# data[].attributes.body
What is so jarring about the new list of rules that Jonas receives after the Ceremony of Twelve? What seems to bother him the most about this list?

The list is very harsh because it involves breaking rules and not talking about what is happening in his life. I think he in bothered by the fact he can't play with his friends anymore and that he can lie or break the rules. I think that he is most bothered by the fact that he can lie and that he must lie to follow some of the rules. "He had been trained since earliest childhood, since the earliest learning of language, never to lie."

# data[].attributes.body
What are the consequences of giving only one person the responsibility of keeping all the memories?

I think the consequence of giving only one person the responsibility memories has the risk that the person might become overwhelmed with all of the memories like Rosemary did. It also really wears out everyone who carried the memories like the giver. Sometimes the memories will make them feel happy and upbeat but then when they start recieving the terrible memories they will be totally un-prepared for it and will suffer profousley.  I know this because in chapter 14 it saysHaving just one person with memories means there are major troubles up the road.

# data[].attributes.body
What kind of suffering is worse in The Giver—physical or emotional? Why?

I think that in The Giver it's worst to suffer emotionally. I think that because after Jonas knew what emotions felt like, he could feel happiness, sadness and anger. When that happened he knew how it was like and how sad and painful in the inside it was. On the other hand, it can also be worst suffering physically because once got physical pain, he felt hurt and sad. I know that because in chapter 14 page 141 he vomited onto the frozen snow and blood drips from his face and he says "Nooooo!". Now I think it is worst to feel physical pain.

# data[].attributes.body
What are the consequences of giving only one person the responsibility of keeping all the memories?

In my opinion the consequence of giving one person the responsibility to keep the memories is because if only one person has the hold of all those memories they would have to keep it until their release they wouldn't pass the memory to others. The Giver says 'That if you let loose of the memories the people would be in chaos and war'. I can understand that the others would be overwhelmed like Rosemary when she did. Her memories got loose and caused the people trouble about this. The community won't be the exact same if they could receive memories like Jonas there would be disorder which would ruin their perfect community. Also if Jonas would be released then all the memories would go into the people.

# data[].attributes.body
What are the consequences of giving only one person the responsibility of keeping all the memories? I think the consequences of giving only one person the memories is in that community everything has to be the same and there aren't suppose to be chaos. Some feelings are sad and could cause chaos. But If only one one person keep it he can learn what hiding in elsewhere or the feeling of the feelings.

# data[].attributes.body
What kind of suffering is worse in The Giver—physical or emotional? Why?

I think that the worst suffering is emotional because,in chapter 15 when Jonas put his hands on the givers back he could experience the pain and  what emotional and physical pain feels like.another example of physical pain is when Jonas breaks his ankle.he turned his head and vomited onto the frozen snow .blood dripped from his face into the vomit.“Noooooo”

# data[].attributes.body
Question:
What are the consequences of giving only one person the responsibility of keeping all the memories?

Personal Answer:
I think that the consequences can be harsh and sad. One of them can be that the Giver might not remember the memory well,  so he won't know how he can help Jonas deal with it. Jonas can't talk about his job, share his feelings, and no one his age has the same responsibility. On the random holiday, Jonas found Asher, Fiona, and some other kids playing in the bushes, and they were fighting with imaginary guns, and when someone was "shot" they fell to the ground and screamed in horror, though Jonas knew the truth and had a heart attack. Nobody was around to understand what he was going threw, and the Giver doesn't go outside.

# data[].attributes.body
Why does The Giver choose to give Rosemary only emotional or mental pain? Was that a good decision? What makes you think that?

I think the reason The Giver choses to give Rosemary only emotional or mental pain because he loves her. The Giver doesn't want her to suffer from all the pain there is to experience. In chapter 20, page 203, when the Giver says "I want to be with my daughter " he was truly happy when he said this, this shows that The Giver loves rosemary too much to transfer psychical pain. I think that this was the wrong decision. I think this because if he doesn't transfer the pain he keeps it to himself, then that means he is in so much pain himself. Also, they chose Rosemary to be the receiver which means they have faith in her, and think she has all the traits needed to be the receiver. Which means they think they have the courage to take on the pain.

# data[].attributes.body
Question: What is so jarring about the new list of rules that Jonas receives after the Ceremony of Twelve?

I think the most jarring rule is to have the permission to lie. In Jonas' community strict rules are put in place and civil disobedience is not acceptable. Children and adults are expected to follow rules. Moreover, if children don't follow a rule, a method called 'chastisement' is put in action, a smack on the hand or leg. Jonas has not experienced lying and the permission to do so can be strident. The following quote shows how disturbed Jonas felt when reading the final rule 'Exemption to lie': 'Still, the final rule said... well, he wasn't quite ready to think about the final rule on the page.' In conclusion, the jarring rule was to have the exemption to lie because Jonas had not yet experienced lying so having the permission to do so can be shocking.

# data[].attributes.body
What kind of suffering is worse in The Giver physical or emotional? Why?

In my opinion I think experiencing emotional pain is worse than physical pain because after Jonas can feel emotions like happiness ,angry and sad he took an awful memory from the giver about war he knew how sad and painful it was inside and how he might never forget it. And physical pain like in the sledge how he broke will heal completely

# data[].attributes.body
Question 1(Suffering):"What kind of suffering is worse in The Giver—physical or emotional? Why?"

I think that the worst suffering is emotionaly.

I think that because when Jonas is first given the memory of pain his idea of the memories completly changes.
When someone is hurt physicly it heals.But when you are hurt emotionaly it will remain in your head for ever.It is more painfull.

'The boy sighed.His head fell back, his lower jaw dropping as if he had been surprised by something.A dull blackness slid slowly across his eyes.He was silent' Page 154

In conclusion, I think that the worst suffering is emotionly because it stays in you head for ever and it is more painfull.

# data[].attributes.body
Why does Jonas choose to stop taking his pills? Does it have any effect on him?

I think that Jonas choose to stop taking his pills because the rules say that no medication was aloud. I would not have stopped taking the pills because I think that the pills are part of medication. I think that the consequence of him not taking