# data[].attributes.body
The Outsiders: When Darry slapped Ponyboy.

Ponyboy fell asleep in the parking lot with Johnny and when he got home it was 3am. Darry, his older brother, got very angry because he was worried. He yelled at Ponyboy then Soda yelled at Darry for yelling at Ponyboy. Then Darry yelled at Soda for him to stay out of it, then Ponyboy yelled at Darry for yelling at Soda. I can see both sides of this and I think they are both to blame. Darry overreacted and slapped Ponyboy while Ponyboy was late and Darry was extremely worried.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter:
1. the main character is Elizabeth she is a determined, intelligent, caring strong, and brave character.
2. some secondary characters are Nicholas and Celeb. Nicholas is the person who saves her and causes her to join the Reformist. Celeb is the one who caused her to be a witch hunter and then she was able to help the reformist because she knew how to fight and she had her stigma.
3. the problem in the book is that magic is ban and if you use magic you will be burned.
4. the main character is trying to destroy the 13th tablet so Nicholas won't die and he can stop Blackwell.
5. I like the fighting and the magic because fantasy and action are my favorite genres and it makes the book come together.
6. I don't like that in the end of the Blackwell does not die because he was a horrible and cruel person.

# data[].attributes.body
The Outsiders: When Johnny killed the Soc.

I was surprised when Johnny killed the Soc because he is a kind hearted, lovable person who wouldn't hurt anyone and would never try to get him or his friends in trouble. Johnny killed the Soc because he was drowning Ponyboy in the fountain. I still did not expect him to be brave enough to do something especially because the Soc was a lot bigger and older than Johnny.

# data[].attributes.body
The Outsiders: after the rumble when they go to see Johnny.

I was surprised that Johnny died. I was surprised because he was a very important part of the book, he was the reason they ran away, he saved Ponyboy's life, he help save the kids in the burning church, and the obvious one that is said a hundred times in the book he holds the hang together. without him the gang would brake apart, Dally would be extremely upset, Ponyboy would horrified and blame himself, Darry would blame himself for slapping Ponyboy causing them to go to the park then kill bob and run away, that would cause soda to be sad that Ponyboy and Darry were sad, that would cause Steve to get mad and attack a Soc and get hurt, and finally because everyone else is sad and depressed Two-bit will be depressed as well.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter:
Throughout the book.

I am wondering how Nicholas became a powerful wizard. He doesn't have a master and he has an apprentice. Either his master died or he finished his apprenticeship to become a wizard.  Even if he were to finish his apprenticeship we probably would have seen his master with the reformist.  Plus, if the master was dead Nicholas would still talk about him and say how he was a great master. I am also wondering what type  elf magic Nicholas specializes in. So far each wizard specializes in one type of magic. For example, they could be a Seer and see the future, they could be a Healer and heal people, there are necromancers who bring people back from the dead to serve them, or he could be a fire wizard. The strange thing is that we haven't seen him use any types of these magics throuought the book. We have only seen him do three things with his magic: 1) open a locked prison door without a key, 2) make illusions of himself, and 3) make a image of a solar system of the galaxy on the ceiling of a room. None of these are specific types of magic. There was one time he cast a spell with his apprentice and we never found out what happened because Elizabeth left before the spell was finished and it must have been extremely powerful because it got rid of 14 people who were used to fighting magic.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: After Elizabeth understands that curses are more powerful when put into a tomb where someone died violently and she realizes everything that happened after she found the 13th tablet in the tomb.

I was surprised when Elizabeth figured out the whole reasoning behind the 13th tablet. It made so much sense yet it was a surprise because they made to make a bunch of foreshadowing but you wouldn't realize it until you got to the section where she sees the tablet. It all makes sense when you read that section of the book. I was also surprised when everything in the book came together and it was so obvious but so well hidden that if I were to read again I would notice the hints. Plus, I was also surprised at how well they transitioned from the test/allusion to reality and what happened because everything that happened in reality seemed to be part of her test/allusion because it was all the things she was scared of and she was still able to overcome it even though it was real.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: the end of the book when Elizabeth goes to kill Blackwell and Celeb got in the way and was killed.

I am unhappy that at the end of the book because she did not kill Blackwell. I was unhappy because Blackwell than became king, he lied and tried to kill them, he killed most of his apprentices, He killed 100s of witches, he torcheres people, and he lied to become king and blamed the problems on the old king as a lie. I feel as though justice was not served. Blackwell in one of the other books is eventually killed, but he is still a formidable foe in the next book. I am expecting justice to be served in the next book of the series. I expect this because most of the time in a book, movie or play there is almost always a resolution and justice i served to the villain at the end of the story.

# data[].attributes.body
the Witch Hunter: the end of the story when Elizabeth kills Celeb.

I fell sorry for Elizabeth because she killed her former friend and who always helped her and was her role model. I can sort of relate because I had a friend that I thought was loyal and they weren't loyal so they choose other friends over me. I also can empathy's for her because if I accidentally killed my former best friend I would only sulk and never face it. But she was brave and did not try and believe that it wasn't true and deny it. I can also empathy's that she felt betrayed by her former friend who tried to hurt her friend

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: the end of the story when John and Elizabeth fall in love

upon reading the end and finding out that they have a mutual attraction/relationship I realized it was a circular story because john's mother and sister were arrested and killed by a witch hunter. but in the end Elizabeth a witch hunter saved his life. His heart was destroyed by a witch hunter but then he fell in love with a witch hunter and his heart was restored.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: The king's guard found a magic herb that fell out of Elizabeth's pocket.

If the guard did not see the herb or if the herb did not fall out of her pocket she would not of been on trial, then she would not of been thrown in jail, rescued by Nicholas, healed by john and would not of helped them against the witch hunters. therefor there would not be a story and there would not be a sequel or a prequel. but because the guard found the herb that fell out of her pocket, she met John, Nicholas, Fifer, and George. then joined them against the witch hunters and is trying to save Nicholas.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: following Elizabeth growth and change from the beginning of the book till now

In the beginning of the book, Elizabeth is very close to a friend named Celeb but later they both changed and grew apart. Celeb used to come by and talk to Elizabeth all the time but towards the middle of the book where I am now, he does not go see her and she does not go to see him. This reminds me of the poem we are reading in class called "JB and I". In this poem the two brothers are twins that used to do everything together until JB started dating Ms. Sweet Tea. They spend all their time together so now the brothers do not do anything together and barely talk.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: following Elizabeth's growth and change from the beginning of the book till now.

The character Elizabeth has changed a lot from the beginning of the book. For example her thoughts on magic and wizards and witches has changed. At first Elizabeth thought magic was dangerous and evil and now she thinks that magic is useful and a great asset. Two people saved her life using magic and this helped her realize that magic truly is good. This reminds me of how I used to think of Spanish class. Before I thought Spanish was useless, that I would never use in my life but now I know that it is very useful. If I go to a Spanish speaking country I would not be confused. Plus I need to learn Spanish to graduate high school.

# data[].attributes.body
The Witch Hunter: She is on trial accused of being a witch.

I was surprised when Blackwell proclaimed her sentence for punishment for being a witch. I was surprised because in the book Elizabeth is one of his best witch hunters(a witch hunter is a person who arrests people who have magic herbs or are using witch craft for better or worse). She is sentenced to death by Blackwell for using 1 tiny herb that can't hurt anyone. I was surprised because I expected him to pardon her sentence. After I read that I thought I had misread it because it was so surprising.

# data[].attributes.body
What is the setting or time period?

the time period is the sail om witch trials and it takes place in an England with real witches, wizards, and magic herbs.

What does the setting look like, sound like, feels like, etc...?

the setting smells of people burning and in a necromancers house it smells like rotting flesh, it looks like some one burning at a cross and being hung in the street Tyburn, it also looks like the city of London, England

What are some similarities and differences to today's time period or America?

There are more differences than similarities. the differences included in the book are that there are laws against magic while our laws don't even mention magic. Also their punishments for breaking laws are being burned or hung in front of the community, though we put people in jail instead. the books setting is in the past in England so they don't have electricity or paper so the laws are posted on stone tablets. so similarities are that we both have secret police and trials to determine if some one is guilty. another similarity is that the people on charge have a lot of power.