# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough, persistence will help you get through it.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough, persistence will help you get through it.

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is arrested and she persistente when the Taliban beat her and her mother and she keeps yelling for her father.
Liza goes through a tough time when her father dies. She preservers when she thinks of the ocean and plans for a better future.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough, it helps to have hope

Answers: Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is taken by the Taliban

Parvana has hope when she lights a lamp for her father
Liza goes through a tough time when her father is killed by the Taliban
Liza shows that she has hope when she paints happy pictures in her paintings instead of dark ones

# data[].attributes.headline
When going through hard times, persevere 

# data[].attributes.subject
When going through hard times, persevere 

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through hard times when she loses her father

Parvana perseveres when she waits for her father

Aman goes through hard times when he had to herd sheep which were bigger than him

Aman perseveres when he works his way out of herding sheep.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer #1: Parvana goes through a hard time when her father gets arrested and she has no man to get her family food.

Answer #2: Parvana persevered when her job didn't make enough money so she tried to find another job, digging up bones, even though it disturbs Parvana.

Answer #3: Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father died of an illness and she and her family had nobody to get them food and resources.

Answer #4: Liza shows that she has hope when she paints the ocean and tries to think of happiness.

# data[].attributes.headline
A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are though, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are though, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through a tough time when her father gets taken away by the Taliban.
Parvana shows she has hope when she goes out alone and works for her family like her father used to and always stays positive.
Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father dies from illness.
Liza shows that she has hope when she  goes to the ocean for the first time in her life.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: when times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: when times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer: Parvana goes through a tough time when her father gets taken away. Parvana has hope when she tries to light the candle for her father to see. Liza goes through a hard time when her father died when she is only 7. Liza has hope when she paints the ocean

# data[].attributes.headline
A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough it helps to have hope. 

# data[].attributes.subject
A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough it helps to have hope. 

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is taken away and she has to care for her family.
Parvana has hope when the gifts from the person in the window drop.
Similarly, Liza goes through a hard time when her father dies.

Like Parvana, Liza shows that she has hope when she thinks about the ocean.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: Parvana and Liza both go through hard times, but at the end they both have hope

Parvana goes through a rough time when her father goes to jail.

Parvana has hope when she goes to looking for her father.

Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father died

Liza shows she has hope when she thinks about making that painting

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: when times are tough, it helps to have hope

Answer #1: Paravana goes through a hard time when… her father gets taken

Answer #2: Paravana perseveres when...she goes to find her father

Answer #3: similarly, Liza faces a hard time when… her father dies

Answer #4: Liza shows that she has hope when… she draws the ocean

Sincerely,

Anonymous man 🤵🧔🏿

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope

Answers:
1) Parvana goes through a hard time when the Taliban soldiers take her father away
2) Parvana has hope when she dresses as a boy and makes money

# data[].attributes.headline
when times are tough , it helps to have hope

# data[].attributes.subject
when times are tough , it helps to have hope

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through a hard time when her father gets captured.

Parvana has hope when she refuses to go with her because she believed her father would come back.

Liza goes through a hard time when her father dies
Liza crosses to have hope when she paints the ocean

# data[].attributes.headline
When times are tough, it is good to have hope

# data[].attributes.subject
When times are tough, it is good to have hope

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through a hard time when her father goes to jail

Parvana perseveres trying to bring her father back

Liza goes through a hard time when the Taliban take over

Liza has hope when she tries to rebuild and rescue Afghanistan culture

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Answers: Parvana goes through a hard time when her father gets taken away by the Taliban.
Parvana has hope when, at the end of the book she goes with her father to find her family.
Similarly, Liza had a tough time when her father had died just when Liza was just age seven and it was during the Taliban.
Liza also like Parvana has hope when she paints the ocean.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: When times are tough, it is important to have hope.

Answers:

1. Parvana goes through a hard time when the Taliban arrest her father.

2. Parvana is hopeful when she talks with Shauzia about their future.

3. Liza goes through a tough time when her father dies.

4.  Liza is hopeful when she paints the ocean and thinks about her future.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.
Answer 1: Parvana goes through a hard time when the Taliban come and take her father to jail.

Answer 2:  Parvana has hope when she doesn't go with her family to Nooria’s wedding because she has hope that her father will come back.

Answer 3:Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father died.

Answer 4: Liza shows that she has hope when she has hope that she will see the ocean in real life one day.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough, it's important to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough, it's important to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer 1: Parvana goes through tough times when her father is taken to prison
Answer 2: Parvana shows hope when she gets up after finding out her mother and sister might be injured
Answer 3: Liza faces a tough time when her father dies
Answer 4: Liza shows hope when she paints the ocean and thinks of a bright future

# data[].attributes.headline
When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
1.) Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is taken to prison and she has to look after her family.
2.) Parvana has hope when her father and her go looking for the rest of her family.
3.) Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father dies.
4.) Liza chose that she has hope when she paints the ocean.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: When times are tough, it helps to have hope.

Parvana goes through a hard time when her dad gets taken away by the Taliban.

Parvana has hope when her father comes home.

Similarly, Liza faces a hard time when her father dies.

Liza shows she has hope when she paints the ocean.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim:
When faced with a hard time, having hope will help.

Answers:
1. Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is arrested

2. Parvana has hope when she is leaving Kabul to go find her mother, brother, and sisters at the end of the novel.

3. Liza goes though a hard time when her father dies.

4. Liza has hope when she describes how one day she will go to the ocean and paint it.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough, persistence will help you get through it.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough, persistence will help you get through it.

# data[].attributes.body
Answers: Parvana goes through a hard time when her father is arrested and she is persistent when the Taliban beat her and her mother. She yells for her father along for her mother even though it causes great danger for her.

Answers 2: Liza goes through a hard time when her father dies and her family can’t go out and get food without danger. She perseveres when

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough, it helps to have hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer: Parvana has a hard time when her father was taken away, but has hope when he returns. Liza has a hard time when she used to have to do nothing and stay inside all day, but she had hope when she paints the ocean, because there are no obstacles.

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana goes through hard times when she loses her father

Parvana perseveres when she waits for her father to come back

Aman goes through a hard time

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: A theme that is present in both the breadwinner and Aman's story in kids of Kabul when times are tough it's important to persevere.

Claim 1: Parvana has a tough time when her father gets arrested

Claim 2: Parvana has perseveres when her mother is depressed and she has to go out to the market place and fetch water.

Claim 3: Aman goes through a tough time when his family dies.

Claim 4: Aman preservers when he works out of the sheep.

# data[].attributes.headline
A theme that is present in both the breadwinner and Amal's story in kids of Kabul is preserve though  tough times.

# data[].attributes.subject
A theme that is present in both the breadwinner and Amal's story in kids of Kabul is preserve though  tough times.

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana has a tough time when her father gets taken away to prision.
Parvana preservers thought a tough time when she has no man in the house and has to go to the market on her own.

Aman goes though a tough time when the Taliban kill 15 of his family members.
Aman perseveres though a tough time when he lives with his sister in a school and by being a Shepard.