# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to that somewhere . I believe this because they traveled very far . More specifically, I believe that they made I there and the people in the community know stuff that Jonas does . For example, when Jonas had saw the new place he heard music and red and green lights. The author shows that it is Christmas time which people in Jonas's old community don't know about.. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe have just gone in a loop , I maintain that this is false because his old community didn't know about Christmas . Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to somewhere because they traveled very far and the things that Jonas saw were not things the other community knew about.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have been to weak to make the end the trip. I believe this because because Jonas’s conscious starts to slip away. More specifically, I believe that Jonas may have died because of how weak he is. For example, the book says “But perhaps it was only an echo”. The author shows that Jonas starts to lose conscious because the word echo does indicate fading away. Although others might disagree that Jonas is just thinking, I maintain that Jonas is most likely dead because of the many times he was struggling and how weak he became. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe been to weak to make the end the trip because Jonas is slipping away from he conscious.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere and it is Christmas time. I believe this because in the town there is colorful lights and it is snowing. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe are in a town of loving people who are celebrating Christmas. For example,”He forced his eyes open as they went downward, down-ward, sliding, and all at once he could see lights, and he recognized them now. He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love.” The author shows that there are lights that Jonas can see through the windows of houses. Although others might disagree that Gabe and Jonas are in an empty town, I maintain that it is Christmas time in a town full of lovely people and if there is no one it the town how would the lights be up. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere and it is Christmas time because in the town there is colorful lights and it is snowing.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to the house around christmas time. I believe this because there were lights and the colors were yellow red and green. More specifically, I believe that because when the Giver gave him the memory of love they said there was a tree. For example, ''there were colored lights: red and green and yellow, twinkling from a tree which was, oddly, inside the room,''. The author shows that when they arrived Jonas recognized the same house in the memory  . Although others might disagree that it could have been a different holiday , I maintain that where else or when else do you have a christmas tree in your house . Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe came to the house in the woods around christmas time because the house they came to was the same as the one in the memories.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe Escaped to a place where people live like they did in the memories.. I believe this because We hear music as Jonas and Gabe Escape. More specifically, I believe that We have moved to a place that has more freedoms than Jonas’s community. For example,We hear music, Jonas doesn’t have music in his community. . The author shows that Jonas and Gabe are going to a place that is very different from Jonas’s community.. Although others might disagree that Jonas has fully escaped the community and is safe, I maintain that Jonas completely moved to a different community because the book ends when Jonas hears people singing. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe escaped to a place where people have more freedoms than Jonas’s community because WE HEARD MUSIC.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe went in a circle around the community. I believe this because Jonas still has some of his memories left and they have been gone for days. More specifically, I believe that they went in a circle because Jonas can still see color even though they left the community and the people at Elsewhere have been waiting for Jonas and the baby Gabriel. For example, in chapter 23 in the third to last paragraph the text states, “He knew they were shining through the windows of rooms, that they were the red, blue, and yellow lights that twinkled from trees in places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love.” . The author shows that Jonas and Gabriel must be near the community because Jonas still sees all of the color. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabriel have gone in a circle around the community, I maintain that Jonas still has some of his memories left and he can see all of the colors. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have gone in a circle around the community area because he still has color.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe get down the hill people from elsewhere  are going to be waiting for them. I believe this because I think Jonas’s community told elsewhere to look for them and return them . More specifically, I believe that the people from elsewhere are going to help Jonas and Gabe because they think it is wrong to kill people. For example, if they get Jonas and Gabe they are might release them. The author shows that in the community they dont want the community to know to much. Although others might disagree that ,it shows that if the community knows to much the community will crash I maintain that because if they dont release them they can tell them everything. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe so that is why I  think it is people from elsewhere because so that is why I think it is the people from elsewhere

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to Elsewhere and they figured out that it is just a Community that is different from their past one. I believe this because if there was houses, music, he knew “they” were waiting for them, it would probably be people. More specifically, I believe that when Jonas said “they” were waiting for them, he meant the people of the Community of Elsewhere. For example, in chapter 23, the book said, “...places where families created and kept memories, where they celebrated love.” The author shows that because it tells the reader that Elsewhere is different from the Community Jonas came from. Although others might disagree that Jonas survived and made it to Elsewhere, I maintain that if Jonas died and didn’t make it, he wouldn’t be hearing and seeing what he is. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe were expected by the people of Elsewhere because Jonas somehow knew “they” were waiting for him and Gabriel.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to ELSEWHERE and there is some kind of party or holiday going on.  I believe this because they saw things and heard thing like music and lights. More specifically, I believe that it is a holiday because there are colored lights and people are singing, they could be singing christmas carols of other types of holiday music. For example, In the text it says there are colored light and Jonas heard someone like music. The author shows that it is christmas because when he was getting to ELSEWHERE there was snow and deers.. Although others might disagree that they have went in a circle. I maintain that they did not go in a circle because the community does not have snow and there are no deers or any animals. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to ELSEWHERE and there is some kind of party or holiday going on.In my opinion I think that Jonas and Gabe  made it to ELSEWHERE and there is some kind of party or holiday going on.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe has died at the end. I believe this because the narrator kept saying how he was throbbing his head. More specifically, I believe that cause the narrator says how he was barely awake going down hill. For example, “he forced his eyes open as they went downward,downward,sliding,and all at once he could see lights”. The author shows that Jonas was also losing consciousness. Although others might disagree that Jonas is actually alive, I maintain that Because it says “Jonas felt himself losing consciousness with his whole being willed himself to stay upright atop the sled”. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe Is dead because the narrator was describing all the signs of fainting or death because of the happy memories.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe are still alive and living happy with the elsewhere people. I believe this because Jonas says they are waiting for him and the baby. More specifically, I believe that because he said there was lights in color and he could see red, green, and yellow and there weren’t any lights in his community. For example, There was a sled and lights in color that Jonas could see . The author shows that Jonas lost all of his memories so he could not have been going back to his community because he would have got the memories back. Although others might disagree that it is true because he would have seen the people of his community and they would most likely come after him., I maintain that his community would have been coming after him and they would have taken Gabe and him. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are very happy with the people elsewhere because Jonas and Gabe are with the elsewhere people happy and safe

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have entered into the memories. I believe this because Jonas goes down the hill on a sled just like in the memories and he sees a house that is filled with love just like the Christmas memory. More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have entered the memories because Jonas says that he already knew that they were waiting for them. For example, the text says, “The hill was steep but the snow was powdery and soft, and he knew that this time there would be no ice, no fall,no pain. The author shows that when he found the sled he could still remember the other memory about the sled and he should not be able to remember them if he left the community. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe are in a dream, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe have went back into the memories. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe are in a memory from the past because Jonas is looking at a house that is the same house from the Christmas memory and he is going down a hill on a sled.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe Have found a new community that they will fit into. . I believe this because Jonas and Gabe are different from the others in their community . More specifically, I believe that Jonas and Gabe had entered a community where everyone is like them. They have pale eyes and have the ability to receive memories . For example, Jonas was able to remember memories of his family and friends as he got closer to this new community . The author shows that Jonas also had heard music, but in his other community the people did not know what music was. . Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe had circled and made it back to their community, I maintain that  their community do not have music and color like Jonas had seen ahead. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe travel to a community  they fit into  because unique differences front the people in their community. For example only Jonas and Gabe could receive memories.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe have died. I believe this because I think Jonas is reliving his happy memories. More specifically, I believe that he is dying from hypothermia so his brain is replaying his memories of  happiness and love. For example, the text says that Jonas is riding a sled and that he sees lights with a house and music. The text also says that Jonas could barely move and was freezing. The author shows that this means Jonas liked the memory of sledding down a hill and he got it. Jonas also had the memory of love in 4the house with music. Although others might disagree that they died and think they survived, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe died from hypothermia. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe have died because Jonas is dying from hypothermia because he is freezing and can barely move).

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere. I believe this because Jonas said they where there waiting for them. More specifically, I believe that because also he said he may have heard music which he could not do in the community. For example, the text said Jonas thought he heard music. The author shows that there could be people ahead when going down the sled. Although others might disagree that Jonas and Gabe didn’t make it, I maintain that Jonas and Gabe made it because all they had to do was go down the sled. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe made it to elsewhere because the text said that they were there waiting for them and also that Jonas thought he heard music and people talking.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe died in the ending of the story. I believe this because they were starved and cold. More specifically, I believe that it may have only been Jonas who died.  For example, the text states “His consciousness grasped at a wisp of another warm memory, and tried desperately to hold it there, to enlarge it, and pass it into Gabriel. The author shows that Jonas is slowly falling unconscious. Although others might disagree that Jonas died, I maintain that Jonas died. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe had not made it to Elsewhere, because Jonas and Gabe had died of starvation and the cold.

# data[].attributes.body
In my view, I believe that Jonas and Gabe will be welcomed into this new community because of they have received happy memories from there before. I believe this because Jonas said he reconizged the community and it felt familiar. More specifically, I believe that somebody will reconizge Jonas and will take him and Gabe in with them. For example, Jonas said he could feel that there were people at the bottom of the hill who were waiting for Jonas and Gabe. The author shows that the community reconizges him and Gabe because of the memories Jonas has got from there. Although others might disagree that Jonas is dying and is experiencing this magical memory before he dies. I maintain that Jonas and Gabe are going to be welcomed into the community. Therefore, I conclude that Jonas and Gabe will be welcomed in the community because Jonas reconizged the place and knew that the community was waiting for him.