# data[].attributes.body
To conclude the final task Katie and I pretty much had the same idea on why the author included 3 stories in the novel which was to show how humanity is truly messed up and very disappointing. We both enjoyed the book and recommend this book to other reader out there.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with what you think  on how the word is cruel and how they can’t change how they are. How do you think they could stand up for themselves tho? Violent or not?

# data[].attributes.body
My outtake on the book was that humanity it cruel in some ways and people who were born in raised in their own country and are suddenly not accepted is very disappointing on their part and we should not just sit back an relax and watch this all happen because what if this is us in the future. Now I'm going to ask you the same question was your outtake?

# data[].attributes.body
I pretty much have the same opinion as you but I personally really enjoyed the book and I learned about how this event took place in different time periods.I also agree that this is very disappointing in many ways and shows how humanity is very cruel. I also learned in more detail about what was really going beside the sense in each situation snd affected me more because I was not reading it out of a text book. Giving it a more emotional affected on me beach it is historical fiction and even tho they are not real people did still happened to people.

# data[].attributes.body
I think Katherine is trying to say just the different Moments in the past or events that have cause cruelty and fear, and how the author is giving you a first person view on each event in the book.

# data[].attributes.body
Yeah I can kinda see where you are coming from when you said that the author wanted to show the different outcomes of the stories.What you said at the end can you elaborate on that more. Like what do you mean the progression throughout history. (co

# data[].attributes.body
Yeah I can kinda see where you are coming from when you said that the author wanted to show the different outcomes of the stories.What you said at the end can you elaborate on that more. Like what do you mean the progression throughout history.

# data[].attributes.body
What I mean is kinda what you said in your first response. Saying how Mahmoud has a phone to contact other people when Josef did not. This can relate to how these even tho time is passing and technology is advancing the amount of cruelty in the world is still the same. That may outtake on the situation. I want to ask you what was your opinion on the book and what did you get from it? (connects to Katie's 6th Response)

# data[].attributes.body
I think the author made 3 different stories of children to make it more interesting and  more exciting, To make the reader always wonder what's going to happen to each character next.

Another reason could be just to show the different main problems or wars around the world that happened in the past/ are going on now.

# data[].attributes.body
Oh yeah very true at the end of the novel Isabel went to go stay at Josef's little sisters house. I really liked how the author connected the stories. It found it very smart and kinda cool.

# data[].attributes.body
Yeah same I liked how the author connected the stories. But going back to the idea of the author on why the author included the 3 stories. I had the idea that the author did that to show the different outcomes of the stories and how some might not end in a happy ending for example Josef died at the end of his story and Isabel made it safely to America and she was able to live a happy and healthy life in total. Also the progression of the changes of the same situation throughout history kinda going back to what you said in your first response.

# data[].attributes.body
True I didn't think about that but it is extremely to have a certain target for an audience so this could be taken different ways through others perspectives. I don't think kids would be scared or be afraid of the events but be more of an emotional roller coster. For example when Ivan died that was emotional for the characters and the readers from my perspective.

# data[].attributes.body
Very true when Ivan died that was very emotional.The book definitely covers more adult topics. I agree with you that the book is an emotional roller coster. The part where I almost started crying was when Josef died in the concentration camp.At the same time very happy for Isabel that she made it to America safety. The coolest part was at the end of the novel where she went to go stay at Josef's little sisters house. This shows how the stories are all connected in some why shape and form.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think that was the main idea that the author wanted to get across because he has a younger audience. Due to this he doesn't want to scare them. But for his adult audience this maybe a possibly to let them know they need to go do something to prevent this from happening again or stop the current situation.

# data[].attributes.body
I agree with what you said about the author wanting to inform younger his younger audience. I didn't really think about that idea till now. But what if the author wanted to give the message that this may happen again in the future because this event is currently happening in the world.

# data[].attributes.body
I can see that you and I have similar responses. I completely agree with everything that you said. I really liked what you said about the author trying to give a message about our mistakes in the past and how it still affects us. I also think the author may have added 3 stories to inform the reader on history today and in the past. By giving a historical fiction twist to each of the stories it may appeal to younger reader. This makes the message clearer for a younger audience.

# data[].attributes.body
To add to what you guys saying for my tier 1 question.I think that they are all related and connected on way or another and going along with humanities mistakes I feel like the author was trying to give a message about not making the same mistake and still remembering the old ones because anything can happen to anyone. The three different stories also depict a closer look into what it was far each separate time period had a phone but none of the other stories did.Also the outcome of how they were mostly all related.

# data[].attributes.body
All 3 story are connected in some why but added in throughout history. For example Josef's story took place in Berlin, Germany-1938.While Isabel was in Havana,Cube-1994. Finally Mahmoud was in Aleppo,Syria-2015. They all have the same kinda of event going on how they are not welcome in their own country. I think the author wanted to show that this is a recurring event and needs to be fixed. Showing how humanity is very messed up. By adding the 3 story's you the reader can see that this has been going on for almost 90 years.

# data[].attributes.body
Why do you think the author includes three stories throughout the novel