# data[].attributes.body
PLT Groups to plan a lesson/activity that include peer assessment and carry it out. Do take photos of students in action/artefacts

Upload your artefacts in this padlet by T3W10.

Your contribution will be featured in the PD Series Site.

# data[].attributes.body
In groups of 3-4 members

Choose 1 out of the 4 featured examples that does not belong to the subject area of the majority of your members

Demonstrate PQP on the selected example

Upload under your group's selected spotlight column

# data[].attributes.body
Spotlight Selected: Science Dept

Peer Feedback from xxx

Praise: I like that the group used a different strategy that is more applicable to their subject area.

Question: How can differentiation be done for students who are of different levels of readiness in the class?

Polish: Provide students with rubrics or scaffold for the reflect part (emphasize the use of Scientific terms)

# data[].attributes.body
P: Give students an opportunity to critique their peers. There is a benefit to peer assessment because it is an opportunity to develop students' assessment literacy. It provides an opportunity to develop growth mindset and forces students to not only look out for the weaknesses, but to identify strengths. Q: Would this work better if you set up expert groups to focus on specific elements. P: Differentiate by giving groups different pieces to listen to.

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: You are specific about the different aspects students are expected to listen out for --> success criteria is very clear!

Question: How familiar are the students with musical terms? E.g. dynamic balance, what is the model Bunga Sayang melody

Polish: Perhaps provide students with success criteria in the form of a checklist with a score for their PQP. --> so it is clearer which sections in the piece the feedback is referring to

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: Success Criteria is clearly stated

Question: What tools are used to draw the mental maps?

Polish: Maybe can explore using the different ways to draw the mental maps

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: I like that both qualitative and quantitative feedback are taken into account. Also, use of rubrics are very beneficial as a guide for students

Question: How can we allow other peers to visibly see other responses real-time?

Are the rubrics catered to students' level of readiness?

Polish: May want to consider using padlet or google docs.

May want to provide scaffolded rubrics to manage students' expectation.

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: Get students to do critical thinking, and the task is a real world context. Interdisciplinary (Sci, DnT, Eco-Stem)

Question: How good is the students' recommendation? How well-versed are they (eg aircon placement is traditionally the ceiling area, but GBTB aircon is on the floor, chilled water on the ground)

Polish: Bring the students on a LJ to see the different kind of infrastructure or provide videos/documentary.

# data[].attributes.body
Praise:

Use of scaffold (demonstration + modelling)

Question:

How many lesson does this take place? Doing it once might not be enough

Not enough context. For instance, does the teacher insist that the students follow her steps exactly? Are there rooms for creativity (different ways of doing the map)

Polish:

Provide additional resources for students who cannot multi-task, eg, listen, understand while trying to follow teacher's demonstration.

Provide more context for students, eg, purpose of map, when do we usually use it, certain examples, etc.

# data[].attributes.headline
Angeline, Amirah, Mabel, Rou Fang, Sunarti, Raudhah

# data[].attributes.subject
Angeline, Amirah, Mabel, Rou Fang, Sunarti, Raudhah

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: Use of physical tool to visualise complex topic.

Question: Do the rubrics include mathematical terms or language that is simple for students to understand?

Polish: Are there any Edtech tools to help students better visuals 3D structures in trigo?

# data[].attributes.body
Praise: teacher modelling gives a clear successful product

Question: would teacher be guiding the students as they work their map or would the feedback be left till the peer feedback?

Polish: have a session for teacher feedback after the peer feedback.

# data[].attributes.body
Praise:

1. There is a deliberate pairing of groups for feedback so it is not free for all.

2. There is a rubric for students to follow.

Question:

1. Are the students familiar with the peer feedback rubrics?

Polish:

1. Good to give an example of the audio that will match the sample pqp answers.

2. Might be good to give more specific feedback.

# data[].attributes.headline
Shahirah, Haslinda, Ernie, Marcus, Hui Cheng

# data[].attributes.subject
Shahirah, Haslinda, Ernie, Marcus, Hui Cheng

# data[].attributes.body
Praise

Use of same musical terms throughout lesson and in rubrics.

Question

Questions are broad - "which sections are unclear to them?"

Polish

Assign different sections to different groups so all have a role to play while a group is presenting. Group 1 presents, Group 2 to focus on melody, Group 3 to focus on beats, and so on

# data[].attributes.body
Praise : uses peer feedback, teacher demonstrates clearly the elements of success criteria

Question : How does the teacher uses rubrics of the elements of success criteria to do peer feedback? Polish : Teacher to provide clearly how to classify the rubrics for different levels for peer feedback

# data[].attributes.body
Praise

•The activity is simple and relatable for students of all readiness levels.

• It allows the students to be creative and to apply and showcase their skills at communicating their mental schema.

• There is a clear checklist of items to include in the map.

• Success is achievable for everyone.

Question

• What are some of the items that need to be included?

• What is the purpose of this map?

• Who is the target audience of this map?

• How big should this map be and how detailed do we want it to be?

Polish

• Would it be better if more of the boundaries were specified?

• Would it help if the students were brought to observe the area to be mapped?

Would it help if specific materials or tools to be used are specified?

•Would it help to discuss divergent or even conflicting ways of expressing similar ideas of communicating mental schemas visually?