# data[].attributes.body
Hi everyone,

I very disagree against this plan because the Native American suffered for several years. That is why it’s essential to reserve the little native population. We should rather redeem ourselves with these poor people who have probably lost great-grandparents !
The Indians are part of the history of our country because they are emblematic our children and our tourism must discover this population that is unique with their original ways of life.
To finish, I think that the American reserves should not be removed, and I think it should rather be more numerous and we should create a link with these Indians ...
I also propose to take the initiatives of this association to make a world association that could help the best Indian. Thank you

# data[].attributes.body
The american government wants to abolish the reservations. I'm against this reform because I don't think this is the good decision for the Indians. First of all because many tribes live in, and they can't live in a city like us because it is their lifestyle. And it belongs to American heritage. If we delete these reservations, most of Indians tribe will disapear and it is a part of the soul of America that will disapear as well. Secondly the indians were the first population in America. So we already took their lands by force that was unacceptable but it was another time and we can't blame whites people for it. But we can help the Indians tribe now that it is our time to act. And we must help them to keep the reservations to leave them live their own life!
I hope this message will be read and will change something to keep the reservations.

# data[].attributes.body
The American government would like to abolish native American reservation and i am against. Fortunately, an association is open to all, to be able to support then and prevent this misfortune from happening. Their reserves should not be destroyed for the simple reason that tribes live there like cherokee, Apache, Siroux and many others who seek to preserve their culture. They live on these reserves to be able to control their own politics. They are tribes that have always existed and that must not change because they have their place in the world and are part of the world culture. Do not forget that when Christophe Colom found America, he first called it india because he was greeted by the Ameriendians. So i do not see why it would be necessary to destroy their reserves which are their living environment, for longer than amercians themselves. That is why I hope that with my message and that of others, the abolition of Amerindian reservations will not take place. And that the concerned tribes will be able to continue their life like before with their culture and customs.

# data[].attributes.body
hello, I write to you to share my opinion. I learned that the US government wanted to abolish Amerindian reserves. Personally I find this idea unacceptable. These are the first to arrive in the United States so removing their reserves would be inhuman and cruel. We must mobilize to save the Amerindian reserves. Native Americans do not have the same way of life as we do, so that's why we have to let them live as they like because if you remove their reserves they will be completely lost and confused. Native Americans have no concept of today's life so they can not live in society with today's world. I really think it's better to leave them in their reserves. I sincerely hope that my message will have an impact on this odious decision and that it will make a difference.
Mathieu Tricot

# data[].attributes.body
We must save the Indian tribes! When I arrived on this web site, I saw what the Americans were going to Indian Reserves and I decided to act.

If we destroy these reserves, we will destroy a culture, a harmony, a society of calm and order. Indians have a lot to teach us about their way of life: community life, ecology, ideologies ...

If we destroy these reserves we risk killing hundreds of Indian communities who have not done anything wrong. It would be a real genocide!

I must fight with them so that they can keep their land and live away from our system of delinquency and corruption.

We must not decide whether or not we should dislodge them
Help us save the Indian tribes!

# data[].attributes.body
Hello, the governement American would like to abolish native. I post a message on this association because I'm shoked by their decision!  I think it's a bad idea. It's inhuman. I do not see interests there.
I not agree with them because the indian tribes live in this american reservation like cherokees, Apaches, Iroquois... This reservation want to preserve their identity, their political culture and their linguistic culture. Then, they were the first habitants of America before european colonisation and they occupy the entire continent. And they defend the environment of their territories. Finally,  the indians suffered during nineteenth century because whites kiled them and there were slaves. I think it would be sad to destroy that. We must save the reservation!

# data[].attributes.body
I was looking for news about this decision about this famous government law, which is controversial at the time, and after falling on several sites I came across yours. I totally agree with everything you say . I do not agree and I do not understand why the american government wants to abolish native American reservations . The Indians are a key pillar in the history of America. They appear in well-known cartoons like Lucky Luck or Les Daltons . The Indians are a people who live quietly in tribe, for example Cherokee, Apache, Spokane etc .... But the whites have arrived to take their territories, colonize them, etc. In taking their territories, the whites were intended to extract the gold that was on the lands of the Indian tribes . But that was not enough, it was necessary that the whites face a genocide of the Indian people, this genocide made a lot of death knowing that this people lived without seeking the confusion with the whites. After that, the Indians had to leave their lands . I really hope that this law will not pass, and that the native American reservations will be preserved !

# data[].attributes.body
Why to destroy the Indian reservations? You don’t find that we have enough already hurt them to this population ? Our ancestors destroyed whole families, expelled them from their home and their only place of refuge which they were able to find, it is necessary the destroyed. We cannot change the past but we can improve the future to be better people! Indeed, I don’t think that to destroy them are beneficial in our country. His reserves bring so much to the economy and to the development of our country generally! Moreover, I really think so that he disturbs nobody, they are in their corner and make their life. They have their own faith and they go themselves, they are free! These reservations protect their custom, their traditions, their religion, their memories, their life. It is necessary to protect him ! It is human beings as us, that need a roof ! They managed to reconstruct hundreds of years then let us leave the quiet! So let’s do something about this injustice !

# data[].attributes.body
Hello , I send this message because , I am avaient the destruction of Amerindian reserves because it would je destroy à culture ,a way of life that is part of a history. They do not disturb anyone in their reserve, and what Will become of them once in the city , without work , without place to sleep and to live. The white men have already taken all their land from them and locked them up like animals on reserves, where they can live almost as they wish. It is therefore horrible to want to take what little they have left.Join our cause, and prevent to destroy part of the history of the United States by destroying these reserves. Together we can prevent this and even allow to improve the conditions of life of the Amerindians killed and persecuted by the white man. We count on your support

# data[].attributes.body
Hello the friends.
I thought I was the only one to want to speak publicly about the situation of Indians. I am happy to have arrived on this forum.
My name is Gautier.
Indians ... We accommodated them. We promised them the good handle them. And now, the state wants to make them leave their houses! I disagree that ! It was a shame ! Certainly, they will be considerate as Americans by the state, but every day they are going to undergo the racism of the American "TRUTHS" … Unfortunately, I think integrate them would be us subject them to a form of all-day discrimination, even if it leaves a good intention. Furthermore, I think that they would be sad has to survive in a modern world. Indeed, their reserves allowed them to keep living has their way. They have a lifestyle completely different from ours. I think that many of them will die. They know nothing about the modern technologies. They do not even know cars! Finally, if you agree with me, let us mobilize to fight this reform!
Bye everyone :) ;)

# data[].attributes.body
Hello, I recently hear that american gouvernement want to abolish native american reservations. That news just get me so angry. That’s why I’m writting this to you. I want to join your association «save the reservations» bacause I totaly agree with your mouvement.

I just find this situation incredible!

American Native people are on their lands. For them otheramericans are foreingers.

This people has been colonized for the gold, this people has been killed by white people, they lost their lands and the gouvernement want to supress one of the last thing that they have.

That’s unbelivable we can’t let that, arrive.

Where is the democracy ?

Did someone just ask them if they agree with that?

We have to preserve amerindian reserves, we have to stand up against this gouvernement resolutions.

For their history, for our history because they are the history of america to. And for their culture and their traditions.

They already suffured enough I don’t want to see them disappear.

Together we can avoid that.

We have the same goal : saving the resevetions! So let’s work together.

# data[].attributes.body
But how can they want to suppress the Indian reserves !
How can they deny this people ? They are part of the history of the United States. Most Indian reserves are located to the west of this vast country, despite the fact that many Indians no longer live in these reserves for political reasons. Others are there and in no case should they remove them.
While the reserves do not belong to the Indians but to, they have all the power to remove these reservations and return them to the « public domain ».
We still talk about being human and remove their place of Life reminds me of the genocide that have suffered in previous years.
It is necessary to exclude them again ?
This people still have a culture and a policy of their own and send them to live in American cities could destroy this culture.
I am complety against this project!
Because for me it is a people who has suffered a lot and that it does not deserve yet this injustice, there is a minimization of a humain people it is incensed and egoistic...
However I think that no one knows that most Indians are fighting to succed in paying for their children’s education in schools near their town while keeping their culture .

# data[].attributes.body
I am so happy to finally see that other people are interested in Indian life. We must really act, they need us ! The little they have left to them should be given to them, they are less numerous, they have been divided over the years and many have died because of wars, epidemics and starvation. Reserves are a place of refuge for them and memories for some as well.
Reserves have already been reduced so why reduce them even more ?
They have had very few rights and freedoms in the past so leave their reservations.
Why should Americans have the right to their own land but not the Indians ?
It is not because they are a minority that we must neglect them.
Put yourself in their place, would you have liked us to do something like this? I'm sure not !
Too many tribes have already lost their reserves so that the little remains to disappear. They should have the freedom to live together, to find themselves between Indians with the same story.
I speak on behalf of all Indians to tell you my wish to be heard. Let's fight and support us !

# data[].attributes.body
I think we should not relocate Indians from American reserves.I find this move would be useless on the part of the Americans.

First of all because they are only a minority and it should be allowed to live in peace because they do not harm anyone. Then they are not in our civilization ( barefoot marches) so they break us once again no problems. This would not be useful because they live in a naturel environement and if Americans want to take gold they would put nature in danger. Moreover it's bad for biodiversity. There would be deforestaton, but if the Americans relocate them that it will be their homes?, In what territories and in what conditions would they live?  because they do not live like us so they will not be well integrated.
That's why I'm against the delocalization of Indians in America.

We must let them live as we wish.

# data[].attributes.body
No ! The American government should not abolish the reserves of the Amerindians, because they were the first on the American territory.
But also, the European colonizers destroyed the Amerindian community by killing them and stealing their land. I think that suppressing Indian reserves would not be fair and not human.
Simply because, I would not have wanted to destroy what remains of my origins.

In addition to this, I think the government should let the Native Americans live quietly because it is the only way for me to repair the injustices of the past at best to erase their origins.

And finally, I do not understand why distroyed the Amerindians because they don't bother us and I think it will create a lot of other problems, like wars and deaths. I think it's not worth it because peace reigns.

In addition, they are part of the story and I think that removing these Amerindian reservations would be a shame. That's why we have to keep Amerindian bookings.

# data[].attributes.body
The american government want to abolish native american reservation, I think this is a mistake. Why do you want to abolish the native american reservation? Are you ashamed of the past? In the time everyworld can do a mistake. Look the First World War or the Second there were lot of soldiers or civils who died but we can't return back in time and save all of people. You! In the past you killed lot of indians like cherokee (indian's tribe) and if you think this was a mistake you have to live with that. Why nobody couldn't visit the territories? Why the future generation of cherokee couldn't return on their territorie. Secondly look after the concentration camps of the Second World War, yes there were lot of bystanders who died but today in Poland we can visit it. So I think lot of people would visit the historic place in the world, and it's like a memory homework to the people's who died in the past, you have to let their place for the honor of the indians who are dead. Let their place for the world, everyworld will think of the indians history and everyworld will say "Why we did it in the past" and "why we killed their..?"

# data[].attributes.body
The American government would like to abolish Native American. I don’t agree ! Fortunately, the association « save reservations » is against this plan. Firstly, we must save the reservations because for generations the Indians tribes live in these reservations. In United States, there are 310 reservations and 110 tribes, for example, Cherokees, Sioux, Apaches… They have their own way of life and prefer to stay beetwen them. Remove reservations, it’s an abomination ! Secondly, for a lot of Indians, these lands are sacred. Moreover, since always, a life of Indians is difficult because they suffered the violence during genocide, but in recent years, the Indians can live as everybody. However, if an American government delete reservations, the peace and tranquility will disappear. It’s inconceivable ! For me, this plan is destructive. The Indians are terrified, they don’t want to lose their territories ! I agree with them ! They just want keep their territories, that is normal isn’t it ? That’s why, we created « save reservations ». Our goal is easy : keep Indians reservations !

# data[].attributes.body
I found your website by chance. I agree with your ideas, I share your opinion. I don't agree with White's ideas to abolish Native American reservations.
Indeed Native Americans were here before White people. It is White people who colonized America and exploited personnes who lived there before. So initially , territories belonged to Native Americans.
Moreover White people made promise to let then their territories. However Whites still want to hunt Native Americans. Why? Just for extracting gold. They covet the land of Native Americans for that. White people only think about money. Therefor they don't think about the population well-being. I am opposed to this. I think that is inhuman. It is sad because Native Americans are a peaceful nation. They just want to live here peacefully, they don't want war. Futhermore the persence of Native Americans nrings a cultural diversity. Indeed Whites and Native Americans have different traditions and histories; Those two populations could share that rather than fight each over. That's why I support your association: to protest against this governement plan.

# data[].attributes.body
Do you not have enough persecuted Indian Tribe?!
So why do you want to abolish native American reservations ? I don’t understand what that is going to bring you. Our ancestrors had already deprived them of their property during  many years. Indians had to reconstruct their living environment in this reservation, so it’s not fair to ask them now once again to start over. Also, they are differents from us, they don’t have the same way of life like us (their culture and traditions for example); it’s in part for that i’m completely disagree with you and your decision. If you abolish reservations, they will have to leave in cities and they never do this, they will be completely disoriented. They don’t even know what is a car or a phone so imagine how this is going to turn ! Moreover, some people in cities shall not see their arrival like a good think, their differences will penalize them. In my opinion, it will be very hard for them to become integrated. For example, it will be hard to command of the language so they will not find job. So I really think that the preservation of the Native American reservations is the best solution.

# data[].attributes.body
No ,we must not abolish the ameridian reserve in the United Stated imagined aboriginal thoussands would see their territoires disappear while some of these people live in since the creation of this reserve in 1851 and where would all those thoussands go without clothes ,whithout diplomas some do not ever speak our language some have Never seen what a ca rien looks lik , and yes it is nobody would go on the street is there already not enough people homeless .Abolish their territoires would be a sign of racism because att the Time the white men hurte ,kill the indians who lived quietly in the Woods and customs suchs a change will lead ton immense problems including especially with the Americans .More over the autochtones hâte white men .If you remove all the reservation Ameriandienne ,you should fight againts the Indians who will be dead many deaths thats why we must leave thé indians in their réservé live quietly each on his side to avaid the wost .Do not do it

# data[].attributes.body
Ladies and Gentlemen
Thanks to God, we live in a free and open society, but some spaces, unfortunately, cause many difficulties in politics, administration and low.
Among this spaces, 310 Indians reserves in danger.
In 1851, we voted for Indians Appropriations, and today, the government heartless, without knowledge, would like to suppress Indians Appropriations.
I think otherwise !
We had a president, Ulysse Grant, elected in 1869. 18th president of United-States of America,a great career soldier, who fought for peace   in order to stop the conflicts between Americans and Indians.
Today we want to eradicate all his Native American land ! NOT AT ALL!
their population is growing, poverty is slowly receding, traditions are reviving. If Native Americans are now full citizens, they are improving american development. They are the first occupants of the continent, and us, we must eradicate them ? Nonsense !
Today, we will have to prevent this ! May god bless you and may god bless United-States of America.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that native american reservation should not be abolish because all this persons are humans and you can't destroy human's houses. They can't survive in urban life,  they don't know how to speak english, they don't know how are the people outside and the most important for me is they don't have enough immune defense to survive all these diseases, they lives in the forest, isolate of all us usual diseases , their body's are not  protecting well.
If you abolish reservation, you have to reinsert all these people in the society because if we take them out  with no money or foods or houses they will all die and a this point,  we will be able to speak about a GENOCIDE .
The government seems to think that these are objects that we can abuse without feelings and I hope this will change, we can't forget that there are mans and most important : womens and chlidren inside the reservation.
I hope that all these messages will not be forget and that de government will change his mind
Destroy reservation is destroy humanity don't forget !

Sincerely, a worried man.

# data[].attributes.body
Hello,i created an association called "saved reservations".This association defends the safeguarding of native americans reservations .I made a message in order to change the decision of the government that is ro anolish that one ! I do not afree with that and you ?
First of all if the reservations disappear,the americans indians will be scattered in the world.what will result in the loss of their culture and the fear of a living environment they do not know so a rejection or racism from some civilization ! Another , they will have to find a new place so do a long journey with a bad conditions.What a shame !
Is not finished,the state givrs money to the natives american of the reservations he does not donate anymore and so they will become poor better,there is already 2,1 milion who live below the poverty line !
All the end if the reservations will disappear,the commercials echanges will stop.
However,i have a mixed feeling on the one hand,i share the sadness of americans indians because they lost their territories.But on the other hand,i share their hatred for the government.
For conclusion,i hope that this message read and heard. Be human !

# data[].attributes.body
Is it the life of more than five million men, women and children that you are about to abolish?

How can you remove all the construction of a life? We could have, you and I, been in the place of these people today! It is a shameful and horrible act to extinguish this colony and it can only remain on your consciousness throughout your life. The government does not have the right to have such a great influence on the future of the Indian tribes.

Would not your need for money be greater than your humanity?

I think very sincerely that the Amerindian reserves should not be destroyed and that we have already done enough damage like that, that it is high time to let them live peacefully and peacefully.

They have fought for so many years to have the right to respect, freedom, you can not afford to make them live a hell! Trying to imagine their arrival in the city between the eyes of the population, the difficulty of finding a new home ...

We sincerely hope that our association and my message will make you think about it please show us that there is humanity left and that we can get justice!

# data[].attributes.body
Hello everybody, my name is Agathe Clerfayt and I decide to write a word to save and give solutions for Indians. The white mens have no rights on these reservations we have to oppose and resist. First of all, if the Americans take their lands the cattle and all their harvests will not survive. And where go these Indians which shall not have a house anymore ? They are going to be plunged into the nigthmare of the privatisation of care and economy. By wanting to abolish the reservations, the American gouvernment created by the problems which he is supposed to solve and deprive these people of their autonomy. What they are doing is horrible, I do not even dare to imagine the damages which this decision are going to engender. The white mens their have already set too much and imposed too many things. And all this for some gold ? It is inadmissible, it is not human ! Thus now we have to unite and recover who belongs to them. (171 words)

# data[].attributes.body
The American gouvernment would like to abolish Native American reservation !
It’s horrible ! How can he do something like this our Indian friends ?
This subject affects me terribly and I’am absolutely against this idea because , as you know , since generations now , Idians Tribes have not stopped fighting against the white man who was in search of territories and gold. Unfortunately , there are even today Tribes which fight for freedom but also against the poverty. We have for example, the Rine Ridge reservation of South Dakota which beats the most sad record of poverty with disastrous living conditions . If we were to remove what they have love most , among other their land , what would become of them ? They would be distroyed ... More , many more American reject the Indians . So , if they come to settle in cities , racism will only increase !
The gouvernment doesn’t have the right to expel them , because it’s inhumain and pure injustice ! I hope that our association can help the Indians and that the government will reconsider his decision.

# data[].attributes.body
I think the American reservations should not be abolished because when the Europeans come’s to colonize the territory of the Indian tribe they made live to the Indian tribes a horror, which nobody can imagine. These acts of barbarism are inscribed in the history of America and abolish these reservation where the Indians preserve their culture, their education and even their religion would be as if Stir the knife into the wound of these tribes. You know it when the Europeans came to colonize the territories they use so much of barbarism? NO! But it’s the reality I insist on it because they did not hesitate to kill people who was yet innocent, but the tribes being weak and  being able to succumb to this colonization. The Government signed a treaty’s with the tribes so that it remains in their reservations. It’s completely inhuman abolished the reservation it will be an act of humanism. When you think that The Federal Government moved and forced Natives to live on reservations, and know they want to abolish them its very shame.

# data[].attributes.body
Join us to save native Americans !

# data[].attributes.body
Why abolish reservations of native ?
Why destroy home of many persons who were already eject of her living place in the past ?
Why condemn native to live in hell whereas they live in peace ?

I think you want to abolish Native American reservations for expand city and grow business or capitalism . But have you got any conscience of the situation of these pepole if they will obligate to live in other place ? No ! You need to think about this because it’s more important than money .

If Indians are expelled , some of them will live in city , and they will suffer of racism or the lifestyle change . City is a dangerous place for them , they can be ram by cars or do anything who is prohibited because they don’t know laws of the country .

But it’s more important than this , white men had did already things ruthless with the deportation of Native in the XIX century . Take off what’s left would be the same than commit genocide towards them .

Please keep thaith in humanity !