# data[].attributes.body
In this chapter Winston feels excited by meeting O'Brien, because he thinks that O'Brien will help him reveal against the government. Winston feels fine by meeting O'Brien by having him also reveal against the government what Winston don't realizes is that this might be a party by the government in order to catch them in what they are doing. But Winston feels secure because he is also a member of the brotherhood. this makes feel secure but they don't know will happen in the future and if this will give them problems. By having more members in the brotherhood they will have the more reasons and people in order to reveal against the government.

# data[].attributes.body
Winston was very excited to meet O’Brien. He thinks that this this is a new hope that he has in order to rebel against Big Brother. This might be a trap that the government is doing to Winston. At first he thought that O’Brien worked with BB. When he told Winston that he was part of the brotherhood, he had hope again. He was excited to meet him, even though that might cause him problems in the future. He is still doing things that goes against what BB tell them to do.i think that they will rebel soon.

# data[].attributes.headline
O’Brien challenges things Winston previously thought by committing thought crime. Winston already had the idea that O’Brien might be like him, against BB, but he wasn’t quite sure. Now, his suspicions have grown because O’Brien talks to him about Syme, the Newspeak expert who has been vanished. BB has strictly decided that talking about vanished people is breaking the law. I think Winston is just desperate to believe in O’Brien because he is willing to die, in hands of the Ministry of Truth, in order to talk with him. I think the reason for this has to do with Julia, because he’s willing to risk everything in order to have a slight possibility for him and Julia to be together. I think Winston feels with more power, since he has committing rebellious acts for a long time now and he hasn’t been caught. Because he hasn’t been caught before he’s hoping he won’t be caught this time too. I think Winston is going to die, he’s going too far against BB and O’Brien could change everything, either by helping o by turning Winston in.

# data[].attributes.subject
O’Brien challenges things Winston previously thought by committing thought crime. Winston already had the idea that O’Brien might be like him, against BB, but he wasn’t quite sure. Now, his suspicions have grown because O’Brien talks to him about Syme, the Newspeak expert who has been vanished. BB has strictly decided that talking about vanished people is breaking the law. I think Winston is just desperate to believe in O’Brien because he is willing to die, in hands of the Ministry of Truth, in order to talk with him. I think the reason for this has to do with Julia, because he’s willing to risk everything in order to have a slight possibility for him and Julia to be together. I think Winston feels with more power, since he has committing rebellious acts for a long time now and he hasn’t been caught. Because he hasn’t been caught before he’s hoping he won’t be caught this time too. I think Winston is going to die, he’s going too far against BB and O’Brien could change everything, either by helping o by turning Winston in.

# data[].attributes.body
Angie Zuniga

# data[].attributes.body
·         How does O’Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see O’Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

Obrien challenge things about the previously thought of Winston are an act of rebellion of Big Brother. Winston thinks that he is against Obrien is like a competition each other. So big brother has much power than Winston so need to have another ways to be against him. Obrien tells brotherhood exists but Winston thinks that was a lie he doesn’t believe to Obrien.  Then Obrien told to Winston that wil gave him a dictionary. I think Winston want to believe that brotherhood exist because he could be more powerful than the government. Yeah I think Winston has fate to Obrien because he will have a new change. He could have more opportunities if brotherhood rebels against big brother. Winston wants to believe on Obrien but I think he have suspicious to believe in him

# data[].attributes.body
O'brien started talking to Winston out of nowhere. He also mentioned a man who is already dead (erased), so Winston started thinking of how all this can be a code word for something. Then, in front of a telescreen, O'brien wrote down his own address and ripped it out and gave it to Winston. Winston thought that this he was challenging BB by doing this. Winston is doubting whether this is real and he is being summoned to fight BB together. I think WInston wants to desperately believe in O'brien because since the first day he saw him, Winston felt a connection with O'Brien.Winston believes this is his fate. He knows this rebellion will bring death to them in Ministry of Love anytime soon. Winston is aware of all this and he still going with it.

# data[].attributes.body
Winston thinks O'Brien is on his side at first because he believes he is against big brother. Winston wants to believe him because he need to thinks there is more ways to defeating big brother than what he knows. Obrien made Winston think the brotherhood still exists. He thinks that by doing small acts of rebellion he will defeat big brother

# data[].attributes.body
Firstly Winston thought that O'Brien was on BB's side. O'Brien told Winston he was part of the Brotherhood. Winston decided to desperately believed in O'Brien's words, because Winston is obsessed with a rebellion. He thinks that the brotherhood is the most efficient way to rebel. Winston thinks that this brotherhood has a lot of power, since his little acts of rebellion don't take him forward. In my opinion, if a brotherhood exists they shall be in secret and have a lot of member with power. Power to defeat the government, this is what Winston thinks of them. Winston thinks this is his faith to follow O'Brien's word and continue what he started before. Since everything is secret, they discuss a topic. They where talking about, the tenth edition of Newspeak, O'Brien invited Winston to visit him later during the noon. This might be a bigger meeting for new ideas.

# data[].attributes.body
When Winston met O'Brien he has the doubt, if O'Brien is in his side or he is with BB. Winston thought that they can beat BB, the little problem is that BB has a lot of power and it will be not difficult for BB to know who is going against him. Winston is trusting in O'Brien, and thinking that brotherhood still exists, but Winston don't know if O'Brien is telling the truth or not, but he wants to because he wants more ways of fighting against the government. All Winston faith is on O'Brien, this is Winston's fate because he started with the idea of defeating BB and he will not be quiet until he achieve it.

# data[].attributes.headline
How does O’Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see O’Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

# data[].attributes.subject
How does O’Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see O’Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

# data[].attributes.body
Winston thought that O'Brien was on his side. Winston thought that the way to rebel against BB was by little acts of rebellion but this is very difficult becuase BB is very powerfull. O'Brien said that the Brotherhood exists, and Winston does not know wether to believe him or not. I think that the only reason why Winston is considering to believe O'Brien is because he thought that if the Brotherhhod existed it had more power than the government. So, the Brotherhood would be a very good option to rebel against BB. They were talking about the Newspeak and O'Brien told Winston that he would gave him a dictionary. I think that rebelling against BB became like an obsession to Winston because he thinks that everything that happens to him can be used against BB. This can cause him trouble because it would be easy to set him a trap. Now, Winston's faith relies on O'Brein.

# data[].attributes.body
First, Winston try to take Big Brother out of the power by doing little acts of rebellion against him. Then he meet O'Brien and he thought that he was on his side. He thought the O'Brien knows the way how to defeat the government. Winston starts believing on him. He was not thinking in what can pass to him or what changes can happen to his plan, but he is desperate to know the way to defeat Big Brother.
O'Brien and Winston start talking about the 10th edition of the newspeak dictionary. Then O'Brien gave him a copy of the dictionary. I think there is fate and that Winston is depending on what O'Brien does, he is waiting to the right moment and then he can follow every step that O'Brien does in order to defeat BB.

# data[].attributes.headline
Chapter 6-   8th Discussion Prompt:  How does O’Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see O’Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

# data[].attributes.subject
Chapter 6-   8th Discussion Prompt:  How does O’Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see O’Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

# data[].attributes.body
O'Brien challenge Winston to rebel against the government. Winston is watching that O'Brien was doing small acts that will make other people follow him and rebel against the big brother. Winston just wants to believe in O'Brien because he talks in secret messages and they talk about newspapers and things they are doing against the government. O'Brien knows things that Winston doesn't know so this makes Winston follow him. Winston is walking to dead because rebelling the government is really dangerous. This is fate because believing in other person you don't know is fate because this could take you to death but Winston doen't care. He wants to live a sign of life and rebellion against the government.

# data[].attributes.body
Winston think that O'Brien was against the BB, when he meet him he think that he will help him to be against the BB. Winston want to do some acts against BB, he think that this will be a great act of rebellion. O’Brien discusses with Winston the tenth edition of the Newspeak dictionary, and tells him that he can take a peek at it if he makes a visit one evening.I think that they talk about this like a secret things, secret messages. I think that Winston is doing this to defeat BB and he will not stop until they finish with this. Winston is doing great thinks against BB.-Hector

# data[].attributes.body
Winston always thought O'Brien was like him, against Big Brotherr. At first Winston thought that by rebelling in small acts they would take BB down. He always thought the Brotherhood could overpower the government, but he never saw signs of it. This act by O'Brien lights a fire in Winston who wants to believe that there is a way to go against Big Brother.  O'Brien communicates in a sevret way, by coded messages like the reference to Syme. They talk about Newspeak and the new dictionary, this might be a way to pass secret information. I don't believe there is fate, but I do think Winston believes this is his. He sees himself walking to a certain death, which I think will happen later on the book, and this is why he believes the has to leave some kind of legacy

# data[].attributes.body
Since the first day that Winston saw O’Brien he thought that he was on his side. Winston thought that they could “beat” BB by doing rebellious acts, but he also knows that it is difficult because the he has a lot of power. O’Brien makes Winston believe that the Brotherhood still exists. I think Winston is not sure of whether O’Brien is telling the truth or not, but he wants to believe on him because he is really desperate to find more ways to rebel against BB and expose the truth. O’Brien and Winston were talking about the Newspeak, and then he tells Winston he would give him a dictionary. Maybe there is a hint in it that tells a way to defeat the government. I think all of this is Winston’s fate. Since he started to do rebellious acts he can’t stop and he will continue doing them until it comes the time to defeat BB. His faith is on O’Brien and he is waiting for him to do the first move and then follow him.

# data[].attributes.body
At first winston thinks that he can defeat big brother just by making random and little acts of rebellion but he realize that he cant. O’Brien discusses with Winston the tenth edition of the Newspeak dictionary, and tells him that he can take a look at it if he makes a visit one evening.  Winston feels confortable with regards to the conspiracy that he has dreamed of. He feels that this event is a continuation of what he started with the diary and then with his affair with Julia. Yet he still accepts that it will eventually lead to death at the Ministry of Love.  O'Brien is changing Winston's thoughts about Big Brother because he proved that brotherhood is a thing. Winston thinks that he will be joining a true rebellion to the party. I think it could be his fate because was always following what Big Brother says.

# data[].attributes.body
How does O Brien challenge things Winston previously thought/ assumed about big brother? How does he cause Winston to doubt himself? Does Winston believe him or just desperately want to believe him? Do you think he believes this is his fate, or is his choice to see  O Brien something Winston feels he can control at this point?

O Brian challenge Winston  since the beginning cause Winston thought they were together to beat big brother. Winston started believing that brotherhood will make him go down and that they could rebel against BB together. I don't think Winston really believes in O Brien but I think that he prefers to believe on it because is the only way he has hope with the idea of BB going down. I do think he has faith in O Brian and that he is just waiting on other way to rebel  against government and Big Brother.

With this I can say we know that two minds think better than one and that it is harder to beat a group than a person itself so maybe this is what makes Winston faith and hope bigger.

# data[].attributes.body
Before meeting O'Brien, Winston thought Big Brother could be outrooted with random acts of rebellion. Now, he understands this is not the way to Big Brother's unmasking. There is someway to effectively attack the government, and O'Brien knows it. Winston doesn't know it, but desperately wants to, which results in a desperate desire to believe O'Brien. This is his fate, he knows he can't control his life from now on. He decided to jump into a river with his first rebellious thoughts, now there is no other way to remain alive but to let the stream carry him. Any spark of intention to doubt his purpose and try to escape his fate, will result in death, not only his but also Julia's. Winston has to remain strong at the same time he lets the consequences of his decisions carry him to: "His Ultimate Goall" -whatever it may be.

# data[].attributes.body
O'Brien got Winston to believe that brotherhood is still a thing, he challenged Winston's thoughts on Big Brother because he showed that the brotherhood still has a say in things. Winston really wants to believe what O'Brien is saying, but he's not sure if he's telling the truth. I believe that Winston just wants to desperately believe in something that will give him hope in the future, that way he won't believe that he has believed in something fake for such a long time. O'Brien will give him the dictionary and he suspects to find a hidden note or message in it. Winston’s hope lies in O’Brien, he thinks this is his fate. Winston also believes this might lead him to death but he has followed the idea of making a rebellion and defeat BB for so long and now it’s time to make his words turn into action. I believe that Winston puts all of his faith in O'Brien to create a future where he can be himself and live a normal life with Julia.