# data[].attributes.body
the sa (pretty sure) part in ch4 made me sob. hes only 13. hes just a baby dude hes went through everything :/

# data[].attributes.body
Does anyone know why the baby was named jupiter???

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie's relationship was normal, but I think that they rushed it. Also I think that the parents made the right decision but they shouldn't be so strict on it. They were only 13 and 14 but I think that Maddie's parents should have let Joseph talk to her before they were separated.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie's relationship was good. This is because they always hung out every day of the week and eventually had a kid and the name of it was Jupiter. After their parents found out about this Maddie was forced to move away, and Joseph was beat, and then forced to go to a correctional facility or a prison like place for kids that are not old enough to go to actual prison like Joseph.

# data[].attributes.body
i think they went to far for there age and i think they should have thought ahead. I do not think there parents treated them fairly after.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie's relationship was unusual to say the very least. I think that Maddie's parents overreacted a little bit, and Joseph's dad was just terrible. He was beating his son, just because Joseph wasn't there to carry the tools.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a good relationship because Joseph would go over to her house every day. Once Joseph was at Stone Mountain though it went down. Maddie's parents didn't like it very well about what Maddie and Joseph while Joseph's dad acted like it was more of a joke.

# data[].attributes.headline
I think Maddie's parents shouln't have been that mean to him. But at the same time they shouldn't have done that. I think they should have been able to date but I don't think it was right for them to do what they did.

# data[].attributes.subject
I think Maddie's parents shouln't have been that mean to him. But at the same time they shouldn't have done that. I think they should have been able to date but I don't think it was right for them to do what they did.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they went way to far and way to fast. This is because they were only 13 and 14. I think that there should have been some more sympathy towards Joseph because of the fact that he lost the person that he cared about most and they would not even let him see his daughter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and maddie had a good relationship but they moved to fast for their age. and did not think of the outcome of things.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Maddie and Joseph's relationship went too far too fast. They were only thirteen,

# data[].attributes.headline
I think that Maddie and Joseph's relationship was a purely loving and compassionate friendship. They didn't like each other because the had money or other things, they did it because they were in love. I think Mr. and Mrs. Joyce should have seen that this was a normal loving relationship, just a few years younger than usual.

# data[].attributes.subject
I think that Maddie and Joseph's relationship was a purely loving and compassionate friendship. They didn't like each other because the had money or other things, they did it because they were in love. I think Mr. and Mrs. Joyce should have seen that this was a normal loving relationship, just a few years younger than usual.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that Joseph and Maddie's relationship was normal other then the fact that they had a baby at age 12. In my opinion Joseph and Maddie should not have had a baby because it affected everyone around them. I feel like the parents did and didn't treat maddie and Joseph right.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that they had a strong and powerful relationship and I think the parents could have been a little nicer to them

# data[].attributes.body
I think that its kinda weird how Joseph and Maddie met each other and yes i dot think their parents treated them the right way.

# data[].attributes.body
I thought Joseph and Maddie's relationship was normal until they had a baby. I think Maddie's parents were doing the right thing they did have a kid in 8th grade.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Madeleine had a very strong relationship. Their relationship wasn't exactly taking place in the best circumstances, but the bond between the two was very strong. I feel as if Madeleine's parents should have treated Madeleine and Joseph's relationship better then they did. But, I believe that they were treating them at least a little fairly, since they were angry that Joseph impregnated their child at a young age.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Madeleine's relationship was meaningful and sweet. I also think it was reckless. They went through all of that trouble to be together and ended up being separated because of one rash decision. Joseph isn't the only one to blame, though. They both had neglectful parents that didn't care enough, or were too busy, to realize what their kids were getting into. I think it was wrong for them to keep Joseph away from his unborn daughter and Madeleine. I do think that he needs to know what they did was wrong, though.

# data[].attributes.body
Maddie and Joseph's relationship is good. Joseph thinks about and loves Maddie. They were best friends and hung out all the time.  Maddie's parents didn't treat Joseph well because they didn't let him see Jupiter. Maddie's parents didn't treat Maddie well by not letting her have an abortion.

# data[].attributes.body
madeline and joseph's relationship was not right and I think that they both knew it. . I think that their parents treated them  unfairly because they didn't know better

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and maddie had a good relationship but went to fast for their age

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Madeline and Josephs relation ship went 0-100 way too quick and that Madeline's parents had a right to react the way they did

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Josephs and Madeline's relationship is hard because Joseph knows that he can never see her again because she is dead and he can never see Jupiter because his father will not let him and Madeline's parents will not let him see her either.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph's and Madeline's relationship was good because they were happy. Although, I do think the parents reacted in the right way because if they never had a kid Madeline wouldn't of died and Joseph wouldn't of gotten in all the trouble he's been through

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that their relationship was incredibly strong...until she died. I don't believe that their parents treated them appropriately.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddie's mom and dad did not treat them fairly after Maddie got pregnant. I get that Joseph should've been punished, but not erased from Maddie's life. Joseph was in love with this person, and you just can't have them separated just like that. He was even erased from Jupiter's life as well! Now that Maddie's dead, Joseph doesn't have anybody. Joseph will not stop at anything to find Jupiter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think the parents shouldve at least talked to Maddie and Joseph t see what they were thinking, Instead of immediately removing them from seeing eachother.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they are retarded for having a baby and I don't think their parents treated them fairly.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddie and Joseph's relationship got too serious too quick .I also think that Joseph and Maddie's parents could have reacted better and let Joseph have a relatioship with Jupiter and see Maddie.

# data[].attributes.headline
Harsimar:I think the Maddie's parent should of stayed with her sometimes on the weekends and Joseph was not a bad kid.He just didn't know what he was doing and getting into. But the parents should have taken care of their daughter but Joseph should not have gone to jail.

# data[].attributes.subject
Harsimar:I think the Maddie's parent should of stayed with her sometimes on the weekends and Joseph was not a bad kid.He just didn't know what he was doing and getting into. But the parents should have taken care of their daughter but Joseph should not have gone to jail.

# data[].attributes.body
I do not think it is fair for their parents to split up their relationship, It's not like Madeleine told Joseph not to do it and he did it anyway, Madeleine wanted to, Joseph should be held responsible and should have to be there for Jupiter and Madeleine.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel like they have a really really good relationship they are with each other a lot. Plus this relationship turned into a love type of a relationship and they didn't think about future affects that this will cause they just did it without thinking which later affected Maddie majorly because Maddie died, and now Joseph is forever hurt.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they really had a good relationship because they meet in her house helping his dad and then he started to walk seven miles just to see her and seven miles back but then they had a kid and she got prente   but the sad thing is that she died.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that it was sad that they had to keep it a secret so their parents wouldn't find out. When they found out they were together they were treated unfairly. When Maddie died at child birth they didn't let Joseph keep the baby and wanted to prosecute him.

# data[].attributes.body
I do not think that they got treated right because they could have at least let them see each other one more time. But her parents were always away. But besides that i think they did have a good relationship. Very good relationship.

# data[].attributes.headline
Kayley Thomas, Cascade middle school :))

# data[].attributes.subject
Kayley Thomas, Cascade middle school :))

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie's relationship was a very strong relationship. I think that she saw him as more then the plumbers son, and he saw her more than the money. I think that it was strong because it doesn't matter the backgrounds they came from it was just based off of love. I do think it developed very quickly though. I think that they should have had abstinence and waited until they were married if they were getting married, because they made one stupid decision it costed them her life.
I think that there parents should have treated them and the situation very differently. I think that Maddie's parents should have been there more often and been there for there daughter. I think that they should have thought about her feeling and included both of the kids, yes they may be just kids but they made the decision  to do that so it's there fault. With Joseph's dad I think he was a coward. I think he needs to be a better dad. There was no reason for him to act the way he did and hit him. I think that any parent who hit's there kid is just taking all of there anger on them. I think that he should have spent time with him, and got his self together. I think that he needs to get himself together and then try to be a dad, and he needs to be way nicer with how he put's things he doesn't need to be so brutal with his words.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think their parents treated them fairly because her parents worked all of the time, and his dad beat him.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel like there relationship was fine until jupiter came in .they were not really treated fairly.they should of given josephe a chance or at least let him explain

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie shouldn't have gotten into things so soon. They were only thirteen; that's a little young to be saying that they love each other and having a kid. I think Maddie's parents treated Joseph fairly because he caused the death of their daughter at only thirteen.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddie's parents though that Joseph was bad and they didn't give him a chance to do anything about the situation. I think that Joseph's parents, didn't really care about what Joseph did but they did know that he did bad things and will continue to do so.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddie and Joseph's relationship was helping Joseph because he felt special and has never felt that way before. But I also think that they shouldn't have had a baby because they were so young and it was uncalled for. And I think that it was unfair that their parents didn't help them out.

# data[].attributes.headline
Ezekiel Charles Campbell Cascade Middle School, Indiana

# data[].attributes.subject
Ezekiel Charles Campbell Cascade Middle School, Indiana

# data[].attributes.body
I feel like Maddies and Josephs relationship didn't go far enough. I believe that they should have been together no matter what their parents said. I also believe that the parents didn't treat them fairly for instance Joseph's father was always treating noone fairly. Maddies parents were never home so they didn't give Joseph a chance. I believe that they should have waited until they were old enough and adopt the baby for themselves after they got married and live together as a happy family. I would atleast allow my son or daughter to have a chance to work things out. Plus I would like to know If my son or daughter was dating anyone so I could check them out. Also I would let them date whoever they want if it is destiny then it was to be. So I believe you should give anyone a chance even if underage. Also I wish I could read or of heard/seen Joseph, Maddie, and Jupiter grow up as a happy family. That would be the best thing. Also If I were in Joseph's shoes I would have waited until I was a little bit older to were maddie could have survived the birth. So if I loved the girl that much I could help her get a job and do anything in my poewer to give her good food, utensils, and a good home. I also believe that if I was in Josephs postition I would have done the exact same thing and try to escape the prison and try to get my dang baby. Even if I was underage. I wouldn't have cared I would do everything in my power even if I died just to get to my child that I helped give birth to. I mean as soon as you become a father everything literally changes. It is awesome. Best feeling in the world I would believe so yeah I think that it should have been different and that it could have ended better.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that their relationship is pretty sad because Joseph walks seven miles just to see her. And when something bad happened Maddis's family just blamed him for being in the wrong. I don't think that the parents treated him fairly becuase it would not be very nice to create a warrant saying that Joesph can't see his girlfriend or daughter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they were treated very unfair because joseph never got to see maddie or jupiter again.There relationship was very strong I know joseph is at lest he walked 7 miles in the winter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think it was unfair that Maddie's parents didn't listen to him or Maddie. Joseph was ready to step up to the plate to take care of his child, but since he was considered a delinquent they didn't listen. I feel like they are a cute couple and that they had a strong bond. It meant a lot to Joseph, especially since he had never felt so much love and warmth before.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that Joseph and Maddie loved each other very much. I don't think their parents treated them fairly after finding out about them because Maddie's parents didn't even try to get to know Joseph. Also they didn't if Maddie wanted to be with Joseph at all. Also after they figured out Maddie was having a child they didn't take Joseph and Maddie's requests into consideration.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie had a great relationship, and they really did like each other, but I think that they took it to far. I also think that even though Maddie is gone now Joseph will always remember her no matter what. I do think that the parents treated them unfairly because Maddie's parents made it to where Joseph couldn't even see his own child, which I don't think was right at all.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that their parents treated them unfairly since Joseph  never got to see his own daughter  and that he wanted to raise Jupiter with Maddie.  Joseph also would never get to see Maddie again which was a little unfair since he "Loved" her.  Both of their parents could of helped them out so it would of been nice and perfect but instead they abandoned it and put it up for adoption.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a good relationship but, they were not really thinking and things got out of hand when Maddie got pregnant. I think it was probably the best thing for Jupiter to be put up for adoption because it would be hard for Joseph and Maddie to take care of her.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that Joseph and Madeline relationship was important to both of them and her parents just took that away from them. I also think that if the parents would have been more accepting nothing would have happened to Joseph, He wouldn't have took the drug which would have not made him try to kill his teacher and he wouldn't ever had gone to Stone Mountain which wouldn't make him have the scar he has now. I don't think that Madeline's parents treated them fairly.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they took it WAY too far with their relationship because they had a kid! And I do think that their parents did treat them fairly other than maddie's parents, they let her go without much of any punishment but joseph got sent to a juvenile school and was put into a new family .

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie's relation was very strong. They understood each other. I also think that their relationship had moved too quickly though. 8th graders shouldn't be having kids at that age. I think that Maddie's parents treated them too unfairly. They were very happy with each other and Maddie's parents decided to tear them apart.

# data[].attributes.body
How do I feel about Joseph and Madeline? I feel at the age of 13 they had a really good relationship and it was strong, but at such a young age they didn't think about doing what they did before they did it. I think their parents made the right decision in splitting them up because they are too young to try or even be able to raise a child

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a really good relationship, but I think they got a little out of hand because they weren't thinking. They only knew that they were in love, and they didn't think about the consequences that would come from what they do.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Madeline's parents needed to be so rude to Joseph as to where they will prosecute him. Joseph and Maddie should have had the right to see each other and the baby because they didn't do anything harmful to each other and Joseph was willing to get a job to support Jupiter. Joseph and Maddie loved each other, even though they were really young. I think Madeline's parents took really extreme measures and they were really rude to Joseph. When Joseph went to apologize to Madeline's parents they didn't care they just wanted him to go away. I think her parents were very rude. Joseph's dad and Joseph aren't really in good terms with each other but I think it was good for him to stay out of Josephs problems because whenever he tries to help he makes it worse.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph relationship with Maddie is hard because they cant see each other and Joseph cant visit Jupiter because of family.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that Josephs and Madeleine's relationship is very strong, nothing can break them. Madeleine will always be with Joseph even though she passed. I think that their parents didn't treat them very fair because Joseph didn't get to choose if he kept Jupiter or not.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a good relationship.
I do not think their parents treated them fairly because they got mad and pushed Joseph the father away instead of dealing with what they have and figuring out a way to make it work.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and maddie

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddies and Josephs relationships went to far. Maddie never would have died if they didnt have a kid. And there is a chance that Joseph and maddie would still be seeing each other.

# data[].attributes.headline
Gaven Stewart from Cascade Middle School 

# data[].attributes.subject
Gaven Stewart from Cascade Middle School 

# data[].attributes.body
i think their relationship was good and that her parents should have been more happy about it and that they should have helped them

# data[].attributes.body
Joseph and maddie are getting tor apart because they cant be seeing each other any more and Maddie's parents are getting mad at Joseph and Josephs parents the Hurd's are not happy with Joseph.

# data[].attributes.body
No, No they did not treat them fairly it was there first time and they should have gave them tips or something along those lines.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Maddie and Joseph had a great relationship because they did everything together. I don't think that they were treated fairly because they could've a less helped Joseph after Maddie died to keep the kid because after all most kids end up looking like there moms expressly girl, so they at less could have helped them out by keeping them together. Because it really is hard growing up with parents and thinking there your real mom and dad and then finding out that there not .

# data[].attributes.body
I think they shouldn't of seen each other everyday without their parents home. I think they should of at least told their parents about each other. I think they would be in as much trouble if they would of told since it wouldn't be a secret. I do not think their parents treated them fairly after finding out about them. I know that if I was the parent I would be mad and very disappointed. But I do not think I would make them stay apart.  I would make it so that they were not together without some one home especially what they were doing.

# data[].attributes.headline
Emma Cline- Cascade Middle School- Indiana

# data[].attributes.subject
Emma Cline- Cascade Middle School- Indiana

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Maddie shouldn't have kept their relationship from her parents. After Maddie's parents found out about Joseph and her they where very angry and wanted to prosecute him for her getting pregnant.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that there relationship was really good because they treated eachother with respect and correctly to each other. I also think that Maddie's parents treated Joseph poorly and shouldv'e given Joseph a chance insted of just turning him down right from the begginning. All Joseph wants to do is see is baby Jupiter for the first time, and see Maddie one more time.

# data[].attributes.body
I do and don't think that they were treated fairly, they weren't treated fairly after the incident when the maid caught them, they became outcasts and separated including their child going into a foster home. They were treated fairly because they were 13 and 14 years old at the time and they were moving along kinda swiftly, and they should have just stayed away from all of that so they wouldn't be split up including their kid. Overall I think that they were treated fairly because if they hadn't of done that their wouldn't be all of the confusion and sadness in the situation.

# data[].attributes.body
I think they treated Maddie and Joseph unfairly because they should have asked them what they wanted to do but they were thirteen so this kind of thing shouldn't have happen but family should support any decision made. I think That it was sad that Maddie died but I think they still should have let Joseph see the baby because Maddie died.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that their parents probably did the right thing. But i do think its unfair because Joseph really wants to see his baby and maddie and joseph really like each other. So thatch unfair. Like kenny said I think that they moved too fast too because they are only 13 and 14.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think they were treated fairly I think they shouldn't have sent Joseph away. I think their relations

# data[].attributes.body
I think the relationship between Maddie and Joseph had gotten way too out of hand. At first it seemed as if it was your typical eighth grade romance but then things started to change where Joseph started to get "addicted" to seeing her. For one no teenager that young should act like that and treat themselves as if they are living in an adult life for they aren't fully matured yet and then later and quickly they couldn't even wait twenty some years to have a child. In conclusion to that I think both Joseph and Maddie got treated somewhat fairly but I say more should have happened. You can see this in your normal romance shows where the guy is always being put down the most for mistakes whether that was the situation Joseph went through or stories that include cheating. You have to think the female was in this too so I think both should receive the same harsh punishment because it wasn't just Joseph it was Maddie as well that was in to this. Then finally I agree that they should've put the baby up for adoption because you aren't going to let people this young take care of another human life when they couldn't even take care of their own correctly the first time. Plus these kids are in eighth grade! Shouldn't they have learned about abstinence...?

# data[].attributes.body
I think that there relationship was normal. I feel like they made a good choice to put the baby in the foster home. But I do think that Joseph maybe could of saw the baby before the baby knew who he was. I also dont think that Joseph should have gotten in trouble. I think that the nanny should have gotten a punishment because she was supposed to be there every day but she was not. So that left Joseph and Madeleine alone.

# data[].attributes.body
I do think that Maddie and Joseph's relationship was good and nice because they treated each other properly except when they went a little to extreme a too quickly. I also do not think that the parents treated them fairly because Jupiter is his daughter and now he will never get to see her in real life and now her for who she is. All Joseph wants to do is see his 3 month old daughter just once and see how she is.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Madeleine's and Joseph's relationship went to extreme levels really fast.I think there parents treated them unfairly because they made them put the baby up for adoption and that is very cruel because Joseph didn't even get to meet his daughter.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Madeleine's relationship moved to fast because they are only 13 and 14 years old. So yes I think they where treated fairly by the parents spliting them up because they are to young and can not take care of a baby.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Joseph and Madeleine's relationship was great because they both liked each other. But I think that the parents would not like it because they already had a baby, and I think that they would not approve of this.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they treated them fair for the baby. I think it was right to separate them because they were far to young to care for a baby, even though the parents MAY have helped.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they got treated fairly because they were only thirteen and fourteen and it just isn't right for any of that to happen.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Madeleine's relationship moved too quickly. I say this because no one should be having a kid in eighth grade. Besides that, I do think Madeleine's parents treated them unfairly. Joseph and Maddie were young and in love, and no one should be taken from that. I also think the prosecution was harsh as well.

# data[].attributes.body
no i don't think they treat them fair. maddy and joseph should have been together.

# data[].attributes.body
No I don't think they were treated fairly I feel like the should have talked to see what they wanted to do first .

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddies relationship moved to fast considering they were young and were not treated fairly by their parents who should've helped them.

# data[].attributes.body
I think their relationship was strong and like they couldn't be away from each other. For the fact Joseph walked 7 miles every day rain, shine, sleet, or snow. No I think their parents should of been more helpful

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a good relationship, however I think things just got out of hand and they weren't really thinking about anything except that they thought they were in love.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Joseph and Maddie had a good relationship, but they did not think about what could come out of the future,when they made those choices.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Maddie and Joseph were treated fairly, and I feel that their relationship wasn't meant to be because Maddie passed away giving birth and Joseph wasn't allowed to see Maddie and he never will again.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel that the relationship was helping Joseph, it made him feel like he had a purpose, but at the same time Maddie was also happy. So it was good, but the baby was unneeded. The parents where very un-supportive, especially Joseph's father, but also the fact the Maddie's parents wanted to prosecute Joseph.

# data[].attributes.body
i think both Joseph and Maddie's parents over reacted and as a result of there over reactions the kids found it kind of risky so they kept meeting.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel like their relationship moved too quickly considering they had a child in eighth grade, before they were even in high school. In my opinion, their parents treated them unfairly. Joseph's dad was angry and decided to be uncooperative but Madeleine's parents decided to refuse Joseph any access to his child. They were both rash and rude,

# data[].attributes.body
I think that they shouldn't have treated them like they did. They should have treated them better than what they did.and they had a unusual relationship

# data[].attributes.body
I think that their parents had a very different reaction. Joseph's dad didn't care at all. While Maddie's parents flipped a lid.