# data[].attributes.body
How did Adnan's "motive" hold up in court?  Adnan's motive had no hold to it.
- The idea that Adnan had a lot of built up anger about Hae dating a car sales man, or that he had a lot of anger about the breakup doesn't add up. in the podcast, Sarah crafts this theory. The idea was that the reason Adnan hasn't snapped and tried to kill Hae before hand is because he didn't see her little or none after the breakup until school started up again. This is wrong though, Adnan did see Hae during that school break or one of those snow days. Hae called him to ask for help for his car. And Don was there too. Don met Adnan, the ex boyfriend, and said he was totally chill about the whole thing. Nothing suspicious. So if Adnan truly did have all of this built up anger over the break up, wouldn't he have at least seemed tense or yell at some point during that time period? A motive is a huge piece of evidence holding Adnan Syed back however the evidence makes sense. Without a motive to kill the killing wouldn't have happened. So disproving his motive disproves the fact that he killed Hae.
http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/serial-subject-adnan-syed-4-key-pieces-of-evidence-explained-20160701
https://adnansyedfacts.wordpress.com/adnans-motive/

# data[].attributes.headline
                                                 Adnan Syed

# data[].attributes.subject
                                                 Adnan Syed

# data[].attributes.body
The call logs are a main piece of evidence against Adnan simply because it follows Jay's story and backs up his story.
things they hold against Adnan:
1. Jay's testimony
2. Adnan being the ex boyfriend
3. Adnan asked Hae for a ride that day she disappeared
4. his paranoid behavior when cops called to ask about Hae
5.Adnan's phone made and received 2 calls linked through leakin' park the day she was buried
6. Finding DNA of Adnan's in hae's car.
7. the fact Adnan does not remember what he did on Jan 13, 1999

# data[].attributes.body
In Jay's statement he says that they bury Hae about 4 and a half hours after she was killed, so why doesn't this match the autopsy report?
-The autopsy report of Hae Lee's body showed blood pools on the frontal areas of her body. To a normal person this means nothing but to a coroner this shows that the body was laying on their stomach after they were killed.  Doctors estimate around 10 hours of the dead body lying face down before being buried.
-The important thing from this piece of evidence is that it doesn't match up with Jay's Testimony.  So why doesn't it?  Maybe it doesn't because he didn't know doctors could figure that out and wanted to pin it on Adnan after he was the one who killed Hae.
http://people.com/crime/adnan-syed-is-innocent-and-i-can-prove-it-lawyer-rabia-chaudry/

# data[].attributes.body
(There's more if you click on it)

Sound-
https://splice.gopro.com/v?id=7rxKgj

If that link doesn't work ^^^^
https://youtu.be/63wGGNxgN6E

# data[].attributes.body
With school traffic, regular traffic, and the distance, how did Adnan make it in time in the Best Buy parking lot to kill Hae?
Sarah herself went and tried out the driving for the times, however she did end up making it.  In her words, "you'd have to really try to make it in time".  However the timings after the murder are what don't make sense. This is a huge part because it shows that he simply might not have had time to do all of these things and kill Hae at that specific time.
-For example, the NIsha call. The Nisha call puts Adnan exactly where Jay says he is except Nisha could've sworn that they talked at night, not in the middle of the day.
- Another example would be the autopsy report.  It shows that Hae's body was lying face first for 10 hours causing blood to pool at the front of the body.  In Jay's story this doesn't add up because he says only a few hours passed till he picked Adnan up at the strip of land, or wait sorry, the Best Buy Parking lot,  and they buried the body at Linkin Park.

# data[].attributes.headline
DNA Evidence Against Adnan (Logos) (outside source)

# data[].attributes.subject
DNA Evidence Against Adnan (Logos) (outside source)

# data[].attributes.body
Truthfully, there is none, so how was he convicted?
-To simply put it, Adnan was convicted due to DNA evidence they found in Hae's car.  They found a sample of Adnan's DNA.  This can be simply explained though, Adnan has been in Hae's car before.  She gave him rides after school among other times he was there.  So having his DNA in the car comes to no shock and shouldn't be a reason that is held against him because it can be simply explained
-In fact, this case could have had a clear suspect if the police analyzed DNA they took from Hae's body. Police did indeed collect swabs, including vaginal swabs to check for rape, however the police didn't end up testing the samples due to a fear that it would show that Adnan truly had no involvement into Hae's murder. If this piece of evidence was tested then Adnan might be a free man.
-Also, the crime scene had some samples of hair in the car of Hae Lee's however it was not a match for Adnan Syed. This shows that there was somebody else in Hae's car.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jul/06/adnan-syed-new-trial-hae-min-lee-rabia-choudry

# data[].attributes.body
How many inconsistencies can someone have before you call them an unreliable source?
- Issue #1
Jay himself has told the police multiple times that he is willing to lie to get himself out of trouble, maybe this is another one of those situations.
- Issue #2
In one testimony for motive against Adnan, Jay said it was because she made him mad.  The next time he said the motive was that Hae had broken Adnan's heart.  Then the next time he just completely changed it and went "He snapped and strangled her"
-Issue #3
Constantly Jay told his friend Jenn that Adnan had plans to kill Hae. In his second interview he said it was planned on the 12th. Later that interview Jay switches this story into the 13th. But then, when he is a witness on trial and during his testimony, he says that Adnan had NO plans to ever kill Hae and that he just snapped.
https://viewfromll2.com/2014/11/26/serial-why-jays-testimony-is-not-credible-evidence-of-adnans-guilt/

# data[].attributes.body
How can you say you where one place when your phone pings a tower in another area?
https://viewfromll2.com/2014/11/23/serial-a-comparison-of-adnans-cell-phone-records-and-the-witness-statements-provided-by-adnan-jay-jenn-and-cathy/

# data[].attributes.headline
                                                            Jay Wilds

# data[].attributes.subject
                                                            Jay Wilds

# data[].attributes.body
Did Adnan actually call her or was it a butt dial?
Jay says that Adnan contacted Nisha and handed him the phone to speak while they were in the car. Although, Nisha remembers that they were in the adult store, where jay works, during the time that she spoke with him. Its possible that Nisha was accidentally called and never picked up but it was still billed. The phone company still bills calls after they have been on the phone for 2 minuets, even if they don't have a machine that picks up.

# data[].attributes.body
If Adnan really was innocent, and knew that Jay was the one telling these lies about him, why isn't he furious at Jay?
Adnan claims that the reason he is not more upset at Jay for telling these lies is because "he does not want to do the same thing to Jay as has been done to him".  This part of reaction towards Jay makes people believe that he really did murder Hae and simply isn't mad at Jay because Jay is right about everything. Well, in the defendants defense, maybe he just gave up?  Adnan has been in jail for 15+ years and until the podcast Serial came out, no one had thought about Adnan being innocent except his family, some friends, and his lawyer. The jury took one look at him and decided he was guilty after hours of discussion, Adnan barely had a chance.  So fighting it all, being angry at the whole situation would do no good for himself.
(this article mentioned it) https://www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/36t3jq/top_ten_reasons_adnan_syed_is_guilty_of_murder/

# data[].attributes.body
During Adnan's trial, the records prove that his race an religion were used against him. The court didn't introduce him as an american citizen, he was introduced as Pakistani Muslim "The defendant is of Pakistani background, he's a Muslim." -prosecutor during Adnan's trial. By telling the jury this the prosecutor is stereotyping Adnan because of his beliefs.

# data[].attributes.body
he is gay

# data[].attributes.body
jhjjjjjjjjjj

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Below are my top ten reasons that the accusation that Adnan murdered Hae Min Lee is proven to the extent that there could be no "reasonable doubt" in the mind of a "reasonable person" that he is guilty of the crime IN THIS WORLD. In the multiple worlds like ours found in our multiverse, Adnan is innocent. Just like Hae is still alive and the Beatles never broke up.

Note that in our legal system there can still be a doubt, but only to the extent that it would not affect a reasonable person's belief regarding whether or not the defendant is guilty. IN THIS WORLD, the preponderance of evidence and statistical probability point overwhelmingly to Adnan's culpability in the strangulation and murder of Hae Min Lee. Granted there are many people who would prefer to believe in the possibilities inherent in living in a multiverse where the fact that something is possible, somehow means it is reasonable to believe.

At any rate, in THIS WORLD the top ten reasons it is reasonable to believe that Adnan is guilty of murder:

1: Statistical probability.

Multiple studies have shown that in America the odds that Hae Min Lee, or any other female murder victim, are murdered by a random stranger is less then 10%. Over 90% of women murdered by men are murdered by someone they know. Of those, 60% are murdered by their intimate partner or ex-partner. Most often, females are "killed by males in the course of an argument between the victim and the offender." By far the leading and most reasonable explanation about what happened to Hae Min Lee is that there was an argument between Adnan and Hae over her new relationship with Don that escalated to violence. Every other theory, particularly given the total lack of any evidence to the contrary, stretches reasonable doubt to the breaking point. IN THIS WORLD. In the multiverse of worlds, Hae is killed by some random serial killer or by a drug gang or by alien abduction.

2: The absurdity of a police conspiracy

Without a doubt the police lead aspects of this case and interrogation. They had an uncooperative suspect (Jay) that they had to make cooperative. But to believe they coerced Jay's testimony in its entirety, you have to believe they also coerced Jen's testimony as well. You have to believe that something as substantial as finding Hae's car was hidden from her family. You have to discount incriminating cell phone evidence, most notably the Leakin Park cell phone pings. You have to develop wild theories about how all corroborating testimony was incorrectly attributed as having occurred on Jan 13th. etc. Is all of this possible? Yes. We live in a multiverse after all. Is it reasonable? No. Any reasonable outside observer can see that the odds that Jay was not involved directly in the burial (and tangentially the murder) of Hae Min Lee are remote. And if Jay is involved, any reasonable person would have to conclude Adnan is by far the most likely perpetrator of the murder. Just as any reasonable person would find Jay and probably Jen, as involved as accessories after the fact.

3: The Incriminating Cell Phone Pings.

In particular the Leakin park cell phone pings in the early evening. If Adnan had is phone at this time, which is what he claims, there is no reasonable explanation for these pings other then that the phone was near or in Leakin park which Adnan claims to have not been near. To get the phone there without Adnan's involvement involves creating scenarios that while certainly possible in this vast multiverse, are highly unlikely in this world, and can be reasonably dismissed as improbable. That something is possible does not mean it is reasonable to assume it could have happened. It bears noting that earlier in the day the cell phone pings do not align in any way with either Jay or Adnan's description of the morning. Very likely something else was going on. Who knows what but it is just another instance of Adnan lying about where he was and what he was doing.

4: Multiple instances of Adnan lying. Some of it deeply disturbing.

Any one instance doesn't say a lot. But taken together they paint the picture of someone who is manipulative and lacks credibility. Lying about Hae wanting to get back together with him is perhaps the most chilling. This was a lie Adnan told the School nurse on the day the news broke that Hae's body had been found. He claimed to have spoken to Hae the night before she disappeared and told the nurse that Hae "had wanted to get back together with him, that she still loved him, but that he didn't want to get back into the relationship in that manner - that they would always be friends." (source trial testimony of nurse: http://postimg.org/image/wz59tmc2p/) Given what we know of the phone log from the evening before the murder, and the very short conversation that Adnan had that AM with Hae, this does not ring true at all. What is creepy is that it sounds very much like what Hae likely told him in the car right before he strangled her. There are of course other damning lies. Lying about asking Hae for a ride on the day of the murder (witnessed by two separate credible witnesses and confirmed by Adnan to a police officer the same day). Lying about his car being unavailable when asking for the rid. Lying about how he wasn't bothered by their breakup. Lying about where he was and it not matching up with cell tower evidence. Stealing from the community Mosque donations. etc.

5: Hae's letters and diary which point to Adnan not accepting the breakup well and at times feeling menaced by his behavior.

6: Adnan's attitude towards Jay is not one of someone wrongfully accused.

Adnan continues to display what can only be described as a bizarre lack of emotion towards Jay. If Adnan is innocent, Jay is lying through his teeth. How could any innocent person not be enraged by this situation? In the best possible scenario, Jay was coerced into his testimony. But here we are 15 years later and Jay continues to lie. Adan's response that "he does not want to do the same thing to Jay as has been done to him" clearly doesn't make sense - Jay is NOT innocent in this situation. If Adnan is innocent Jay is LYING. Andan must KNOW this. How could such a moral person as himself not insist on finding out the truth regarding Jay? Note further that if there was not a police conspiracy then Jay was clearly involved somehow in his beloved Hae's murder. So not only does Jay kill his beloved Hae, he puts Adnan away for life. And Adnan doesn't want to accuse him of anything? Give me a break.

7: Adnan claiming no memory of the day.

This after a police call enquiring if he knew her whereabouts as she did not pick up her nephew which Adnan himself has argued was so important to Hae that he wouldn't even think of asking her for a ride. Anyone who genuinely cared about Hae would have been deeply alarmed. Just as all her close friends and family were. And he never attempts to contact her from this point on.

8: Multiple instances of both Jay and Jenn telling third party strangers about the strangulation death of Hae Min Lee BEFORE any police interrogations.

9: Writing "I'm going to kill" on a breakup note from Hae.

Assuming this was related to THIS WORLD and not the multiverse of worlds, and against the background of everything else that happened in THIS WORLD, it is pretty damning.

10: The Nisha call.

Reasonable to believe it was a butt dial? Sure. Just as it is reasonable to believe it was an actual phone call in an effort to provide an alibi for his whereabouts. Namely that he was with Jay. An alibi that he could no longer rely on once Jay flipped.

In conclusion, the most reasonable thing to believe happened in THIS WORLD is the following. Adnan got a ride from Hae Min Lee most likely with the intent of rekindling their relationship. They argued over their relationship and Don. Adnan in a fit of rage strangled Hae Min Lee. Adnan, with Jay's assistance, scouted Leakin Park in the early evening and returned later to bury Hae's body. Given how odd Jen's testimony is i wouldn't be surprised to find out she was involved somehow in the burial as well. Again, all in this world. In the multiverse, Adnan is innocent.

This is an incredibly sad case made sadder by the misplaced efforts by many who live in the multiverse rather then this world to secure the release of a murderer who refuses to take responsibility for his actions IN THIS WORLD.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
r/serialpodcast - Top Ten Reasons Adnan Syed is Guilty of Murder Beyond a Reasonable Doubt In This World But Innocent in the Intergalactic Multiverse

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Below are my top ten reasons that the accusation that Adnan murdered Hae Min Lee is proven to the extent that there could be no "reasonable doubt" in the mind of a "reasonable person" that he is guilty of the crime IN THIS WORLD.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
Adnan Syed is Innocent and I Can Prove It: Lawyer Rabia Chaudry

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
After the 2014 podcast Serial became a worldwide sensation, many were left doubting that convicted murderer Adnan Syed was guilty...