# data[].attributes.body
i dont think we need help, the polar bears need help

# data[].attributes.body
Nil

# data[].attributes.body
Explaining more about the visual semiotic mode

# data[].attributes.body
- How to not go out of point

# data[].attributes.body
We wonder if the use of unconventional and fictatious understandings can be used in the inference. For example, the polar bear is suffering should that really be our fault when using karma as a form of implication.

# data[].attributes.body
nil

# data[].attributes.body
Knowledge for the youths

# data[].attributes.body
nil

# data[].attributes.body
nothing

# data[].attributes.body
nil

# data[].attributes.body
knowledge on how to identify the find context to infer about.

# data[].attributes.body
Nothing!!!

# data[].attributes.body
talk move 🗣🗣🗣application

# data[].attributes.body
-the polar bear's hunger is not directly due to climate change
-life and death is inevitable
-climate change is caused by humans

# data[].attributes.body
climate change,  the rise of temperature causes ice to melt and the habitats will be destoryed.

stravation, the poalr bear is hungry due to the lack of seals and have to find food through human settlements.

# data[].attributes.body
- some people may feel that why should they care about these polar bears, like it doesn't affect them too.

- when you talk about climate change, you are not caring about the polar bear but about the environment while this polar bear is struggling.

- nat geog as an organisation can do things to help the polar bear but instead they're doing videos to increase awareness about climate change and being 'attentive'. they are just watching and not helping the polar bear which goes against what nat geo stands for.

# data[].attributes.body
-Zoologists and polar bear enthusiasts might be disheartened and concerned about the conditions of polar bears across the world.
-Another group of people might feel guilty because of humans' contribution to climate change.
-People might feel that it is not what they have done that caused climate change or they might feel that they cannot do anything to stop climate change.

# data[].attributes.body
The photographer narrowed down to the effects of climate change and wanted to show what starvation is like and how it affects humans and animals.

National Geographic has a wider perspective to climate change in general. National Geographic wanted to show what climate change does to animals and the environment.

# data[].attributes.body
people might agree that the video showing the polar bear is from the cause of illegal trafficking then releasing them at any place which is not their habitat when they are no longer needed. there is also no definite prove that shows the polar bear is in that area through the cause of global warming.

# data[].attributes.body
"this is what starvation looks like" doesn't necessarily mean humans. While most people would assume it applies to humans. Not able of people take into perspective the other lives on this planet.

# data[].attributes.body
- Some people will be concerned about the situation of polar bears going extinct due to the lack of food sources for them
- When Nat Geo brought up this is what climate change looks like, their addressing an issue at large, in a broader perspective, as in its the underlying cause of starvation, which is what the photographer mentioned.
- Some see it as a sign for human to take action, others side by the side watching unable to do anything, while a minority just show that they don't care and accept it as how it is

# data[].attributes.body
1. Scientific Perspective:

Climate Change Impact: Explain the scientific evidence linking climate change to the loss of sea ice, which affects the polar bear's hunting and feeding patterns.

Food Chain Disruption: Discuss how reduced sea ice impacts the polar bear's primary prey, seals, and how this disruption affects the bear's ability to find sufficient food.

2. Environmental Perspective:

people explore the broader implications of a starving polar bear on the Arctic ecosystem. The loss of polar bears could disrupt the balance and health of the entire region.

3. Conservation Perspective:

Endangered Species Highlight the polar bear's status as a threatened or endangered species and discuss ongoing conservation efforts to protect their habitat and ensure their survival.

4. Human Impact Perspective:

Responsibility and Action: Discuss the role of human activities, such as carbon emissions and deforestation, in driving climate change and its consequences for polar bears.

Ethics and Empathy: Present the emotional and ethical impact of witnessing a starving polar bear, encouraging viewers to empathize with the bear's plight and consider their own choices.

5. Socioeconomic Perspective:

people who explore how climate change affects icommunities that rely on the Arctic ecosystem for their way of life, including hunting and cultural practices.

Discuss potential economic impacts of losing polar bears, such as impacts on tourism and potential effects on the broader economy.

6.Hope and Solutions Perspective:

for the emotionally sympathetic perspective of society

# data[].attributes.body
the photographer thinks that the polar bear is starving as in the video it is looking for food in order to survive however national geographic thinks that the starvation of the polar bear is stemmed from the main cause of climate

# data[].attributes.body
Climate change is bad because of animals lost of habitat
How can humans make up for global warming
Are we the next to starve to death
This isnt the cause of human because the meteor hitting the earth started the climate change

# data[].attributes.body
The polar bear is skinny which only suggests that it is starving due to the lack of food sources. But it cannot be fully linked to climate change without prove.

# data[].attributes.body
1. Climate change
2. Starvation
3. Animal life (the hardships of an animal is higher than we thought)
4. Food cycle (polar bears die a useless life)
5. Human action (the cause of all this is because of human action against the environment)
6. No action to help (it was illegal to feed polar bears)

# data[].attributes.body
It isn't necessarily sad because everything will die

Life and death are concepts that are inevitable to all living things, in due time we will all perish.

# data[].attributes.body
1. the polar bear is skinny and malnourished due to the lack of food. climate change has made these animals do the absolute most just to survive.
2. the music is slow and depressing which depicts a gloomy atmosphere. this enhances the negative effects of climate change.
3. the polar bear is weak and its movements are abnormally slow. this means that as the polar bear is starving, it is not able to move as quickly as usual.

# data[].attributes.body
The background music shows us the atmosphere of the situation, makes us feel gulity and pity for the bears. :( This is because whatever situation they are facing right now is all because of what humans have done and have greatly impacted their lives.

the polar bear in the video looks weak, lifeless, smaller in size and also seems sadder. This shows that it does not have the food he needs meaning he is starving and severely malnourished.

The video itself is very dull -> lacks colour, indicating the gloominess of the situation.

Shows polar bears are critically endangered - indirectly telling us that we should take action now to make the situation better.

# data[].attributes.body
visual-Polar bear is very skinny and have to face the consequences of our actions
audio- the background music and the tone of the narrator is saddddd
genstural- the polar bear have to find food from human food waste

# data[].attributes.headline
MOHAMED RAFI MOHAMED IRFAN, TEOW YIK NIAM, GOH YI XUAN

# data[].attributes.subject
MOHAMED RAFI MOHAMED IRFAN, TEOW YIK NIAM, GOH YI XUAN

# data[].attributes.body
Polar Bear are starving and dying
Polar Bear bones were visible
Polar Bear look exhausted
The Audio Is Very Sad
Polar Bear looks desperate for food

# data[].attributes.body
My initial thoughts on the video is that global warming is bad for the environment. This is supported by the video as the in the video there is a sad background audio playing and there is a clip of a polar bear starving and scavenging for food along with the fact that it is not living in its natural habitat of arctic. This shows the bad effects of climate change on the environment as the home of the Polar bear is destoryed

# data[].attributes.body
The polar bears are very skinny which gives the idea that they are severely malnourished.
The audio set the atmosphere to be gloomy and makes me sympathize for the polar bears.
The polars bear's movemenrs suggests that is extremely weak and slow.

# data[].attributes.body
The polar bear looks frail and weak. It looks like it hasn't eaten in days. It doesn't look healthy. This shows the effects of global warming. The music was also slow paced. Making the event seem more depressing.

# data[].attributes.body
The polar bear looks tired and sad as it is unable to find food. The polar bear is desperate to find food as it searches in barrels. There is sad music playing in the background to set a depressing mood.

# data[].attributes.body
The music ties in the mood and atmosphere which emphasises the vulnerability of the polar bear. This evokes feelings of pity and sympathy in the viewers, accompanied by the visuals of the scrawny polar bear scavenging for food. Furthermore, the polar bear's posture highlights its lack of energy being in an unfamiliar environment.

# data[].attributes.body
The audio in the video is sad, dramatic.

The polar bear in the video is limping as it does not have enough nutrition and energy to walk around because they don't have enough nutrition and energy.

There is no ice, this isn't the normal habitat of a polar bear.

# data[].attributes.body
Polar bear is not in its natural habitat
Looks very sad. The condition of the bear is bad.

# data[].attributes.body
Audio- makes the video sound more sad and depressing
Gestural- the actions and facial expression shows that the desperation of the polar bear in search for food.
Visual- the background shows that the polar bear is not in its natural habitat

# data[].attributes.body
1. The polar bear is skin and bones from starving
2. Desperately searching for food.
3. The music was slow paced and sad.
4. The polar bear's colour was contrasting with the environment
5. The focus was on the polar that was searching for food.
6. The polar was slouching which represents that it is tired.

# data[].attributes.body
Polar bear's movements are sluggish and weak, probably from nausea and starvation

Polar bear is malnourished

Polar bear is outside natural habitat

The video used a depressing soundtrack to add emphasis on the proportional depressing situation

near he climax of the video the polar bear layed helpless on the ground, implying its lack of strength and motivation to continue fighting for food

# data[].attributes.body
Talk Moves Questions
- Why do you say so?
- What evidence could you give to support…
- Could you add on?
- What have you discussed so far?

Semiotic Modes
Visual (colour, focus)
Gestural (facial expressions, action, posture)
and Audio (music, sound effect)

# data[].attributes.body
Acknowledging Diverse Perspectives
“This is what starvation looks like” – Instagram post by the photographer
“This is what climate change looks like” – National Geographic

Talk Moves
- To build on an idea

Semiotic Modes
Linguistic (word choices)