# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: a topic that is present in both arman and the breadwinner is hope

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: a topic that is present in both arman and the breadwinner is hope

# data[].attributes.body
1:  in the breadwinner Parvana shows hope for her father to get out of jail.

2: in arman he shows hope that this labor will end soon

*The boy's name is Aman*

2: I would rewrite it to be: Aman is receiving an education and this is making him hopeful.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A topic that is present in both Lizas story and The Breadwinner is perseverance

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A topic that is present in both Lizas story and The Breadwinner is perseverance

# data[].attributes.body
1.In the Breadwinner, Parvana has struggles with family and perseveres through it.
2. In Lizas’s story she persevere s after her father died.

Great!

# data[].attributes.body
Even during hard times, try to stay hopeful for the future.

1 answer:

Great

# data[].attributes.body
Theme: when times are hard you should have hope.

Answer 1: Parvana was hoping that her father would come back

Answer 2: Parvana is hopeful that Maryam will have a good future

Answer 3: Liza hopes that she will be a painter when she's older

Answer 4: Liza hopes that someday she will see the ocean in person

# data[].attributes.headline
Stay hopefull, you never know what might happen

# data[].attributes.subject
Stay hopefull, you never know what might happen

# data[].attributes.body
In The Breadwinner Parvana stayed hopeful and her father came back

In Amans story he stayed hopeful and got to go to school

In The Breadwinner if parvana stays hopeful she will be more motivated to find her family

In Amans story he is hopeful he will become a doctor some day

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A topic that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is they both face struggles.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A topic that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is they both face struggles.

# data[].attributes.body
answer 1: Parvana struggles when she has to do a strange job to make money.

answer 2: Liza is a girl with struggles as well. Liza struggles when her father dies.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer 1: Parvana struggles when her father is taken to prison by the Taliban.

Answer 2: Liza struggles when her father dies.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: In the book “The Breadwinner” by Deborah Ellis, and the Book of narratives “Kids of Kabul” also by Deborah Ellis, they both share a common theme. That theme is, “Even during tough times, try to have hope.”

Answer #1: Parvana is very hopeful for the future.

Answer#2: Parvana is brave for going outside alone

Answer#3: Liza is hopeful for the future by painting the ocean

Answer#4: Liza is persevering through tough times.

# data[].attributes.body
Answer 1. in The Breadwinner By: Deborah Ellis, Parvana faces a tough time when her father is arrested and she fights through that and works for her family.
2. In The Breadwinner By: Deborah Ellis, Shauzia has a tough time when her parents are fighting with her grandparents and all of them rely on her to bring in money but despite these challenges, Shauzia pushes through and works to help her family.
3. Aman faces a tough time when 15 people in his family die. Although this is a tough time, Aman pushed through and keeps supporting the people left in his family and his self.

YES I KNOW THERE IS ONLY 3!

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: try to have hope, even during hard times

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: try to have hope, even during hard times

# data[].attributes.body
Answers:
Parvana had hope that her father would return to them

Parvana was having a hard time going to the market alone as a girl

*Her names is spelled Liza*

Lisa is hoping that one day, she will see the ocean

Lisa has having a hard time because she (and other women) were 'silenced' and are treated unfairly

# data[].attributes.body
The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is Never give up, and perseveres.

# data[].attributes.body
A theme that is present in both is they never give up hope even in really hard and difficult times.

Great claim!

# data[].attributes.body
My theme is: Always have hope during hard times.

Answer 1: Parvana has hope that her father will come home

Answer 2: Parvana has hope that Maryam will have a bright future

Answer 3: Liza has hope that one day she will see the ocean in   Real life

Answer 4: Liza hopes one day she will be a famous painter

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A common theme in The Breadwinner and Lizas story in Kids Of Kabul is When times are tough it helps to have hope. In the Breadwinner Paravana went through a tough  time when her father get arrested for no reason reason. In the breadwinner Paravana remained hopeful when she wanted to light the lamp for her father. In the Kids of Kabul Liza went through a tough time when she had to watch her father die. In the Kids Of Kabul Liza is hopeful that Afghanistan will change into a better place.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A common theme in The Breadwinner and Lizas story in Kids Of Kabul is When times are tough it helps to have hope. In the Breadwinner Paravana went through a tough  time when her father get arrested for no reason reason. In the breadwinner Paravana remained hopeful when she wanted to light the lamp for her father. In the Kids of Kabul Liza went through a tough time when she had to watch her father die. In the Kids Of Kabul Liza is hopeful that Afghanistan will change into a better place.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Aman’s story in Kids of Kabul is that even during hard times try to stay hopeful about the future.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Aman’s story in Kids of Kabul is that even during hard times try to stay hopeful about the future.

# data[].attributes.body
answer 1 parvana  is sad that her father is in prison but she stays hopeful that her and her family will survive through this time of cris.

Answer 2 Aman has fifteen family members that are dead but he stays hopeful that one day he will become a doctor to heal kids in Afghanistan.

Answer 3 parvana’s  family left her and she doesn’t know what to do without them but she stays hopeful and works hard so she can feed herself.

Answer 4 Aman  knows the crisis he is going to and it hurts him a lot but to stay hopeful he thinks of his future because it might be a good future.

# data[].attributes.body
A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when you are determined and persistent, things may end well.
Answer 1: One reason why a common theme in The Breadwinner and Liza’s story is, when you are determined and persistent, things may end well is because both stories tell how the characters have plans for the future and look towards what they want to do.

You do not need to repeat your claim in your answer.

Answer 2: Another reason why a common theme in The Breadwinner and Liza’s story is, when you are determined and persistent, things may end well is because both characters have lost someone important to them, but they didn't stop, they kept on going.

You do not need to repeat your claim in your answer.

Answer 3: Another reason why a common theme in The Breadwinner and Liza’s story is, when you are determined and persistent, things may end well is because both characters let their ideas take place of all the negativity around them. They dream big and are proud.

Give a specific example Liza is persistent.

Answer 4: One last reason why a common theme in The Breadwinner and Liza’s story is, when you are determined and persistent, things may end well is because they are both determined to help others and make sacrifices so that everyone else can be happy.

Give a specific example: When is Liza hopeful in her story?

# data[].attributes.body
A topic in the breadwinner and in the kids of Kabul story is to persevere.

Answer 1: Parvana goes through a hard time (and persevers) when the Taliban take her father to prison.

Answer 2: Amen feels pain around his whole body when he thinks of the family members he lost. He always thinks of his future to get rid of that pain though--your talking about how he is hopeful here, not about how he perseveres.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A topic that is a present in both is hope.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A topic that is a present in both is hope.

# data[].attributes.body
Great!

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: If you stay hopeful during hard times, you have a better chance of success.
Answer #1, Breadwinner: Even when her father is taken away, Parvana stays hopeful that he will come back.
Answer #2, Breadwinner: Shauzia is hopeful she will go to Paris and escape Afghanistan and her grandparents, and in the end, we know she has a good plan to get there.
Answer #1, Liza: In Liza's story, she talks about filling your head with thoughts that are hopeful.
Answer #2, Liza: Liza says that after the Taliban's reign ended, she was hopeful.  Then, she tells us about her going to an art school every day, something she loves doing.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: that you should always have hope during hard times.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: that you should always have hope during hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
Your claim is good

Your answers do not make sense.

Answer #1: Parvana goes through a hard time when...

Answer #2: Parvana has hope when...

Answer #3: Liza goes through a hard time when...

Answer #4: Liza has hope when...

4 answers: that you should always have hope during hard times. Tough times can have a good outcome. That home is always home. That Afghans don't give up

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Kids of Kabul is try your best to stay positive during hard times.

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Kids of Kabul is try your best to stay positive during hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
Four Answers:
One way Parvana stays in The Breadwinner is when she still believes that her father is coming back even when Shauzia doubts that he will.
One way Parvana is dealing with hard times is that her father went to prison.
One way Liza stays positive in Kids of Kabul is when she still goes to the art center even though she is dealing with a loss.
One way Liza is dealing with hard times is that her father died.

This looks great!

# data[].attributes.body
Theme: Stay hopeful during hard times it will sometimes have good results.

Answer 1: In the story Breadwinner by Deborah Ellis Parvana's father gets put into jail. Parvana’s family is very sad but that does not stop Parvana from hoping that her father is going to come back one day.

Answer 2:  then because she had hope and Parvana  persevered. One night her father returned home from jail.

answer 3: In the story kids of Kabul by Deborah Ellis Liza’s dad dies but Liza did not give up hope that one day everything will turn out ok.

Answer 4: One day, Liza start thinking on the bright side of things she loves art and was thinking about pain in the ocean because it she said the ocean is long and you cannot see the sad parts of it

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is ‘try to have hope in hard times.’

Answers:
1. A moment in The Breadwinner that supports this claim is when Parvana and Shauzia are hopeful in getting better jobs that pay better.
2. Another moment in the Breadwinner that supports this claim is when Parvana is hopeful that her father will come back
3. A moment in Kids of Kabul that supports my claim is when the Taliban left Afghanistan and Liza could focus on her art.
4. Another moment in Kids of Kabul that supports this claim is when Liza is looking at other pieces of artwork.