# data[].attributes.body
1. 我看到了一位身穿芭蕾舞裙的小女孩闭着眼睛在感受这个舞台，这个雕塑是铜制成的，黄灰芭蕾舞裙是似乎是纤维制成的。
2.我认为是主观的。因为个人的审美以及对于这件作品的欣赏角度是完全不一样的，是纯粹主观的，也许我在看这个作品的时候看到小女孩的表情是闭着眼睛很享受这个她用脚触摸的舞台，享受的表情是美的。但是可能有人就会觉得她的内心是喜悦的，因为她刚刚表演完了一场芭蕾演出，她还沉静在演出成功的喜悦当中。所以主观色彩去欣赏一个艺术作品所产生的结果是不一样的。
3. 我认为是个作品可以起到社会作用。因为我的主观感受，我认为这件作品体现了每个人心中都充满了自己向往的东西，这个小女孩可能是芭蕾舞，但总的来说作者想要表达一个人最深处内心，不管社会是怎样的残酷，内心总有自己坚守和向往的东西，也就是初心。‘
4. 我认为这个作品与中国文化不大，因为芭蕾都是国外所起源的，我们也是根据了解国外的文化才了解了芭蕾这门艺术。

评价 Rita 的 作品
1. 我看到了一个戴眼镜的男人头上戴了一个箭靶，然后有很多支箭射向了男人头上的箭靶上，但是只有一根箭射到了正中。
2. 是主观的，因为只是我个人主观看到这个作品的时候，我看出了一个男人就像是被人当作了至高无上的王者，他就像是人们想要达到的目标，但是由于这样他已经感到无味了。但是别人可能认为他想表达他脑子里的混乱。
3.画家是个精神病患者，所以通过这幅画让我看出了精神病患者的世界，也同时呼吁人们对这一群体引起重视。
4.我认为这和中国文化没有关系。

# data[].attributes.body
评价lavender的artwork（Amy）

1. 首先这个艺术作品的材质是金属的，然后他是一个小女孩穿着金黄色的芭蕾舞裙

2. 是主观的，首先是审美不一样，因为每个人对于美的理解是不一样的，这可能是人们不同的艺术修养，或者人们在欣赏艺术的角度是不一样的，所以会导致艺术品的美学价值是主观的

3. 我认为有些艺术作品是可以起到反射社会现实的，或者制作者通过艺术作品表达自己的内心，引发人们的思考。

4. 我认为这个雕塑和中国文化没有很大的关系。

评价rita的artwork（Amy）

1. 首先这个艺术是一个绘画作品，是患有精神分裂症的画家bryan charnley的自画像。在这幅画的中间是有一个人头，然后人头的上面有个靶子，靶心和大脑的中间相互重叠，同时有很多箭射在了靶子的后面。同时整个人头也是陷入了一个靶子，那个靶子上也有很多箭。

2. 是主观的，在我看来我认为每一个人欣赏美的角度是不一样的，同时每一个人对于美的理解也是不一样的，这会是其中一个导致艺术品的美学价值是非常主观的原因，

3. 我认为这个艺术作品还是会引起社会深思的，其中首先是因为当大家了解到画家自身的背景以及他想要表达的主要思想。之后我认为可以引起大家对于这一精神疾病，也就是精神分裂症患者的一一些重视，所以这还是会起到一些正面的社会作用的。

4. 我认为这个绘画和中国文化没有很大的关系。

# data[].attributes.body
1. 我在这个雕塑中看到了一个金属做的小女孩穿着金色的芭蕾舞裙。女孩的肤色和五官让我觉得她是一个非洲人。女孩的皮肤并没有使用抛光的金属，反而带有一些磨痕，让我觉得这个女孩的身份可能有些贫穷。
2. 是主观的。由于每个人有着不同的文化背景和经历，在他们看到艺术时会产生不一样的想法。

3. 我觉得这个雕塑传达了“追求梦想”这个主旨，可以引起人们对青少年“追梦”以及“平等”的思考。

4. 我觉得这个雕塑和中国文化的关联并不是很大。

# data[].attributes.headline
对于 “Rita” 选择的艺术作品的评论 （Jerry 张桥雨 著）

# data[].attributes.subject
对于 “Rita” 选择的艺术作品的评论 （Jerry 张桥雨 著）

# data[].attributes.body
1. 我在这幅画中看到了一个硕大的人头。这个人头处在一个靶子的中心，靶心正好是他的大脑位置。有好多箭矢插向了他。右下角放置了一个不明物体，但我猜想这和画的主旨有很大程度上的联系，但是我没看懂……
2. 先说结论：艺术品的美学价值是纯粹主观的。这是因为我们每个人都会对美有着不同的定义，尽管我们可能同样地认为某一两件艺术作品是美的，但是这种认为并不客观。
3. 它能够使得人们开始一些对于社会舆论的强攻击性的反思.
4. 因为我来自于中国文化，因此我在看到这个艺术作品的时候会不自觉地联想到我之前所知的中国舆论的强烈攻击性。这也使得我联想到了问题3的答案。

# data[].attributes.body
Comment to Amy's art piece

1. Through Amy's artwork, I see a traditional Peking opera character. It is a artwork inspired from The drunken Concubine. This artwork expresses the drunk motion in a very fluent way. Even though it is a 2D image, but it let us feels like the concubine has drunk right in front of us.
2. I think artwork is not a purely subjective matter. I think the general theme is often objective, however the specific content is subjective. Through this art piece, people can get the theme of Peking opera objectively from the appearance of the character. However, the story of this image, and also the idea that the artist wants to convey is subjective. For example, some people may interpret this as The Drunken Concubine, but others may think this is about another story.
3. I think this art piece is playing a very important social function as it reminds and educate people about the Chinese traditional culture. For example, as a Chinese, seeing this art piece let people reflect on the beauty of traditional culture. As a people from other culture, seeing this art piece allow them to know about Peking Opera and the story behind it. Because they are from a different culture, it might be difficult for them to understand because they don’t have the culture background that makes them enjoy and understand.
4. Chinese culture helps me determine the theme of the artwork as well as the traditional story behind it. It helps me identify that this is about traditional culture. Since Chinese culture tells me through intuition that this is traditional, it helps me define the value of this art.

Comment to Rita’s art piece:
1. This artwork is a self-portrait by Bryan Charnley, who is an artist with schizophrenia. Because schizophrenia is a very serious mental disease. He uses art to record his life as a diary. This is one of his self-portrait recorded in his diary. In this artwork, I see many arrow shooting on his face. Which shows that he is very suffering and feels like he is being attacked. Also, on his mouth, there’s a nail. This shows that what he says is not what he really what to express. So, he feels very suffer about that.

2. In this case, art can be both objective and subjective. If the audience don’t know the background of the artist. Then, this art piece is completely a subjective piece, because through this self-portrait, people can interpret many things. For example, this person can be angry, sad, or even happy base on different people’s interpretation. However, if people know the background of the artist and the content in his artwork diary. Then, this artwork become more objective. Since, people know his background, and everyone can get that his artwork is about his suffer of the disease. However, the details, for example what is the arrow representing is still subjective, which means different people can have different interpretation of what the arrow represent.

3. For this artwork, it let people knows about the mental disease of schizophrenia. Since mental disease is not a kind of disease that can be will recognized by people, so there’s always some misunderstandings that causes people with schizophrenia to feels very sad. Hence, through this artwork it let normal people sees what inside a schizophrenia patient, and let people know about and understand the disease.

4. In China, recent year, there are many focuses on metal diseases. For example, depression, and schizophrenia. So, when I see this artwork and learn about the artist. I quickly related the artwork with metal diseases. Because in China, I have saw many news and social media expressing about that. For some people come from other places that does not have many knowledge about metal disease may not easily recognize this ar

# data[].attributes.body
Comments:
To Maggie's Art piece:
This art piece is different from all the other piece chosen in this class, because the artist did not design the scene in the art piece. To explain, the artist is the photographer, neither the violinist nor the surgeons. So, the  scene in the art piece is not designed but captured.
Some of the aesthetic value of an artwork is subjective and some part is objective. For example, in a music piece the natural harmony is one of the aesthetic value that make people feel comfortable, and this is the objective part of the aesthetic value where people can feel the beauty naturally. Other factors in the art piece may be subjective, because different people may have different feeling or experience after they see a certain art piece. For example in Maggie's art piece, some people may think this is a beautiful and insightful art piece and some people may think it is scary.
To create insights to the society. Intentionally, the violinist was playing violin to calm her self down and be relaxed in the operation room. However this is a creative way that no people ever thought of doing in the operation room.

# data[].attributes.body
Comments:
To Michael's:
1. I see an art piece about bookshelves which you can see different appearances from different angles.
2. Mostly it is subjective.
3. It gives the audience a new way of world perception. People can view the same thing differently from different angles.
4. To a small extend since they are not related. However, there are some Chinese stories that teach you to see things differently.

To Jerry's:
1. I see a game that reflect some actual events happening in modern society in an ironic way.
3. It helps people understand some world issues.
4. There are similar things happening in China which makes me accept the idea from the art piece.

# data[].attributes.body
Comment to Jerry Zhang's art piece:
1. What do you see and what does the art piece say to you
I see a chaos society caused by  irresponsible media.
2. Is the aesthetic value of an artwork purely a subjective matter?
It is definitely a subjective view. We all individuals so we have different art taste. Personally, i may like new school stuff but some one may like old school stuff. We shall never judge other's art taste.
3. What social function do you think this art piece is playing?
This art piece allows people reflect on today's society. What kind of media industry do we expect? What is the responsibility of media? It is highly related with  COVID19 situation because plenty of fake news existed during this time.
4. TWE does Chinese culture help you define the value of this art?
Actually, i will jump out from Chinese culture to view art piece. It is more like a communication in mind level. Chinese culture will limit us in our view. I always believe the point that art is no culture boundary.

# data[].attributes.body
"We become what we behold" (Indigame)

# data[].attributes.headline
Share your art pieces under your names and comment on other people's chosen art pieces (with your names): 

# data[].attributes.subject
Share your art pieces under your names and comment on other people's chosen art pieces (with your names): 

# data[].attributes.body
1. What do you see and what does the art piece say to you 你从这个艺术品中看到了什么?
2. Is the aesthetic value of an artwork purely a subjective matter 艺术品的美学价值纯粹是主观的吗?
3. What social function do you think this art piece is playing? 你认为这个艺术作品起到了什么社会作用（或有什么社会功能）？
4. TWE does Chinese culture help you define the value of this art? 中国文化在何种程度上帮助你决定了这个艺术作品的价值？

# data[].attributes.body
Self Portrait by Bryan Charnley