# data[].attributes.body
Adnan said, "He drives his own car to school” Due to this, Adnan couldn't have gotten into Hae's car unless he was lying about about driving his own car to school.

# data[].attributes.headline
Something that might prove that Adnan is guilty for killing Hae is that he told one police officer that he never asked Hae for a ride home but then he told a different police officer that he did ask Hae for a ride home. That can prove that he either forgot about it or he is just lying which could really hurt his case.

# data[].attributes.subject
Something that might prove that Adnan is guilty for killing Hae is that he told one police officer that he never asked Hae for a ride home but then he told a different police officer that he did ask Hae for a ride home. That can prove that he either forgot about it or he is just lying which could really hurt his case.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that an interesting fact is that the state got the idea that Adnan killed Hae because he was angry from Jay, even though there were other people that disagreed. They said that said Adnan dealt with the break up like any other teenage and that they didn't see any signs of him being obsessed over Hae. I think that this is a obscure fact because even though there were lots of witnesses that said differently they choose to believe Jays story.

# data[].attributes.body
States case gives a report on how Adnan was unstable and prepared to do something rash, while most would say the break up was rational, and he quickly moved on with other girls.

# data[].attributes.headline
Asia Mclain claimed that she saw Adnan in the library at the time of the murder.

# data[].attributes.subject
Asia Mclain claimed that she saw Adnan in the library at the time of the murder.

# data[].attributes.body
One fact is that can show Adnan guilty is that he told one cop that he did ask Hae for a ride the day she got Murdered . But then 2 weeks later he said to a different cop that he did not ask Hae for a ride because he drove himself in his own car.

# data[].attributes.headline
Something that proves Adnan is guilty is his story that he told to the cops.  The day Hae disappeared one cop asked Adnan if he knew anything about where Hae the day he disappeared and he said he didn't ask for a ride.  But later on he was asked the same question but his response was different.  Adnan said that he didn't ask Hae for a ride.  Is Adnan changing his story to cover up something else he did, or is it just an honest mistake?

# data[].attributes.subject
Something that proves Adnan is guilty is his story that he told to the cops.  The day Hae disappeared one cop asked Adnan if he knew anything about where Hae the day he disappeared and he said he didn't ask for a ride.  But later on he was asked the same question but his response was different.  Adnan said that he didn't ask Hae for a ride.  Is Adnan changing his story to cover up something else he did, or is it just an honest mistake?

# data[].attributes.headline
A key idea and lead of the states suspicion towards Adnan is that he was a suspect of killing her because he might have been over obsessed and still jealous of Hae's significant others after the breakup. Although, Sarah now believes that the state's accusation of this reasoning is false. Apparently according to both and Adnan's Physcology teacher and classmates, he was not over obsessed and crazy head over hills for Hae after their breakup. The teacher specifically said that he wasn't acting different after they permanently had split, he just was sad like any other guy would have been after a regular breakup.

# data[].attributes.subject
A key idea and lead of the states suspicion towards Adnan is that he was a suspect of killing her because he might have been over obsessed and still jealous of Hae's significant others after the breakup. Although, Sarah now believes that the state's accusation of this reasoning is false. Apparently according to both and Adnan's Physcology teacher and classmates, he was not over obsessed and crazy head over hills for Hae after their breakup. The teacher specifically said that he wasn't acting different after they permanently had split, he just was sad like any other guy would have been after a regular breakup.

# data[].attributes.headline
Kristle, one of Hae's friends says that Adnan did indeed ask for a ride but Hae later rejects his offer but from Kritle's view Adnan did not seem to be bothered or irritated in any way, he simply just went on his way looking for another ride. This is some more evidence that is leaning to the fact hes innocent because it shows he never got in the car and he also wasn't angry at her.

# data[].attributes.subject
Kristle, one of Hae's friends says that Adnan did indeed ask for a ride but Hae later rejects his offer but from Kritle's view Adnan did not seem to be bothered or irritated in any way, he simply just went on his way looking for another ride. This is some more evidence that is leaning to the fact hes innocent because it shows he never got in the car and he also wasn't angry at her.

# data[].attributes.headline
When Have first went missing, Adnan claims that he did ask Have for a ride after school. 2 weeks after she went missing he claims that he did not ask her for a ride and that he drove his own car to school. Why would he change his story?

# data[].attributes.subject
When Have first went missing, Adnan claims that he did ask Have for a ride after school. 2 weeks after she went missing he claims that he did not ask her for a ride and that he drove his own car to school. Why would he change his story?

# data[].attributes.headline
claims that he wouldn’t claim to ask Hae for a ride, but some friends say he did ask Hae for a ride

# data[].attributes.subject
claims that he wouldn’t claim to ask Hae for a ride, but some friends say he did ask Hae for a ride

# data[].attributes.headline
Only Jae said that Adnan was angry after the breakup.

# data[].attributes.subject
Only Jae said that Adnan was angry after the breakup.

# data[].attributes.body
Everyone else said that Adnan consistently kept getting with girls and was not very affected  by the breakup.  Also,  Adnan still helped Hae and Don even when they were dating. Hae and Adnan still seemed to be friends since they were still talking from time to time. Jae was the only one who mentioned that Adnan was upset about the breakup.

# data[].attributes.headline
After the breakup between Hae and Adnan, Adnan moved on to other girls and didn't beg for Hae back, showing that he wasn't overly obsessed with Hae. Yes, he was upset, but not angry to the point where he would go to her house and yell at her. It was never that extreme. 

# data[].attributes.subject
After the breakup between Hae and Adnan, Adnan moved on to other girls and didn't beg for Hae back, showing that he wasn't overly obsessed with Hae. Yes, he was upset, but not angry to the point where he would go to her house and yell at her. It was never that extreme. 

# data[].attributes.headline
Adnan had told officers that he asked Hae for a ride the day she was murdered, however after Hae left the story he had changed the story and said that he always drives a car to school and wouldn't bother asking Hae for they had already broken up and had been seeing other people, according to Jay for Adnan this was multiple people. Before this interview Jay was interviewed and said that Adnan killed Hae, he planned on telling her that his car broke  down and that he would need a ride home. This is trippy because at first Adnan had tolf officers he needed a ride home, but then suddenly changed this moments later and said he aways brings his own car to school. What makes this obscure is that I do not know if Adnan had just made a mistake by saying that he got/needed a ride home because he was probably so used to saying that being he had answered so many questions about their relationship... Or whether Adnan is lying which could lead me towards believing that he is guilty. But if he is already in jail why should telling the truth even matter, and why is Jay automatically blaming and throwing Adnan under the bus. This leads me to believe that Jay is guilty, for Jay and Adnan were not even the best of friends, why would you tell just any one of your friends that you were going to kill your ex girlfriend. After writing and re-thinking this I believe that Adnan could be more innocent and Jay is guilty. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Adnan had told officers that he asked Hae for a ride the day she was murdered, however after Hae left the story he had changed the story and said that he always drives a car to school and wouldn't bother asking Hae for they had already broken up and had been seeing other people, according to Jay for Adnan this was multiple people. Before this interview Jay was interviewed and said that Adnan killed Hae, he planned on telling her that his car broke  down and that he would need a ride home. This is trippy because at first Adnan had tolf officers he needed a ride home, but then suddenly changed this moments later and said he aways brings his own car to school. What makes this obscure is that I do not know if Adnan had just made a mistake by saying that he got/needed a ride home because he was probably so used to saying that being he had answered so many questions about their relationship... Or whether Adnan is lying which could lead me towards believing that he is guilty. But if he is already in jail why should telling the truth even matter, and why is Jay automatically blaming and throwing Adnan under the bus. This leads me to believe that Jay is guilty, for Jay and Adnan were not even the best of friends, why would you tell just any one of your friends that you were going to kill your ex girlfriend. After writing and re-thinking this I believe that Adnan could be more innocent and Jay is guilty. 

# data[].attributes.body
The fact about Adnan getting into Hae's car can go both ways.  Many students claim that Adnan asked Hae for a ride and he got into the car. Others say that Hae agreed to give Adnan a ride but then said no. But Adnan himself told the detectives two different stories. Overall, the evidence showed can prove Adnan guilty or innocent.

# data[].attributes.headline
Almost everybody said that Adnan did not seem to be obsessed with Hae after the breakup

# data[].attributes.subject
Almost everybody said that Adnan did not seem to be obsessed with Hae after the breakup

# data[].attributes.headline
Hae was still flirting with Adnan. If Adnan did murder Hae, could the flirting have driven him.

# data[].attributes.subject
Hae was still flirting with Adnan. If Adnan did murder Hae, could the flirting have driven him.

# data[].attributes.headline
One fact that proves Adnan guilty is that he did ask Hae for a ride then he didn't this makes it seem that Adnan is hiding something and trying to cover it up.

# data[].attributes.subject
One fact that proves Adnan guilty is that he did ask Hae for a ride then he didn't this makes it seem that Adnan is hiding something and trying to cover it up.

# data[].attributes.body
One of the states reasons for the belief that Adnan was guilty was Jay's claim that Adnan was telling him, that he was going to kill her in her car. That day, as Jay said, Adnan got asked for a ride from Hae, and Hae accepted. This is a very compelling piece of evidence against Adnan but out of all of Hae and Adnan's friends only two others were able to confirm this fact, which makes Jay's credibility questionable. This makes the fact very blurry, and not a strong fact to support either side, but Adnan said something very interesting. He first confirmed the fact that he got a ride from Hae then week later, he denied it.

# data[].attributes.headline
We don’t hear the rest of the tape, we don’t hear what Jay was told.

# data[].attributes.subject
We don’t hear the rest of the tape, we don’t hear what Jay was told.

# data[].attributes.headline
Jay is the only one who has reported that Adnan was enraged and utterly heart broken when Have broke up with him. Everybody else (teachers and peers) claimed that he was taking the break up like any normal teenager. Sure, he was sad but he didn't seem frustrated or angry. This suggests that Jay may have been lying because he was the only one who stated this and he and Adnan weren't even the best of friends. So, why would Adnan tell somebody who isn't his best friend or extremely close with him that he was going to kill Hae? 

# data[].attributes.subject
Jay is the only one who has reported that Adnan was enraged and utterly heart broken when Have broke up with him. Everybody else (teachers and peers) claimed that he was taking the break up like any normal teenager. Sure, he was sad but he didn't seem frustrated or angry. This suggests that Jay may have been lying because he was the only one who stated this and he and Adnan weren't even the best of friends. So, why would Adnan tell somebody who isn't his best friend or extremely close with him that he was going to kill Hae? 

# data[].attributes.headline
After Adnan and Hae split up, there was no evidence that Adnan was mad at Hae. Adnan told Jae that he was going to kill Hae because she broke her heart, but others said that he was not rage-filled, just sad. Also, Adnan was seeing other girls at the time and he would have no reason to still be mad at her. Finally, no one has evidence of Adnan getting into Haes car to kill her. 

# data[].attributes.subject
After Adnan and Hae split up, there was no evidence that Adnan was mad at Hae. Adnan told Jae that he was going to kill Hae because she broke her heart, but others said that he was not rage-filled, just sad. Also, Adnan was seeing other girls at the time and he would have no reason to still be mad at her. Finally, no one has evidence of Adnan getting into Haes car to kill her. 

# data[].attributes.headline
since he was an EMT,so he knew how to strangle

# data[].attributes.subject
since he was an EMT,so he knew how to strangle

# data[].attributes.headline
Jay had proof of Adnan in the car with Hae, along with several other people that heard  about seeing the two of them in the car. However, Adnan says that he brought his own car to school that day, but told a cop otherwise. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Jay had proof of Adnan in the car with Hae, along with several other people that heard  about seeing the two of them in the car. However, Adnan says that he brought his own car to school that day, but told a cop otherwise. 

# data[].attributes.body
One thing that shows Adnan is guilty would be that Hae's friend Becky remembers Adnan asking Hae for a ride. Since she is not the only one who remembers this it seems like Adnan asking for a ride is true. This makes him look guilty because him being in the car gives him a time and place to kill Hae.

# data[].attributes.body
Something that may proove Adnan Guilty, is the fact that when he first was interveiwed by a cop, he claimed he did ask Hae for a ride, but was later denied by her. The second time he was interveiwed by a different cop, he said he did not ask Hae for a ride because he drove himself to school. The author of the serial podcast interveiwed some of his past classmates, three of them say that he infact did ask Hae for a ride, but she later said she couldn't because she had somewhere to go.

Also, Something that may prove Don guilty is the fact that Hae was supposed to meet Don at the mall later, and Don refuses to be interveiwed about this. There is not enough information to proove Don guilty, because he won't give his story.

Another person who could be guilty is Jay.

# data[].attributes.headline
Several things were found in the letters from Asia that she wouldn't have known unless she had contact from Adnan or the police. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Several things were found in the letters from Asia that she wouldn't have known unless she had contact from Adnan or the police. 

# data[].attributes.body
The case said that his motive for killing Hae was that he was made at her for breaking his heart. But when interviewing numerous people, they almost all said that he was never showing any real rage or anger that would. He just acted like a normal boy in a high school breakup. Also, he was dating many other girls in after they broke up. That shows how he moved on and was not totally angry on the breakup.

# data[].attributes.headline
the fact that he got his first phone two days before the murder. This suggests that he bought the phone while planning the murder.

# data[].attributes.subject
the fact that he got his first phone two days before the murder. This suggests that he bought the phone while planning the murder.

# data[].attributes.headline
The woman running the concession stand claims that Hae left her car on right outside of the stand and ran in to grab her daily snack. She also says that she did not see Adnan near her car. If Adnan was going to try to kill her by involving her car, then would have been the time to do that. But, the concession stand lady did not see him. 

# data[].attributes.subject
The woman running the concession stand claims that Hae left her car on right outside of the stand and ran in to grab her daily snack. She also says that she did not see Adnan near her car. If Adnan was going to try to kill her by involving her car, then would have been the time to do that. But, the concession stand lady did not see him. 

# data[].attributes.body
Apparently a testifying investigator stated Adnan did say he asked Hae for a ride, he told another in a police report that this was untrue, was he high when talking to the investigators about this, are his memories a little shaky, were the witnesses thinking of another day, or is he covering something up?

# data[].attributes.headline
We don’t hear the rest of the tape, we don’t hear what Jay was told.

# data[].attributes.subject
We don’t hear the rest of the tape, we don’t hear what Jay was told.

# data[].attributes.body
Could have been forced to testify to not get charged for drugs, and also could have been told a supposed scenario for hours and got tired of it and "admitted to what happened"

# data[].attributes.headline
Jay mentioned that Adnan said, "I think I'm gonna kill her" after the two broke up. However, Adnan said that he was over Hae a month later and was upset here and there but it was never to serious to the point where he was depressed or mad in any kind of way. Jay also mentioned that Adnan didn't have a plan that Jay was aware of yet, but Adnan did tell Jay that he would get a ride from Hae after school and that was when the plan would happen. (This might not be accurate though.)

# data[].attributes.subject
Jay mentioned that Adnan said, "I think I'm gonna kill her" after the two broke up. However, Adnan said that he was over Hae a month later and was upset here and there but it was never to serious to the point where he was depressed or mad in any kind of way. Jay also mentioned that Adnan didn't have a plan that Jay was aware of yet, but Adnan did tell Jay that he would get a ride from Hae after school and that was when the plan would happen. (This might not be accurate though.)

# data[].attributes.headline
Jay told the police officers that Adnan was going to killed Hae in her car yet two people who witnessed Adnan and Hae's conversation remember Hae saying that she couldn't give Adnan a ride. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Jay told the police officers that Adnan was going to killed Hae in her car yet two people who witnessed Adnan and Hae's conversation remember Hae saying that she couldn't give Adnan a ride. 

# data[].attributes.headline
Right after Hae went missing, Adnan says that didn't ask her for a ride, but 2 weeks after she went missing he claims he did. Does this indicate that he simply forgot, or he was hiding something?

# data[].attributes.subject
Right after Hae went missing, Adnan says that didn't ask her for a ride, but 2 weeks after she went missing he claims he did. Does this indicate that he simply forgot, or he was hiding something?

# data[].attributes.headline
He might have gotten the new phone to detail how the murder was planned and when it was going to take place.

# data[].attributes.subject
He might have gotten the new phone to detail how the murder was planned and when it was going to take place.

# data[].attributes.body
Why would he tell on his friend, even if he was already in prison, it just does not sound right, are his memories shaky too, or is this a flat out lie, is he trying to cover himself, up, or someone else, keep investigators from digging?

# data[].attributes.headline
Since he was an EMT, they believe that he already knew how to strangle someone.

# data[].attributes.subject
Since he was an EMT, they believe that he already knew how to strangle someone.