# data[].attributes.body
Activity Title: "From Prompt to Pen: The Human Core"

How it works: Students ask an AI tool to write a short autobiographical paragraph or a creative reflection on a personal memory (e.g., a memorable summer day or a moment of overcoming a fear). Naturally, the AI will produce a generic, cliché-rich text. The core task of the student is to take that sterile AI draft, strip out the generic phrasing, and rewrite it by injecting their own sensory details, unique memories, and genuine emotional voice.

Why it works: It clearly demonstrates the boundary between automated text generation and authentic human expression. It teaches students that AI can build a basic foundation or skeleton, but only human experience and introspection can give writing a true soul.

Dott.ssa Maria Pia Cirolla

# data[].attributes.body
Activity Title: "Defend Against the Algorithm"

How it works: Working in small groups, students ask an AI tool to argue in favor of a controversial thesis (e.g., "Technology makes us more isolated"). The group must analyze the AI-generated arguments, identify logical weaknesses, and prepare a live debate to either refute them or defend them using their own original arguments.

Why it works: It trains rhetoric, critical analysis, and prevents the passive use of the tool by forcing students to actively challenge and evaluate machine output.

Dott.ssa Maria Pia Cirolla

# data[].attributes.body
Ricerca (Research)

Sono d'accordo con: Definizioni o spiegazioni di un concetto. L'intelligenza artificiale funziona come un ottimo glossario interattivo, utile per semplificare concetti complessi e offrire un punto di partenza per l'approfondimento.

Non sono d'accordo con: Dare risposte dirette a una domanda dei compiti. Fornire la risposta secca elimina lo sforzo cognitivo e impedisce allo studente di sviluppare il proprio pensiero critico.

Dott.ssa Maria Pia Cirolla

# data[].attributes.body
"AI will never replace teachers."

Artificial Intelligence can efficiently handle repetitive tasks, generate lesson plans, and personalize study paths, acting as a powerful co-pilot. However, education goes far beyond the mere transfer of information.

Teaching requires genuine empathy, emotional intelligence, moral guidance, and the ability to inspire critical thinking—qualities exclusive to humans. An algorithm can explain what a concept is, but only a teacher in the classroom can nurture a student's soul, manage complex social dynamics, and teach respect. AI will not replace teachers; rather, teachers who use AI will replace those who do not.

Dott.ssa Maria Pia Cirolla

# data[].attributes.body
L'Intelligenza Artificiale e il Ruolo del Docente: Alleati, non Rivali

L'introduzione dell'Intelligenza Artificiale nel mondo della scuola e della formazione viene spesso accolta con un misto di entusiasmo salvifico e timore reverenziale. Si teme che gli algoritmi possano un giorno sostituire l'insegnante in cattedra. La realtà, soprattutto quando parliamo di educazione complessa, prevenzione e crescita emotiva, è profondamente diversa: l'IA non sostituirà mai un buon insegnante, ma un insegnante che usa l'IA sostituirà presto quello che non la usa.

L'Alleggerimento del Carico Burocratico e Didattico: Per un docente, gran parte del tempo è assorbito da compiti ripetitivi: la stesura di griglie di valutazione, la pianificazione di schemi di lezione, la ricerca di materiali differenziati o la creazione di esercizi su misura per studenti con bisogni educativi speciali (BES). In questo l'IA è un co-pilota eccezionale: automatizza la routine, velocizza la progettazione e permette al professore di concentrarsi su ciò che sa fare meglio: la relazione umana.

La Personalizzazione dell'Apprendimento: L'IA eccelle nell'analisi dei dati su larga scala. Può aiutare il docente a identificare tempestivamente quali studenti stanno faticando in un determinato concetto, suggerendo percorsi di recupero personalizzati. Tuttavia, il dato algoritmico resta sterile se non viene letto attraverso la sensibilità umana: solo l'insegnante sa cogliere lo sguardo spento, il calo di attenzione o il disagio emotivo celato dietro un calo di rendimento.

Il Valore Insostituibile del Fattore Umano: Insegnare non significa semplicemente travasare nozioni (cosa che un chatbot sa fare benissimo). Educare significa trasmettere valori, insegnare il pensiero critico, gestire i conflitti in aula, accogliere le fragilità e dare speranza. Su temi delicati come la cittadinanza digitale, il bullismo, la violenza di genere o la gestione dell'etica tecnologica, la guida umana è imprescindibile. L'IA può spiegare cos'è un algoritmo, ma solo un docente in carne ed ossa può insegnare l'empatia, il rispetto e la responsabilità morale nell'usarlo.

# data[].attributes.body
Against: AI will never fully replace teachers. While AI can enhance educational experiences by providing personalized learning, automating administrative tasks, and offering supplementary resources, it lacks the human touch essential for effective teaching. Teachers provide empathy, encouragement, and adaptability, fostering critical thinking and socio-emotional skills crucial for student development. Moreover, human educators inspire creativity, collaboration, and cultural understanding, aspects of education that AI cannot replicate. In a rapidly evolving world, teachers remain indispensable mentors, guides, and role models, shaping students into well-rounded individuals beyond what any AI could achieve.

# data[].attributes.body
Süheyla,Türkiye

Only teachers meet the individual needs of students. It is a fact that artificial intelligence cannot do it. He is the teacher who provides the indispensable human touch in the classroom, hugs, makes people feel and develops emotions. Artificial intelligence can provide learning experiences, explain with examples, and research, but it can never replace the teacher.

# data[].attributes.body
Teaching is a complex and nuanced profession that requires empathy, creativity, and the ability to build relationships with students. AI may be able to assist teachers by providing personalized learning experiences and grading assignments, but it cannot replace the human touch that is essential for effective teaching. Additionally, human teachers can adapt to the individual needs of students in a way that AI cannot, making them irreplaceable in the classroom.

# data[].attributes.body
AI can't replicate the emotional support, guidance and encouragement a teacher provides. Teachers can inspire a love of learning, celebrate student achievements, and offer personalized support!

A classroom is a dynamic environment: teachers can navigate these complexities with understanding and flexibility. Not AI!

While AI can offer information and practice exercises, it can't foster critical thinking or independent problem-solving skills like a teacher can. Teachers can guide discussions, encourage debate and push students to think beyond the obvious.

AI cannot replace the value of teamwork, communication and conflict resolution skills fostered through teacher-led activities and group projects.

# data[].attributes.body
If the only reason to keep children at school is to entertain them, take care of them and keep them controlled while their parents are working, the answer is yes.

But if you aim to train these children to analyse and use critically the AI, that cannot be accomplished by an AI itself.

# data[].attributes.body
Laurence

It's very difficult for me to have an idea but I guess that in a not too long future the teachers could be replaced by AI. We are all training AI every day by posting photos, questioning Google or another searching engine, etc... I know that I'm ridiculous, but I remember the movie "AI artificial intelligence" and the little boy (David I guess) develops some emotions and human feelings. So, why not?

# data[].attributes.body
Students need teachers. Teachers need to know their students emotional states in real time. A computer cannot do that.

# data[].attributes.body
Igors Ardasevs

I do not believe that AI replace teachers. Maybe some lessons will be more used AI tools. Some of teachers with technophobia will lose job. But real communication during a educational process will be ever. Teacher compare are like a bot teacher and the same moment bot tester in one person.

# data[].attributes.body
Sandra Magnuszewska

Sandra Magnuszewska

For the time being AI will not replace teachers. Even though it may ba attractive to both students and teachers, the second group is unreplaceable. AI lacks this important component which is common sense and that is why it isn’t flawlass. It can help students learnto some extent, for instance by using GPTChat for looking forfacts etc. Teachers can rely on it for preparing lesson plans. But teaching is not only about studying. The proces is not only informative. There is some kind of relationship between students and teachers based on common trust. This creates perfect envirinment for honing skills and learing new things.

# data[].attributes.body
A IA não substituirá os professores porque os professores possuem inteligência emocional, tão importante para trabalhar com os alunos. A Interação humana e as competências socioemocionais são qualidades únicas que a IA não pode substituir.

A IA pode sim ser usada para auxiliar e melhorar o processo de ensino e aprendizagem na sala de aula.

# data[].attributes.body
Eva, Hungary

I would choose a middle arguement if we had such a coloumn :) I don't think AI will replace teachers but it is likely to take over many of our administrative tasks, making our work easier. This way we would have more time to focus on pedagogy and personal connection with students.

# data[].attributes.body
Empathy, inspiration, and personal connection are irreplaceable.

# data[].attributes.body
I do not think AI could replace teachers. No one but humans could understand little humans's emotions and emotional intelligence. AI could become a valuable tool in class, but it can never replace a person. Working will children needs a lot of re-adapting/ readjusting during the process. Children need someone who can understand their emotions, and their language is not always standard, nothing is predictable with children.

# data[].attributes.body
AI's advancements in personalized learning, adaptive tutoring, and data analysis suggest it will eventually replace traditional teaching methods. With tailored content, instant feedback, and round-the-clock availability, AI can cater to individual student needs more efficiently. Moreover, AI's scalability can address educational disparities by providing quality education to remote or underserved areas. As technology continues to evolve, AI-driven teaching platforms will revolutionize education, making learning more accessible, engaging, and effective for students worldwide.

# data[].attributes.body
AI will not replace teachers. While AI can enhance educational experiences with personalized learning and automated grading, it lacks the empathy, creativity, and interpersonal skills essential for effective teaching. Teachers provide mentorship, emotional support, and personalized guidance tailored to each student's needs, fostering critical thinking and social-emotional development. AI may complement teaching by automating routine tasks, but human educators offer irreplaceable qualities crucial for holistic learning and student success.