# data[].attributes.body
https://www.greenerpractice.co.uk/information-and-resources/clinical-considerations/prescribing-and-deprescribing/

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
NICE guidance suggests that medicines optimisation should be part of routine practice. The CQC sees deprescribing as an important element of good patient care. Deprescribing can be supported by ensuring that there is a clear and appropriate diagnosis, alongside social prescribing and green prescribing, person-centred medicine and increased personal self-efficacy.

The DHSC Report " Good for you, Good for Us, Good for Everybody" outlines the importance of this issue. The Royal Pharmaceutical Society has produced a useful document summarising the principles of medicines optimisation. A variety of tools are available to support deprescribing, including Medstopper and PrescQIPP. The Stopp Start tool also helps support rational prescribing in older patients. A useful area of focus for deprescribing in the elderly would be those with a high anticholinergic burden as these drugs increase the risk of falls, dementia and early death. An easy scoring tool is here.

NHS Scotland and Realistic Medicine produced this comprehensive guide to polypharmacy.

The Open Prescribing website sends monthly bulletins on the prescribing data for your practice. This can help identify areas of unnecessary, expensive or environmentally costly prescribing.

NHS England has developed a Greener NHS Prescribing Dashboard for use by practices.

The Royal Pharmaceutical Society quotes studies finding that only 16% of patients who are prescribed a new medicine take it as prescribed, experience no problems and receive as much information as they need. Ten days after starting a medicine, almost a third of patients are already not taking them correctly. NICE estimates between 30-50% of medications taken for long term conditions are not taken as intended. Medicine taken incorrectly, or not taken at all, is a potential risk to patients and leads to medicine wastage, placing a huge financial (£300m/year) and carbon burden on the NHS.

A well-structured medication review can identify medications that are being ordered when they are either not needed or not wanted. Some CCGs have identified huge savings by attempting to address this. Read an example of this here.

Dr Deb Gombertz has shared with us a poster explaining the importance of asking patients ' Show me your meds, please '.

Green Prescribing

Improving Welfare through Urban Nature (IWUN) are group completing a research project into how Sheffield's natural environment can improve the health and well being of the city's resident.

The IWUN reports can be found here.

The IWUN academic papers can be found here.

Jake Robinson has published two papers discussing the co-benefits of green prescribing and the socio-economic features to consider around green prescribing.

You can also find information released by RSPB on a pilot study of Green prescribing in Edinburgh.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
NICE guidance suggests that medicines optimisation should be part of routine practice. The CQC sees deprescribing as an important element of good patient care. Deprescribing can be supported by ensuring that there is a clear and appropriate diagnosis, alongside social prescribing and green prescribing, person-centred medicine and increased personal self-efficacy.

# data[].attributes.body
https://openprescribing.net/practice/C86007/measures/?tags=greenernhs

# data[].attributes.body
We want to reduce the impact of the Burns Practice on the environment whilst improving the health and wellbeing of our patients and staff.

What do you think? Comment below

# data[].attributes.headline
How to use this padlet (except if you need to add a section, please ask Dom or leave a note here)

# data[].attributes.subject
How to use this padlet (except if you need to add a section, please ask Dom or leave a note here)

# data[].attributes.body
https://vimeo.com/796546937/77cc560dfe

# data[].attributes.body
https://www.greenerpractice.co.uk/

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Greener practice can improve health now, mitigate the climate crisis and reduce health inequalities. It can also improve workload and reduce costs through improved population health and reduced prescribing. Explore the website to find out more.

Find out more

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
Greener Practice - Greener Practice - UK's primary care sustainability network

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
We are a community of healthcare professionals working together to inspire sustainable primary care.

# data[].attributes.headline
Six steps to better and greener primary care

# data[].attributes.subject
Six steps to better and greener primary care

# data[].attributes.body
https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2020/12/15/aarti-bansal-and-grant-blashki-six-steps-to-both-greener-and-better-primary-care/

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Approximately two-thirds of general practice's carbon footprint comes from prescribing. Reducing unnecessary prescribing is an obvious first place to start and has flow on benefits for patients such as in reducing problematic polypharmacy . The open prescribing website gives UK general practices easy access to their prescribing data to help support safe and efficient prescribing.

Most health determinants lie outside of healthcare and there is a growing appreciation of the vital role that communities have in health creation . Co-creating the conditions of health with communities can develop resources and assets specific to that community's needs. Peer volunteers and champions can work alongside trained link-workers to help patients access community-based resources. Activities such as community food growing, green gyms and social cafes can improve health and wellbeing through social connectedness, sustainable healthy diets, increased physical activity and access to biodiverse green spaces in local environments.

The climate crisis disproportionately affects poorer sections of society, and there is increasing recognition of the need to address health inequalities on the road to a green and fair recovery. One specific area for action is support for people living in cold homes who are at increased risk of many health conditions leading to excess winter deaths . Initiatives where general practices have identified patients who are unable to afford a warm home and directed them to support around energy efficiency, have demonstrated significant reductions in GP appointments, hospital admissions and fossil fuel use. Innovative award-winning projects such as "Saving lives with solar" have combined reducing the NHS carbon footprint with raising funds for fuel poverty schemes.

In the world of fake news and obsession with social media, GPs and nurses remain trusted source s of health information and guidance. Through advertising their participation in green initiatives, general practices send a public health message to their patients about the importance and urgency of action on environmental sustainability. By choosing to walk or cycle to work and home visits, clinicians can model the benefits of active transport on individual health through exercise and promote the gains to population health through lower air pollution. Clinicians are ideally situated to advocate for urgent action for a healthy recovery from Covid-19 through and international networks.
Aarti Bansal is a GP in Sheffield, an NIHR research fellow at Hull York Medical School and the founder of the Greener Practice initiative which aims to support general practices to take action for the health of patients and planet. Grant Blashki is an Australian GP, Associate Professor of Global Health at the University of Melbourne, Australia. He is a cofounder of Doctors for the Environment Australia, and Former Chair of the Environmental Working Group of WONCA

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
Aarti Bansal and Grant Blashki: Six steps to both greener and better primary care - The BMJ

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Approximately two-thirds of general practice's carbon footprint comes from prescribing. Reducing unnecessary prescribing is an obvious first place to start and has flow on benefits for patients such as in reducing problematic polypharmacy . The open prescribing website gives UK general practices easy access to their prescribing data to help support safe and efficient prescribing.

# data[].attributes.body
https://toolkit.sos-uk.org/greenimpact/giforhealth/login

# data[].attributes.body
https://www.bmj.com/content/379/bmj-2021-066699

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Practice Practice Pointer BMJ 2022; 379 doi: Cite this as: BMJ 2022;379:e066699 https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2021-066699
Linked Practice

Towards zero carbon healthcare: anaesthesia

1. Rachel Stancliffe , director 1,

2. Aarti Bansal , GP , and net zero clinical lead 2 3,

3. Georgina Sowman , locum GP , and physical activity clinical champion for North East England Office of Health Improvement and Disparities 4,

4. Frances Mortimer , medical director 1

1. 1The Centre for Sustainable Healthcare, Oxford, UK

2. 2Burngreave Surgery, Sheffield, UK

3. 3Humber and North Yorkshire Health and Care Partnership, UK

4. 4Alnwick Medical Group, Northumberland, UK

Correspondence to R Stancliffe Rachel.stancliffe{at}sustainablehealthcare.org.uk

What you need to know

Reduce use of health services and improve healthcare efficiency by integrating the following principles into daily clinical practice and quality improvement: prevention, patient empowerment, lean systems, and low carbon alternatives

Encourage sustainable healthcare principles in all populations (including those currently under-served) to reduce health inequalities

Consider strategies to reduce duplication and waste, for example, when booking appointments, requesting investigations, prescribing, allocating resources, and arranging patient or staff travel

Case-A 47 year old woman who takes metformin and amlodipine for type 2 diabetes and hypertension visits her GP to discuss her HbA1C levels, which have been steadily increasing. She is a single mother with two children at school and works full time in an office. They discuss the option of increasing her diabetes medication and how. High quality control of long term conditions with medication has a lower burden on patients' physical, mental, and social health-as well as a lower carbon footprint-than poor control, which may result in complications and admissions. However, the patient doesn't want to increase her medication as she experiences several side effects from the medicines she already takes.
Our essential life support systems-water, air, food, and a stable climate-are being destroyed by the global climate and ecological emergency. This is claiming millions of lives and its impacts are disproportionately felt by people who are poorer and more vulnerable. 1

A report from Health Care Without Harm suggests that the climate footprint of healthcare worldwide is equivalent to 4.4% of global net carbon emissions-ie, if the health sector were a country, it would be the fifth largest emitter on the planet. 2

The authors of this article are based in the UK, but the content is relevant for all healthcare teams worldwide, providing sustainable clinical healthcare principles that can be integrated into daily practice, healthcare improvement activity, education, leadership, and research. It also introduces a series of papers, Towards net zero healthcare, written by groups in various countries and aimed more directly at specialty teams.

What is the problem?

The direct impacts of the climate emergency, such as heatwaves, wildfires, and flooding, affect human health through increased air pollution and by changing the distributions of vector-borne, diarrhoeal, and other infections. Indirectly, climate instability (including fast rising temperatures and changing rainfall patterns) causes failed harvests, shortages of food and water, malnutrition, and increased conflict over scarce resources. 3

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)-the United Nations' body for assessing climate change science-predicts that, when average global temperatures reach 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, risks for natural and human systems will include ice cap melting, sea level rises, drought in extended areas, mass displacement of populations, and insufficient food and drinking water. 4 The IPCC special report, published in August 2021, 5 stated that this threshold would be breached in less than a decade.

What is net zero?

Net zero is an internationally agreed goal for avoiding worsening global heating in the second half of the 21st century. As a concept, net zero aims to balance the quantities of greenhouse gases (also referred to as carbon emissions because they mostly comprise carbon dioxide) released into and removed from the atmosphere, 6 ie, to achieve carbon neutrality or net zero.

Commonly used climate change terms

Carbon emissions/greenhouse gases (GHGs): gases that are released into the atmosphere and absorb solar energy 35

Carbon dioxide equivalent (CO ₂ e): equivalent mass of carbon dioxide used as a measurement unit of GHG release and removal

Carbon/climate footprint: the measurement of how much carbon dioxide equivalent is generated by a particular object, pathway, operation, etc.

Global warming potential (GWP): integrating the amount of energy a GHG absorbs (its radiative efficiency) with its atmospheric lifespan, 35 to compare the impact of atmospheric release of a substance with the release of an equivalent mass of carbon dioxide (CO ₂e) over a specified time horizon (eg, GWP ₁₀₀ is over 100 years)

Climate mitigation: avoiding carbon emissions by changing practices

Climate adaptation: adapting to the inevitable increases in temperature, flooding, diseases, etc, that are already happening because of climate change

What is the evidence?

Evidence showing that climate change affects health was summarised over a decade ago. 7 Now, we need research that prioritises solutions. Many studies for measuring and achieving sustainability in healthcare are still at the stage of defining frameworks and presenting data based on economic input-output methodology, 2 8 9 10 but more specific evidence is also available. Examples include studies of how one intervention differs from another in terms of carbon emissions, patient outcomes, and other factors, including several life cycle analyses 11 12 13 14 15 16 and systematic reviews. 17

Limitations to evidence on sustainable healthcare

A dearth of standards for measurement and reporting means that studies mostly use different boundaries and are of variable quality

The contextual element of the evidence makes comparison between different interventions difficult. Because the result of interest is multi-faceted (at its simplest, patient outcome per resource input), it is more difficult to measure than most clinical research, which focuses on outcomes alone. Sustainable healthcare research bears more resemblance to health economics research, but with the inclusion of environmental metrics alongside financial cost

When studying an intervention or procedure, as well as assessing the material object itself (a drug or tool), assessment of its production and implementation-in terms of materials, people, energy use, water use, and staff and patient time-is also needed, which adds complexity

What can clinicians do?

Healthcare practitioners can participate in innovation, adoption, and embedding of low carbon practices. By openly framing the climate emergency as a health crisis, they can inspire sustainable practice in colleagues, the public, 18 and leaders.

Apply sustainable clinical practice principles to daily clinical practice (table 1)

Healthcare professionals can use CSH's Principles of Sustainable Clinical Practice 13 to improve patient outcomes while minimising the environmental, social, and financial costs:

Prevention-eg, early identification of patients with declining kidney function can reduce the number of people going on to require carbon intensive dialysis 27

Patient empowerment and self-care-eg, patients with good inhaler technique need fewer inhalers and achieve better asthma control 28

Lean care systems-eg, adherence to prescribing guidelines for flupenthixol decanoate by reducing the frequency of doses from two- to six-weekly, saves travel, equipment, money, and time 29

Low carbon alternatives-eg, the carbon footprint of one hour of general anaesthetic is equivalent to driving 190 miles (300 km) using inhaled desflurane compared with only 4 miles (6.5 km) using inhaled sevoflurane. 30

Despite the research limitations outlined above, a growing evidence base supports the following widely applicable actions:

Choose reusable instruments instead of single-use varieties 31

Use thorough handwashing instead of gloves for infection control when exposure to blood or other body fluids is not anticipated, in line with NHS guidelines 32

When clinically appropriate and preferred by patients, arrange remote consultations for follow-up. 27

Agree standard metrics for measuring impacts over time

Clinicians can collaborate with those involved in carbon measurement to suggest and develop standard metrics that routinely measure environmental and social impacts (such as carbon footprint or waste produced per unit of care), and use these to make balanced decisions about progression towards net zero care.
Case continued The patient is pleased that she will spend less time in a car in traffic, and that she and her children will be exposed to less air pollution, spend active time together in a green space, and experience benefits to their health. The patient is referred to the practice's social prescriber, who further supports her, and shares information and maps of safe local walking routes through nature. -When asked what matters most to her, the patient says that she is currently inactive, with several barriers to everyday exercise-she drives to school and work and finds few opportunities or incentives to be active at work. With her permission, the GP discusses the benefits of physical activity and healthy eating. The patient decides that three times a week she will get up 20 minutes earlier than usual, park away from the children's school, and walk that distance through a park with her children.
Table 1 (middle column) shows how the principles of sustainable clinical practice care have been applied to this case.

Figure 1 shows the wider population level benefits that may follow from this intervention.

Link sustainability to quality improvement

Actively address sustainability as part of healthcare quality improvement (QI) activities. The Centre for Sustainable Healthcare (CSH) has developed a sustainable QI approach (see example, fig 2) that allows assessment of sustainable value on potential service changes. 33 28

Maximise the theoretical sustainable value of a service or care pathway

In partnership with management colleagues, when improving or redesigning systems (eg, concerning energy or water use, lower emission transport, home visiting strategies, procurement of low carbon treatments or technologies), weigh up the outcomes for patients and populations against the environmental, social, and financial costs. 33 34

Use decarbonisation actions to help address health inequality

As outlined in the 2020 Marmot Review, prioritising preventive health, encouraging the growth of food locally, and encouraging access to green space can all contribute to reducing inequalities. The principles are applicable globally.

What support is needed?

Incorporating planetary health into medical education

Policy makers, educators, and students support incorporating planetary health into healthcare curricula, and several usable frameworks have been published. 29 30 37

Clinical leadership

Clinical leaders can examine speciality pathways and lobby for prevention funding. By linking with public health, GPs, and local authorities, they can also advocate for and implement societal changes through policy development and commissioning, eg, reducing air pollution to help reduce respiratory conditions; ensuring green walking and cycling routes for staff and patients 38 39

Research

Urgent research on solutions and further collaboration with health economists will enable consideration of carbon in resource modelling, health technology assessments, and clinical guidelines

Patient involvement

Patients are entitled to be informed about the connections between climate and health, and be given the chance to advocate for change. They can contribute to sustainability as well as their own care through lifestyle measures, treatment adherence, early identification of deteriorations or complications (leading to swifter interventions), and, with shared decision making, can help providers to avoid enforcing low value, unwanted procedures.

Considerations specific to the UK

The UK Health Alliance on Climate Change (UKHACC) includes more than 900 000 UK healthcare professionals who are members of organisations acting on climate change 40

The 2020 Marmot Review from the UCL Institute of Health Equity outlines how decarbonisation actions such as improved housing and heating can reduce health inequalities 41

The Greener NHS team has committed to achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2045, and is supporting NHS action in several areas (via integrated care systems, provider organisations, and including clinical practice, buildings, and supply chain) 42

Since 2008, the UK's Centre for Sustainable Healthcare has worked to expand the meaning of sustainable healthcare beyond buildings to include clinical care, developing sustainable healthcare frameworks, influencing medical school curricula, training specialists and front line teams in measuring carbon, and contributing to sustainable healthcare research 43

The UK charity Medact has outlined and advocated for a healthy green recovery from the covid-19 crisis, including a rapid energy transition away from fossil fuels and shifting agricultural subsidies towards healthy sustainable food production 44

The NHS in England and Wales is starting to reward operational changes such as reducing energy usage. Procurement policy now applies higher weighting to environmental factors when awarding tenders (ie, where sustainability contributes at least 10% of a procurement proposal in in England, 15% in Wales). 45 46 Scotland and NI are also prioritising the environment via different mechanisms.

Research councils and funders are beginning to fund sustainable healthcare work 47 and organisations such as the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence and the Good Clinical Trials Collaborative are starting to include sustainability in their research and frameworks. 48

How patients were involved in the creation of this article and the Towards net zero healthcare series

In this article, the authors are writing as patients, healthcare professionals, and sustainability experts. Patients have been involved in the work of The Centre for Sustainable Healthcare in developing better patient pathways and sustainable practice, and will be involved in the creation of each of this series' specialty based articles, either as co-authors or contributors.

How this article was created

This article was written after discussion with Fiona Godlee, Sabreena Malik, and the Education team at The BMJ. It is an introduction to a series on lower carbon healthcare for healthcare professionals in different specialty areas. It draws on the authors' experience, accumulated since 2008, in working to engage clinicians in sustainable healthcare.

Footnotes

Contributorship and guarantor: Rachel Stancliffe and Frances Mortimer conceived the article and are guarantors. All authors wrote and reviewed the article. Georgie Sowman provided the fictionalised case story and figure 1.

We acknowledge the contribution to research, practice, and education of all people involved in developing global sustainable healthcare;

Competing interests: The BMJ has judged that CSH and the authors have no disqualifying financial ties to commercial companies that are relevant to this paper. Other interests: CSH has received commercial funding towards sustainability work that is specifically relevant to surgery and ophthalmology topics and will therefore not contribute to any of The BMJ Education papers on those topics.

Provenance and peer review: commissioned, based on an idea from the author; externally peer reviewed.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
What you need to know Case -A 47 year old woman who takes metformin and amlodipine for type 2 diabetes and hypertension visits her GP to discuss her HbA1C levels, which have been steadily increasing. She is a single mother with two children at school and works full time in an office.

# data[].attributes.body
Is solar working at cantley? Could we install more?
Could we install heat pump at Cantley?
Insulation at AP?
Secondary double glazing at AP?

# data[].attributes.headline
Minimise printing and print double-sided

# data[].attributes.subject
Minimise printing and print double-sided

# data[].attributes.headline
Reusable / washable equipment where possible?

# data[].attributes.subject
Reusable / washable equipment where possible?

# data[].attributes.body
Staff are car sharing to work wherever possible.

# data[].attributes.body
Practice switch from vagifem to vagirux (reusable) underway

# data[].attributes.headline
If you want a whole section adding, let Dom know

# data[].attributes.subject
If you want a whole section adding, let Dom know

# data[].attributes.headline
Take your recycling home i.e. soup tins, pop cans, jars

# data[].attributes.subject
Take your recycling home i.e. soup tins, pop cans, jars

# data[].attributes.body
Recycle printer toner cartridges - a few years ago a charity used to collect all used toners for recycling.

# data[].attributes.body
Is there anyway to recycle inhalers?

# data[].attributes.body
Can something be done re the amount of urine samples we receive? People hand them in without symptoms because they feel 'off'. The amount of plastic we must be wasting there

# data[].attributes.body
I feel we are behind on jumping on this as the hospitals have been using recycled paper for a few years now.

# data[].attributes.body
Is there a way of recycling the syringes we use? The sharps bins are equipped with edges which make it easy to remove the sharps from the syringe, then could they get recycled?