# data[].attributes.body
I would say that the givers society is not considered a utopia because Jonas asked his parents if they loved him and thy said no. Even if that is a rule you shouldn't say that to you child, this rule is a cruel rule that can make people depressed and sad

# data[].attributes.body
i say that the givers society is not a utopian society because they are being brain washed and people dont even have there memories and there is a lo of communist in the givers society

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that The Givers' society truly is a utopian. I say this because the main focus of a utopian is where  hunger, abuse, racism don't exist. A utopian world is our regular fantasies of the world being a better place as the video states. The Giver just happens to be sort of like a fantasy reality, where you actually have to come up with your own ways to bring equality. In different ways their society may seem dystopian but it really isn't, people in the community dont worry if they'll be hungry or if they don't have enough  or if they'll be able to sleep in a house. The Giver only appears as a dystopian because there is a price to pay. Though sometimes citizens of the society have their own choices, like how if you don't like the the assignment your given, you are allowed to change it.

# data[].attributes.body
I say that the giver isn't really considered as a utopian in my point of view. As see in the "The Giver first 18 chapters they really try there best to make it an Utopian society by making guidelines which are you aren't supposed to have emotion toward people or to your self so we could be happier in life by you know giving out memories or taking out memories which has that job is Jonas. But to be honest that doesn't sound like a utopian society , its supposed to be perfect and perfect sound like loving one and other, having feeling for one and other.

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think The Giver's society can really be called a Utopian society. A Utopian society is where everything is perfect and the world is the best condition for the people. I do not think the world in The Giver is in the  best condition. Even with weather control and other advanced technologies, I still think it isn't considered a Utopian society because of the many things the people in The Giver have lost. Like snow and the memories they had. But they are all gone now.

# data[].attributes.body
the giver is not a utopian society because the giver was brainwashing people and only bad things come from brain washing who do you know is a good person that brainwashes. the givers government is a whole bunch of communists

# data[].attributes.body
I say that the giver is not considered a Utopian society. I say this because a utopian society is supposed to be a place where no one is angry and it's like a fairy tale since the society is just the most perfect place ever but in the giver sameness isn't like that because the Giver and Jonas both feel pain and that shouldn't be happening to them if their society is such an amazing place. Also, in the Giver everyone gets their jobs picked which shouldn't happen in a Utopian society since they should be able to be free and be happy with what they are doing. But in sameness they are getting chose on the job that they have to do which isn't right in a Utopian society, since someone could not like their job but they would have to do it for the rest of their life and they would also have be upset for the rest of their life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think The  Giver is and isn't a Utopian society because without the reciever you would look at it as a Utopian Society but in a utopian your not supposed to experience pain and you arent supposed to feel angry and sad about yourself. In a perfect world no pain will ever be involved but since Jonas has experienced pain and is feeling upset it isnt considered a utopian society anymore.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe it is not a utopian society because it isn’t perfect and it’s supposed to be a world where nothing’s wrong but clearly some stuff is wrong in the giver

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think that the society in the Giver is a Utopian society. I say this because there are a lot of things that are hidden from the people. For example, they don't know how the world was like before sameness.

# data[].attributes.headline
Can The Giver's society truly be considered Utopian?

# data[].attributes.subject
Can The Giver's society truly be considered Utopian?

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion I think The Giver's society is not a Utopian Society. I say this because you are not supposed to fell pain or angry moods.For example, in a Utopian Society you should fell happy all the time. But in the Giver's society Jonas and The Giver both felt pain. Jonas was also very angry at himself.

# data[].attributes.body
I believe that in the book The Giver the world they live in where everyone is equal. But i believe in a Utopian society everyone should have equity which everyone is at a level where THEY can succeed in life.

# data[].attributes.body
I think that the givers society is not to be considered Utopian because in a Utopian society everything should be perfect but in the giver nothing is perfect.

# data[].attributes.body
i find this society not a utopian. utopian society are supposed to be perfect and like a dream even though everything an everyone is equal to me that doesn't make a utopia

# data[].attributes.body
I think the Giver’s society can not be a utopian society because it isn’t beneficial to anyone in this society. Everyone has to get their own jobs picked and they can only do certain things, and if they don’t follow the rules you get kicked out of this society. It’s not right that you can’t even have fun or be a kid in this society and, you can’t even let your parents know how much you love them in this society, and they can’t tell you that either. The answer to the first question at the end of the video is that, it might be possible to have a utopian society since we could possible all get along one day without fighting with each other, We might all have things we live to do that we can do without anyone saying something. So having a utopian society could be achieved one day if everyone just got along.

# data[].attributes.body
A utopia is an imagined community where everything is perfect.  I think The Givers truly be considered Utopian because they don’t know what pain is. And hunger, pain, fear is not part of The Givers society. However, it also can’t be utopian because now The Giver is giving Jonas memories, and some of them are painful. So, Jonas will now know what pain is. —— Maria.

# data[].attributes.body
no it is not Utopian since if everything is perfect then what about happiness it can it truly be called perfect''for its lack of happy enjoyment toward the community so no it is not not fair not equity in no way -brayon t

# data[].attributes.body
The Giver's society can't be considered Utopian, because it isn't benefiting the people, because they aren't self aware. They aren't choosing to live in the so-called 'perfect' society, and they can't contribute to making it better. There can not be a perfect society if the people have no appreciation for it, and can't know what could have been.
-Alex

# data[].attributes.body
In my opinion, I strongly believe that The Giver's society can be  Utopian or not. I think that The Giver's society is not 100% truly Utopian but it still is Utopian.  I say this because a Utopian society is when everything is a perfect paradise and for the most part everything is equal. It is a community or society that is perfect and equally to each person inside of the society. In this society, people are given there own jobs, specially selected. The world inside the book, "The Giver" has removed any fear, hunger, problems, and much more, whereas in a normal community, these things would all exist. The book states that when you turn 12, at the ceremony of 12 you are given your own job assignment based on your personal hobbies and interests. Also, in the book, it states that when Jonas was little he accidentally said he was starving, but then he was told that no one is ever starving in this society, and that he was only hungry. These details show how the society is considered Utopian because all these things are done to have everyone equal and not different from each other. On the other hand, the society is not considered equal because Jonas has been selected to hold all the pain of memories from generations and generations back. He is also selected to make wise decisions using these memories which is not considered fair since the entire community does not have a say in the decisions. This shows how the society is not equal because of all the honor that one person holds. The answer to the first question in the video is that yes it's possible to have a Utopian society. I say this because we could have a certain set of rules to follow that would equal a Utopian society among each other, and it will help to get to a Utopian society. In conclusion, this shows if The Giver's society is considered Utopian and if it is possible to have a Utopian society.

# data[].attributes.body
It is not a Utopian Sociaty because There no colore in the World No Happyness or joy and everyone have to be the same age in a classroom that is messed up and only one viacle wont cut it like a bike no you must'v been joking i know like it dont take gas and all like it does not need oilbut its life men and you dont know how long you would live in it just try to make the most of it.

# data[].attributes.body
No because we don't get to chose our jobs and we can only have certain vehicles and we only get to have what they want us to have and we don't even know what snow is and every day things we probably could not do there and every one is unique in their own way and that is not a bad thing and also the is no such thing as having a utopia because there will always be people who don't want to listen then there will be punishment and that is not a good thing

# data[].attributes.body
I don't think a utopia is possible because everyone has a unique personality, this can cause fights to break out and a utopia is only great based on the people in it. If you had a place where the surroundings where perfect the people would never be. And if u had perfect people They wouldn't care as much about the outside. To add on to this point if a place truly got perfect someone would come and ruin it. I think a utopia is a place where everyone wishes they can be. Everything is perfect almost like a fairy tale is what i think a utopia is.