# data[].attributes.body
upbringing, educational and career background, religiosity, anyone they found inspirational

Raniere was born on August 26, 1960, in Brooklyn, NY. Money was tight for his family, leading to a move to Suffern, NY and his father being often away for work. His parents would fight constantly, leaving Raniere to wonder if he was to blame for their arguments. The fighting and absence of his father ultimately led to his parent's divorce when he was 8 years old. Raniere lived with his mother who suffered from heart disease; his father was no longer in his life. At age 13, his mother had open heart surgery which developed an emotional strain in their relationship. Raneire would often think about how his mother could die at any time, leaving him all alone in this world, as he was an only child and had no close relatives living nearby. He devoted most of his time to caring for his mother, although she started drinking heavily at this time.

His struggling home dynamics did not affect him academically though. He strived in high school and was admitted early to Rensselaer Polytech Institute (RPI), in Troy, NY. A former headmaster at Rockland Country Day School described him as "a brilliant student of mathematics and science and certainly an adequate student of humanities, well prepared for college academically, socially, and emotionally". However, some previous classmates stated that Raniere was a quiet loner, an avid chess player, and a kid who did not seem to hang out with anyone or have friends. He graduated from RPI in 1982 with majors in computer science, biology and mathematics.

Throughout the 80s, Raniere was involved with Amway, a multi-level marketing company before he launched his own, Consumers' Buyline Inc (CBI) in 1990. This buying company offered discounts in exchange for recruitment. In 1994, he created National Health Network, a multi-seller of vitamins that failed three years later.

During an interview with Barbara Bouchey (ex-girlfriend), she describes a phone call she had with Raniere's father explaining to her how when Raniere had an intelligence test at 8 years old, a "switch went off" when he found out he was gifted. James Raniere explained to Bouchey that "suddenly overnight, [Keither Raniere] turned into Jesus Christ and he was superior and better than everybody like a diety".

# data[].attributes.body
"NXIVM embodies a set of consistent and universal principles in which all humans can participate. These principles, apart from any mystical or religious notions, allow for life to persist and uphold a diversity of beliefs. By creating a new understanding, we can actualize our potential to live and work together and consequently bring human existence to a whole new level. Yet this cannot be done without first raising human awareness, fostering an ethical humanitarianism, and celebrating what it truly means to be human - and this is our mission" - mission statement from NXIVM website, 2003

Raniere stated that the purpose of NXIVM was to provide more joy in an individual's life

courses provided to help entrepreneurs reach their goals

women were to be monogamous and men were to be polygamous

the classes were extensive and expensive workshops that occurred over weeks or weekends that were supposedly to help an individual overcome their trauma

these classes were told to make an individual the best versions of themselves

# data[].attributes.body
AGE -> The members were generally adults who ranged from their late 20s to mid-40s. It is important to note though that there were younger and older members in this group as well

RACE -> members were predominantly white, but there were individuals from other racial and ethnic backgrounds

GENDER -> Both men and women were in this group, however, there were more women. Especially in the secretive subgroup, DOS or The Vow.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION ->

many members were well-educated with college or advanced degrees. they were individuals who valued learning and self-improvement

Raniere has been careful to avoid accepting troubled students

there was a variety of professional backgrounds in this group. such as actors, entrepreneurs, business professionals and people within the wellness and self-help sectors.

due to the high price-point of the courses and programs within NXIVM, members typically had to be able to afford the $2700 classes. This indicated that members were in the middle to upper class.

# data[].attributes.body
Raniere's constant presentation of his high intelligence coerced followers to trust him and what he preached. He presented himself as someone who was uniquely intelligent and enlightened. He promised members that he could help provide them with growth in their lives, both personally and professionally. By making these promises, it would benefit him because it would result in hefty financial payments or unethical, illegal activities.

He would listen to individuals very carefully and that was a part of his charisma. Heidi Hutchinson, a former member, explained that "when [Raniere] was listening [to a conversation] he was actually calculating how to influence you through [the] conversation".

Raniere used psychological tactics to exploit the vulnerabilities of his followers and use this to maintain dominance. By exploiting the vulnerabilities he would offer solutions that were only provided by NXIVM thus increasing the dependency an individual would have on NXIVM.

Raniere used manipulation and blackmail to enforce obedience to the group. This was prominently seen within the subgroup, DOS. He would manipulate women into becoming slaves by branding them with his initials. He would require them to provide collateral, which included nude photos, confidential information or documents that were signed under duress. If any of these women disobeyed or leave the group he would use this collateral against them.

# data[].attributes.headline
strategies for resisting the routinization of charisma

# data[].attributes.subject
strategies for resisting the routinization of charisma

# data[].attributes.body
to keep followers' attention on the words and wishes of the charismatic leader, he or she may alter the policies and practices of the group, sometimes very suddenly

quickly into the development of NXIVM there became a pyramid scheme. An individual would be identified as a 'master' (typically someone highly renounced in the group) and their job was to collect 'slaves'. These slaves would then have to provide collateral to their masters to prove their loyalty and, commitment and in case they ever tried to leave the group

according to the FBI, Allison Mack was Raniere's personal slave. He was her 'master' and the collateral she gave him was a legal document that stated if she were to break her commitment; her home would be placed into Raniere's name and her future children (birthed by her) would be his. Letters that addressed the abuse of her nieces.

some charismatic leaders may seek constant reaffirmation of loyalty from their followers, leading to an escalation in the demands they place on members for personal service and sacrifice to the group

around 2015, women were being approached by other female members in the group asking if they felt 'stuck' in their growth and wanted to join secretive women-only self-help group

this group, DOS or The Vow, claimed to be an additional subgroup of NXIVM, meant solely to promote female empowerment

Many charismatic leaders test loyalty, heighten emotional dependence, and generally disrupt potential sources of alternative authority by criticizing or even physically separating couples and other close pairings within the religious groups

Former member, Toni Natalie states that after Raniere helped her quit smoking she was hooked. However, after one year of first meeting Raniere her marriage had ended. Raniere had convinced her that her husband was sleeping with their nanny.

women within DOS, were told that to show their commitment and loyalty to the sisterhood they would have to seduce Raniere, as he did not prefer to put himself on the line when it came to sexual interactions

Charismatic leaders will often call into question the inspired messages of all competitors for authority, both external and internal to the group

women who joined the DOS were to be branded with a symbol.

if you looked closely at this symbol there would be small initials of K.R. (Keith Raniere) that literally branded his authority within the group

When all else fails, and sometimes earlier, some charismatic leaders have tried to consolidate their control and diminish countervailing influences by changing the location, and hence the operating environment, of their groups. often these moves are to a more isolated spot.

Although this group never moved to an isolated area, the majority of the group lived in Clifton Park, a town just outside of Albany, NY. A testimony from a former member explained that she was forced into isolation, in her family home.

members would encourage individuals to move to Clifton Park, New York (where Raniere and many other members resided) to help the group's mission

Michelle, a former member, explained in her testimony that when she confided in Raniere about a relationship she had with another member her freedom and possessions started to slowly, including her phone, iPod, computer and immigration papers and documents (she was from Mexico)

this relationship had been deemed as an 'ethical breach' and Raniere has manipulated her family to believe that the only way Michelle could rid of the breach was to stay in isolation in her family home indefinitely

Michelle was in isolation for almost two years with nothing to do but write letters to Raniere

the precautiousness of charismatic leadership reinforces the tendency of members to demonize their enemies

throughout the trial, Raniere would remind his remaining followers that reports on NXIVM in the media could not be trusted

he stated that the media was dishonourable

# data[].attributes.body
what made NXIVM well-known:

many famous and well-known individuals were a part of NXIVM

Clare and Sara Bronfman - daughters of billionaire Seagrams chairman

Allision Mack - American actress known for her role in the television series, Smallville

India Oxenburg - daughter of actress Catherine Oxenburg

Emiliano Salinas - son of former Mexican president

The beginning of the end:

In 2017, several former members of NXIVM had asked NYS authorities to investigate the group. Their complaints were about a subgroup within NXIVM called "The Vow" or "D.O.S.' They stated that these members were branded and some were then required to have sex with Raniere. When a report about the branding was released in The New York Times, authorities began a criminal investigation.

During this investigation, Raniere moved to Mexico, where he was arrested. An FBI stated that Raniere had maintained a group of 15 to 20 women whom he had sexual relationships with.

In 2018, Raniere and five women in NXIVM were charged with racketeering conspiracy involving crimes that included:

identity theft

extortion

forced labor

sex trafficking

money laundering

wire fraud

obstruction of justice

# data[].attributes.body
Raniere had the idea that he could change the world by bettering the population. He believed that through his courses and teaching his followers would become the best versions of themselves.

There is no debate that Raniere fits the bill for Narcissistic personality disorder. Narcissistic personality disorder is a "mental health condition in which people have an unreasonably high sense of their own importance" (Mayo Clinic). This is indicated through the examples of characteristics listed below:

grandiose sense of self-importance (exaggerates achievements and talents and believes they should be recognized for them, whether valid or not)

an intelligence test that Keith took when he was younger, that indicated he was brilliant, was actually an at-home intelligence test.

claimed he spoke in full sentences at the age of one, taught himself high school math in 19 hours at the age of twelve, and when he was 13 had learned three years of college math and several computer languages

classified himself as the "smartest man in the world" according to the Guinness Book of World Records (that was only available in Australia for one year)

preoccupied with a fantasy of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal love

it was no question or debate that Raniere was infatuated with his "brilliance" as noted above he constantly reminded his followers of how intelligent he was

he kept reminding his followers that women were meant to be in monogamous relationships meanwhile men were to be polygamous.

belief they are special and unique and should associate with or be understood by only other special or high-status people or institutions

had his members call him "Vanguard"

interpersonally exploitative (taking advantage of others to achieve their own ends)

required members to submit collateral, since his members were socioeconomically stable he didn't want them to give him a diamond necklace or a fancy watch (something that they could just repurchase) he insisted they provide him with explicit photos, legal documents or personal confessions that he could use to exploit them if need be

had numerous relationships with women, although they were under the impression that he was only seeing them and that their relationship was real

shows arrogant behaviour or attitudes. In this box, you should list each of the characteristics they fit and for each one include an example of how this presents itself

controlling -> as stated above with the use of collateral

misogynistic -> numerous relationships with women not caring if he hurt them when they found out he was seeing others

egotistically -> the constant reminder of how smart and intelligent he was

# data[].attributes.body
When women were recruited they were required to hand over collateral which included:

embarrassing and incriminating information

nude photos

These would be publicly released if they disclosed the existence of the secretive subgroup, disobeyed or tried to break their commitment.

Mark Vicente, director of "What the Bleep Do We Know" and former member", stated in the opening scene of The Vow that he was worried about speaking out due to backlash he would receive from the group. He was afraid they would tarnish his reputation, attack him physically and socially, and drag his name through the mud.

# data[].attributes.body
the secretive subgroup within NXIVM was identified as DOS (Dominus Obseqious Sororium)

this group was exclusively female and was presented as a women's empowerment group to lure in more members

these members needed to present with a strong commitment to NXIVM. They did this by provided collateral which proved their trust and loyalty

these members were more emotionally vulnerable and sought for a deeper meaning and connection

they were looking for empowerment and DOS was marketed as a exclusive and elite group that focused on female empowerment and leadership

# data[].attributes.body
1. Grigoriadis V: Inside nxivm, the “sex cult” that preached empowerment The New York Times, 2018 Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/30/magazine/sex-cult-empowerment-nxivm-keith-raniere.html. Accessed June 24, 2024.

2. Hong N: Nxivm “Sex Cult” was also a huge pyramid scheme, lawsuit says The New York Times, 2020 Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/29/nyregion/nxivm-lawsuit-keith-raniere.html. Accessed June 24, 2024.

3. Moghe S: “please let me out”: Former NXIVM member testifies about being held in a room for 2 years CNN, 2019 Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/02/us/nxivm-room-testimony/index.html. Accessed June 24, 2024.

4. Correa C: A timeline of the nxivm sex cult case The New York Times, 2020 Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/article/nxivm-timeline.html. Accessed June 24, 2024.

5. Dickson E: HOW NXIVM was the ultimate wellness scam Rolling Stone, 2020 Available at: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/nxivm-keith-raniere-wellness-scam-sex-cult-848439/. Accessed June 24, 2024.

6. Cult of personality: Forbes, 2013 Available at: https://www.forbes.com/forbes/2003/1013/088.html. Accessed June 24, 2024.

7. Bloch J: Uncover: Escaping NXIVM CBCnews, 2018 Available at: https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/longform/escaping-nxivm/. Accessed June 24, 2024.

8. Yakowicz W: When we exposed Keith Raniere, the leader of the nxivm “sex cult” Forbes, 2019 Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/willyakowicz/2019/05/15/keith-raniere-the-leader-of-the-nxivm-sex-cult/. Accessed June 24, 2024.