# data[].attributes.body
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is even when times are tough, always have hope.

Answer 1: Times were tough in the breadwinner because Parvana lost her family during some of the book.

Answer 2:Parvana always had hope because she always believed her father would come back

Answer 3: Liza had hope when Liza had watched her father die and she couldn't do anything about it.

Answer 4: Liza had hope when the Taliban left, she wanted to have a normal life again.

# data[].attributes.body
B1:  Pervana perseveres when  her father gets taken to prison and Pervana never stops trying to get money for the family.

B2: Even when things are hard for her, Liza still paints.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: Even when things are hard, never give up hope

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: Even when things are hard, never give up hope

# data[].attributes.body
Answer 1: In The Breadwinner by Deborah Ellis, Parvana has hard times when she loses her father

Answer 2: In The Breadwinner by Deborah Ellis, Parvana has hard times when she loses her father

Answer 3: In Kids of Kabul by Deborah Ellis, Liza has hard times when she loses her father.

Answer 4: In Kids of Kabul by Deborah Ellis, Liza never gives up hope when she continuously paints pictures of the ocean.

# data[].attributes.body
They persevered even during hard times. Parvana went through a hard time when her father was taken away to prison. Parvana had hope when she and Shauzia got paid from digging the bones. Parvana got paid a lot more than she had before.  Liza tried to distract herself by painting and not thinking about the violence around her. She lost hope when her father died of an illness.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: during hard times you have to persevere

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: during hard times you have to persevere

# data[].attributes.body
B1: Parvana goes through a hard time when she loses her father
B2: Parvana perseveres when she decides to become a boy
B3: Liza goes through a hard times when she loses her father
B4: Liza perseveres when she continues to paint

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: Even when times are tough, you never give up on what you are doing and keep trying.

Answer 2: In the breadwinner and the kids of kabul book, characters both in the books go through tough times. For instance, Parvana had gotten her father taken away and had no way to earn money, or get an education.

Answer 2:In the kids of Kabul story the kids also were not able to get an education. Yet Parvana and her family kept trying and got more help to eventually find her father. And in the kids of Kabul book, Liza had days when she had nothing to do, so she had to just argue to find something to do.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim and 2 answers: a topic in the breadwinner and liza's story is family 

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim and 2 answers: a topic in the breadwinner and liza's story is family 

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is to not give hope even when times are tough. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is to not give hope even when times are tough. 

# data[].attributes.body
Ans 1: In the Breadwinner it was tough for Parvana because she lost parts of her family through out the book.
Ans 2: Parvana always had hope because she always believed that her father would come back.
Ans 3: When Liza watched her father die she couldn’t do anything about it.
Ans 4: When the Taliban left, Liza had hope that her life would be normal again.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: Even when you have very little, you still need to work hard

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: Even when you have very little, you still need to work hard

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana has very little since she needs to sell all of her food clothes in order to have money.
She continues to work hard though when she digs for bones even though it is hard work. Aman has very little since 15 family members of his were killed. He continues to work hard though finding a job to get money for him and his sister.

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim and 4 answers: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is...When times are tough, never give up. 

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim and 4 answers: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is...When times are tough, never give up. 

# data[].attributes.body
Answer 1: Always have Hope.
Answer 2: Losing someone.

Answer 3: Not being aloud to do something

Answer 4: Having good education.

# data[].attributes.body
C: In both stories a common theme is staying positive in horrific circumstances.

A: Parvana shows that she is staying positive by laughing with Shauzia throughout the book.

A: The kids of Kabul use hopeful thoughts to help stay positive.

# data[].attributes.body
Parvana keeps working to get money despite what happened
Liza is still optimistic

# data[].attributes.headline
Claim: When times are tough stay hopeful 

# data[].attributes.subject
Claim: When times are tough stay hopeful 

# data[].attributes.body
1. Parvana had a hard time when her father went to jail.
2. Parvana was hopeful when she waited for her father to come back
3. Liza had a hard time when her father died
4. Liza remained hopeful when she wanted to be a painter

# data[].attributes.headline
When times are though never give up hope. 

# data[].attributes.subject
When times are though never give up hope. 

# data[].attributes.body
1. Parvana went through a tough time when her father got taken to prison.

2. Parvana never gave up hope when she is waiting for her father to return home from jail.

3. Liza goes through a tough time when her father dies

4. Liza is hopeful when she does her art.

# data[].attributes.headline
 Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough, it is important to stay hopeful

# data[].attributes.subject
 Claim: A theme that is present in both The Breadwinner and Liza’s story in Kids of Kabul is when times are tough, it is important to stay hopeful

# data[].attributes.body
1. Times got very hard for Parvana and her family.
2. Parvana stayed hopeful during those times.
3. Things were hard for Liza.

4. Liza also stayed hopeful and positive during the hard times.

# data[].attributes.body
They preserved

# data[].attributes.body
C: In times of need people, will support each other.

A1: Parvana and her family go through a time of need when their father is thrown in jail

A2: Parvana supports her family by disguising herself as a boy and going into the marketplace.

A3: Aman goes through a time of need when many of his family members are killed by the Taliban.

A4: Aman supports him and his sister by shepherding sheep to earn money for basic necessities.

# data[].attributes.body
Never give up hope even in tough times:
Ans 1: In the bread winner , Parvana goes through a tough times when her father gets taken away
Ans 2: Parvana never gives up hope when she turns into a boy and goes into the market
Ans 3: Similarly, Aman goes through a hard time when his parents get killed
Ans 4: Aman stays hopeful when he starts herding sheep and thinking about a bright future

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: I think that the common theme between The Breadwinner  by Deborah Ellis and Kids of Kabul by Deborah Ellis is that you should never give up hope during hard times.

Answer 1: One time that Aman is going through a tough time in his story is when the Taliban walked into his house and killed 15 members of his family, leaving him, his sister, and his grandfather.

Answer 2: A time when Aman was hopeful in his story was when he was thinking about wanting a better future for himself.

Answer 3: A time when Parvana was going through a hard time in her story was when the Taliban took away her father from her family, the only person who could make them money.

Answer 4: One time Parvana is hopeful in her story is when she talks to her friend Shauzia about how she wants to get her father back, and how she is very hopeful it will happen.

# data[].attributes.body
Claim: A theme in both The Breadwinner and Aman’s story in Kids of Kabul is even when times are tough, you need to work hard to get what you need.

Answer 1: A time when Parvana is having a tough time is when  her father was taken away.

Answer 2: A time when Parvana works hard is when she turns into a boy and tries to earn money.

Answer 3: A time when Aman is having a tough time is when 15 relatives of his die.

Answer 4: A time when Aman works hard is when he studies harder at school in order to take care of his sister.

# data[].attributes.body
Theme 1: when times are tough, you need to persist. Answer 1: because if there dads leaving answer 2: because of there mothers being beaten

Theme 2: when your in a dark place, you need to have hope. Answer 1: when they closed down schools Answer 2: when they made women stay inside

Theme 3: when times are rough: it will help to be hopeful Answer 1: when they need to leave because it's dangerous Answer 2: because they don't feel safe in there Homes

Theme 4. Never give up hope, even when times are tough. Answer 1: they had to both worked to stay alive Answer 2: