# data[].attributes.body
GREAT RESPONSE, BUT WHERE'S YOUR QUOTE/PASSAGE, MIKAYLA?
Amir sees America as an opportunity to start new. He is trying to bury his guilt over the wrongs he committed in Afghanistan. Baba, however, is having a harder time adjusting. He misses his home and believes America is what is best for them only because it is what is best for Amir.

# data[].attributes.body
GREAT CHOICE AND ANALYSIS!
Ch.11: Ch. 11: How does Amir and Baba’s view of America differ?

"For me, America was a place to bury my memories. For Baba, a place to mourn his,"(129). This quote signifies the juxtaposition between Baba and Amir and their transition to America. Amir used America as a way to reinvent himself. Furthermore, he used America as a way to forget all the dreadful things that happened in Afghanistan. He is using his new memories to block out the old ones. On the other hand, for Baba, it is a remainder of the things he lost or had to lose for his new life in America. In Afghanistan, he was considered wealthy, but in America that changed because he works in a gas station to receive an income. However, Baba is still giving because when he took Amir to a bar and he treated people to drinks. And In Afghanistan, he took people out and treated them to dinner to celebrate Amir winning the kite race. I feel like Amir is transitioning easier than Baba because of age and different amount of opportunities. So I believe it is similar, but also different.

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S YOUR QUOTE TO SUPPORT THIS? Amir claims to use America to bury his memories whereas for Baba it's place to mourn his. Amir embraces America and uses it as an escape, but for Baba he is a totally different person because in Afghanistan he is wealthy person but in the U.S he is an immigrant  who can't speak English very well

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK
"There is chemotherapy, of course,' he said. 'But it would only be palliative... But no chemo medication for me.' He had the same resolved look on his face as the day he'd dropped the stack of food stamps on Mrs. Dobbin's desk."

I believe Baba refuses chemotherapy because it ties into his entire persona of being a strong man who doesn't need help from anyone. It also strongly ties to the theme, Toxic Masculinity, because it furthers the idea that men are not supposed to accept help and just simply deal with whatever problem they have themselves.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK
"For me,America was a place to bury my memories.
For Baba,a place to mourn his"(Hosseini 129).This show how Amir and Baba view on America is different.Amir kind of want a fresh start in America and to not think about the past.But with Baba he doesn't want to get rid of the memories or start fresh.He wants to grieve his past.

# data[].attributes.body
PLEASE INCLUDE DIRECT QUOTE NEXT TIME--NOT JUST PAGE NUMBER
Baba's refusal to chemotherapy treatment falls under  character development.  i say this because Baba use to be this strong guy who never showed weakness. Now, he no longer has a theme of toxic masculinity, because he's basically accepting his fate and refusing treatment because he thinks the outcome will be the same either way.  On page 156,  the doctor tells baba the treatment wouldn't change his fate, just. prolong it and Baba responds that it is clear answer to him why he will not do the chemo therapy.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK
Amir and Baba's view of America differs because Baba sees the new country as a place where he's not respected and he doesnt have a lot of money so he cant provide like he used to in his old country; meanwhile Amir has taken a liking to the country and sees it as a new beginning/ clean slate.  Amir would go on to say " America was different. America was a river, roaring along, unmindful of the past."

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S THE DIRECT QUOTE AND PAGE NUMBER?
for amir America was a place to "burry" his memories where as baba, was to "mourn." and being a immigrant in America isn't always the most pleasant thing, it humbled baba because back in his home town he was this popular rich guy but in America he is just an immigrant.

# data[].attributes.body
GREAT ANALYSIS BUT WHERE'S THE DIRECT QUOTE TO PROVE IT?
Baba and Amir find out that Baba has cancer in one of his lungs. The doctor tells them both that chemotherapy can slow the growth of the mass in his lung but Baba refuses the chemo. I think this goes under the theme of masculinity because Baba doesn't like to show weakness. He prefers to take the harder route in life, kind of like they way he refused to take the food stamps even though they were struggling for money.

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S YOUR DIRECT QUOTE TO PROVE THIS?
Baba refuses treatment because he believes he's just prolonging the inevitable. Baba continues to show that he believes Amir can be stronger and more "like a man" living without him.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD ANALYSIS, BUT WHERE'S YOUR DIRECT QUOTE AS EVIDENCE?
Amir sees America as a new start to his life where he can forget his past and move forward with his writing and find love.

Baba refuses chemotherapy because he doesn't think he needs help or he doesn't want to appear weak and ask others for help and so he continues to suffer from the effects of cancer

When Baba first comes to America he still has his sense of elitism and pride which causes problems in finding jobs to survive as he acts to proud and snooty to take regular jobs until finally he has to to survive .

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S YOUR DIRECT QUOTE? IS BABA ADJUSTING?
CH 11: In chapter 11, things had began to look like there was a sense of hope but Baba was asked for his ID when he knocked over the magazine stand.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD ANALYSIS, BUT WHERE'S YOUR PROOF FROM THE TEXT?
Baba enjoys the life in America. He sees living there as a new opportunity for them. Its still an adjustment though as when Baba goes to the convenience store he gets upset when they ask for his ID. He takes it as them questioning his trust and loyalty. Amir meanwhile suggest Baba to go back to Pakistastan. Still Amir sees America as a place to bury his memories and to escape his past

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD ANALYSIS, BUT WHERE'S YOUR QUOTE TO SUPPORT?
Baba and Amir's views of America differ, because baba more so views America as a means to an end rather than a new opportunity like Amir does. Amir sees America as a chance to repent and become someone different, to finally make something of himself rather than wallow in his past whereas baba would rather return to his past than change.

# data[].attributes.body
WHICH QUESTION ARE YOUR ANSWERING? THERE'S NO ANALYSIS HERE.
"There are only three real men in the world. He'd count them all on his fingers: America the brash savior, Britain, and Israel.  The rest of them- he used to wave his hand and make a psht sound- they're like gossiping old women."

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S YOUR QUOTE TO SUPPORT THIS?
Amir has more of a grateful view about America and adjusts quickly. Baba however seems to have more of a negative view on America. For example, when the store owners ask him for an I.D, Baba gets defensive and feels like they are out to get him.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK
While describing Baba's differences with the rest of his neighbors. "Most of our neighbors in Fremont were...exactly the sort of blue-collar peaople who sould soon suffocate under the pillow Reganomics pressed to their faces. Baba was the lone Republican in our building. " (Hosseini 106). This illustrates the ideological and economic differences between Baba and the other members of the apartment. Baba comes from wealth and continues holding onto his Republican ideologies from Afghanistan.  Although he lost most of his money after moving to America, but still identifies strongly with the upperclass.

# data[].attributes.body
GREAT CHOICE OF QUOTE!
"The visit with the pulmonologist, Dr. Schneider, was going well until Baba asked where he was from. Dr Schneider said Russia. Baba lost it" (Hosseini 155). This quote illustrates the idea of toxic masculinity. Baba is very patriotic of his country and even goes so far as to risk his life over it. In one way it shows how pride can alter a man in a toxic way but on the other hand it shows his loyalty.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK!
" I wanted to tell them that, in Kabul, we snapped a tree branch and used it as a credit card....At the end of the month, my father paid him for the number of notches on the stick." (128)

This is an example of Culture clash because of the contrast between how payment in Kabul was based on trust and credibility, but in America the store clerks were required to ask for ID, no matter how many times you have bought from them. This enraged Baba and caused him to lash out because he is used to people trusting in him and taking his word and he hasn't made that adjustment yet, therefore  causing a Culture Clash.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK!
and example of an identity clash is when baba tries to write a check or the Nguyens and trashes the store when asked for ID. This quote shows the difference: "I wanted to tell them that, in Kabul, we snapped a tree branch and used it as a credit card. Hassan and I would take the wooden stick to the bread maker. he'd carve notches on our stick with his knife, one notch for each loaf of naan he'd pull for us from the tandoor's roaring flames. At the end of the month, my father paid him for the number of notches on the stick. That was it. No questions. No ID." This shows Baba's conflict with asking for ID. He feels that the Nguyens don't trust him, after all the service he's given them and also doesn't feel respected, unlike in Kabul, where is word was trusted.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK!
An example of cultural identity/cultural clash is when Baba  tried to pay with a check. "Does he think I'm a thief?' Baba said, his voice rising. People had gathered outside. They were staring."What kind of country is this? No one trusts anybody!" (Hosseini 128) Back in Kabul there was no ID or checks so Baba didn't think to have his ID. This led to an altercation with Baba and the store owner's because he thought they were mistreating him.

# data[].attributes.body
WHAT DOES YOUR 2ND QUOTE SUGGEST? YOU DIDN'T THOROUGHLY ADDRESS IT.
Chapter 11: "Baba loved the idea of America. It was living in America that gave him an ulcer" (Hosseni 125). I believe becaue Baba is such a very respected man and very wealthy that when he gets America he is just a brown man who is an immigrant and also can't speak english that well.  "The Bay Area's smog stung his eyes, the traffic noise gave him headaches, and the pollen made him cough" (126). Amir embrace America and uses it generally as an ecape from his past.

# data[].attributes.body
IT'S NOT EVERYONE IS OUT TO GET HIM, AS YOU SUGGEST. IT'S A DIFFERENT CULTURE THAT REQUIRES IDENTIFICATION RATHER THAN TRUSTING EACH OTHER.
In the text it says, "Does he think I''m a thief?" Baba said, his voice rising. People had gathered outside. They were staring. "What kind of country is this? No one trusts anybody." This shows that Baba is uncomfortable and feels as if everyone is out to get him. He seems very aggressive and on edge. Meanwhile, Amir, was already well adjusted in America and just had calm Baba down in order for him to be able to get things from the store. Amir sees america as almost anther home for him.

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD WORK.
"For me, America was a place to bury my memories. For Baba, a place to mourn his" (Hosseini 129).  At the start of the chapter, we are introduced to Baba's struggles in America. Unlike Afghanistan, Baba was not the hero in America like he was in Afghanistan. He was in a world where he was no longer put on a pedestal; in america, he was just like everyone else. In addition  to being stripped of his title of superiority, he was faced with more hardships. While in Afghanistan, he knew everyone, had connections with everyone, and was considered quite wealthy, all of this was loss in America. He was faced with the harsh reality of being considered normal. For Amir, America was his fresh start. By moving to America, he left behind all his baggage such as his awful treatment towards Hasaan. All of his biggest regrets were wiped when he came to America. America was his opportunity to start with a fresh slate and strive for his dreams. We see him striving for his dreams, when he announces to his father of studying creative writing in college, knowing that his father would not approve.

# data[].attributes.body
WHERE'S YOUR SUPPORT FOR THIS FROM THE TEXT?
Baba's refusal for chemo could fall under this whole father and son  complicated relationship thing, why would he not want to try to live longer when he has a son?

# data[].attributes.headline
"Mr. Nguyen had asked for an ID... does he think im a thief? What kind of a country is this? No one trusts anybody" (pgs. 127-128) 

# data[].attributes.subject
"Mr. Nguyen had asked for an ID... does he think im a thief? What kind of a country is this? No one trusts anybody" (pgs. 127-128) 

# data[].attributes.body
GOOD CHOICE.
This is an example of a culture clash, because Baba views Mr. Nguyen asking for ID as a form of not trusting him, but in reality in America, you need an ID to write a check to verify the legitimacy of that check.
-TRENT P