# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, I don't know. I would have to listen to the podcast more. Because both sides could be right, I think he's not guilty because of a faulty lawyer.

# data[].attributes.body
I think this entire case was mishandled by everyone there. the entire case was made off of what high schools said and every day for a high schooler is the same

# data[].attributes.body
I think it's frustrating that Asia didn't come foward earlier, because if she did then Adnan wouldn't be spending his life in jail. What I don't understand is how Jay isn't in trouble? I mean the story he told the police, didn't he incriminate himself? Adnan is spending a life sentence in prison over a case without a single piece of concrete evidence?

# data[].attributes.body
I think Adnan is guilty, I was listening closely and he really doesn’t sound to sincere about the situation. I personally think he is trying to manipulate his way out of Prison.

# data[].attributes.body
Hard to say really, a lot has been brought up within the 50 minutes we've listened. And frankly, there's a lot of information that could or could not have happened for both sides. The only issue is the fact that absolutely nothing is concrete. Most of it is entirely backed up by only a single witness. Jay on the prosecution, and Asia for defense. My opinion on the matter tells me that I cannot form an objective opinion on whether or not the prosecuted is truly innocent or guilty. Therefore, I find it most appropriate to hold off on making such quick opinions until further information to properly base an opinion of arise.

# data[].attributes.body
He's guilty because he know a lot of details for a high person and his story changes a lot.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that he is innocent. My three main reasons for my belief are: one, there was absolutely no physical evidence that can link him to the murder. Two, while Jay's story was (suspiciously) detailed, his reputation doesn't make him seem like a very trustable source. Three, Asia was able to positively place him at the library during the exact time at which the murder took place. I find it unsettling how Asia didn't come forward sooner. I get not wanting to be involved, but she should have testified her information, rather than contradicting her statement. Her testimony could have saved Adnon from 15 years of prison time.

# data[].attributes.body
He's innocent, I think he was set up by jay. Jay created a false story to cover up what he did.

# data[].attributes.body
He seems to know a lot more details that a drug dealer who smoked a lot should remember from something that happened 15 years prior

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Jay told a false story and that there is a good chance that he is actually innocent.

# data[].attributes.body
So far, with the evidence shown, I believe Adnan is innocent. I know in order for someone to remember specific events something important must happen, that's why Adnan couldn't really remember anything becuase like he said"it was just another normal day." The fact that Jay could recite every specific detail of that day while also smoking weed doesn't make sense to me. Also Asia remembers the day because of the events that happened to her that day, she had to spend multiple hours at the library which made her angry. It caused a lot of strong emotions that helped her remember. She's Adnan's alibi but was never mentioned in the case.

# data[].attributes.body
I think he is innocent. He was a great student in high school with no reason to kill anybody. His girlfriend broke up with him but he says in the podcast that he never had a reason to hate her or no reason to kill her. They also used Jay's story to convict him but the podcast says he is the high school drug dealer. I also think Asia should have come forward sooner and looked into the case, she thought they proved he did it so she backed out which did not help Adnan. Also from Jay's story he says he helped Adnan bury the body, so how is not not in any trouble?

# data[].attributes.headline
                                       Saucedo 1/23                           High school student live is been going the same that everyone wouldn't have to remember specific dates, maybe they didn't even want to remember does days.  I feel like everybody needs to make conscience on every action they make.   

# data[].attributes.subject
                                       Saucedo 1/23                           High school student live is been going the same that everyone wouldn't have to remember specific dates, maybe they didn't even want to remember does days.  I feel like everybody needs to make conscience on every action they make.   

# data[].attributes.body
I think that Adnan is probably guilty even with Asia's testimony. making high schoolers remember where they were and Adnan remembering most of his day is kinda crazy. Also the fact that he didn't sound even remotely sound any different with his speech after figuring out about Asia was upholding her letters saying they were true is wierd.

# data[].attributes.body
What if Jay killed Hae to put Adnon in prison because he was jealous of how close he was to Stephanie???? It's a little interesting how McClain can testify to what happened that night but Jay had a completely different story that was based on hearsay 🧐🧐🧐

# data[].attributes.body
Adnan seems to be innocent, there is no physical evidence and Asia seems to have a good alibi for him. Jay seems suspicious, his story makes it sound like he could be covering for himself.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Adnan is innocent because if what Asia is saying is true and he truly was in the library then it couldn't have been him. But at the same time it's really hard to know who's lying because at the end of the day they were all just highschoolers at the time and it's not the best idea to rely on highschoolers for a murder case.

# data[].attributes.body
Asia has an alibi for adnan. Jay seems odd.

# data[].attributes.body
I noticed that during Jay's interrogation, he hesitated a lot. Which made me think that his story isn't 100% true. I think that Adnan's voice seemed very genuine, but that could also just be a good act. But as we know, there is no concrete evidence so I'm not fully on one side or another. If I had to guess based on what I know already, I would guess that Adnan is innocent. I believe that Asia is telling the truth but I also think some of the things she said in her letter were a little odd and it seemed to be planned. Another thought is, that there was nothing left behind from the murder so this person had to be smart. I don't think this is something a drug dealer could pull off. And since we know Adnan smoked and stuff too, he might not be the smartest either. I'm not sure. But I wouldn't be surprised if Stephanie was the one who did it. She could've been jealous of Hae and Adnan's relationship.

# data[].attributes.body
Episode 2

1/25

I think that he may not be guilty of the murder but the whole where his car was and if he was getting a ride which is very confusing why start telling two cops two different stories when witnesses claim something else.

# data[].attributes.body
I still stand with my opinion that he is innocent. Nothing really stood out to me that would make me change my mind. He took the breakups like a normal high school student would and all of his classmates would agree. That makes me believe more that he is innocent.

# data[].attributes.body
Overall, my stance on the matter has not been swayed really. More information has certainly been brought to light, but the question is if this is fully concrete. Which personally, I do not find as such. I still find myself generally apprehensive of taking a stance. The entire thing that will crack this case open is finding out precisely what Adnan was doing those twenty-one minutes.

# data[].attributes.body
I’m starting to think he is not guilty and Jay has something to do with the

Murder his story made a lot of sense but none at a the same time . This Episode is kinda leading me towards Adnan being Not guilty .

# data[].attributes.body
After listening to this episode I think the fact that Adnan told one cop he did ask Hay for a ride but then told the next cop he didn't ask for a ride is a red flag. My first thoughts were why would he tell the cop that he did ask for a ride if he didn't need a ride in the first place? But I still believe Adnan is innocent.

# data[].attributes.body
I still believe Adnan is innocent and that Jay killed her. Everybody seems to agree with Adnan and his story. The only person to disagree and switch the story was Jay. I feel like Jay was seriously jealous of Adnan. Everyone seemed to like Adnan, Jay must've felt some type of way about that. I think Jay wanted what Adnan had.

# data[].attributes.body
Episode2: After listening to the second episode, my opinion still stands. I believe that Adnan is innocent. I do wonder where Adnan's car was though. Was the car in the shop? Was the car with Jay? I would also question why Adnan's story would be changing. Does he just not remember, or is it because he is guilty and doesn't want to get caught up?

# data[].attributes.body
My opinion of Adnan's innocence remains unchanged. There were many factors that play into his unfair imprisonment, such as: inconvenient line up of evidence, people's lack of ability to remember the events, and a bad lawyer, etc. Although there was undoubtedly more evidence brought up about this case in this episode, I still do not think Adnan is guilty. My belief that Jay is the real suspect still stands. The only questions I really have are-- one: Where was he for those 21 miniutes? And two: Was his contradiction regarding the car ride simply a slip up due to faulty memory, or is there something more to it?

# data[].attributes.body
My thoughts still stay the same about Adnan being innocent but him telling cops different things and him changing the story is a little suspicious, it could be because he forgot but how could he forget stuff he was doing on the day that someone he cared about died.

# data[].attributes.body
Episode 2:In my opinion, I think Adnan is innocent, but when he told a different story to the cops, it's a red flag. However, maybe he doesn't remember exactly how it happened. I still believe he's innocent.

# data[].attributes.body
My opinion still stands, I believe Adnan is guilty. The only thing that bugs me is why in the world did he lie to one of the cops? I think Jay is a very suspicious character, and im not sure why he wasn't looked into more?

# data[].attributes.body
i feel like this episode hasnt changed my mind at all everything still doesnt add up and i dont think adnan is guilty. still someone needs to prove why jay is credible at all

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that Adnan is either lying or believes one. I also believe that Jay is lying but how many things he's lied about is something I don't have a clue about. I also don't believe that Adnan murdered Hae because his motive is less clear than before.

# data[].attributes.body
I still think adnan is innocent

# data[].attributes.body
Episode 3

I think that Jay did it but that MR S was apart of it but only to move the the eyes away from Jay because then someone found it and we know that Jay does drugs and that Mr S does some questionable things enough to seem like it's not just drinks making him act like that.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Mr. S is a very weird addition to this story. I mean, it's obvious this guy's a werido but what kind of motive would he have to kill Hae? The suspect I keep thinking back to is Jay.

# data[].attributes.body
With the introduction of Mr.S, I'm beginning to actually form my opinion that something just doesn't make sense from the perspective of Jay and him. Of course Hindsight is 20/20 and I don't wanna jump the gun too soon.

# data[].attributes.body
Mr. S seems sketchy to me. He is kind of an alcoholic and has been convicted prior to this crime. Also the park is over an hour from Adnan and the time frames don't add up. But I think Mr. S had to be looking for the body, in my mind there is no way he just stumbles upon the body when a professional couldn't even spot the body.

# data[].attributes.body
that dude mr s is an interesting fellow for sure. gives me the heebie-jeebies.

why is he at the crime scene? how did he find it so easily when someone else who was trained to find it couldn't??? he's a sketchy dude.

I still think that Jay did it, but I think that Mr. S may have been an accomplice.

# data[].attributes.body
I feel like jay very much did it and Mr S is wierd i dont know that mr s would have any reason to kill hae i still think jay did it

# data[].attributes.body
Mr.S is a creep but I don't think he did it. I think this episode was just for a bit of comic relief and just to make fun of the guy

# data[].attributes.body
I personally don't believe that Mr. S is the murderer just that his connections to the case are very coincidental. I do believe that if he is tied to the case that it would be through the actual murderer.

# data[].attributes.body
The detectives are suspicious of Mr. S because he story seems off. They question why he needed to suddenly go to the bathroom even though he had just left his house. On top of that, to stop and take a quick leak he traveled farther into the woods than they would've expected. To me Mr. S seems suspicious but there is not enough evidence to say whether I think he did it or not. So yes, he does sway my opinion about Adnan's guilt. It is just coincidental that Mr. S was able to find her body.

# data[].attributes.body
I still believe that jay was the one to kill her. Now, it looks like Mr. S is one of Jay's friends, who is trying to help cleanup his story. Maybe Mr. S helped Jay??? I believe they are guilty and sent up Adnan.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Mr. S is directly involved with the murder, but I do think that he knew where the body was. With the detail provided, it seems like the body was nearly impossible to spot. I think he may have heard about the body from someone else, or he was loosely involved, but I do not think he did it.

# data[].attributes.body
I have no idea who could have killed her, In my opinion the evidence was scare so I couldn't blame anyone.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Mr. S killed her, but it's a bit suspicious how he easily found the body when the detectives couldn't. I think he didn't kill her, but he might be an accomplice to Jay and helping to cover up their crime.

# data[].attributes.body
I think the detectives wanted to get the case over with quickly because it involved a young girl and they didn't want people to get scared. I also think Mr. S might have done it for the fact that you would have to walk in a certain way and direction to find the way and if he didn't the why did he fail the polygraph test. I think Mr. s and Jay killed her and don't want anyone to know.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Mr. S did it because the way Sarah and the other reporters said that how far back he had walked would still be reasonable to go pee because you could still see cars clearly. The fact that he did see the body when the surveyor knew where the body was and still couldn't see it is kind of suspicious. Maybe he's linked somehow but if this is the only time we hear of him probably not.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Mr. S is really suspicious. His story just doesn't make sense to me. Why didn't he just walk like two feet into the woods to go pee? And why couldn't he just hold it and drive home or to a gas station? And it's suspicious that he didn't have to go pee 7 minutes before. I don't think he did it but I want to know why he was out there looking for the body.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Mr.S is not guilty but he is really suspicious and weird because he might be the only person to go out naked and pee and it'sa kind've odd that he stumbled open the body. Detectives are suspicious of him because of his back round and how he found the body.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think Mr.s did it. Just think he's odd

# data[].attributes.body
Another case of an episode throwing me for a loop, a lot of things just line up for both parties to the point where it really confuses me on who really could be behind the operation. Still confused at this point in time but I suppose more will be revealed eventually to tie up these loose ends.

# data[].attributes.body
This whole episode confused me and didn't necessarily persuade me to one side or the other. I think it is kinda sus that they only used 4/15 of the towers though.

# data[].attributes.body
I still don't believe jay to be completely innocent, but I can understand small inconsistencies due to the fact hes trying to recall every detail from 1 particular day 6 weeks ago. The cell tower pinging Adnans phone at the park is not looking good.. this episode didn't completely sway me one way or the other.

# data[].attributes.body
I still believe that Adnan was set up and is innocent until proven guilty. Jay's story doesn't match up and he keeps changing details every time. Jay seems like he has something to hide. He isn't a good liar, and seems very suspicious to me.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Mr.S knows something that he doesn't want to say there is just a lot of suspicious activity during this series I'm excited to see how it's going to play out.

# data[].attributes.body
This episode didn't really sway me one way or the other, it kind of just confused me. There are still a lot of holes in both stories. I am still going to say Adnan is innocent. They only used 4/15 cell towers. And they tested the time it took to get to best buy right out of school, I don't think Hey was strangled in less than three minutes and put into the trunk in less than 3 minutes.

# data[].attributes.body
This episode just has me confused, but I still believe Adnan is innocent. However, I don't think Jay is innocent. This episode didn't make me change my opinion about Adnan.

# data[].attributes.body
this episode didnt really change my opinion at all. it left me confused ngl. my opinion on adnan hasnt changed

# data[].attributes.body
This episode had a lot of twist and turns its a little confusing when both sides kind of sound real but Its just a lot to process and think about . I think adnan is innocent because of the tone and the way he is explaining and I just get a weird vibe from Jay.

# data[].attributes.body
Im still pretty confused but if anything it just keeps on showing me the inconsistencies that Jay has with his story. I still believe Jay has something to do with this but every episode just keeps on looking like they have more to blame on Adnan. It's kind've crazy to me how the police officers didn't interview more students who were at track practice.

# data[].attributes.body
I was not swayed one way or the other. I am not completely caught on with the timeline. There were so many calls and it confuses me a little bit. I do not believe that Adnan would've had enough time to get from the school to best buy and kill her in that 21 minutes. The only thing I would question is if the phone call would've been made before the murder, would Adnan have had time to kill her while Jay was supposed to be on his way? Jay just makes me suspicious. I feel like if he didn't play a part with Adnan, Jay was the one that killed her.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the map timeline is not adding up for the fact that after the murder Adnan had track practice at 4 but Jay said they went somewhere at 4:16 and by the time Jay could have dropped Adnan off for tack the coach and everyone would have noticed because he would have been really late.

# data[].attributes.body
Its getting confused, Jay is the only one I don't trust but at the same time i do.

Adnan has to be innocent there is nothing concrete about him that we can use to prove that he is the criminal in this case.

# data[].attributes.body
Episode 5 - Route Talk

I think Jay still did the murder I think he's putting the blame on his "Best friend" when all they did was smoke together but how he talks about the case is like he's leaving out information that could be useful but could also point the murder onto Jay

# data[].attributes.body
I think Jay is trying to frame adnan.

# data[].attributes.body
One of the pieces of evidence that makes me question a lot of Adnan's innocence is his remarks about not attempting to contact her after her disappearance. He states that he never would've spoken to her and just only gotten information from his friends who were a lot closer to her. Despite this however, there were three recorded calls coming from Adnan to her the previous night, before the disappearance. Which simply didn't line up with the logic behind his statement, it feels so incredibly inconsistent.

# data[].attributes.body
Not paging her after the missing report is strange and shady because he didn't desire to find her even if he wasn't the best friend. He just stopped paging her after those three times. He stated nothing that he was not paging he repeatedly in when she went "missing" because Haes's friends were telling him updates and information.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that while it is somewhat suspicious, its not super surprising that Adnan would want to cut contact with his ex lover. In terms of Kathy's story, I do think its strange how Jay seemed to be acting so agitated, but Adnan was just acting high, and Adnan picked up the phone even after apparently being "warned" that the police were gonna call and question him. This is strange because why would Adnan pick up the phone if he was warned about being called and questioned by the police?

# data[].attributes.body
I stand by my recent points. I still believe that Jay was, or was involved with the real killer. He lied and changed his story constantly, which makes his alibi seem very unstable

# data[].attributes.body
I think it is strange that Adnan called Hay 3 times the night before her disappearance then not at all afterwards. I can understand that Adnan wouldn't want to talk to his ex though. The fact that one of the girls said Jay was at the store he worked at when she got the call but he wasn't employed at that time is suspicious and doesn't make sense. Adnan being weird about getting a call that a cop was going to call him doesn't seem that odd to me because he was high so his response can be justified. The fact that Adnan friend zoned Sarah and said she didn't really know him doesn't stick out to me because I agree with Adnan, I don't think you can really know someone by just talking over the phone for awhile.

# data[].attributes.body
I think the reason why Adnan didn't call Hay after he called her 3 times the day she disappeared is because he's friends with Hay's best friends so if she's not answering them why would she answer me like that would be weird if she did because like he's her ex.

# data[].attributes.body
As the episodes go on i start to believe that Adnan is the killer. He is becoming more and more suspicious, no story is adding up. I want to believe that he got set up but i have a feeling that more than one person did it. One thing that sticks out to me is how he was blowing up her phone the night before the incident. Meanwhile, the day of the accident he simply didn't care anymore.

# data[].attributes.body
One of the pieces of evidence that does confuse me is the one about him calling her three times the night before she went missing and then not attempting to call her after that. It would make me question whether or not he knows anything about her disappearance. What I would use to "justify" this piece of evidence would be the fact that he was in the loop with her friends, why would he feel the need to try and reach out if no one else could get ahold of her? It is a little suspicious. The interaction with Kathy also throws me off a little. I could understand why he would be nervous to talk to the cops though. He was super high which would affect how he was handling the situation and how he was processing everything.

# data[].attributes.body
The standout piece of evidence from this episode to me was that he called Hae 3 times the night before she disappeared, and then 0 times after. Also Kathys story of someone calling Adnan warning him about a police call would imply there was a third person involved. if Jay took a plea deal for no/minimal charges in exchange for all the information he has about the murder, he would've said something about another person.

# data[].attributes.body
If Adnan is the one who was calling then I don't think he knew what was happening, But its confused because after her disappearance so it may be just a play smart of Adnan, we don't know yet.

# data[].attributes.body
I think it's respectable to know that Adnan would want to cut contact with his ex but the way he called her 3 times the day before her disappearance and never contacted her again is very odd. I think as the episodes go Adnan just keeps on being more guilty. There's a lot of coincidences in this story and if those coincidences were figured out then I think we would know who the killer is.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Adnan is guilty almost 90% sure because story and allegations from other people are sounding to true. The situation with jay is very confusing, there is a lot of twist and turns.

# data[].attributes.body
When the episodes began I believed that Adnan was innocent but as we progress each time Adnan seems more guilty and if he continues like this we will know who is really guilty of the murder.

# data[].attributes.body
I think what Deirdre makes sense, you don't get lucky with a charming psychopath. I have more respect for Jay after this episode because of the way he handled being yelled at in the court room and keeping his composure, especially not having any family to back him up. I also think if Jay had done it he wouldn't have even talked to Sarah let alone allow them to come inside and talk about the situation. This makes me lean more towards Adnan being guilty but there's just so many facts that don't make sense and don't add up to me I can't be sure.

# data[].attributes.body
I was shocked that Koenig went to Jays house, and I'm surprised by everyone's description of him. this episode helped me to see Jay as more of a real person, instead of just a character the police got all this information from. He handled getting screamed at in court very well, and he has a little bit more credibility in my mind now. I thought I was sure that Adnan was innocent, but as these episodes progress I'm not so sure anymore.

# data[].attributes.body
I still think Jay did it and ep 2 the break up shows that Adnan was not a bad person. He was over Hae and was going on with life. He didn't have a motive to kill Hae. The only thing that stuck out was how he might have lied about asking Hae for a ride.

# data[].attributes.body
ep 10

I thought the court case and adnon lawyer with the problems she has caused in the past even if she did really try it wasn't something she was able to do like the podcast said she had to many cases and as well as Jay having a lawyer giving to him by state.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that jay did it and the cops are covering up for him. They don't have enough evidence so they are just believing whatever is being told. They are setting up Adnan. They gave him a lawyer when he was their witness.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think that the reason Adnan was convicted is because he's muslim like his mom thinks, and I think it's interesting that gutierrez's whole defense was to try and make other people look suspicious. I think it's true that the police are ignoring other key witnesses (Jay) simply because he provided them with the story. I've never heard of a conviction being made without any physical evidence before..

# data[].attributes.body
I think the fact that the cops helped Jay get an attorney just proves that they were trying to help him out so they could wrap up their story. I also don't like Adnan's attorney because of the past cases she's done where she was taking advantage of the families money for herself, like she did with Adnan's parents. I feel like if Adnan had gotten a better attorney then the whole case could've gone the other way.

# data[].attributes.body
Adnan's attorney taking advantage of other families makes me suspicious. It seems like she was going through something throughout Adnan's trial. She really was not doing a great job at helping Adnan's case. Her main focus was to point the murder to someone else. She should've been defending him and really pushing evidence to support his innocence. I was shocked when I heard that Jay was given a lawyer by the prosecutor. It seems as though Jays testimony could've been altered to fit what the prosecutors wanted. There is a large possibility that Jay was working with the detectives etc and saying what they wanted to hear. Jay and the prosecutors make me feel uneasy when it comes to this case.

# data[].attributes.body
I really find the fact that the police department confided in the case to help individuals like Jay get an attorney just feels incredibly unfair and like something us going on underneath the surface. Including the fact of how abhorrently awful Adnan's attorney is, with her completely taking advantage of him in his vulnerable state. It just doesn't feel right.

# data[].attributes.body
The case was deffenetly misshandled and should've been a misstrial and redone. There were a tun of different angles the detectives and prosecutors could have looked through but the got the easyest and just pushed for that.