# data[].attributes.body
Using digital technology to record feedback promotes:

It makes the process more efficient, accessible and achievable.

It helps both the assessor and learner to track progress more accurately.

It is stored and recorded together in one place, making it more organised and accessible. This also makes it easily retrievable.

# data[].attributes.body
Digital feedback allows us to provide more personal feedback to learners.

This can be done through:

OneFile Assist

Chat GPT

Verbal feedback on a recording

Remote sessions with learners

# data[].attributes.body
Examples of Constructive Feedback;

Written feedback

Verbal Feedback

Monthly Reports

Progress Reviews

Following the TRACK model for trainers

Setting SMART targets.

Sandwich effect feedback.

Being mindful of how learners interpret feedback being given.

Using the tool Realise Assist.

Learning Journal Feedback

# data[].attributes.body
Digital technology enhances the feedback process by making it faster, more flexible, and more insightful. Recording feedback enables assessors to make informed, data-driven decisions and promote continuous improvements.

While digital technology for recording feedback can be modernised. It also comes with limitations such as sampling biases, data overload, technical barriers, privacy concerns. Addressing these issues requires careful planning, improved tools for analysing feedback, and a balanced approach that combines digital feedback with other methods of engagement.

# data[].attributes.body
Giving constructive feedback to early years practitioners is about supporting their professional development while recognising the importance of their work with young children. Feedback should be specific, encouraging, and focused on both strengths and areas for growth, here is an example.

A practitioner is great at engaging with children but sometimes misses opportunities to encourage independence.

Feedback:

"I love how you get down to the children’s level and interact with them in such a warm, caring way, they clearly feel comfortable with you. One idea to build on this could be to give them more time to try things independently before stepping in to help. For instance, when setting up an art activity, you might encourage them to choose their own materials or try things on their own first. This can really build their confidence and sense of independence."

This feedback acknowledges the practitioner’s strengths and provides a clear, actionable idea that enhances children’s independence without diminishing the practitioner’s strengths.

# data[].attributes.body
The purpose of constructive feedback is:

To give specific, clear and informative guidance to expand on learning.

Provides a clear plan of actionable suggestions which are intended to be helpful, supportive and promote growth.

Provides a clear pathway into the learners personal progression.

Creates structure of learning topics and aims for both the learner and assessor.

Build's confidence and self esteem and motivates the learners.

Tailored to the learner and is specific to the learners behaviour's.

Feedback is given in a timely manner and documented in a variety of ways.

# data[].attributes.body
SMART Feedback

Be sensitive

Focus on improvement, don't look at the negatives

Offer solutions and guidance

Complete feedback timely so it is fresh and relevant

# data[].attributes.body
The purpose of feedback in the assessment cycle is:

To guide improvement, detailing developmental feedback. This helps learners to understand their strengths and identify area's for improvement. This will support their overall holistic development.

Encourages reflection

Build motivation and confidence.

Close learning gaps.

Provides learners with both professional and personal growth.

Provides individually tailored feedback.

Supports the learner to understand criteria that they have or haven't met. And how to achieve this.

Allows for a plan of action to be put into place to develop knowledge and skills and work towards evidencing this.

# data[].attributes.body
Constructive feedback is developmental feedback that allows the learner to develop and improve a learners knowledge and skills.

Feedback should be helpful and allow the learner to improve in a specific area to stretch and challenge their knowledge in a positive way.

# data[].attributes.body
Constructive feedback is how we deliver feedback to our learners. When giving feedback, we need to make sure we are giving clear feedback that the learner understands and making sure it is relevant to the activity that has just taken place. When giving feedback, it has to have some developmental feedback so the learner can reflect on their practice and set themselves new goals. The best technique to use when giving feedback is the sandwiching technique, starting off the feedback positively then offering developmental feedback and how learners can achieve this.

# data[].attributes.body
To review what they have learnt and make a plan of what to do next to enhance knowledge and meet criteria that needs to be met. To make a plan of what how you are going to support your learner with this and directing them to the relevant resources.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Providing constructive feedback examples to students is an important part of the learning journey and is crucial to student improvement. It can be used to feed a student's love of learning and help build a strong student-teacher relationship. But it can be difficult to balance the "constructive" with the "feedback" in an effective way.

On one hand, we risk the student not absorbing the information, and therefore missing an opportunity for growth when we offer criticism, even when constructive. On the other hand, there is a risk of discouraging the student, dampening their desire to learn, or even harming their self-confidence. Further complicating the matter is the fact that every student learns differently, hears and absorbs feedback differently, and is at a different level of emotional and intellectual development than their peers.

We know that we can't teach every student the exact same way and expect the same results for each of them; the same holds true for providing constructive feedback examples. For best results, it's important to tailor how constructive feedback is provided based on content, student needs, and a variety of other factors.

In this blog, we'll take a look at constructive feedback examples and the value of effective instructor feedback, centering on Dr. John Hattie's research on "Where to next?" feedback. We'll also offer key examples for students, so instructors at different grade levels can apply best practices right away.

What is constructive feedback?

In 1992, Dr. John Hattie-in a meta-analysis of multiple scientific studies-found that "feedback has one of the positive influences on student achievement," building on Sadler's concept that good feedback can close the gap between where students are and where they aim to be (Sadler, 1989).

But before getting too far into specifics, it would be helpful to talk about what "constructive feedback" is. Not everyone will define it in quite the same way - indeed, there is no singular accepted definition of the phrase.

For example, a researcher in Buenos Aires, Argentina who studies medical school student and resident performance, defines it, rather dryly, as "the act of giving information to a student or resident through the description of their performance in an observed clinical situation." In workplace scenarios, you'll often hear it described as feedback that "reinforces desired behaviors" or, a definition that is closer to educators' goals in the classroom, "a supportive way to improve areas of opportunity."

Hattie and Clarke ( 2019) define feedback as the information about a learning task that helps students understand what is aimed to be understood versus what is being understood.

For the purposes of this discussion, a good definition of constructive feedback is any feedback that the giver provides with the intention of producing a positive result. This working definition includes important parts from other, varied definitions. In educational spaces, "positive result" usually means growth, improvement, or a lesson learned. This is typically accomplished by including clear learning goals and success criteria within the feedback, motivating students towards completing the task.

When should you give constructive feedback?

If you read this header and thought "well... always?" - yes. In an ideal world, all feedback would be constructive feedback.

Of course, the actual answer is: as soon, and as often, as possible.

Learners benefit most from reinforcement that's delivered regularly. This is true for learners of all ages but is particularly so for younger students. It's best for them to receive constructive feedback as regularly, and quickly, as possible. Study after study - such as this one by Indiana University researchers - shows that student information retention, understanding of tasks, and learning outcomes increase when they receive constructive feedback examples soon after the learning moment.

There is, of course, some debate as to precise timing, as to how soon is soon enough. Carnegie Mellon University has been using their proprietary math software, Cognitive Tutor, since the mid-90s. The program gives students immediate feedback on math problems - the university reports that students who use Cognitive Tutor perform better on a variety of assessments, including standardized exams, than their peers who haven't.

By contrast, a study by Duke University and the University of Texas El Paso found that students who received feedback after a one-week delay retained new knowledge more effectively than students who received feedback immediately. Interestingly, despite better performance, students in the one-week delayed feedback group reported a preference for immediate feedback, revealing a metacognitive disconnect between actual and perceived effectiveness. Could the week delay have allowed for space between the emotionality of test-taking day and the calm, open-to-feedback mental state of post-assessment? Or perhaps the feedback one week later came in greater detail and with a more personalized approach than instant, general commentary? With that in mind, it's important to note that this study looked at one week following an assessment, not feedback that was given several weeks or months after the exam, which is to say: it may behoove instructors to consider a general window-from immediate to one/two weeks out-after one assessment and before the next assessment for the most effective constructive feedback.

The quality of feedback, as mentioned above, can also influence what is well absorbed and what is not. If an instructor can offer nuanced, actionable feedback tailored to specific students, then there is a likelihood that those students will receive and apply that constructive feedback more readily, no matter if that feedback is given minutes or days after an assessment.

What makes constructive feedback helpful?

Constructive feedback is effective because it positively influences actions students are able to take to improve their own work. And quick feedback works within student workflows because they have the information they need in time to prepare for the next assessment.

No teacher needs a study to tell them that motivated, positive, and supported students succeed, while those that are frustrated, discouraged, or defeated tend to struggle. That said, there are plenty of studies to point to as reference - this 2007 study review and this study from 2010 are good examples - that show exactly that.

How instructors provide feedback to students can have a big impact on whether they are positive and motivated or discouraged and frustrated. In short, constructive feedback sets the stage for effective learning by giving students the chance to take ownership of their own growth and progress.

How to give constructive feedback?

It's one thing to know what constructive feedback is and to understand its importance. Actually giving it to students, in a helpful and productive way, is entirely another. Let's dive into a few elements of successful constructive feedback:

Be specific

When it comes to providing constructive feedback that students can act on, instructors need to be specific.

Telling a student "good job!" can build them up, but it's vague - a student may be left wondering which part of an assessment they did good on, or why "good" as opposed to "great" or "excellent". There are a variety of ways to go beyond "Good job!" on feedback.

On the other side of the coin, a note such as "needs work" is equally as vague - which part needs work, and how much? And as a negative comment (the opposite of constructive feedback), we risk frustrating them or hurting their confidence.

Science backs up the idea that specificity is important. As much as possible, educators should be taking the time to provide student-specific feedback directly to them in a one-on-one way.

Be goal oriented

There is a substantial need to craft constructive feedback examples in a way that they actively address students' individual learning goals. If a student understands how the feedback they are receiving will help them progress toward their goal, they're more likely to absorb it.

Our veteran Turnitin team of educators worked directly with Dr. John Hattie to research the impact of "Where to next?" feedback, a powerful equation for goal-oriented constructive feedback that-when applied formatively and thoughtfully-has been shown to dramatically improve learning outcomes. Students are more likely to revise their writing when instructors include the following three essential components in their feedback:

1. Issue: Highlighting and clearly describing the specific issue related to the writing task.

2. Relevance: Aligning feedback explicitly to the stated expectations of the assignment (i.e. rubric).

3. Action: Providing the learner with their "next steps," appropriately guiding the work, but not giving away the answer.

It's also worth noting that quality feedback does not give the answer outright to the student; rather, it offers guidelines and boundaries so the students themselves can do their own thinking, reasoning, and application of their learning.

Be sensitive

As mentioned earlier, it's hard to balance the "constructive" with the "feedback" in an effective way. It's hard, but it's important that instructors learn how to do it, because how feedback is presented to a student can have a major impact on how they receive it.

Does the student struggle with self confidence? It might be helpful to precede the corrective part of the feedback acknowledging something they did well. Does their performance suffer when they think they're being watched? It might be important not to overwhelm them with a long list of ideas on what they could improve.

Constructive feedback examples, while cued into the learning goals and assignment criteria, also benefit from being tailored to both how students learn best and their emotional needs. And it goes without saying that feedback looks different at different stages in the journey, when considering the age of the students, the subject area, the point of time in the term or curriculum, etc.

What are some constructive feedback examples?

In keeping everything mentioned above in mind, let's dive into five different ways an instructor could give constructive feedback to a student. Below, we'll look at varying scenarios in which the "Where to next?" feedback structure could be applied. Keep in mind that feedback is all the more powerful when directly applied to rubrics or assignment expectations to which students can directly refer.

Below is the template that can be used for feedback. Again, an instructor may also choose to couple the sentences below with an encouraging remark before or after, like: "It's clear you are working hard to add descriptive words to your body paragraphs" or "I can tell that you conducted in-depth research for this particular section."

Constructive feedback example for essays

For instructors with a pile of essays needing feedback and marks, it can feel overwhelming to offer meaningful comments on each one. One tip is to focus on one thing at a time (structure, grammar, punctuation), instead of trying to address each and every issue. This makes feedback not only more manageable from an instructor's point of view, but also more digestible from a student's perspective.
Example: This sentence might be difficult for your readers to understand. Reword this sentence so your meaning is clear to your audience.
Constructive feedback example tied to a rubric

Rubrics are an integral piece of the learning journey because they communicate an assignment's expectations to students. When rubrics are meaningfully tied to a project, it is clear to both instructors and students how an assignment can be completed at the highest level. Constructive feedback can then tie directly to the rubric, connecting what a student may be missing to the overarching goals of the assignment.
Example: The rubric requires at least three citations in this paper. Consider integrating additional citations in this section so that your audience understands how your perspective on the topic fits in with current research.
Within Turnitin Feedback Studio, instructors can add an existing rubric, modify an existing rubric in your account, or create a new rubric for each new assignment.

Constructive feedback example for QuickMarks

QuickMark comments are sets of comments for educators to easily leave feedback on student work within Turnitin Feedback Studio.

Educators may either use the numerous QuickMarks sets readily available in Turnitin Feedback Studio, or they may create sets of commonly used comments on their own. Regardless, as a method for leaving feedback, QuickMarks are ideal for leaving "Where to next?" feedback on student work.
Here is an example of "Where to next?" feedback in QuickMarks:

Constructive feedback non-example for QuickMarks

It can be just as helpful to see a non-example of "Where to next?" feedback. In the image below, a well-meaning instructor offers feedback to a student, reminding them of what type of evidence is required in an argumentative essay. However, Issue and Action are missing, which leaves the student wondering: "Where exactly do I need to improve my support? And what next steps ought to be taken?"
Here is a non-example of "Where to next?" feedback in QuickMarks:

Constructive feedback examples for assignments outside of writing

As an instructor in a STEM class, one might be wondering, "How do I apply this structure to my feedback?" While "Where to next?" feedback is most readily applied to English Language Arts/writing course assignments, instructors across subject areas can and should try to implement this type of feedback on their assignments by following the structure: Issue + Relevance + Action. Below is an example of how you might apply this constructive feedback structure to a Computer Science project:
Example: The rubric asks you to avoid "hard coding" values, where possible. In this line, consider if you can find a way to reference the size of the array instead.
Overview: Constructive feedback examples for students

As educators, we have an incredible power: the power to help struggling students improve, and the power to help propel excelling students on to ever greater heights.

This power lies in how we provide feedback. If our feedback is negative, punitive, or vague, our students will suffer for it. But if it's clear, concise, and, most importantly, constructive feedback, it can help students to learn and succeed.

Study after study have highlighted the importance of giving students constructive feedback, and giving it to them relatively quickly. The sooner we can give them feedback, the fresher the information is in their minds. The more constructively that we package that feedback, the more likely they are to be open to receiving it. And the more regularly that we provide constructive feedback examples, the more likely they are to absorb those lessons and prepare for the next assessment.

The significance of providing effective constructive feedback to students cannot be overstated. By offering specific, actionable insights, educators foster a sense of self-improvement and can truly help to propel students toward their full potential.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
5 effective constructive feedback examples: Unlocking student potential

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Enhance learning with effective constructive feedback examples. Inspire progress and development in various contexts.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
What to think about when composing feedback

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Assessment - information regarding assessing learning.