data is correctly tracked
Michelle - no
Jason - yes
Clarance - yes
Lillian - no
Saphia - low chance
Simon - possible, but not able to identify motive.
Bo Jing - no
Tan Choon Beng - suspicious because not at the same place with Charles (is Charles = Charlie?)
Charles - possible

# data[].attributes.body
- "I have been working with Christina and Stephen for the last 5 years."
- 'I spent Thursday morning meeting with a client, Simon Carter at the office.  He left around 1230 and I popped out to collect lunch. "
--> "I left around 1115 and spent the rest of the day on the phone to my teak carvers in Bali. " by Simon --> conflicts of Simon's left time
- "I was surprised that she was keen to get involved with Simon Carter but she seemed insistent."
- "I left work around 530 and drove home. "
- "He arrived around 630 and we ate and had a bottle of wine.  We went to bed around 11pm."
--> data has proved Michelle's route
--> takes 1 hour 55 min walking, 22 minutes driving, 40 minutes by bicycle
| 80 Robinson Rd  | 20/9/2018 13:17
| 159 Sixth Avenue  | 20/9/2018 18:05
| 159 Sixth Avenue  | 20/9/2018 23:55
| 80 Robinson Rd  | 21/9/2018 9:06
--> Question: how to get the data
- "I was on my way to work the following morning when Jason called to tell me that Christina was dead.  "

# data[].attributes.body
Jason - 20:32 (claims Christina didnt see him)
Clarence - 21:59 (4 mins after Christina arrival)

# data[].attributes.body
Simon Carter
a) Luxury yatch seller based in Queensland
b) Works done in Singapore with interiors done in Indonesia
c) Deal directly with Christina but moved to Michelle (why?)
d) Meeting on Thursday, entered office at 950am --> from location trace, did not see Simon entering office at 954am, Simon's location is at The Great Room, One George Street
e) Christina joined at 1045am but they would not budge (means?)
f) Left around 1115am and spent rest of the day communicating with teak carvers in Bali (legit, since interiors done in Indonesia), but communicated in hotel?
g) Room service in hotel (the whole day?) --> Where is the hotel located?
h) Received call of Christina's death on 3pm Friday (who called? the cops?)

Relationship: Christina and Michelle

Bo Jin
a) Property investor with father starting the business and herself continuing the business and based on Jahor and Singapore.
b) Only daughter
c) Christina was her rock and more of a friend than a lawyer.
d) Health issues with heart and would ask Christina to look after her affairs after she is gone.
e) Stephen also good friend. Met Stephen for dinner on Thursday at Club Street to discuss new will (why discuss new will OUTSIDE of office). Consistent with Stephen's statement.
f) Leave everything to monastery.
g) Reach home at 1030pm and went straight to bed.
h) 280 Ocean Drive, Sentosa Cove --> assume that's her house address

Relationship: Christina and Stephen

Beng
a) Debt collector
b) Clarence help him to ensure everything he does is above board.
c) Clarence advise when to push and when to hold back.
d) Got himself into a spot of bother, and Clarence help him stay clean.
e) Trading business with Charlie Park (Michelle's Husband)
f) Spent Thursday in lock up sorting things (what lock up and why?)
g) Charlie Park dropped by around 3pm and hang out for about 45mins. --> Charlie did not meet Beng. They were not in the same place at all.
h) By 345pm or later, went for beer and food with Clarence and finished by 830pm --> verified.
i) After 830pm, moved on to a place in Orchard Towers for more beers.
j) Lost track of Clarence and did not see him till next day.
k)

Relationship: Clarence and Charlie Park

# data[].attributes.body
Background Information:
- Office manager
- Worked for 2 Years
- Enjoys her job and her colleagues

Analysis:
- Mentioned that Jason was shouting at Christina. Are they on really bad terms? What is it that they have disagreements on?
- Went home at 1700 and stayed home (Bukit Batok Ave 6).No evidence and support of alibi.
> False statement. On 21/9, 20:55 she was found to be at 99 Meyer Road.
> Stephen (Partner) was at 99 Meyer Road on 20/9, 22:06 to 21/9, 06:54.
> May have chances that Saphia was with Stephen till the morning of 21/9, and went to the office after.

Chances of Saphia and Stephen being in a secret office relationship is high. But low suspect for the murder.

# data[].attributes.body
- "I’ve known Christina nearly six years ago now. "
- "I came in late on Thursday because I’d been out with friends playing rugby on Wednesday evening and we’d been drinking until late."
- "I had a meeting in the evening with Bo Jing on club street, one of my clients.  suppose I got home around  930 or 10."
--> 12 minutes walk from Club Street to office
--> "character data" has shown his route and not lying
| 85 Club Street  | 20/9/2018 18:19 --> meeting with Bo Jing
| 99 Meyer Rd  | 20/9/2018 22:06 --> should be his home
| 99 Meyer Rd  | 21/9/2018 6:54
| 80 Robinson Rd  | 21/9/2018 9:25 --> office
--> Question: how to get the data? mobile phone or car?
- "Jason called me in the morning and I came straight in.  I must have gotten there by about 915am."

# data[].attributes.body
Clarence was back to office at 21:59 according to location info but he hide that in his statement - what did he do at office?

# data[].attributes.body
20/9
19:06 - 90 Robertson Quay (Maybe her home? according to map)
20:55 - 80 Robinson Rd
21:55 - 80 Robinson Rd
22:00 ~ 23:00 - Time of Death

21/9
07:15 Found Dead

# data[].attributes.body
What is the personal financial situation of Christina ?

Is there any chance that this is related to the lending money business of Charles ?

# data[].attributes.body
Background Information:
- Office Cleaner
- Worked for 3 Years
- Starts her shift at 6:30am
- Night Owl: Sleeps during the day and Stay up during the night.
- First person to found Christina dead on Friday morning

Analysis:
- Would the sleeping pills belong to her?
> No evidence of this.

- She sleeps during office hours?
> No. Based on her timestamp, she lives at 76A Redhill Road and went home after her work at 80 Robinson Road.

- Spend nights out means there is a possibility that she is in the office at night (but, no mentions of it so far).
> Based on her character data, she was at 10 Bayfront Ave on 20/9, 21:32 - not the office.

- Why did Lillian look exhausted to Clarence when she stuck with her usual sleeping routine? Was it only that Friday morning? Where did Lillian go that night (no mentions of it yet)?
> Based on her character data, she was at 10 Bayfront Ave on 20/9, 21:32 - not the office.

- Lillian called Michelle and spoke to Charles instead
> Not a suspicious activity

- The one who called the police
> Not a suspicious activity

Lillian activities and statement is not fishy. Doesn't seem like the suspect.

# data[].attributes.body
Not knowing Christina well ... does not make sense while he has been married with the Michelle for 15 years ?

At least the relationship should be closer than "not knowing well" ?

There might be some hidden relations between these 3 persons?

# data[].attributes.body
Doctor DID NOT prescribe her nay sleeping pills nor did she ever reported needing any

# data[].attributes.body
He claimed,  "I do know that Clarence is pretty mad that he hasn’t been made a partner and that Saphia and Stephen spend way more time together than work colleagues should."

-Secret relationship between Saphia and Stephen?

# data[].attributes.headline
Clarence Cheung, Staff & Tan Choon, Client

# data[].attributes.subject
Clarence Cheung, Staff & Tan Choon, Client

# data[].attributes.body
Clarence claimed "We had dinner and a drink on Orchard Road until late.  I don’t remember when I got home but it must have been about 11pm."

However, his client, Tan Choon said "We must have finished about 830 and then moved on to a place in Orchard Towers and had a few more beers. I lost track of him later on and did not see him again until today at here at the station."

- Is Clarence lying about the time? As Christina time of death was between 2200-2300

# data[].attributes.body
·       Dead for about 8 hours
·       Which part of the office found?
·       Fishy - heart attack with traces of sleeping pills
·       Found dead in her office.