# data[].attributes.body
Pa changed from not liking shiloh to liking shiloh because he said he could have him if it was okay with Judd Traver but Marty worked for shiloh and he got shiloh and they both were happy and Judd was kind of nice

# data[].attributes.body
Marty changed by getting Shiloh because he loves Shiloh and they play together and they have fun.I think Marty and Shiloh have a good connection.

# data[].attributes.body
At first Marty was scared of Judd but then he wasn't. We know he is scared because in the story Marty found a dog that got shot in its head and Marty thought that Judd might shoot him too if he tells anyone about the doe.But they made a deal that Marty works 2 dollars an hour.

# data[].attributes.body
Pa at first,didn't want Shiloh.Later on in the story Pa said that Marty could have Shiloh if it was okay with Judd.

# data[].attributes.body
from the breggining of the story judd was mean to his dogs and marty.judd was nicer to marty and his dogs. Then they got along well.Judd let Marty keep the dog because Marty worked for him.And thats how Judd and Marty got along.Marty played with shioh. Judd gave Marty a couler.It was a old couler.Marty was happy that happy that he had the dog.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning of the story ma did not like shiloh but now she does.She is starting to like him in bits and pieces and shiloh is getting famous for Ma. she is also kind to him. Even shiloh likes Ma a lot.shiloh is cute is what Ma thinks.

# data[].attributes.body
ln the story pa did't like shiloh but in the end pa likes him.

# data[].attributes.body
Pa said no to Marty to keep Shiloh the beggining of the story now Pa said yes to Marty to keep Shiloh.Pa did not like Shiloh at first now Pa loves him. Pa is Martys Dad.He feed Shiloh any crumbs they have left overs from breakfist,lunch,and dinner.He was poor.Pa was never vain.He wants to know everything , so no secrets!!They cannot afford a dog.

# data[].attributes.body
Judd was mean in the biggining but nice at the end because at the biggining it said that marty was very mad at Judd.And at the end Judd gave shiloh to Marty

# data[].attributes.body
In the beggning judd was nice. And judd was mean frist.

# data[].attributes.body
In the begening Judd is bad because he went in to Marty,s house with out asking. but at the end he was a little nice because he gave Marty a dog collar.

# data[].attributes.body
Marty changed from lieing .

# data[].attributes.body
Marty changes Ma by making her like Shiloh. Also by getting Ma to get Shiloh to lick her face a lot of times. It seems that Ma likes Shiloh now. Instead of the first time Ma met Shiloh. Now she is comfortable with Shiloh. Also Ma plays with Shiloh in the grass sometimes. Marty is happy that Ma likes Shiloh a lot. Ma is also nice to Shiloh. Ma is nice to Shiloh that's why Shiloh is nice to Ma.

# data[].attributes.body
PA poor dad.He does not have enough money to buy a telephone.He's STRICT because he sends MARTY to bring SHILOH.He's proud.Because he takes PRIDE in his FAMILY.He's a HARD WORKER because he's a MAILMAN.He's KIND to MARTY.He dosen't agree that Marty could keep SHILOH.Now,PA agrees that Marty could keep SHILOH.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beging of the story Judd was mean because he kicked his dogs .But now Judd is nice because he gave Marty a collar that is how he changed and two of the days that Marty came to work for Judd he was very nice.Also he gives Marty water when he is working.Another thing is Judd gave a chance for Marty because Judd killed the deer but Marty needs a sight the paper So that means that Judd gave Marty a chance.

# data[].attributes.body
Marty changed by he lied now he doesn't any more. He is very nice. He tells lies to get him out of trouble. Marty loves Shiloh because they have a good conection. Marty is happy because he got Shiloh.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning Judd was mean at the end he is good because he gave the collar.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginng ma

# data[].attributes.body
At the beginning Ma did not let Marty keep Shiloh.But at the end Ma likes Shiloh because she lets him lick her hand and lets Marty keep Shiloh.

# data[].attributes.body
At the beginning Marty was mean to Jud for not being nice to his dogs.At the end he was nice to him for leting him keep the dog.

# data[].attributes.body
Marty took shiloh to the doctor when he was hurt Because the grermen shepper hurt.

# data[].attributes.body
Ma was strick at the begnning of the story.Then Ma changed and start to like Shiloh.

# data[].attributes.body
Judd became a little bit kind because he gave Shiloh to Marty and a collar Marty too. This is how I think Judd became nice and kind.

# data[].attributes.body
In the beginning Marty lied a lot but in the end

he told the truth about Judd giving him Shiloh

because he wanted to keep him.