# data[].attributes.body
I don't like pain 
FrEd?ErIK
FrEd?ErIK
why dont people have birthdays instead of ceremonies with a bunch of other people that are turning 12.  I agree with sophia.
Nathan
Nathan
  I think that  will be the giver who is the giver?  what does the receiver do?  can he see his family?  what kind of pain?  when is he going to meet the giver? 
Did she get reelect?    






 
  
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one should not h

# data[].attributes.body
hy dont people have birthdays instead of ceremonies with a bunch of other people that are turning 12.  I agree with sophia.
Nathan
Nathan
  I think that  will be the giver who is the giver?  what does the receiver do?  can he see his family?  what kind of pain?  when is he going to meet the giver? 
Did she get reelect?    






 
  
 
more_vert
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have 

# data[].attributes.body
Did she get reelect?    






 
  
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one 

# data[].attributes.body
 
  
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one should not have there 12 thing on the same day. why did't  Jonas get a job. i would never take the pill. because i think that the makes you not be able to feel love and  love makes the world go round.  why will have pain.   i think the reason that Jonas is not allowed is tell his dreams is that is may give them an idea of this job 
sophia
sophia
I think it's odd that they get things when they're a certain age. Like a bike when your 9 or your independence. That's something for your parents to decide, not the Elders , a random group of old people. I would never take that pill. I had my bike before 9, I don't want to rely on someone all the time where. I also want cars in a community because they're much faster. But no cars wouldn't be the end of the world. Because cars bring oil and gas. This reminds e of one of those movies where they tell that character that they're a queen or something. And you have to defeat an evil sorceress or something. I think Jonas feels scared uncomfortable but special. I agree with Decorah about the apple. I feel bad for Jonas because he didn't believe in himself. He thought their was a mistake about him. I have the same question as Haven about do they even have birthday's. I'm happy for Jonas because I think it's important to feel different and special. Because if everyone felt the same nothing would really be different, this community is very fair to other people but sometimes people don't like fair because then everyone would have the same things and no one would feel special. And again it's important to feel that about yourself because then people will doubt their selves, and an example of that is when he was selected to be the receiver he immediately thought it was a mistake because he didn't believe himself. I agree with Nicole that he's not aloud to talk about his dreams because he can see the feature. Jonas gets more rights than other now and I think that's not fair, the receiver job makes the community not fair when the goal is to be fair. That proves that even if we did take the pill it still wouldn't be perfect.  Jonas is going against what he was taught sense he was a kid. 

Wesley#6
Wesley#6
do they have to where 

# data[].attributes.body
Nathan
Nathan
  I think that  will be the giver who is the giver?  what does the receiver do?  can he see his family?  what kind of pain?  when is he going to meet the giver? 
Did she get reelect?    






 
  
 
more_vert
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think t

# data[].attributes.body
elect?    






 
  
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one should not have there 12 thing on the same day. why did't  Jonas 

# data[].attributes.body
 
  
decorah
decorah
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one should not have 

# data[].attributes.body
e can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 
That Jones will not talk to
That Jones will not talk to 
I think the jones is not happy with his new job . Ezekiel 12
I think the jo
back. who see in the back
 back. who see in the background  a camera. 
 
more_vert
I think something is going to
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 

# data[].attributes.body
e can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 
That Jones will not talk to
That Jones will not talk to 
I think the jones is not happy with his new job . Ezekiel 12
I think the jo
back. who see in the back
 back. who see in the background  a camera. 
 
more_vert
I think something is going to
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
????????????????????????????
I think something is goi
 
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
I t
I t
alayna
because when i was five i
 because when i was five i had a bike
e can see the futer. I th
 e can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 
That Jones will not talk to
That Jones will not talk to 
I think the jones is not happy with his new job . Ezekiel 12
I think the jo
back. who see in the back
 back. who see in the background  a camera. 
 
more_vert
I think something is going to
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
????????????????????????????
I think something is goi
 
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
I t
I t
alayna
because when i was five i
 because when i was five i had a bike

# data[].attributes.body
e can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 
That Jones will not talk to
That Jones will not talk to 
I think the jones is not happy with his new job . Ezekiel 12
I think the jo
back. who see in the back
 back. who see in the background  a camera. 
 
more_vert
I think something is going to
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking
????????????????????????????
I think something is goi
 
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
I t
I t
alayna
because when i was five i
 because when i was five i had a bike

# data[].attributes.headline
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking

# data[].attributes.subject
TOKHIR you will stop reading people thinking

# data[].attributes.body
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
I t
I t
alayna
because when i was five i
 because when i was five i had a bike. He can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 
That Jones will not talk to
That Jones will not talk to 
I think the jones is not happy with his new job . Ezekiel 12
I think the jo

# data[].attributes.body
back. who see in the background  a camera. 
 
more_vert
I think something is going to
I think something is going to 
happen to jones   Ezekiel  12
I think
I think 
I t
I t
alayna

# data[].attributes.body
because when i was five i had a bike. He can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope 

# data[].attributes.headline
That Jones will not talk about his jobs and not his dreams and not to talk    about anything about his job   . Ezekiel

# data[].attributes.subject
That Jones will not talk about his jobs and not his dreams and not to talk    about anything about his job   . Ezekiel

# data[].attributes.headline
I think the jones is not  happy with his new job .  Ezekiel 12 

# data[].attributes.subject
I think the jones is not  happy with his new job .  Ezekiel 12 

# data[].attributes.headline
So he going what the commute is hiding in the

# data[].attributes.subject
So he going what the commute is hiding in the

# data[].attributes.body
past

# data[].attributes.body
I think child's family gonna come back. who see in the background  a camera.

# data[].attributes.body
happen to jones Ezekiel 12

# data[].attributes.body
If i was Jonas i would refuse to take the pills

why lse would people cange

# data[].attributes.body
I think that joes is going to get giver.I agree with decorah because when i was five i had a bike. He can see the futer. I think when they are a twleve you are an adoult. I think she died. I hope he dos't die. I think he become the giver.I wonder i if he is going to take the pills. I tink he is going to lie to the comty that he did't tell hes family about hes dream. I think they are't able to lie.
\

# data[].attributes.body
this is a good story why would they do the number thing i also agree with sophia and fred

# data[].attributes.body
that is a lot of rols

# data[].attributes.body
I don't like pain

# data[].attributes.body
why dont people have birthdays instead of ceremonies with a bunch of other people that are turning 12.  I agree with sophia.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that  will be the giver who is the giver?  what does the receiver do?  can he see his family?  what kind of pain?  when is he going to meet the giver?
Did she get reelect?

# data[].attributes.body
i would not want to have to have other people do things for me.  i don't think that you should have to be 9 to get a bike and i think that ever one should not have there 12 thing on the same day. why did't  Jonas get a job. i would never take the pill. because i think that the makes you not be able to feel love and  love makes the world go round.  why will have pain.   i think the reason that Jonas is not allowed is tell his dreams is that is may give them an idea of this job

# data[].attributes.body
I think it's odd that they get things when they're a certain age. Like a bike when your 9 or your independence. That's something for your parents to decide, not the Elders , a random group of old people. I would never take that pill. I had my bike before 9, I don't want to rely on someone all the time where. I also want cars in a community because they're much faster. But no cars wouldn't be the end of the world. Because cars bring oil and gas. This reminds e of one of those movies where they tell that character that they're a queen or something. And you have to defeat an evil sorceress or something. I think Jonas feels scared uncomfortable but special. I agree with Decorah about the apple. I feel bad for Jonas because he didn't believe in himself. He thought their was a mistake about him. I have the same question as Haven about do they even have birthday's. I'm happy for Jonas because I think it's important to feel different and special. Because if everyone felt the same nothing would really be different, this community is very fair to other people but sometimes people don't like fair because then everyone would have the same things and no one would feel special. And again it's important to feel that about yourself because then people will doubt their selves, and an example of that is when he was selected to be the receiver he immediately thought it was a mistake because he didn't believe himself. I agree with Nicole that he's not aloud to talk about his dreams because he can see the feature. Jonas gets more rights than other now and I think that's not fair, the receiver job makes the community not fair when the goal is to be fair. That proves that even if we did take the pill it still wouldn't be perfect.  Jonas is going against what he was taught sense he was a kid.

# data[].attributes.body
do they have to where any thing a to teach them a lesson when they are 11

# data[].attributes.body
does the community give everyone stuff by the age group they are in. i think the kid should be able to do stuff by there self. i think they should have a normal birthday. i wonder how they knew he was the one. i think that he is going to tell his dreams.

# data[].attributes.body
I wish they could chosse more things on there own, like have thing whenever you want , for example you don't get a comfort object taken away when you are a certien age. I wonder if you can vollinter for every job, otherwise how would theyh know what you injoy. I wonder what they mean by watching Jonas do they place camreas in there house, do the citizens have to tell the elders everything that happens.

# data[].attributes.body
I wonder what gob Jones will get? What dose the reserve even do?

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they will make a special job for Jonas or he will be the Giver.
I think he is the Re server or Giver.
That's the guy on the cover.
I think that Jonas doesn't want to be the Receiver because then he will be alone and apart.
If he doesn't want to will he say NO and run or except it? Will he be a legend from saying NO

# data[].attributes.body
Jonas is almost 12, and i wonder when people start to have real birthdays but this could also take a long time. i think that he had skiped because he didn't get a job . i wonder how he is feeling right now. OMG!! I can not believe that he was chose to be the receiver. I don't really get why alone and away from others. I wonder what the quality's are  to be able to be the receiver. what does the receiver do?  Alayna , what do you mean by he can see color? didn't really know that they had a long good relationship. why cant you talk about the name and name your child that. what if you planed to have a child named that and you had that name just token away from you. why wouldn't he be able to tel her dreams. He should be to take a medication, and nobody should be able to lie and what about other 11's . what if they had the same quality as Jonas . how would they pick on a child. I think that the sentence will get them intruble it would

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they were so surprised why it was Jonas and not anyone else but he did not even now what was happening.
I agree with Nicole

# data[].attributes.body
NO ONE LIKE WARM HUGS  i bet he did not take the pill. if he didint take the pill mabye he will get hunt dowen. i wonder if they do. he was ainbarist

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jonas will get sent to a special place because the Community will not know what to give him for a job.
I wonder why kids under 8 have to wear ribbons and don't get to ride bikes.
Also I wonder why the Community gives jobs at 12. Why 12 instead of 18 or something?
I wonder why the Community has no cars and don't know of animals. They seem to have some technology better than us
Who keeps saying other people's names?

# data[].attributes.body
I wonder why his friends are thinking about the Elders  when they skipped Jonas.
I think that Jonas will soon be liking his job.
They weren't allowed to lie before?
So children aren't allowed to lie but when you are an adult or a 12 then you can? Why?

# data[].attributes.body
I wonder what they are going to name the kids. I don't think childhood should end at the age of twelve. Why don't they have normal birthdays. I wonder why they don't develop during training. I wonder what he saw.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they have to help each other with there coats and stuf to learn help each other  stuuf will happen he dosent have a job why is he the resever I think he dosent want to have the job cool he has the job of a resever I think hill almost die from the training
she was relsed I think thats how the girl got firerd

# data[].attributes.body
hopefully he will still use this job as a really good help to him

# data[].attributes.body
Jonas is going to turn 12 in December and he has a sister named Lily. And i think that the elders aren't going to know what to give him as a job because he wouldn't like any of the normal jobs so i think that he will have a different job than anyone else. I don't think that Jonas took the pills and i also think that Jonas is going to become the new giver once he gets older. I think that Jonas is going to become the receiver because he saw the apple do something in the air or in more simple terms, rot and that was going to happen in the future and i also think that he is going to be the first receiver in a long time.