# data[].attributes.body
First, "Offline learning is more effective because it provides direct interaction between students and teachers."

In a traditional classroom setting, students can ask questions and receive immediate feedback. This helps clarify misunderstandings right away. Additionally, face-to-face learning encourages better focus and discipline, as students are in a structured environment with fewer distractions.

Second, "Online learning is more effective because it offers flexibility and access to a wider range of resources."

Students can learn at their own pace, which helps them better understand the material. Online platforms also provide access to videos, interactive quizzes, and international courses that may not be available in local schools. For many, this flexibility improves motivation and learning outcomes.

# data[].attributes.body
Online learning is very effective because it is easy to understand and very exciting. Meanwhile, offline learning is a bit difficult to understand because of many distractions such as no network or sound.

A.ANGGA SAPUTRA

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, offline learning is more effective than online learning

Offline learning is more effective because you can meet face-to-face, making learning easier to understand.

Second, it's more effective because it allows for greater focus and reduces distractions such as poor network connectivity.
Ericsun loenardo(11)

# data[].attributes.body
• Offline learning improves focus and understanding.

In a face-to-face classroom, students can concentrate better because there are fewer distractions compared to online learning. They can also directly ask the teacher if they do not understand the lesson, which helps them understand the material more effectively.

•Offline learning improves communication and social skills.

When students learn in a classroom, they can interact directly with teachers and classmates. This builds better communication, teamwork, and social skills, which are important for their personal and academic development.

# data[].attributes.body
Offline learning is more enjoyable because students can interact directly with teachers and classmates. It creates a lively classroom atmosphere, improves focus, and makes discussions or group activities more engaging. Face-to-face learning also helps build stronger social relationships and provides immediate feedback, which is harder to achieve in online learning.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that offline learning is better than online learning because it allows for direct interaction between students and teachers. In a physical classroom, students can ask questions and receive immediate feedback, which helps them understand the material more clearly. They can also participate in group discussions and activities that make learning more engaging and interactive.

In addition, offline learning helps students stay focused and disciplined. Unlike studying at home, where there are many distractions, being in a classroom creates a structured environment that encourages concentration. It also helps students develop social skills by interacting with peers face-to-face, which is an important part of personal growth and education.

AL FADH AUFAR GEZHA(04)

# data[].attributes.body
Opinion 1: Offline study provides direct interaction with teachers and classmates, which helps students develop teamwork, communication, and social skills that are essential for real-life situations.

Opinion 2: Studying offline creates a disciplined and focused atmosphere, where students can better concentrate, follow a fixed schedule, and receive immediate guidance from teachers when facing difficulties.

# data[].attributes.body
Andhy sumpala (8)

Opinion:
I believe offline learning is better than online learning. In the classroom, students can focus more, ask questions directly, and get clear explanations from the teacher. They can also interact with friends, share ideas, and practice teamwork. This makes offline learning not only more effective, but also more enjoyable and meaningful.

# data[].attributes.body
Neither online nor offline learning is inherently more effective; effectiveness depends on the individual learner's preferences, learning style, and goals, as well as the specific learning environment and content. Online learning offers flexibility and self-paced study, while offline learning excels at providing direct interaction, immediate feedback, and a structured environment

# data[].attributes.body
First, Face-to-face interaction in offline learning creates a more engaging and structured learning environment. Students can directly ask questions, receive immediate feedback, and participate in group discussions more naturally. This environment helps build discipline, improves focus, and enhances understanding through real-time communication with teachers and peers.

Second, Online learning provides greater flexibility and accessibility, allowing students to learn at their own pace and from any location. It also offers a wide variety of resources such as video lectures, interactive quizzes, and discussion forums. For self-motivated learners, this can lead to deeper understanding and improved time management skills, making online learning highly effective in today's digital world.

# data[].attributes.body
. Argument for Offline Learning (Face-to-Face):

Offline learning is more effective because it allows direct interaction between students and teachers. This face-to-face communication helps students understand the material better, ask questions immediately, and receive instant feedback. In addition, the classroom environment encourages focus and discipline, which can be harder to achieve in online settings.

2. Argument for Online Learning (E-Learning):

Online learning is more effective because it provides flexibility and accessibility for students. Learners can access materials anytime and anywhere, which supports independent study and accommodates different learning paces. Moreover, digital tools and platforms offer a variety of resources, such as recorded lectures and interactive activities, making the learning experience more personalized and engaging.

# data[].attributes.body
1. In my opinion, offline learning is important because it allows direct interaction with teachers and classmates, improves focus, and builds discipline as well as real-life experiences that are hard to get online. 2.In my opinion, online learning is beneficial because it is more flexible, accessible from anywhere, and helps students get used to technology, although it sometimes lacks focus and social interaction.

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, offline learning is more effective because in online learning I don't really understand the lessons

# data[].attributes.body
•Offline learning improves focus and understanding.

In a face-to-face classroom, students can concentrate better because there are fewer distractions compared to online learning. They can also directly ask the teacher if they do not understand the lesson, which helps them understand the material more effectively.

•Offline learning improves communication and social skills.

When students learn in a classroom, they can interact directly with teachers and classmates. This builds better communication, teamwork, and social skills, which are important for their personal and academic development.

Indah Cahaya Kirana

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, offline learning is more effective than online learning. First, face-to-face interaction with teachers makes lessons easier to understand because students can ask questions directly and receive immediate feedback. Second, the classroom environment helps students stay disciplined and focused on studying, without being distracted by gadgets or social media.

Kayyisah Nurazizah (13)

# data[].attributes.body
MUHAMMAD FARIQ IKRAM (24) (XII.5)

Many people believe that offline learning is more effective than online learning because it gives students better interaction and stronger focus.

First, offline learning allows direct interaction between teachers and students. This makes it easier for students to ask questions and get immediate feedback.

Second, studying in the classroom helps students focus more because there are fewer distractions compared to studying at home.

# data[].attributes.body
Offline learning is more effective because it allows direct interaction, classroom discipline, and immediate guidance from teachers.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe offline learning is more effective than online learning because in class we can meet teachers and friends directly, focus better without many distractions, and also build discipline and social skills.

# data[].attributes.body
Offline Learning is More Effective

Argumen 1 :Direct Interaction with Teachers and Peers: Offline learning allows students to interact directly with teachers and peers, which can enhance understanding and motivation.

Argumen 2 :Better Monitoring and Feedback:Teachers can monitor student progress more effectively and provide timely feedback in offline learning settings.

# data[].attributes.body
Offline learning is more effective

First, offline learning gives a real learning atmosphere. In the classroom, students feel serious to study because the teacher is in front of them.

Second, offline learning improve social skills. Students meet friends every day, work in groups, and learn teamwork directly.

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, effective learning is offline or face-to-face learning at school, because there is interaction without barriers in this case, for example, online learning like this, there are many Obstacles such as poor network, or very wasteful internet quota for learning via Zoom if using an internet package instead of using Wi-Fi, thank you

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, online learning is not effective because:

1. It is constrained by the network and the material is a bit difficult to understand.

Meanwhile, offline learning is more effective because:

1. You can meet face-to-face and focus more on receiving the material, and also if there is something you don't understand, it can be explained directly to make it easier to understand.

Marchell Agung Saputra

# data[].attributes.body
Opinion 1: Effective

Online learning is effective because it's flexible, allowing students to learn anytime and anywhere.

Opinion 2: Less Effective

Online learning is less effective due to limited direct interaction with teachers and peers, potentially causing isolation and low motivation.

# data[].attributes.body
I personally think i prefer Offline learning, here's my reason:

1. Being in a physical classroom removes the temptations of my phone, video games, and other tabs. The environment is designed for learning, which helps me actually pay attention and absorb the material.

2. Offline learning allows for immediate questions, spontaneous discussions, and reading the room. I can get help from the teacher or a classmate right when I need it, which is faster and more effective than waiting for an email or a chat reply.

# data[].attributes.body
Offline learning is more effective because it allows better interaction between teachers and students, making it easier to ask questions and get answers directly. It also helps students focus more since there are fewer distractions compared to online classes. Moreover, offline learning develops social skills as students can communicate and work together face-to-face with their classmates.(Muh. Revan Radithya Al 22)

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, offline learning is more effective than online learning.

First, offline learning makes interaction easier. I can ask my teacher directly and get a fast response, which is harder to do in online classes.

Second, offline learning helps me focus better. At school, the environment is made for studying, while at home there are many distractions such as noise or gadgets.

(Muh.Royhan)

# data[].attributes.body
offline learning is more effective and easier to understand. If you study online, it is difficult to understand because the network or signal is disruptive.

Marvell Tiago Sudjono